Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I have to say that it's dispiriting to put forth rebuttals in this thread and simply have them go in one ear and out the other (or eye, I guess, in this case). In a country of 320 million people, overreaction by the teachers, principals, and even the security officers (i.e. the police assigned to the school) probably happens dozens of times per year (if not, per week) in high schools. You just don't hear about it. If it happened to my kid, I can guarantee that you would not be hearing about it. I would not rush to the media and try to get as much attention as possible. I would pursue it through the established legal channels (which are highly developed and generally responsive). But even if I did rush to the media, nobody would give a crap. The left-wing media doesn't care about my child's ethnicity because it doesn't fit their preferred narrative of oppression (although, ironically, that ethnicity is a blend of two ethnic groups which have suffered substantial institutional racism in the US).

Ahmed's ethnicity in no way explains the response of the school and police to his little stunt. It explains everything about the response to the response, though.

And?
 
Well if your arguments make no sense and no one buys your "teaching teachers" crap and then suddenly remembering you've got kids the same colour as the kid in question is getting any traction, you can always just keep shouting racist at everyone until they go away. And then you've won I suppose? Maybe capitalize random words more that should do it.

Well, I don't think truethat made that up. However I do think it might, er, colour, if you will, her interpretation of this event.
 
And what would you call these wild generalizations without evidence?

For the record, I have already shown that the mayor did not engage in some wacky anti-Muslim campaign. In response to news that a Sharia-based arbitration service would be set up in her city, she expressed concern and then support for a proposed state law that would nullify any ruling by any religious arbitration that conflicts with the Texas constitution. For that, she was viciously attacked as an Islamophobe, which then of course turned into something of a self-fulfilling battle with Muslim activists. Most of the battle was about defending herself from accusations of being an Islamophobe.



It's funny after reading all this. Earlier in the thread I mentioned a situation where a girl sprayed pepper spray going up a flight of stairs in a very small school. She got suspended and my son had to "testify" at her School Board meeting because he was in the hallway.

The girl was a Muslim Hijabi girl (head covered) No one EVER tried to portray it as a "terrorist" act. I mean it's ridiculous she was a kid who did something stupid.

I can't fathom why someone would LEAP to the idea that the school thought Ahmed was trying to pull off a terrorist attack or mention 911 when it's been glaringly obvious to me from day one that if they DID think he was doing a hoax bomb etc. it would be related to the School Shootings going around.

I seriously don't understand this mindset. And I also feel your pain of in one eye and out the other.


:cool:
 
Last edited:
Well, I don't think truethat made that up. However I do think it might, er, colour, if you will, her interpretation of this event.

I agree with this. I also have to laugh at the insinuation that I've "suddenly came up with two Muslim kids"

I've posted on this site about my kids for YEARS.:rolleyes:
 
I agree with this. I also have to laugh at the insinuation that I've "suddenly came up with two Muslim kids"

I've posted on this site about my kids for YEARS.:rolleyes:

Sure you have. It's in those posts where you talk about your job teaching teachers. I bet you run a multicultural clock building class in your spare time so you'll have an anecdote that really happened that perfectly dovetails with your argument as well. :rolleyes:
 
Ahmed's ethnicity in no way explains the response of the school and police to his little stunt. It explains everything about the response to the response, though.

Ahmed's ethnicity explains everything about the response of the school and police.

That doesn't mean it's the only possible explanation.


As I said, when there is bizarre behavior, people try to find an explanation. Islamophobia is one possible explanation. There are other possible explanations. As I have said throughout most of this thread, I think that technophobia and a distrust of weird, geeky, electronics lovers played a significant role in the incident. Islamophobia may be a secondary or reinforcing element.

Of course, we can never know the true answer, because we have insufficient data. Anything we say about why it happened s necessarily speculative.
 
Ahmed's ethnicity explains everything about the response of the school and police.

No, it actually explains very little. If they had actually thought he was a jihadist planning to commit a terrorist act, the focus of the interrogation would probably be on whether he had been radicalized or whether he hated the school or the city or his classmates. The interrogation would probably also have focused on whether he had accomplices, and whether he had been in contact with like-minded individuals on the internet. We don't know specifically what was asked and answered in the interrogation, but there hasn't been any public hint that the questioning followed along the lines of the police being suspicious of a jihadist connection. I'm pretty sure we would have heard about it, if it had happened.

<snip>

As I said, when there is bizarre behavior, people try to find an explanation. Islamophobia is one possible explanation. There are other possible explanations. As I have said throughout most of this thread, I think that technophobia and a distrust of weird, geeky, electronics lovers played a significant role in the incident. Islamophobia may be a secondary or reinforcing element.

And my point is that what you think is bizarre behavior isn't so bizarre. You just think it's bizarre because of availability bias. It only gets brought to your attention when certain elements of such behavior align with a preferred media narrative.

Of course, we can never know the true answer, because we have insufficient data. Anything we say about why it happened s necessarily speculative.

Not anything. We can say that Ahmed did not build anything praiseworthy, and that he also intentionally brought attention to his device in a second class, despite his teacher in the first class telling him to put it away and not show it to anybody else. We can also say that the family was extremely quick to run to the media with the story and has milked it long and hard. Drawing conclusions from those facts is speculative, but I think an objective analysis would lead one to be considerably more skeptical of Ahmed's side of the story than the media have been.
 
I don´t know why you keep talking about islamophobia and stuff, when the whole thing looks like an agitprop stunt plotted by Ahmed´s father, who, it is claimed, has a histroy of similar publicity-seeking acts.

Ahmed didn´t "invent " a clock, just took one out of its case and made it look like bomb out of a cheesy film:

http://blogs.artvoice.com/techvoice...gineering-ahmed-mohameds-clock-and-ourselves/

The fact that the whole thing has been media-silenced since geeks reverse-engineered the "bomb" makes this view more and more believable as time goes by. I mean, where are the pitures of Ahmed and Obama in the White House visit? I think they realised of how foolish they were in inviting him over and now they just want everyone to forget about it...

(I haven´t read this whole thread, only half a dozen pages but I haven´t seen this addressed)
 
The two aren't mutually-exclusive.

No, but if it was a publicity stunt annd Ahmed behaved provocatively in order to be detained, asked to put handcuffs on for the photo, lied about his motives etc. it wouldn´t be a case of islamophobia. Quite the opposite.
 
No, but if it was a publicity stunt annd Ahmed behaved provocatively in order to be detained, asked to put handcuffs on for the photo, lied about his motives etc. it wouldn´t be a case of islamophobia. Quite the opposite.

There's a difference between suspecting that the father may have pushed his son to bring the contraption to school to goad them to overreact, and the over-the-top utter speculation you wrote here.
 
There's a difference between suspecting that the father may have pushed his son to bring the contraption to school to goad them to overreact, and the over-the-top utter speculation you wrote here.

What??? What did I speculate about apart from "suspecting that the father may have pushed his son to bring the contraption to school to goad them to overreact" That Obama may be kicking himself for inviting Ahmed to the White House too quickly before knowing that it was all a stunt?
 
No, it actually explains very little. If they had actually thought he was a jihadist planning to commit a terrorist act, the focus of the interrogation would probably be on whether he had been radicalized or whether he hated the school or the city or his classmates. The interrogation would probably also have focused on whether he had accomplices, and whether he had been in contact with like-minded individuals on the internet. We don't know specifically what was asked and answered in the interrogation, but there hasn't been any public hint that the questioning followed along the lines of the police being suspicious of a jihadist connection. I'm pretty sure we would have heard about it, if it had happened.

I am extremely confident that we would not have heard about it, because the policy is to not release that information. All we know is that Ahmed is accused of being "passive-aggressive" during questioning. We know nothing about what they asked, other than vague reports that he was asked what it was, "a clock" and why he brought it to school. (Answer unknown. Later he would say it was to show his engineering teacher.)





And my point is that what you think is bizarre behavior isn't so bizarre. You just think it's bizarre because of availability bias. It only gets brought to your attention when certain elements of such behavior align with a preferred media narrative.

As noted earlier, we can compare it to our experience as students, as parents, or in some cases as educators. No one seems to have any comparable experience with any such event. The arrest was bizarre.



Not anything. We can say that Ahmed did not build anything praiseworthy,

I vociferously disagree. I don't care that it was an unimpressive engineering feat. I don't judge 14 year olds based on the quality of their work in their spare time.



and that he also intentionally brought attention to his device in a second class, despite his teacher in the first class telling him to put it away and not show it to anybody else.

True. A normal reaction to this would not involve an arrest. Even a three day suspension would seem extreme, but we do not know if, possibly, there is more to that aspect of the story.

We can also say that the family was extremely quick to run to the media with the story and has milked it long and hard.

Who cares? Seriously. Why does this matter at all?

I have agreed with you in the past that he could easily have been "trolling" the school. Let us suppose, for the sake of argument, that he was. Who cares? How does it make any difference at all? Trolling isn't even against the membership agreement, much less against the law. Why should anyone care?

He made a clock. He told people it was a clock. He was arrested for a hoax bomb. That makes no sense, trolling or no trolling.
 
Sure you have. It's in those posts where you talk about your job teaching teachers. I bet you run a multicultural clock building class in your spare time so you'll have an anecdote that really happened that perfectly dovetails with your argument as well. :rolleyes:

Your post sounds like someone making an ass out of themselves considering how many people actually know what I do for a living.

It also underscores to those people why I feel the need to keep it anonymous because of ******** who will probably try to troll the business.

;)

Or you could think that "Geeeee I wonder.......do ya think MAYBEEEEE this is why she is so interested in this particular topic?"

Nahhhhh couldn't be.



"Suddenly remembered", which is even more insulting, I think.


Well I do confess that sometimes when they drive me crazy I try to forget them!!!
 
Last edited:
Not even google knew about that! (At least I couln´t find it)

If this blog is right (http://blogs.artvoice.com/techvoice...gineering-ahmed-mohameds-clock-and-ourselves/) it will be quite awkward for him to meet with the geeks that supposedly will attend the Astronomy Night...

When I typed in "Ahmed astronomy night" (without the quotes), this was the first link that came up: https://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2015/09/16/we-stand-ahmed-and-we-hope-hell-join-us-astronomy-night
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom