Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

*Puts on criminal defense attorney hat.*: Seems very clear that "defense counsel hat on" means you are not really "analyzing" anything, you are advocating a position.

You really don't know how criminal defense works, do you? The first step is to analyze the statute and determine if it even fits. (BTW, I've also worked as a prosecutor.) Police and prosecutors are not perfect, and they don't know every law by heart. (Every prosecutor I've worked for and against takes a book of the most up-to-date criminal statutes with them to court so they can look up the statutes in question.) Sometimes (more often than not, to be honest), the statute is applicable. That's when an attorney either starts looking for other options to reduce or dismiss the charges. (Often 4th, 5th, or 6th Amendment violations, but there's other options.)

Those are two different things, your law school should have mentioned that.

No, actually, they aren't. Analyzing (as I said above) is applying the fact pattern to the applicable statute. The statute requires "knowledge" and "intent," both of which are missing in the fact pattern as it currently stands. Sometimes the language of a statute or the fact pattern is vague enough to give wiggle room. In those cases, the attorneys on both sides go digging for precedent to back up the argument they want to make. This is not one of those situations, given the current fact pattern.

"Knowledge" and "intent" are very clear legal terms. I guess I should back up and better explain them as a legal terms.

Knowledge is a conscious action. The actor must be aware of the action they are taking. For example, every weekday morning, I get in my car and drive to work. I consciously get behind the wheel, turn the key, and maneuver the car along the roads to the parking lot of the building where I work. To contrast, there are accounts of people causing accidents because they sleep-walked to their car, got in, and began to drive. A person doing that is not guilty of a crime with a knowledge requirement because they did not consciously know they were carrying out an action. (Alcohol and drug use, even if a person is blacked out, do not excuse a "knowledge" requirement because getting drunk or taking drugs is a willful act. However, a person who was drugged against their will would have a defense against a "know" requirement.)

"Intent" means you desire the result to happen. Let's say we have a domestic abuse victim. One night, the abuser gets out the gun they (legally) own and starts waving it around, threatening to shoot and kill the victim. (1) The victim grabs the gun and tries to take it away from the abuser. In the fight, the gun goes off and the abuser is killed. (2) The abuser puts the gun down and goes to bed. The victim picks the gun up, goes to the bedroom, and shoots and kills the abuser.

In both cases, the abuser is dead. The difference is the intent of the victim/shooter. In scenario (1), there was no intent. The victim did not mean for the abuser to die. In scenario (2), there was intent. The victim's purpose was the ensure the abuser would stop by killing the abuser.

(1) Knowingly: Ahmed had to know he was building a hoax bomb. Since he was building a clock, that point fails. ; Ok, my reply is ..... record player screeching noise.... wait a minute.... Since he was building a clock, What the hell happened to Issue, Rule, Analysis, Conclusion??? It is clear that you forgot about that and leapt right to CONCLUSION.

No, I didn't. All the steps are there. The entire issue (which you brought up) is whether the hoax bomb statute is applicable to Ahmed's actions. You also provided the Rule. The analysis is the sentence "Ahmed had to know he was making a hoax bomb." I did gloss through and left out the implied sentence "Ahmed believed he was was building a clock." The conclusion is that the element fails because Ahmed did not know he was building a hoax bomb.

I did not use a formal IRAC format in my analysis because I did not realize this forum is a law school exam.

HE WAS BUILDING A CLOCK. Oh well, defense counsel declared it so it MUST be so. We don't need no stinking 'rule' and certainly no analysis .

Er, no. The element is question is the knowledge element. As I stated at the time, Ahmed had to know he was building a hoax bomb. He maintains (and through lengthy questioning by the police) that he was building a clock. He did not KNOW he was building a hoax bomb.
 
Lack of imagination and understanding BY ADULT EDUCATIONAL PROFESSIONALS misidentified the object and reacted appropriately to the only thing their limited imagination could conceive for a kid mounting a circuitboard to a toolbox.

Oh I think their limited imaginations were a bit more concerned with the safety and well being of the other 1000 students in the school, and could be excused for being less concerned with the fact that the Lil' Inventor turned a perfectly fine clock into garbage.

I'm sure that their limited imaginations did not foresee the wildly overblown hysteria from the Lil' Inventor's supporters tho.
 
Oh I think their limited imaginations were a bit more concerned with the safety and well being of the other 1000 students in the school, and could be excused for being less concerned with the fact that the Lil' Inventor turned a perfectly fine clock into garbage.

I'm not sure exactly what they were concerned about, to be honest. If we can question the kid's or his parents' motives, I think it's fair to question the school authorities' as well.
 
You really don't know how criminal defense works, do you?

Face palm.

I should have stopped there, but I unfortunately I kept reading searching for a semblance of a point.....

And I get to your response to my statement that "analyzing" and "advocating" are two different things.

You say: "No, actually, they aren't. Analyzing (as I said above) is... word words words...."

But you never actually even try to show that analyzing an issue and advocating a position are the same thing! I mean your statement on its face was so silly because of course they are different, but you didn't even try!
 
As someone who grew up in a household full of electronics, it looks like it could be a clock to me, or any number of hacked together devices that kids playing with electronics build.



so without the explosives it's not a bomb.

But potentially a bomb. Also, it could be a hoax bomb. I think if you brought an empty hand grenade to school, you would probably get into trouble for a variety of reasons.

oh good grief. So you assume that it might have explosives hidden in it somewhere? Why? Because his name is Mohammed?

Starting with the implicit accusations of bigotry already? You asked where explosives might be put. I answered. Assuming that a suspicious object might have explosives in it somewhere is a rational thing to do, depending upon circumstances. I was simply indicating that it was not possible to see, just from casual observation, that there were no explosives. In the most recent terrorist incident in the US, the terrorists threw a piece of copper pipe with a rag stuffed in it at police. There was no explosive in it, but it might have.
 
Last edited:
Form follows function. Function does not follow form. Ahmed's Clock was a random appliance a curious person with a screwdriver took apart at some point. Him? Maybe, maybe not. My mom used to buy me random crap at thrift stores to keep me busy. Generally tearing things down results in an object not returning to service. Parts get lost, case halves get stepped on, screws fall down a heat vent.

Ahmed managed to return to the thing to some level of service. Pictures I've seen show solder rework. One comment, something he said in his video, suggested the display was only partially functional. Once a kid has soldered a wire back to the board he realizes holding things still prevents the solder joints from getting messed up again. He screwed it into a non-conductive box. And in the morning he was still excited by this little victory and took it to a teacher.

Form follows function, function does not follow form. A teacher held on to he's box for some time, apparently, before concluding the object represented some form of danger that required "procedures."

Lack of imagination and understanding BY ADULT EDUCATIONAL PROFESSIONALS misidentified the object and reacted appropriately to the only thing their limited imagination could conceive for a kid mounting a circuitboard to a toolbox.

Even if the so-called professionals lacked imagination or the level of sophistication you expect of them, what harm was done? It's not like they shot the kid, or even roughed him up. Getting interrogated, and even arrested in what was probably a very gentle way, is hardly a big deal. It was probably a useful experience.
 
Even if the so-called professionals lacked imagination or the level of sophistication you expect of them, what harm was done? It's not like they shot the kid, or even roughed him up. Getting interrogated, and even arrested in what was probably a very gentle way, is hardly a big deal. It was probably a useful experience.

Oh well, in that case why don't we find reasons to arrest every single kid in high school? After all, they must have at some point done SOMETHING that someone else considered questionable and possibly illegal, and since getting arrested is "useful", clearly every child should go through it regardless of whether they actually did anything illegal or not. We've discovered the new crime prevention program here, folks!
 
Face palm.

I should have stopped there, but I unfortunately I kept reading searching for a semblance of a point.....

And I get to your response to my statement that "analyzing" and "advocating" are two different things.

You say: "No, actually, they aren't. Analyzing (as I said above) is... word words words...."

But you never actually even try to show that analyzing an issue and advocating a position are the same thing! I mean your statement on its face was so silly because of course they are different, but you didn't even try!

OK, here's the difference. Ahmed isn't my client, so there is no advocacy.

I notice that you have made no effort to address my legal analysis. Please do so. After all, you are the one who originally posted the statute and stated (with no analysis of your own) that you believe he is guilty of it. Please explain why you believe so.

Even if the so-called professionals lacked imagination or the level of sophistication you expect of them, what harm was done?

Being taken out of his school in handcuffs in front of other students.

It was probably a useful experience.

Oh yes, everyone needs a dose of public humiliation. (/sarcasm)
 
<snip>

Being taken out of his school in handcuffs in front of other students.



Oh yes, everyone needs a dose of public humiliation. (/sarcasm)

If you think this rises to the level of public humiliation for a high school student in high school, then perhaps you were one of the "cool" kids, and not one of the geeks like I was.
 
OK, here's the difference. Ahmed isn't my client, so there is no advocacy.

I notice that you have made no effort to address my legal analysis. Please do so. After all, you are the one who originally posted the statute and stated (with no analysis of your own) that you believe he is guilty of it. Please explain why you believe so.

"here's the difference?" But... you said they were not different...:confused::confused:

After all, you are the one who originally posted the statute and stated (with no analysis of your own) that you believe he is guilty of it. Please explain why you believe so.

I said what now? Lets take a look:


here is the statute:

Seems like there was probable cause to inquire why Ahmad took a perfectly useful clock, made a hot mess of it, and brought it to school.

I'll charitably assume you simply forgot what I said....
 
Well lets take a gander at that shall we?



*Puts on criminal defense attorney hat.*: Seems very clear that "defense counsel hat on" means you are not really "analyzing" anything, you are advocating a position. Those are two different things, your law school should have mentioned that. Nothing wrong with being an advocate, but don't blow smoke up our skirts and claiming you are "analyzing" anything.

But we press on...

(1) Knowingly: Ahmed had to know he was building a hoax bomb. Since he was building a clock, that point fails. ; Ok, my reply is ..... record player screeching noise.... wait a minute.... Since he was building a clock, What the hell happened to Issue, Rule, Analysis, Conclusion??? It is clear that you forgot about that and leapt right to CONCLUSION.

HE WAS BUILDING A CLOCK. Oh well, defense counsel declared it so it MUST be so. We don't need no stinking 'rule' and certainly no analysis .

And that is where I rolled my eyes and basically ignored everything else.

By the way?

No, actually, "knowledge" and "intent" are both conclusions of fact. Did Ahmed know or not know that he was building a hoax bomb, and did he intend to use the bomb?

that is not what he said and that is not what I was replying to. Please read more closely next time.


Increasingly strident?

:rolleyes:
 
Oh I think their limited imaginations were a bit more concerned with the safety and well being of the other 1000 students in the school, and could be excused for being less concerned with the fact that the Lil' Inventor turned a perfectly fine clock into garbage.


That would explain evacuating the building.

Oh. Wait ...

Errr ...

That would explain evacuating the classroom.

Oh. Wait ...

I'm sure that their limited imaginations did not foresee the wildly overblown hysteria from the Lil' Inventor's supporters tho.


Increasingly strident?

Obviously there is a lot they didn't foresee.

Being called on their mistreatment of a fourteen yr. old would be high on the list of things they didn't foresee.

I wonder why that is. Could they be accustomed to getting away with that sort of thing?

Nah.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Face palm.

I should have stopped there, but I unfortunately I kept reading searching for a semblance of a point.....

And I get to your response to my statement that "analyzing" and "advocating" are two different things.

You say: "No, actually, they aren't. Analyzing (as I said above) is... word words words...."

But you never actually even try to show that analyzing an issue and advocating a position are the same thing! I mean your statement on its face was so silly because of course they are different, but you didn't even try!


Just for background. What are your credentials in the field of law?

Are you a lawyer?
 
Just for background. What are your credentials in the field of law?

Are you a lawyer?

That is a curious question, before I answer, I have to know what are your credentials in the field of asking for credentials in the field of law?

HA! No, just *********** with you, a silly question deserves a silly response.

By the way, anytime you want to focus on the argument and not the arguer would be all right by me.
 
Even if the so-called professionals lacked imagination or the level of sophistication you expect of them, what harm was done? It's not like they shot the kid, or even roughed him up. Getting interrogated, and even arrested in what was probably a very gentle way, is hardly a big deal. It was probably a useful experience.


Sure.

Every eighth grader should be handcuffed, locked in a room and browbeaten by a tag team of cops for no good reason and then dragged down to the police station for a little more "experience".

Sounds like a great idea and, as you say, probably useful. Especially in the right-wingnut world of law enforcement.

Why don't you recommend it to your local middle school. Maybe it'll catch on.

Let us know how that works out.
 
If you think this rises to the level of public humiliation for a high school student in high school, then perhaps you were one of the "cool" kids, and not one of the geeks like I was.


Were you one of the minority geeks in a town that values its bigotry so much it lauds its mayor for showing it off to the nation?

I don't think his treatment would add any "cool kid" creds to his reputation.

It would just make him an even bigger target than he already was. Adding the color of law to any abuse he might receive from his peers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom