Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I don't agree. And you've just once again proven my point.

Solely based on what my son looks like you have indicated that he will be discriminated against and treated differently.

That to me is racist. I have tried for years to keep people with such sentiments as far away from him as possible when growing up. That's why I laughed before at the idea that you somehow think you are on Ahmed's side. :rolleyes:


Your position seems to be that it is intrinsically racist to recognize the simple fact that racists and racist behavior exist.

Do you have any idea how silly that is?

It is not necessary at all, even a little bit, for me to be racist to be aware that other people are and act on their prejudices as a result.

I see evidence of such behavior often. I grew up seeing it, and when I had a black girlfriend in high school I experienced it first hand.

It is obvious that you have no idea what you are talking about and live in some sort of cotton candy and sugar plum version of reality.

Or ... you are simply being disingenuous for the purpose of trying to bolster your position in this discussion.

Neither reflects well on you.
 
I see you added to your post.


<snip>

Here's another example.


I'm shopping with a friend of mind who is black and another "well meaning white chick" The black chick comes out of the store annoyed. "The stupid sales girl was up my ass the entire time I was in there!"

The "well meaning white chick" "Why did she think you were trying to shoplift? What a ***** "

Black chick "No she saw my expensive bag and thought she was going to get a big commission out of me, why would you think she thought I was shoplifting?"

The "well meaning white chick" "Well because you're black, and you know how "those people" think that you shoplift, she's probably a racist."


Um........no errrrr......who's the racist here?


Pretty easy to construct examples out of thin air, isn't it.

What you seem to be overlooking is that such a scenario wouldn't be possible if it wasn't for the fact that such suspicions are relatively common, and your pretend outcome has no impact if that was not the case.

In other words, it proves the point you are trying to argue against.
 

(link)
​
Not sure how this relates. Aside from the probability that someone who engages in bigotry based on perceived racial differences is probably a "racialist"

Someone recognizing that bigotry exists and that some people do actually behave that way may not be, and probably isn't. Otherwise they wouldn't consider it bigotry.

Would you go into more depth as to what your intended meaning is please? It isn't clear from context.

I think this cite from your source is closer to what I had in mind:

While [Nelson] Mandela, like the others, is clearly not racist, he also must be counted as racialist, because his struggle against apartheid was predicated on the race-based solidarity of those who were enslaved, based on race, under the system of apartheid: you cannot fight racism without introducing race as a predicate of your action.​

I.e., that racialism is the practice of introducing race as a predicate of your argument. An example of a racialist argument would be something like: The kid is black, therefore the reaction to his behavior must be race-based or racist in nature.

Or, as you so sarcastically put it:

There is no racism anymore. Or any ethnic or religious prejudice either.

Especially in small Texas towns.

Anyone who suggests there might be is obviously a racist bigot.

Though I would say "racialist bigot" -- unless they can substantiate their insinuation of a racist motive, of course. So I should probably have directed my question at you, not Belz...:

Are you [quadraginta] ... asserting that there is racism in the action?​
 
Well, one definition of racism, or at least bigotry, is using a generalization about a group based on ethnicity (statistically justified or not) and applying it to the individual - usually in a pejorative sense.

Despite the fact that the mods here don't seem to think that an accusation of racism is sufficiently derogatory to merit a Rule 12 violation, it is in fact considered a serious insult by normal people. Therefore, assuming a person of a certain ethnicity is a racist, simply because of his ethnicity, would in fact be bigoted.

Of course bigotry is not just confined to ethnicity. There can be regional and geographic bigotry as well. I think we've seen quite a bit of it in this thread with respect to Irving, Texas, despite the fact that it is a diverse city, and the school district and the police must have considerable experience interacting with people of every conceivable culture and hue.
 
Well, well, turns out Clock Boy's dad is also a 9-11 Truther:

Al Qaeda’s attack on September 11, 2001 is a recurring topic of discussion on Mohammed’s own Arabic-language National Reform Party Facebook page where—beside photos of his family enjoying their newfound fame—are posted articles, photos and videos featuring both implicit, and explicit claims that the 9/11 attacks were a US-sponsored hoax to launch a war against Islam and Muslims.
 
Well, well, turns out Clock Boy's dad is also a 9-11 Truther:

Not saying that it's wrong, but the tone of the article is anything but objective fact-based journalism, the home page has a column of articles that are basically "Prominent Democrat Sucks". There are literally three anti hilary articles, that would be stacked up in a row if they weren't broken up by an attack on Planned Parenthood.

These are not the people I trust to bring me a factual translation and contextual reading of a facebook post in a language I don't speak.
 
Your position seems to be that it is intrinsically racist to recognize the simple fact that racists and racist behavior exist.

No it's not, and I'm not going to continue this derail. I've asked you a SIMPLE question and several other people the same one.

I have NEVER gotten an answer.

What actions did the SCHOOL and the TEACHER do that indicated to you they reacted this way because he was a "dark skinned Muslim"

(It's like it hasn't registered to so many that Texas isn't made up of tons of white people. A large Hispanic population lives in Texas. You don't even know the race of the teacher involved and you are just jumping the gun.)

How do you know the teacher isn't Arab or Persian, Black? Or Mexican?

You don't.

Here's the list of the school administrators. As you can see they are all honkin' white cowboys with their KKK flags waving behind them.


http://www.irvingisd.net/domain/2031


Here is a list of the English teachers.

http://www.irvingisd.net/domain/1671

Your presumption is based SOLELY on the race of the child. Treating the child like a LABEL and presuming that people will all respond to the label that you use to identify him is racist in my opinion.

You've further posited that my son has lead a "sheltered life" and that the minute he gets out of this "Special Environment" everyone else will treat him poorly.

Meanwhile he's 22 and has traveled all through the south, North and South Carolina, Maryland, Florida, Georgia, Arizona, LA and also to Canada, England and France and he's never been mistreated for looking like an Arab Muslim.





Do you have any idea how silly that is?

It is not necessary at all, even a little bit, for me to be racist to be aware that other people are and act on their prejudices as a result.

I see evidence of such behavior often. I grew up seeing it, and when I had a black girlfriend in high school I experienced it first hand.


Great, so yet again IN THIS SITUATION what ACTIONS did the Principal and teacher take to indicate to you that they were behaving in such a way that demonstrated that they were treating Ahmed differently because he was a "dark skinned Muslim"


You really have no idea how incredibly racist your comments are. Do you? Right down to the "some of my best friends are black" canard. LOL

SMDH

I won't be responding to your reply but I'm sure others would like to read it.
 
Last edited:
I think this cite from your source is closer to what I had in mind:
While [Nelson] Mandela, like the others, is clearly not racist, he also must be counted as racialist, because his struggle against apartheid was predicated on the race-based solidarity of those who were enslaved, based on race, under the system of apartheid: you cannot fight racism without introducing race as a predicate of your action.​
I.e., that racialism is the practice of introducing race as a predicate of your argument. An example of a racialist argument would be something like: The kid is black, therefore the reaction to his behavior must be race-based or racist in nature.


There's where the flaw in your proposition lies.

Or, as you so sarcastically put it:



Though I would say "racialist bigot" -- unless they can substantiate their insinuation of a racist motive, of course. So I should probably have directed my question at you, not Belz...:
Are you [quadraginta] ... asserting that there is racism in the action?​


I was asserting that it was very likely.

This is based not only on the circumstances of the incident itself but as well on known behaviors apparently supported by the town as a whole.

A mayor who is hunting face time trying to campaign against a non-existent threat of "sharia law".

TT's position is that the very idea that any racial or ethnic bigotry could possibly be involved is totally impossible, and that anyone who even suggests that such a thing might be involved is therefore a racist.

Now we are playing word games. "Racist" -"Racialist". The word doesn't matter. What does is the claim that simply recognizing the existence of such behavior means that you "must be" practicing it.

Do you think it is intrinsically racist to suspect that there might have been racism and/or bigotry involved in the way Abdul was treated?
 
Last edited:
There's where the flaw in your proposition lies.




I was asserting that it was very likely.

This is based not only on the circumstances of the incident itself but as well on known behaviors apparently supported by the town as a whole.

A mayor who is hunting face time trying to campaign against a non-existent threat of "sharia law".

TT's position is that the very idea that any racial or ethnic bigotry could possibly be involved is totally impossible, and that anyone who even suggests that such a thing might be involved is therefore a racist.

Now we are playing word games. "Racist" -"Racialist". The word doesn't matter. What does is the claim that simply recognizing the existence of such behavior means that you "must be" practicing it.

Do you think it is intrinsically racist to suspect that there might have been racism and/or bigotry involved in the way Abdul was treated?

Yes.

For example it isn't racist to say that Dylan Roof was motivated by racism.

Nor is it racist to say that the stop and search and arrest rates in many US police forces (e.g. Ferguson, MO) have racial discrimination, and that the staff have demonstrated documented racist behaviour.

It is hard to prove any single instance is due to discrimination unless the perpetrator proclaims it, but many legal systems recognise this.
 
What does the MAYOR have to do with what the TEACHER and the PRINCIPAL and the school did?

Answer a direct question


What ACTIONS did the SCHOOL, Teacher or Principal DO that indicate to you that they were motivated because he was a dark skinned Muslim? Please answer the question


Also stop asserting what I mean when you clearly do not understand my point.
 
Last edited:
The school called the police. They had no reason to suppose it was a hoax bomb. Their behaviour showed they didn't think it was a threat.

The police then arrested him, and didn't let him speak to his parents - which looks pretty dodgy.

It would be nice to think that the school and police would be this maliciously incompetent with WASP kids, but both have certainly behaved in a manner that means they need to explain why they think their behaviour was not based on prejudice.

Even if they treat white kids this badly, it still doesn't negate the fact that they have been documented as treating Ahmed badly.
 
The school called the police.

You concede that they didn't think it was a hoax bomb. They called the police because they were following protocol.

Then you, like has been done ENDLESSLY in this thread, lay out what the POLICE did to Ahmed.

We've gone over this a bazillion times already. The cops may have been racist.

But what did the TEACHER or SCHOOL do that indicates they reacted this way because he was a "dark skinned Muslim"

If the school called the police because they are overreactive ********, it's got NOTHING to do with his skin color.

Here's a review of the school written in MAY earlier this year. Although you won't see anything about the principal being racist, you do see that he seems to be willing to call the cops pretty quickly.

Posted May 22, 2015
- a parent This school has gone from a 10 to a 1 in a matter of 9 months. I blame this 100% on the new Principal. This school is run like a military camp, with horrible food, unrealistic rules, and all 'fun' activities taken away. They are threatened with court and jail if they are tardy. Theft is so rampant at this school that it is unbelievable. AP History teachers give several hours of notes each night, instead of actually TEACHING while they are in class, which means no time for their core class homework or sports. They refuse, and I mean refuse to let your child out of AP, even when you have signed several slips for this to happen. Teachers obviously set you up to fail. They just don't care. This is true for 50% of the teachers at this school. And don't report bullying. Your child will be blamed instead of the child who is actually doing the bullying. And the parent is put down as well. We just don't report theft or bullying anymore. Not worth the humiliation and disrespect that the 'fine' staff at Mac makes sure you endure.




I swear to god I don't understand how people function in the world these days. What is so freakin' difficult about the question?

LOL
 
Last edited:
The school called the police.

You concede that they didn't think it was a hoax bomb. They called the police because they were following protocol.

Then you, like has been done ENDLESSLY in this thread, lay out what the POLICE did to Ahmed.

We've gone over this a bazillion times already. The cops may have been racist.

But what did the TEACHER or SCHOOL do that indicates they reacted this way because he was a "dark skinned Muslim"

If the school called the police because they are overreactive ********, it's got NOTHING to do with his skin color.

Here's a review of the school written in MAY earlier this year. Although you won't see anything about the principal being racist, you do see that he seems to be willing to call the cops pretty quickly.






I swear to god I don't understand how people function in the world these days. What is so freakin' difficult about the question?

LOL
I don't think that highlighted part means what you think it means.


If the school had had reasonable grounds for believing that it was a hoax bomb, then, depending on circumstances, it might have been appropriate. There were no reasonable grounds for that belief, so their actions were unreasonable.

You keep saying that the school followed protocol, but a threat wasn't made, and there was no reason to believe that there was a threat. No protocol is going to require action for a non-existent threat that nobody made.
 
What action did the school do to Ahmed because he was a 'dark skinned Muslim" that they would not have done to a white kid?
 
Now we are playing word games. "Racist" -"Racialist". The word doesn't matter. What does is the claim that simply recognizing the existence of such behavior means that you "must be" practicing it.

Actually, the word does matter. From what I understand, the first hates or discriminates against a specific ethnic group, or certain ethnic groups in general, while the latter makes issues ones of race unjustifiably. There's a big difference there.
 
There's where the flaw in your proposition lies.




I was asserting that it was very likely.

This is based not only on the circumstances of the incident itself but as well on known behaviors apparently supported by the town as a whole.

A mayor who is hunting face time trying to campaign against a non-existent threat of "sharia law".

TT's position is that the very idea that any racial or ethnic bigotry could possibly be involved is totally impossible, and that anyone who even suggests that such a thing might be involved is therefore a racist.

Now we are playing word games. "Racist" -"Racialist". The word doesn't matter. What does is the claim that simply recognizing the existence of such behavior means that you "must be" practicing it.

Do you think it is intrinsically racist to suspect that there might have been racism and/or bigotry involved in the way Abdul was treated?
Belz... has already addressed the distinction between racism and attributing racism as a cause.

I don't think it is intrinsically racialist to ask whether racism played a part, especially where precedent or context suggests it. I do think it's racialist to prefer a racist explanation without more than circumstantial evidence.
 
I also have to laugh that you keep calling Ahmed Mohamed. Abdul. I mean seriously? Abdul, Ahmed, Anwar.....what's the difference right?

LOL
 
Belz... has already addressed the distinction between racism and attributing racism as a cause.

I don't think it is intrinsically racialist to ask whether racism played a part, especially where precedent or context suggests it. I do think it's racialist to prefer a racist explanation without more than circumstantial evidence.

Because otherwise it's just a typical "school and cops overreact" story. But if it's "school and cops overreact to Muslim" it becomes an opportunity to lecture us all on how racist or whatever American society is.
 
Well, well, turns out Clock Boy's dad is also a 9-11 Truther:

Aha! Now it all makes sense.

The kid makes a clock.
He's arrested for a hoax bomb. This seems odd, but now, with this extra tidbit of information, we can understand the incident better and conclude..................OBAMA SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

That's the point isn't it? Because I certainly can't understand why else this would be relevant.
 
Yes.

For example it isn't racist to say that Dylan Roof was motivated by racism.

Nor is it racist to say that the stop and search and arrest rates in many US police forces (e.g. Ferguson, MO) have racial discrimination, and that the staff have demonstrated documented racist behaviour.

It is hard to prove any single instance is due to discrimination unless the perpetrator proclaims it, but many legal systems recognise this.

I have a bunch of other rebuttals and points that hopefully I can get to tomorrow, but for now I wanted to agree very much with this. This last point is one I made fairly early in the Michael Brown thread. In that case, I was arguing against those who were so sure it was racially caused; here I invoke the same point against those who are so sure it isn't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom