Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Actually, the word does matter. From what I understand, the first hates or discriminates against a specific ethnic group, or certain ethnic groups in general, while the latter makes issues ones of race unjustifiably. There's a big difference there.


Wikipedia-
Racialism is the belief that the human species is naturally divided into distinct biological categories called "races."

Free dictionary-
a person with a prejudiced belief that one race is superior to others. racist. bigot - a prejudiced person who is intolerant of any opinions differing from his own.

Miriam Webster-
a theory that race determines human traits and capacities; also : racism
​
Explain to me how this applies to recognizing that other people can base their behavior on bigoted beliefs.

The contention here is that seeing a possibility that some actions may be based on bigoted or racist beliefs means a priori that that person must be a racist.

No one seems to have done anything more to further that claim than whip out another word and misapply it.

Not impressed. It smacks more of the sort of lame crap that racists use to excuse and conceal their behavior while trying to pretend that racism ... real racism and bigotry where people are mistreated because of their ethnic or religious backgrounds ... doesn't exist or has somehow gone away.

"Oh. I'm not the racist. You are."

What a load of bull hockey.
 
Belz... has already addressed the distinction between racism and attributing racism as a cause.

I don't think it is intrinsically racialist to ask whether racism played a part, especially where precedent or context suggests it. I do think it's racialist to prefer a racist explanation without more than circumstantial evidence.


Not by any normal, conventional use of the word.

Of course, if you're going to decide that words mean whatever you want them to mean then communication is going to get a bit rocky.

Not sure how you weasel "prefer" into there. Cute try, though.
 
Your position seems to be that it is intrinsically racist to recognize the simple fact that racists and racist behavior exist.

No it's not, and I'm not going to continue this derail. I've asked you a SIMPLE question and several other people the same one.


Sure it is. I won't even bother quoting you anymore. Everyone else can read for themselves, and it is obvious what you said and what you meant.

And, as usual, the derail is your own. As usual, you decide it's a "derail" when you start looking too silly to keep going.

Nice backpedal, though. No messing around. Just denial.

<snip>
(It's like it hasn't registered to so many that Texas isn't made up of tons of white people. A large Hispanic population lives in Texas. You don't even know the race of the teacher involved and you are just jumping the gun.)


Are you saying that someone with a Hispanic background can't be prejudiced?

Interesting.

<snip>http://www.irvingisd.net/domain/1671

Your presumption is based SOLELY on the race of the child.


Nope. I'm basing my assessment on his ethnic and religious background and the clearly demonstrated hostility of the community in which he lives to people with such a background.

Treating the child like a LABEL and presuming that people will all respond to the label that you use to identify him is racist in my opinion.


Good thing I'm not doing that.

And you've pretty much demonstrated what your opinion is worth.

You can't even keep your accusations straight. When you get called on them you start backpedaling.


You've further posited that my son has lead a "sheltered life" and that the minute he gets out of this "Special Environment" everyone else will treat him poorly.

Meanwhile he's 22 and has traveled all through the south, North and South Carolina, Maryland, Florida, Georgia, Arizona, LA and also to Canada, England and France and he's never been mistreated for looking like an Arab Muslim.

<snip>


So he's led a sheltered life for twenty two years.

Good for him. I hope his luck holds.

Shall we start collecting the stories of people who haven't been so lucky? We can start with the Sikhs who were beaten for looking like Arabs when McVeigh blew up the Murrah Building. That was pre-9/11, so people weren't quite so quick to jump to conclusions.
 
Your comments are racist. Especially about my son. I don't mind continuing the discussion about Ahmed (his name is not Abdul, why don't you just call him Ahab the Arab and be done with it) but I think the conversation about my son is off topic and derailing.

So back to the actual topic?


I notice in the break down you didn't once answer the question that I've repeatedly asked you.

What actions did the Teacher and School take because he was a Dark skinned Muslim?

In fact it's funny. In my opinion it's actually strange that they called the cops on him. I think it would have been a much more serious reaction if some "emo" white kid did the same thing.

So where exactly does the "racism" come into it? Or is it just that you "dated a black girl in high school" and feel like you get to wear that like a badge of honor for the rest of your life and decide other people's life experiences for them?



Your posts remind me of this Mad TV clip. LOL

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JaewfHk9KiA
 
Last edited:
Your comments are racist. Especially about my son. I don't mind continuing the discussion about Ahmed (his name is not Abdul, why don't you just call him Ahab the Arab and be done with it) but I think the conversation about my son is off topic and derailing.

<snip>


Then why do you keep bringing him up?

Nice job not replying, by the way.

Keep up the good work.
 
I think people jump to the conclusion that racism/islamophobia was involved here because, when encountering bizarre behavior, people try to seek an explanation.

The arrest of a boy who made a clock is bizarre behavior.

That particular explanation fits all the available evidence.

No one will ever admit, "We were suspicious of him because he was a Muslim.", so there will never be any way to confirm that Islamophobia played a role in the arrest. Also, the number of similar incidents is so small, i.e. zero, that we can't even get a statistical verification. We are stuck with speculation to explain the motive.
 
I think people jump to the conclusion that racism/islamophobia was involved here because, when encountering bizarre behavior, people try to seek an explanation.

The arrest of a boy who made a clock is bizarre behavior.

That particular explanation fits all the available evidence.

No one will ever admit, "We were suspicious of him because he was a Muslim.", so there will never be any way to confirm that Islamophobia played a role in the arrest. Also, the number of similar incidents is so small, i.e. zero, that we can't even get a statistical verification. We are stuck with speculation to explain the motive.


And of course we can't take into account that the entire town admires and encourages their mayor when she takes time off to engage in wacky anti-Mulim campaigns?

I suspect that would be "racist", too.
 
I think people jump to the conclusion that racism/islamophobia was involved here because, when encountering bizarre behavior, people try to seek an explanation.

The arrest of a boy who made a clock is bizarre behavior.

That particular explanation fits all the available evidence.

No one will ever admit, "We were suspicious of him because he was a Muslim.", so there will never be any way to confirm that Islamophobia played a role in the arrest. Also, the number of similar incidents is so small, i.e. zero, that we can't even get a statistical verification. We are stuck with speculation to explain the motive.



Seriously this is the kind of comment that seems racist to me.

First of all there have been a LOT of school shootings lately and public shootings where bombs were set off.

In almost ALL of these cases WHITE KIDS did it.

So I don't see how the school would act any differently if a white kid did it. I think it has more to do with protocol, rules, overreacting principals etc. in calling the police.

But none of this has anything to do with Ahmed being Muslim. Because you guys can't get past that you perpetuate racism.

I'm still waiting to hear why they wouldn't have reacted the same way if they thought a white kid brought a hoax bomb to school.

It's fake grandstanding and patronizing. The fact that we have to back to PRE 911 beating up Sikhs (who are not Muslim btw, what kind of stupid comment is that) to rationalize why a school principal would have called the cops for an electronic device brought to school.

Again, WHERE DOES 911 come into this? Where does "terrorism" come into this? The majority of school shootings have been done by WHITE KIDS

Muslim terrorism has nothing to do with it. The fact that y'all can't wrap your mind around that it most likely had to do with "School Shootings" and not 911 shows how you can't see this kid as a regular high school student.

In your minds you associate him with Muslim terrorism. Not teenagers shooting up schools.

That's freaky weird racism right there. Sorry.:confused:
 
Seriously this is the kind of comment that seems racist to me.

<snip>


Of course it does.

It seems like nearly everything seems like racism to you.

You might want to get some help for that.

It's fake grandstanding and patronizing. The fact that we have to back to PRE 911 beating up Sikhs (who are not Muslim btw,


No kidding. Good catch. That was sort of the point. Anti-Muslim prejudice is that pervasive.

Get it yet?

what kind of stupid comment is that) to rationalize why a school principal would have called the cops for an electronic device brought to school.

Again, WHERE DOES 911 come into this? Where does "terrorism" come into this?


I don't believe you can ask that question seriously.

The majority of school shootings have been done by WHITE KIDS

Muslim terrorism has nothing to do with it. The fact that y'all can't wrap your mind around that it most likely had to do with "School Shootings" and not 911 shows how you can't see this kid as a regular high school student.


You must not pay much attention to the news. Whenever something even marginally bomb related happens the Islamophobes come out of the woodwork like cockroaches. They don't even need an Arabic sounding name to get cranked up. That's just icing on the cake for them.

You need to get out more.

Or at least quit pretending that you're really clueless.

In your minds you associate him with Muslim terrorism. Not teenagers shooting up schools.


It wasn't a not-a-fake-gun, you know. It was a not-a-fake-bomb.

Bombs and Muslims are associated with terrorists by a lot more than the minds of people in this thread.

That's freaky weird racism right there. Sorry.:confused:


I associate him with some kid who was mistreated by the system.

Given certain facts it is not unreasonable to surmise what the cause may have been.

No.

That isn't racism.

Not by any remotely sane definition, anyhow.
 
You guys are the ones associating it with "Terrorism" and "911"

Anyone with a modicum of common sense would realize that it was more likely if the school was worried that they were thinking along the lines of a "school shooting" type prank.

The fact that you automatically think they reacted because of 911 and terrorism SHOWS the racist nature of your comments.

I know you still won't get it but it's pretty damn obvious.

Thank you for proving my point.
 
Wikipedia-
Racialism is the belief that the human species is naturally divided into distinct biological categories called "races."​


Well, truethat quoted from another dictionary with a different definition. Now you post your own. We can play these games all day and get nowhere. Why not use the definition that the word's user uses and agree that this is what it means in the context of this discussion and move on?​
 
Well if your arguments make no sense and no one buys your "teaching teachers" crap and then suddenly remembering you've got kids the same colour as the kid in question is getting any traction, you can always just keep shouting racist at everyone until they go away. And then you've won I suppose? Maybe capitalize random words more that should do it.
 
I think people jump to the conclusion that racism/islamophobia was involved here because, when encountering bizarre behavior, people try to seek an explanation.

The arrest of a boy who made a clock is bizarre behavior.

That particular explanation fits all the available evidence.

No one will ever admit, "We were suspicious of him because he was a Muslim.", so there will never be any way to confirm that Islamophobia played a role in the arrest. Also, the number of similar incidents is so small, i.e. zero, that we can't even get a statistical verification. We are stuck with speculation to explain the motive.

I have to say that it's dispiriting to put forth rebuttals in this thread and simply have them go in one ear and out the other (or eye, I guess, in this case). In a country of 320 million people, overreaction by the teachers, principals, and even the security officers (i.e. the police assigned to the school) probably happens dozens of times per year (if not, per week) in high schools. You just don't hear about it. If it happened to my kid, I can guarantee that you would not be hearing about it. I would not rush to the media and try to get as much attention as possible. I would pursue it through the established legal channels (which are highly developed and generally responsive). But even if I did rush to the media, nobody would give a crap. The left-wing media doesn't care about my child's ethnicity because it doesn't fit their preferred narrative of oppression (although, ironically, that ethnicity is a blend of two ethnic groups which have suffered substantial institutional racism in the US).

Ahmed's ethnicity in no way explains the response of the school and police to his little stunt. It explains everything about the response to the response, though.
 
Well if your arguments make no sense and no one buys your "teaching teachers" crap and then suddenly remembering you've got kids the same colour as the kid in question is getting any traction, you can always just keep shouting racist at everyone until they go away. And then you've won I suppose? Maybe capitalize random words more that should do it.

Right I'm LYING LMAO That's always a clever reply.
 
Last edited:
And of course we can't take into account that the entire town admires and encourages their mayor when she takes time off to engage in wacky anti-Mulim campaigns?

I suspect that would be "racist", too.

And what would you call these wild generalizations without evidence?

For the record, I have already shown that the mayor did not engage in some wacky anti-Muslim campaign. In response to news that a Sharia-based arbitration service would be set up in her city, she expressed concern and then support for a proposed state law that would nullify any ruling by any religious arbitration that conflicts with the Texas constitution. For that, she was viciously attacked as an Islamophobe, which then of course turned into something of a self-fulfilling battle with Muslim activists. Most of the battle was about defending herself from accusations of being an Islamophobe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom