Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

What evidence leads those of you to believe this? Are not white kids busted at school for a myriad of similar things, not to mention actual mass shootings, at schools? Is it because it's a bomb in question and not a gun, and bombs are associated with Muslims?

My first thought when I found out about clock boy is that he was probably white. Many famous bombings in the US were perpetrated by white men - Olympic bombing (Richard Jewell), Oklahoma (McVeigh), Unabomber (Kaczynski), various abortion clinic bombings.

You can believe all you want, but without some sort of evidence it is just as prejudice as knowing the color of a cop killer without reading the article.



This is the thing I don't understand either. When is the last time a school shooting incident was done by a Muslim kid? When is the last time a bomb was blown in a school by a Muslim kid?

They've pretty much all been white kids. So I'd love to know where THEY are getting their mindset that the teacher reacted to him because he was a "dark skinned Muslim"

Like I said. Who is the racist here making presumptions? And dumb presumptions at that because as far as problems at schools have gone I don't think I've even heard about an incident with a Muslim kid.before this.

An alternative hypothesis is at least as plausible, which is that this kind of thing has happened before but you only hear about it when it happens to the son of a Muslim activist. Personally, I doubt very much that Ahmed's ethnicity registered in the minds of the teachers, principal, or the police. On the other hand, I'm quite sure that the reaction by the left-wing blogosphere, and, consequently, by the mainstream media, Democratic politicians, and left-leaning titans of the tech industry, had everything to do with Ahmed's ethnicity. If this had happened to a white kid, there's no way the left-wing would have given a crap. The roles would have been reversed between left-wing and right-wing, except for two differences: (1) it wouldn't have gone viral; and (2) when the right wing found out that Ahmed/Andy just stuck an old clock in a box, they would have dropped the subject like a hot potato.


this!! :)
 
Last edited:
An alternative hypothesis is at least as plausible, which is that this kind of thing has happened before but you only hear about it when it happens to the son of a Muslim activist.

That is plausible. Let's investigate it. Maybe someone can find a comparable news story. We have teachers on this forum, maybe they can provide an anecdote from their own experience. We have parents here. Maybe their children have shared a comparable story. We have all been to school ourselves, although some of us were there in an age with fewer electronic devices.

I, personally, have never encountered anything at all like this, but maybe others have. mgidm86 said a myriad of white kids had been busted for similar things. Surely out of that myriad someone can find some example that fits the bill.


I must admit, though, I'm a bit skeptical, just because after saying that a myriad of white kids had been busted for similar things, he talked about things that weren't very similar. He talked about bombings and shootings. He didn't mention anything about clocks or contraptions.
 
I do not like to repeat previous statements that I have already made. But I will add a small bit of new information. I previously mentioned that I am a teacher and a lot of friends and relatives of mine teach K-12. Yesterday I asked a few at random if they EVER (there I go with all-CAPS) heard of a student being suspended in their schools due to bringing in an object that was odd or interesting enough that it led to disruption of a class. They ALL thought the idea was absolutely absurd and they NEVER had heard of such a thing. Even refusing a teacher's instruction on and off during a day would never lead to a suspension, let alone a 3 day suspension.

At most the object might be confiscated for a day. Talking back to a teacher might lead to a trip to the Principal's office for a few hours. The only school suspensions that they knew of related to student-initiated violence, repeated disruption of class over many days, or the possession of a banned and obviously dangerous weapon.

Now these people teach in systems from 60,000 to 400,000 students in California. I have no idea, as I previously noted, how a student of any religion or ethnicity might be treated in Texas. But I am suspicious for these reasons that this is an UNUSUAL suspension. Others here have created their own, highly speculative, scenarios ("I am certain that there must be a hidden..."). Okay, but we all all guessing in the absence of actual knowledge.

As mentioned, my willingness to use all CAPS indicates I need to take a holiday from this thread.
 
Meadmaker


I love how you think semantics and splitting hairs is a logical discussion.


Trivial objections (also referred to as hair-splitting, nothing but objections, barrage of objections and banal objections) is an informal logical fallacy where irrelevant and sometimes frivolous objections are made to divert the attention away from the topic that is being discussed. This type of argument is called a "quibble" or "quillet". Trivial objections are a special case of red herring.

The fallacy often appears when an argument is difficult to oppose. The person making a trivial objection may appear ready to accept the argument in question, but at the same time they will oppose it in many different ways. These objections can appear in the form of lists, hypotheticals, and even accusations.

Such objections themselves may be valid, but they fail to confront the main argument under consideration. Instead, the objection opposes a small, irrelevant part of the main argument. The fallacy is committed because of this diversion; it is fallacious to oppose a point on the basis of minor and incidental aspects, rather than responding to the main claim.

Wiki
or


hair·split·ting (hâr′splĭt′ĭng)
n.
The making of unreasonably fine distinctions.
 
Last edited:
I do not like to repeat previous statements that I have already made. But I will add a small bit of new information. I previously mentioned that I am a teacher and a lot of friends and relatives of mine teach K-12. Yesterday I asked a few at random if they EVER (there I go with all-CAPS) heard of a student being suspended in their schools due to bringing in an object that was odd or interesting enough that it led to disruption of a class. They ALL thought the idea was absolutely absurd and they NEVER had heard of such a thing. Even refusing a teacher's instruction on and off during a day would never lead to a suspension, let alone a 3 day suspension.

At most the object might be confiscated for a day. Talking back to a teacher might lead to a trip to the Principal's office for a few hours. The only school suspensions that they knew of related to student-initiated violence, repeated disruption of class over many days, or the possession of a banned and obviously dangerous weapon.

Now these people teach in systems from 60,000 to 400,000 students in California. I have no idea, as I previously noted, how a student of any religion or ethnicity might be treated in Texas. But I am suspicious for these reasons that this is an UNUSUAL suspension. Others here have created their own, highly speculative, scenarios ("I am certain that there must be a hidden..."). Okay, but we all all guessing in the absence of actual knowledge.

As mentioned, my willingness to use all CAPS indicates I need to take a holiday from this thread.

Again you didn't ask them the question I asked you. You LEAP FROGGED right over it and asked a loaded question.

The question again is this.

If you were a teacher in the classroom and student brought in an electronic device like his and you DIDN'T know what it was, are you not mandated to take it to the principals office.

Since you are taking a break go ask them that.
 
Again you didn't ask them the question I asked you. You LEAP FROGGED right over it and asked a loaded question.

The question again is this.

If you were a teacher in the classroom and student brought in an electronic device like his and you DIDN'T know what it was, are you not mandated to take it to the principals office.

Since you are taking a break go ask them that.

You accused me of this before and I provided a highlighted citation of one of my recent posts where I had already addressed this very question. You even appeared to have acknowledged this in your own subsequent post. Look just above in this thread if you wish a reminder and documentation.

This is one reason I find the politics-related threads so repetitive.

Post 1235 if you have any trouble finding it.
 
Last edited:
This is the thing I don't understand either. When is the last time a school shooting incident was done by a Muslim kid? When is the last time a bomb was blown in a school by a Muslim kid?

They've pretty much all been white kids. So I'd love to know where THEY are getting their mindset that the teacher reacted to him because he was a "dark skinned Muslim"
Like I said. Who is the racist here making presumptions? And dumb presumptions at that because as far as problems at schools have gone I don't think I've even heard about an incident with a Muslim kid.before this.




this!! :)


Your argument here, as written, is that because such bigotry is irrational, such bigotry does not or would not exist.

Do I really need to point out the ineradicable failure in this reasoning?
 
You accused me of this before and I provided a highlighted citation of one of my recent posts where I had already addressed this very question. You even appeared to have acknowledged this in your own subsequent post. Look just above in this thread if you wish a reminder and documentation.

This is one reason I find the politics-related threads so repetitive.

Post 1235 if you have any trouble finding it.

Ok so then who did something wrong here?:o


As to the rest of your "none of my family has ever heard of such a thing ever!!!" well pop on google and you'll find quite a few of them. Or just look up zero tolerance and you'll see some cases there. So I'm not sure what your family's opinion has to do with what actually happened.
 
Last edited:
Your argument here, as written, is that because such bigotry is irrational, such bigotry does not or would not exist.

Do I really need to point out the ineradicable failure in this reasoning?

No it's not. My argument is that the teacher didn't do anything wrong in this situation. There's nothing in this situation from the teacher or the school that indicates the boy was targeted for being a "Dark Skinned Muslim"

She followed protocol.


I can't speak for the cops. But I'm not talking about racism in general. IMO if you generalize a person and their life experience based on their race, you are also racist.

Example. "Oh the black guy, well they probably thought he was in a gang and had a gun, those racists!!!!"

Well why would YOU say that when nothing in the situation indicates that is what happened. You saw the kid and he's a mannered, well spoken young man and doesn't act in any way that suggests he in a gang or has a gun.

"Yeah it doesn't matter they still probably thought he was in a gang and had a gun."

Why would you think that?

"Because he's Black! And you know what "those people" think of black people."

But there's no indication that they did this?

"Trust me I know they did it because he was black!"


Um seriously? Who is the racist here?
 
<snip>
Bringing in TOYS could be considered disrupting the learning environment. (Remember when years ago they banned Pokemon cards from school) Not because the kids are being particularly disruptive but if the kids are focused on Johnny having the cards and want to look at them before and after class starts, they aren't focused on the learning.

http://www.debate.org/opinions/should-pokemon-cards-be-allowed-in-schools<snip>

When I worked as a computer lab teacher in a South Texas school district, two students were suspended 3 days for bringing Tazos (milk caps that were a huge fad) to school and trading them during class, much like kids pass notes back and forth. This was after the school made an announcement that Tazos were not allowed in class because they were causing a huge disruption.

My experience tells me that if this kid had been suspended for disruptions in the past and brought another disruption in, then that would have been grounds for suspension again. Seems pretty simple to me.
 
When I worked as a computer lab teacher in a South Texas school district, two students were suspended 3 days for bringing Tazos (milk caps that were a huge fad) to school and trading them during class, much like kids pass notes back and forth. This was after the school made an announcement that Tazos were not allowed in class because they were causing a huge disruption.

My experience tells me that if this kid had been suspended for disruptions in the past and brought another disruption in, then that would have been grounds for suspension again. Seems pretty simple to me.

Me too!:thumbsup::D
 
My experience tells me that if this kid had been suspended for disruptions in the past and brought another disruption in, then that would have been grounds for suspension again. Seems pretty simple to me.

The school could have had all sorts of reasons for suspending Ahmed. They are prohibited by their privacy policy from explaining or justifying it publicly.

There are two things, though, that separate this case from every other case that I'm aware of.

The small difference is that, unlike trading Tazos, building electronics is something we actually want kids to do. It's important. We should encourage it. If, somehow, the electronics are part of a classroom disruption, that's bad, and that could result in some disciplinary action. No problem with that.


The huge difference is the arrest. If it weren't for the handcuffs, we wouldn't have a story here.



(And....three days for Tazos? Ok. One day because the school had specifically banned them. Unless the kid got suspended for one day, and then did it again, three days seems ridiculous. It could be a "body of work" thing, with either Ahmed or the Tazos boy you speak of.)
 
The school could have had all sorts of reasons for suspending Ahmed. They are prohibited by their privacy policy from explaining or justifying it publicly.

There are two things, though, that separate this case from every other case that I'm aware of.

The small difference is that, unlike trading Tazos, building electronics is something we actually want kids to do. It's important. We should encourage it. If, somehow, the electronics are part of a classroom disruption, that's bad, and that could result in some disciplinary action. No problem with that.
I agree with you that ingenuity is something that should be encouraged. But using ingenuity to pull a prank that disrupts the classroom seems like a reasonable place to draw a line.
The huge difference is the arrest. If it weren't for the handcuffs, we wouldn't have a story here.
I think everyone agrees that was out of line. But, in the real world, if I even say the word bomb in an airport line I will be arrested, searched and probably charged with a crime. I think that's a little crazy too but it's the world we live in.

(And....three days for Tazos? Ok. One day because the school had specifically banned them. Unless the kid got suspended for one day, and then did it again, three days seems ridiculous. It could be a "body of work" thing, with either Ahmed or the Tazos boy you speak of.)
Totally agree that three days for Tazos was crazy. I was just pointing out that crazy stuff does indeed happen in schools so a suspension for disrupting the class in this manner doesn't seem out of the realm of possibility and indeed seems likely.
 
But, in the real world, if I even say the word bomb in an airport line I will be arrested, searched and probably charged with a crime. I think that's a little crazy too but it's the world we live in.

No you won't. The word itself is not illegal. If you say you have a bomb, even as a joke, the security staff will treat you like you're being serious. And they will arrest you. However some statements with bomb related vocabulary that won't get you arrested:

"Oh man, did you see that bomb that <quarterback> threw last night? It was like 80 yards!"

"I totally bombed my math test yesterday"

"I'm glad I'm going on this trip, I used a bug bomb just before I left and my house is gonna stink for days"
 
My first thought when I found out about clock boy is that he was probably white. Many famous bombings in the US were perpetrated by white men - Olympic bombing (Richard Jewell), Oklahoma (McVeigh), Unabomber (Kaczynski), various abortion clinic bombings.

Your first thought? BS...you don't even check your facts, so how are you going to have any meaningful thoughts?

Richard Jewell was a suspect, but was cleared and they found they guy that really did bomb the Olympics. The Hell that Richard Jewell was put through is one of the greatest injustices of the American Legal System and is the reason why so many politicians later personally apologized to Richard Jewell - including the Attorney General of the United States.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Jewell

You, on the other hand, obviously don't want to be bothered by facts, and you make a post that not only Libels an innocent Man who saved the lives of many by clearing the area of the blast of potential victims, but also makes the rest of us stupider for having read it.

YOU FAIL!!!!
 
Last edited:
In Orange Co. FL, prior to my retirement (teacher - mostly science), I would have been required to call the office and request an administrator to come to the room in the given situation. If it looked like an actual bomb (I would know - have the proper AF handbook for id'ing and have seen several in real life (mostly training models) I would note that. This is, by the by, so unlikely as to be immediately rejected. The only rational method for an actual bomber is to bring the device in in a vehicle and call in a bomb scare about 15 minutes before the bomb is due to go off. Since most schools use the parking lots to gather the classes and most of the admin during fire or other drill/call in, that and/or the also used football/athletic field are the logical placement areas. Nobody seems to think of this and it has been the technique at all of the OC schools I have taught at. Fortunately none have had any actual explosions - and I hope none ever do.........


Hey Fuelair, sorry I missed this. This is such a great point. If they really thought it was a "fake bomb" or a "hoax bomb" you are correct, they would have cleared the classroom and called security and administration to come to the classroom.

The fact that they picked it up and took it to the office shows they didn't think it was a fake bomb.

Thanks for pointing this out.
 
That's cool and thanks for being more specific in your next post.


You keep minimizing what happened. You do realize this. Example

He brought an alarm clock to school and it rang ONCE

A student confused a PEN for a sword.

Etc.


I keep pointing out that I do not know why people keep MINIMIZING what happened.

A. The teacher DID NOT KNOW IT WAS A CLOCK

It's wrong to turn around in hindsight and "it was a clock" and as I have conceded several times, maybe to everyone else she's an idiot for not being able to see it was clock immediately.

But she DIDN'T and because she DIDN'T she was obligated to take it to the office.

I have asked this question SEVERAL times and pointed this out in the thread several times and people just LEAP FROG right over it.

So I'll ask you again


If you DIDN'T know what it was and it was a wired contraption like that. Would you not have an obligation to turn it into the principal?

Now the only reason you keep dodging this question IMO is that you know damn well I'm right.

Especially if you work in NYC but it seems you only went to school many years ago in NYC. And after all this is about Texas.

And I've always said the cops ********** up, from DAY ONE. I've given other reasons why they might have reacted the way they did. But I guess you didn't read it. (Pass on that as it was many pages ago) but please don't tell me I have never said that if you haven't read all my posts.

Just looking over this thread and found this.

If she thought it might be a bomb, taking it to the principle would be the dumbest thing she could do. Moving it at all would have been dumb, period. If she had any suspicion at all, the suspected bomb should have been moved as little as possible and the classroom evacuated.
 
Hey Fuelair, sorry I missed this. This is such a great point. If they really thought it was a "fake bomb" or a "hoax bomb" you are correct, they would have cleared the classroom and called security and administration to come to the classroom.

The fact that they picked it up and took it to the office shows they didn't think it was a fake bomb.

Thanks for pointing this out.
Given the above... Why was the police called?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom