Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Given the above... Why was the police called?

Honestly we don't know, but in my opinion it was because of Ahmed shutting down. From the small amount of information the school and police WERE able to give, it seems he was not cooperative when he was interviewed by the principal and they didn't know what was going on.

It's also why they said he was arrested and taken to the police station.

IMO I think they thought he might have been involved in setting up a prank at the school and when he shut down and wouldn't cooperate the called the police out of concern for safety issues.
 
Just looking over this thread and found this.

If she thought it might be a bomb, taking it to the principle would be the dumbest thing she could do. Moving it at all would have been dumb, period. If she had any suspicion at all, the suspected bomb should have been moved as little as possible and the classroom evacuated.

Maybe she didn't like the principal? Just joking.
 
Hey Fuelair, sorry I missed this. This is such a great point. If they really thought it was a "fake bomb" or a "hoax bomb" you are correct, they would have cleared the classroom and called security and administration to come to the classroom.

The fact that they picked it up and took it to the office shows they didn't think it was a fake bomb.

Thanks for pointing this out.

I am pretty sure that point has been made lots of times before...

Which is why the arrest was so ridiculous.
 
Hey Fuelair, sorry I missed this. This is such a great point. If they really thought it was a "fake bomb" or a "hoax bomb" you are correct, they would have cleared the classroom and called security and administration to come to the classroom.

The fact that they picked it up and took it to the office shows they didn't think it was a fake bomb.
Thanks for pointing this out.

Surely it only shows that they didn't think it was a real bomb.
 
I haven't seen how the investigation panned out. Did the cops check the kid's computer to see if he'd been visiting ISIS/bomb-making sites?
 
No it's not.

As written, yes, it is. The words you used in the post I quoted mean that. If you meant something else then you are retracting that part of that post.

As for your question from that post of 'where they are getting that idea', it's because we know such bigotry exists. People argue for why such bigotry is justified. It fits as a perfectly reasonable explanation for the over-reaction, based on what is known. There are details that everyone has be speculating on that could make it more or less likely as an explanation, but those details are not actually known.

Arguing that it doesn't have to be bigotry is one thing, arguing that it couldn't be is another. You don't think it was, but your opinion doesn't invalidate it as an explanation.

My argument is that the teacher didn't do anything wrong in this situation. There's nothing in this situation from the teacher or the school that indicates the boy was targeted for being a "Dark Skinned Muslim"

She followed protocol.

You don't know if the teacher did anything wrong or not. Those details aren't available. They may have or may not have. Nothing so far requires either. You're speculating that they (she?) followed protocol, but the only way to know that would be to have her cite the protocol she claims to have followed and see if it matches her actions. That's simply not in evidence. Personally I'd remain agnostic on that but err on the side of 'innocent' in any interaction where it might matter. That's unlikely to come up, so 'maybe' is all I'm going to muster on the teacher.


I can't speak for the cops. But I'm not talking about racism in general. IMO if you generalize a person and their life experience based on their race, you are also racist.

Example. "Oh the black guy, well they probably thought he was in a gang and had a gun, those racists!!!!"

Well why would YOU say that when nothing in the situation indicates that is what happened. You saw the kid and he's a mannered, well spoken young man and doesn't act in any way that suggests he in a gang or has a gun.

"Yeah it doesn't matter they still probably thought he was in a gang and had a gun."

Why would you think that?

"Because he's Black! And you know what "those people" think of black people."

But there's no indication that they did this?

"Trust me I know they did it because he was black!"


Um seriously? Who is the racist here?


I don't follow your example at all. We know (from many, many studies on the matter) that laws are enforced more harshly against black people, and against men. It's therefore not unreasonable to consider and investigate if some action by police (you example doesn't contain one, but it seems that's what you're trying to talk about) might be motivated by racism. That doesn't mean we assume racism, but to automatically discount it is wrong.
 
I haven't seen how the investigation panned out. Did the cops check the kid's computer to see if he'd been visiting ISIS/bomb-making sites?

No. At least, I assume not, or I think we would have heard about it. I'm sure we would have heard if a search warrant for his computers would have been obtained.

I don't think there was any real "investigation" beyond interrogating Ahmed.
 
As written, yes, it is. The words you used in the post I quoted mean that. If you meant something else then you are retracting that part of that post.

As for your question from that post of 'where they are getting that idea', it's because we know such bigotry exists. People argue for why such bigotry is justified. It fits as a perfectly reasonable explanation for the over-reaction, based on what is known. There are details that everyone has be speculating on that could make it more or less likely as an explanation, but those details are not actually known.

Arguing that it doesn't have to be bigotry is one thing, arguing that it couldn't be is another. You don't think it was, but your opinion doesn't invalidate it as an explanation.



You don't know if the teacher did anything wrong or not. Those details aren't available. They may have or may not have. Nothing so far requires either. You're speculating that they (she?) followed protocol, but the only way to know that would be to have her cite the protocol she claims to have followed and see if it matches her actions. That's simply not in evidence. Personally I'd remain agnostic on that but err on the side of 'innocent' in any interaction where it might matter. That's unlikely to come up, so 'maybe' is all I'm going to muster on the teacher.





I don't follow your example at all. We know (from many, many studies on the matter) that laws are enforced more harshly against black people, and against men. It's therefore not unreasonable to consider and investigate if some action by police (you example doesn't contain one, but it seems that's what you're trying to talk about) might be motivated by racism. That doesn't mean we assume racism, but to automatically discount it is wrong.


Jumping the gun to bigotry is racist in and of itself. In my opinion.

Perhaps what I am seeing is easier for me to recognize because I have two Arab Muslim boys

One came out like his Dad, very dark skin and dark eyes and kinky hair

The other one came out like my side of the family (Picture the little girl in Poltergeist although his hair got darker as he got older)


I've watched over the years people making presumptions about them just based on what they LOOKED LIKE

You'll notice I didn't really take issue with it until people started mentioning his "dark skin" because I've seen racism myself with my own two kids.

I don't feel like derailing the thread with it, but to me the insistence that they targeted Ahmed because of what he LOOKED LIKE and insisting that they thought things about him because of what he LOOKED LIKE is just as racist to me.

Example People saying to me and my son "Oh wow were people mean to you after 911?" No why would they be? "Well because you look Arab and Muslim and your name is one of the terrorists names."

I'd get really pissed off because NO people don't treat him that way because he's a beautiful respectful young man and people think his name is cool you *********** *******.



And again, the actions of the police are very different than the actions of the school simply because the Teacher KNEW HIM and so did the principal. The cops may have made a judgment about him, but what indications do you have that ANYONE in the school targeted him for being a "Dark Skinned Muslim" ???

So I can see your argument about the police, (as I have said several times) but not about the teacher and the school.

Insisting that they targeted him for being a "Dark skinned Muslim" is racist. Insisting that the only reason they took him to the office was because of him being a "Dark Skinned Muslim" when that's not what happened is perpetuating racism.

I know it's a slight nuance that is difficult to see so I'll leave it at agreeing to disagree.


You could try seeing it this way.


Imagine we are having the conversation at a dinner table and my son is sitting there. You all keep saying "Well of course they targeted him for being a Dark SKinned Muslim" and my son is sitting there listening to this. What message are you sending to my son?

The message that you are sending to my son is that if someone has an issue with you it's always because of what you "look like" not about who you are as person.

When I see Ahmed I see a well spoken young man. He seems very polite and nice and he's cute too.

You see a label.

I doubt very much that his teachers just see the label. I bet they know him very well.


The cops may have been racist. But when you discuss a child by his "label" you identify to all children who look like that label that there is something inherently "wrong with them" according to society.

Consider again both my sons sitting at the table and the one who is "WHITE" is never told that there is something problematic about what he looks like. But the one who is DARK is told constantly that there's a problem.

Who is the racist here now?

An old picture of the boys. :)



I'll be deleting the link later.



 
Last edited:
I still don't see how it's racist to see racism in someone's actions. Is it merely because it introduces ethnicity into the discussion?

Neither do I.

So I'll ask you AGAIN "What actions" did the teacher or the school do with Ahmed that they wouldn't have done with a white kid who did the same thing?

Um NOTHING. So the person who is pushing the racism is the person who can't see that, simply because Ahmed is a "dark skinned Muslim"

Please list the things that the teacher or school did that you think they did because he was a "dark skinned Muslim"

I'm waiting.....:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Neither do I.

You're the one who's arguing that it is. :boggled:

I don't think calling something racist is racist, itself. That makes no sense to me.

Are you asking if there is racism in the action,or asserting that there is racism in the action?

Neither. I am addressing truethat's assertion that calling it racist is racist. By that logic, calling something sexist or discriminatory is also sexist or discriminatory, which is nonsense.
 
Hmmm thanks for that theprestige. I'm a she btw.

That's a good distinction.

racialist
Also found in: Medical, Legal, Encyclopedia, Wikipedia.
ra·cial·ism (rā′shə-lĭz′əm)
n.
1.
a. An emphasis on race or racial considerations, as in determining policy or interpreting events.
b. Policy or practice based on racial considerations.
2. Chiefly British Variant of racism.
 
I think the term he's looking for is 'racialist'. quadraginta provides another example just now.

Racialism is the belief that the human species is naturally divided into distinct biological categories called "races."
(link)
​
Not sure how this relates. Aside from the probability that someone who engages in bigotry based on perceived racial differences is probably a "racialist"

Someone recognizing that bigotry exists and that some people do actually behave that way may not be, and probably isn't. Otherwise they wouldn't consider it bigotry.

Would you go into more depth as to what your intended meaning is please? It isn't clear from context.
 
Last edited:
My son who is Dark Skinned is not treated differently because of what he looks like. He experiences more crap at the hand of "well meaning white people" who constantly point out to him that there's an "issue" with what he looks like. That he remains "the other" and will never really belong.


It's kind of like asking someone what their nationality is when they look Indian or Arab. "Where are you from?" I'm American, "Yeah but where are you from, what's your parents background???"

My parents are American. "Ok yeah I get that but what is your ethnic background"

I'm Irish. "Oh wow really, no seriously what's your ethnic background?"

"Well my father is Lebanese and Egyptian."




Ohhhhh so you're Egyptian!!!



I will leave it at this. It's derailed too much.
 
Last edited:
My son who is Dark Skinned is not treated differently because of what he looks like. He experiences more crap at the hand of "well meaning white people" who constantly point out to him that there's an "issue" with what he looks like. That he remains "the other" and will never really belong.

<snip>


I'm very happy for your son, and I hope you understand how fortunate he is to be growing up in such an environment.

If you think that he would be equally well treated everywhere else in this country then you'd best not move. You would be severely disappointed.

The crap from well meaning white people would be the very least of your problems.
 
I don't agree. And you've just once again proven my point.

Solely based on what my son looks like you have indicated that he will be discriminated against and treated differently.
n
That to me is racist. I have tried for years to keep people with such sentiments as far away from him as possible when growing up. That's why I laughed before at the idea that you somehow think you are on Ahmed's side. :rolleyes:


Here's another example.


I'm shopping with a friend of mind who is black and another "well meaning white chick" The black chick comes out of the store annoyed. "The stupid sales girl was up my ass the entire time I was in there!"

The "well meaning white chick" "Why did she think you were trying to shoplift? What a ***** "

Black chick "No she saw my expensive bag and thought she was going to get a big commission out of me, why would you think she thought I was shoplifting?"

The "well meaning white chick" "Well because you're black, and you know how "those people" think that you shoplift, she's probably a racist."


Um........no errrrr......who's the racist here?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom