Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

How would you know he´d be invited to Astronomy night before knowing he´d be invited to Astronomy night? I searched for "Ahmed invited white house" and similar things with no success.

Oh no. My cover has been blown. Or.....something. WTF? What are you getting at?


I knew he had been invited to Astronomy Night because I read in a news article that he had been invited to Astronomy Night.
 
Oh no. My cover has been blown. Or.....something. WTF? What are you getting at?


I knew he had been invited to Astronomy Night because I read in a news article that he had been invited to Astronomy Night.

Yes, but your rebuttal to me when I said that not even google knew when he was going to go to the White House makes no sense. And don´t be so quick in calling me a cospiracist, I wasn´t saying that!

(although you could be a social media sock puppet for all I know, those things exist after all. The low quality of the arguments and the sheer amount of postage obfuscating the case with the meme of "Ahmed was a victim of islamophobia" seem to point to their presence)
 
Last edited:
Well, truethat quoted from another dictionary with a different definition.


One which she conveniently neglected to actually cite.

Now you post your own.


All of which were primary (as in most standard) usages.

All of which were actually cited so that people could review the sources and evaluate them.

One of which was actually singled out as a source by TT herself. An alternative she didn't see fit to actually quote, although including the reference certainly seemed to add the color of authority to her claim. (At least in her own mind.)

Have you ever noticed how often desperate people offer sources which don't actually support the claims they are making, apparently in the hope that no one will actually look at them?

We can play these games all day and get nowhere. Why not use the definition that the word's user uses and agree that this is what it means in the context of this discussion and move on?


Because when people craft definitions (or cherry pick them) they are doing it because the actual, accurate meanings do not support the assertions which they are making. It is an act of overt duplicity.

Words can't just mean whatever someone wants them to mean for the convenience of the moment. That makes them relatively useless for the purposes of honest communication.

But I shall take note that you believe this to be perfectly okay, both when I attempt to judge the meanings of your comments, and when I respond to them.
 
Personally, I think a recent episode of "Big Bang Theory" explains this incident better than Islamophobia.

Because I am technically revealing part of the plot, I will put it into a spoiler tag.

The four scientists can't manage to remove a lug nut in order to fix a flat tire. After several scientific attempts, they try to use some improvised thermite, formed by scraping various bits of the car, to melt the nut. They end up blowing up the van.


Scientists and brainy people in general are scary people who do scary things. They probably have secret ways of bomb making that don't require any fuel or explosive material. Oh, sure, that is just a bunch of printed circuit boards, but how do we know they aren't explosives? It could be anything! And even if we know it isn't a bomb, we can't figure out why anyone would do that, so we had best not take chances. We have to get to the bottom of this!

People don't trust what they don't understand, and smart people, by definition, are things that the average person doesn't understand. Smart Muslims are even weirder.
 
How would you know he´d be invited to Astronomy night before knowing he´d be invited to Astronomy night? I searched for "Ahmed invited white house" and similar things with no success.

Maybe google is just extremely good at tailoring results based on past searches, in which case we could end up getting search results that are different. In my case, I got curious what would happen if I typed in "Ahmed invited white house" (no quotes) into google, and the first link was:

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/...s-clock-white-house-astronomy-night/32507227/
 
Personally, I think a recent episode of "Big Bang Theory" explains this incident better than Islamophobia.

Because I am technically revealing part of the plot, I will put it into a spoiler tag.

The four scientists can't manage to remove a lug nut in order to fix a flat tire. After several scientific attempts, they try to use some improvised thermite, formed by scraping various bits of the car, to melt the nut. They end up blowing up the van.


Scientists and brainy people in general are scary people who do scary things. They probably have secret ways of bomb making that don't require any fuel or explosive material. Oh, sure, that is just a bunch of printed circuit boards, but how do we know they aren't explosives? It could be anything! And even if we know it isn't a bomb, we can't figure out why anyone would do that, so we had best not take chances. We have to get to the bottom of this!

People don't trust what they don't understand, and smart people, by definition, are things that the average person doesn't understand. Smart Muslims are even weirder.

WTH are you on about? Did you read the link I posted before?http://blogs.artvoice.com/techvoice...gineering-ahmed-mohameds-clock-and-ourselves/ It´s well worth a read. Ahmed is no genius, a five year old could do that. It certainly looks like he only took it out of its original case and put it in the aluminium case to make it look like a bomb, so he could be detained and cry "islamophobia!" .

(unless the pictures they´ve shown us are not of his clock, of course)
 
<snip>

If it happened to my kid, I can guarantee that you would not be hearing about it. I would not rush to the media and try to get as much attention as possible.


Too bad for your kid. Or his classmates.

If any of my kids were dragged off in handcuffs for no better reasons than the ones claimed in this incident I would make damn sure that everybody I could manage would hear about it, if for no other reason than to make certain that the school and the cops involved thought very carefully before they tried pulling a stunt like that again.

This is exactly the kind of abuse of power which needs all the light shown on it that can be.

I would pursue it through the established legal channels


That too.

(which are highly developed and generally responsive).


In what world? Over and over again when schools abuse their authority they have been shown to circle their wagons and resist any acknowledgement of a problem until they are forced to. The ACLU has squads of lawyers who spend more time than should be needed forcing recalcitrant, unrepentant school system and officials to perform their duties the way they are supposed to, not the way they want to.

This is why the legal channels are responsive in these instances. Because they are forced to be.

Someone without the financial backing to take on a government bureaucracy by themselves isn't going to see much responsiveness.

That's exactly why making as much noise as possible is not only justified, but also the very best course of action for any real hope of redress.

But even if I did rush to the media, nobody would give a crap. The left-wing media doesn't care about my child's ethnicity because it doesn't fit their preferred narrative of oppression (although, ironically, that ethnicity is a blend of two ethnic groups which have suffered substantial institutional racism in the US).


You need to resolve this claim with the people in this thread who have based their own defenses of the way this incident was handled not least on the claim that ethnicity was irrelevant, and that we hear about this sort of thing happening to kids who are good ol' WASPs.
Ahmed's ethnicity in no way explains the response of the school and police to his little stunt.


Same burden which TT asks for. Can you prove that it doesn't? What evidence do you have?

It explains everything about the response to the response, though.

It makes no difference to me what ethnicity was involved, except that there is more than a little basis to suspect that the incident would have gone down much differently had the kid been from a middle class WASP family, and had a name like "Smith".

I am puzzled by those who are so adamantly certain that ethnicity played no part at all.

I have been far less assured in my opinions. And have never made any such claims of certainty. Apparently it's okay to be convinced of your rectitude and authority when you are arguing that prejudice doesn't exist and anyone who suggests it might is a racist than when you are simply pointing out that there is good reason to suspect it might have been a contributing factor.
 
Maybe google is just extremely good at tailoring results based on past searches, in which case we could end up getting search results that are different. In my case, I got curious what would happen if I typed in "Ahmed invited white house" (no quotes) into google, and the first link was:

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/...s-clock-white-house-astronomy-night/32507227/

It didn´t work for me, although I diodn´t spend much time at it, I admit.

But it´s irrelevant anyway. Have you seen the links I posted? It looks like a hoax, from every angle.
 
WTH are you on about? Did you read the link I posted before?http://blogs.artvoice.com/techvoice...gineering-ahmed-mohameds-clock-and-ourselves/ It´s well worth a read. Ahmed is no genius, a five year old could do that. It certainly looks like he only took it out of its original case and put it in the aluminium case to make it look like a bomb, so he could be detained and cry "islamophobia!" .

(unless the pictures they´ve shown us are not of his clock, of course)

If this was the case then why did he show it to the first teacher? Wouldn't that have squashed his plan if the teacher, who knew and liked him, had simply confiscated it and turned it in?

I will say I agree with Meadmaker on this point. Not knowing what it was to me it would be clear it wasn't a bomb right in front of me. (I'd probably not think it was a bomb at all) But I'd wonder if there was some "cell phone signal detonator" thing going on that would do things like

Set off all the sprinklers
Hack into a computer system
Release stink bombs (not the explosion kinds) in the toilets

Etc.
 
WTH are you on about? Did you read the link I posted before?http://blogs.artvoice.com/techvoice...gineering-ahmed-mohameds-clock-and-ourselves/ It´s well worth a read. Ahmed is no genius, a five year old could do that. It certainly looks like he only took it out of its original case and put it in the aluminium case to make it look like a bomb, so he could be detained and cry "islamophobia!" .

(unless the pictures they´ve shown us are not of his clock, of course)

If he put it into an aluminum case in order to make it look like a bomb, he failed, because it doesn't look like a bomb. It looks like a clock in a pencil case.


I don't know how smart Ahmed is. Based on news reports I've read, he's pretty smart. This particular project, he said, took about 20 minutes to do, but he has done others that required more effort.

The point is that he is an electronics tinkerer and people are suspicious of odd, unusual, behavior, like rewiring clocks. They could end up doing damage, just like those four highly respected scientists shown on the TV show.

I like Big Bang Theory. It's funny. I watch it. However, there is always a voice in the back of my mind telling me that idiots think those portrayals are accurate. It says something about our society that that is the image of scientists in pop culture.
 
I am extremely confident that we would not have heard about it, because the policy is to not release that information. All we know is that Ahmed is accused of being "passive-aggressive" during questioning. We know nothing about what they asked, other than vague reports that he was asked what it was, "a clock" and why he brought it to school. (Answer unknown. Later he would say it was to show his engineering teacher.)

We know Ahmed's side of the story. I think he and his family would have told the media if in fact Ahmed were asked probing questions about his connections to Islamic terrorism. Initially, it was reported that one of the police said, upon Ahmed entering the room, "that's who I thought it was." That came from Ahmed presumably. Later, that was disputed by somebody connected to the police or the school, and it seems to have dropped from the narrative.


As noted earlier, we can compare it to our experience as students, as parents, or in some cases as educators. No one seems to have any comparable experience with any such event. The arrest was bizarre.

No one? Well, I've heard about similar stuff happening. Not an absolutely identical situation of course, but it is not uncommon at all for the police to be called because of something suspicious that a kid brings to school. Remember also that the police were already at the school. The school is big enough and urban enough that there are so-called school resource officers on site during the school day. So it's not like somebody called 911. They simply called the SROs who were already there. And, frankly, it's quite typical for things like this to escalate because any nuance in the initial cause for alarm is lost as new people are brought in. The "clock" did not look like a clock. Furthermore, there was no point to it. Why would somebody put a clock in a pencil case unless they wanted the ability to hide it? There were reasonable questions that reasonable people would have expected reasonable answers to. And, in the absence of such reasonable answers, those reasonable people would become reasonably suspicious. All reasonable. The only thing that seemed unreasonable was putting the kid in handcuffs. But then again, maybe it's just some stupid protocol that the police thought they were following. Note also that Ahmed seemed to have immediate access to a picture of himself in handcuffs. Who took that picture? Why did the police allow such a picture be taken? Did they really not allow him to call his parents? I don't know the answer to these questions, but most of the police's detractors seem to believe they do.


I vociferously disagree. I don't care that it was an unimpressive engineering feat. I don't judge 14 year olds based on the quality of their work in their spare time.

I wasn't judging him. I was judging his actions in this particular instance. In any case, I have no problem judging him based on what I've seen. From what I've seen, he is a very personable and confident teenager, who appears to enjoy the limelight. There is no evidence of any particular aptitude for science or engineering. There is actually evidence to the contrary given that he thought putting a clock in a box was worthy of showing his teachers.

<snip>

Who cares? Seriously. Why does this matter at all?

If you don't care, and it doesn't matter, why are you reading, let alone posting, in this thread? It matters because it became a viral sensation, and it led to scorn being heaped on school and police officials trying to do their job as they saw it. It matters because maybe next time school and police officials will be discouraged from acting proactively to remove what they see as potential threats to safety or classroom discipline. That could be a good thing. Or maybe it could be a bad thing. But I would hope the consequences are actually commensurate with the objective facts of the case, rather than the spin and clutter that have obscured this case from the beginning.
 
Last edited:
If he put it into an aluminum case in order to make it look like a bomb, he failed, because it doesn't look like a bomb. It looks like a clock in a pencil case.

I think you are either lying to yourself or us. It obviously looks like a bomb, out of a film. LCD display, wires, aluminium case...

These people seem to think that way too:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xc_Rh3dPLVQ

I don't know how smart Ahmed is. Based on news reports I've read, he's pretty smart. This particular project, he said, took about 20 minutes to do, but he has done others that required more effort.

Well, that´s 11:30 minutes too much, have a look at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHk_6Vh4Qeo
 
Last edited:
One thing I've mentioned several times that is also ignored, is that one of the reasons I'm fairly confident that Ahmed was only suspended for disrupting the learning environment or something equivalent and NOT bringing a hoax bomb to school is this

His parents have not allowed the school to release the details of the suspension to the public.

Even if they didn't want to sign a release form and open up Ahmed's history, they surely have a copy of the note explaining the suspension.

Why haven't they shown this to the public?


In my opinion it's because it would get in the way of the narrative of "Muslim Kid accused of being a terrorist and making a hoax bomb" if the actual report said something like this


Ahmed has a history of doing disruptive pranks, like the bubbles in the bathroom incident. Setting off the alarm clock in the classroom was another disruption and bringing in homemade electronic devices for the purpose of disrupting the class is not allowed.

Suspended for three days.
 
Last edited:
If you don't care, and it doesn't matter, why are you reading, let alone posting, in this thread? It matters because it became a viral sensation, and it led to scorn being heaped on school and police officials trying to do their job as they saw it. It matters because maybe next time school and police officials will be discouraged from acting proactively to remove what they see as potential threats to safety or classroom discipline. That could be a good thing. Or maybe it could be a bad thing. But I would hope the consequences are actually commensurate with the objective facts of the case, rather than the spin and clutter that have obscured this case from the beginning.

The point about "who cares?" and "why does it matter?" is that some people have accuse Ahmed of deliberately doing something to attract attention.

All right, that is a possibility. Maybe he was deliberately doing something with the purpose of showing that the police were idiotic islamophobes. He was trolling them. He made something that did not look like a bomb. However, he made something that looked like something that was supposed to make people think that he had made something that looked like a bomb. (Yes, that sentence actually parses correctly, and contains only the descriptions necessary to explain the behavior of which he is suspected.)

Well, if that was his intention:

1. It isn't illegal, so he shouldn't have been arrested and
2. It worked. The police looked like idiotic islamophobes.
 
I think you are either lying to yourself or us. It obviously looks like a bomb, out of a film. LCD display, wires, aluminium case...

These people seem to think that way too:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xc_Rh3dPLVQ



Well, that´s 11:30 minutes too much, have a look at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHk_6Vh4Qeo

Actual bombs do not typically resemble those seen in the movies. A Google image search for "improvised explosive device" turns up mostly the following types of images:

ied-2.jpg


aside-2-ieds.jpg


iraq_roadside_bomb.jpg


ied-a.jpg


By contrast, a movie style bomb looks much more polished and put together:

dynamite1-large.jpg


maxresdefault.jpg


FKWXFE7GQOPTSD5.LARGE.jpg


Point being, people who actually know what bombs look like in real life and not according to the movies would never mistake Ahmed's retooled clock for a bomb.

(edited to put spoiler tags around the largest images; didn't realize they were so big)
 
Last edited:
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom