Please reread what I wrote. I explained the legal terms and then applied those terms to the situation at hand. That is how statute analysis is done in the court system. My law school called it the IRAC (Issue, Rule, Analysis, Conclusion), though I've hear it referred to with different acronyms.
To use it here:
Issue: Whether Ahmed's actions constitute bringing a hoax bomb to school.
Rule: This is the statute, which you provided.
Analysis: This is where the elements of the rule are applied to the fact pattern. It involves breaking down the terms and phrases, defining them, and then deciding whether the applicable facts fall under the each element.
Conclusion: This is taking each part the analysis from the above step and looking at it as a whole. Since we are looking at a criminal statute, all elements must be met for the accused to be guilty. Several of the elements were not met (including the major elements of "knowledge" and "intent"), which means the charge fails.
I conceded to sunmaster14 above that my analysis is based on the fact pattern that we currently have. Time may show that that fact pattern is wrong and that Ahmed did have knowledge that he was building a hoax bomb and intended to use it as a hoax bomb. However, I stand by my statements that too many things in that scenario do not add up in my mind. (Ahmed not actually using the hoax bomb. Police not speaking to the engineering teacher.)
The first one is a conclusion of law and thus not a fact, and is silly because they were INVESTIGATING whether the law applied.
No, actually, "knowledge" and "intent" are both conclusions of fact. Did Ahmed know or not know that he was building a hoax bomb, and did he intend to use the bomb?
The second is your conclusion,
Conclusions based on the my analysis of the fact pattern as presented and applied to the applicable statute. Conclusions based on the kind of analysis I do in real life. Am I an expert defense attorney? Much as my ego hates to admit it, no. But I am a defense attorney, and it is my job to take fact patterns and apply them to the statute under which my client is charged. Sometimes that involves
pounding the table, but there's many situations where either the law or the facts are on my side. This seems to be a situation where I would have the facts.
As I said several posts ago (and repeated above), my analysis is based only on the fact pattern presented.