Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

"analysis" is a bit of a stretch, wouldn't you agree?

Given that this is a general internet forum and not a forum specifically for lawyers, a basic breakdown of the statute is sufficient. I could have done a multi-page break-down with case cites, but thought would be too much.

But you are correct that I did ignore it. If I wanted to listen to some perp's defense lawyer giving a closing argument I'd go to 26th and Cal.

So you chose to have your own beliefs, rather than listen to someone who knows what they are talking about? You posted the statute and claimed that Ahmed's clock and arrest fit the statute. I pointed out why, based on the information we have, his actions do not fall under the statute.
 
Which seems to be your standard policy when confronted with inconvenient facts you are unable to refute.

And then this sort of derisive comment, which you seem to think is some sort of internet-point-winning substitute.

It isn't.

It just makes you look sillier.

there were no "facts" in the post to which I was replying, in fact the poster specifically stated he was arguing from defense counsel's stand point. In any event, I freely admit that I ignored the argument from "defense attorney," particularly when I got the point that Ahmad said he was building a clock, as if that was in a way dispositive. In fact I rolled my eyes when I got to that point.

Your honor, the defendant says he didn't do it!
Oh in THAT case, you are free to go. Case dismissed.

protip: Next time try writing something without personalizing the argument so much! Heck try writing ANYTHING that isn't personalizing. Just a tip!
 
Trying to cash in for millions of dollars is a dead giveaway.

That seems to me to be opportunism on the part of his parents. Unless the default position is to be that a plaintiff suing for damages baited the defendant into doing it, and you'd then need evidence that the plaintiffs didn't engage in baiting.
 
This is getting ridiculous. It wasn't a bomb, and it wasn't a hoax bomb, which is a non-bomb intended to appear as a bomb, but it may be intended to appear as a hoax bomb? How many turtles is that?

This is something that so many people don't seem to understand.

A bomb is illegal.
A hoax bomb is illegal.
A thing that appears like it might be a hoax bomb is not illegal. There's no law against hoax hoax bombs.

Yes, that second "hoax" matters.
 
there were no "facts" in the post to which I was replying, i


You mean, except for the fact that intent has to be established before any part of the hoax bomb statute begins to apply?

And the fact that at no time did the kid do or say anything to any of the people with whom he interacted which can in any way be twisted into claiming he was trying to make someone think it was a bomb?

Other than those facts?
 
Last edited:
No you didn't.


Sure he did. Quite clearly and irrefutably.

You just can't concede that because without that one, basic claim being validated there is nothing left for the people who want to demonize the fourteen yr. old kid.

All that remains is teachers, administrators, and cops acting overreacting stupidly.

This doesn't fit some peoples' agendas. The ones who seem to think it is vital to demonize a fourteen yr. old kid.
 
That seems to me to be opportunism on the part of his parents. Unless the default position is to be that a plaintiff suing for damages baited the defendant into doing it, and you'd then need evidence that the plaintiffs didn't engage in baiting.


Instead the assertion seems to be that with diabolical, genius level manipulation they succeeded in getting all of the officials involved, teachers, admins, cops, to behave so stupidly ... in concert and in sequence ... to give them the opportunity to bring this suit.

Until we know what is done with any award which the family might receive, accusations of opportunism are absolutely nothing but fabricated calumny.

And at 5% of a single year's budget for the city I don't consider the initial number to be particularly excessive. It has to be enough to get them to change their behavior or it won't do any good at all.

Lawsuits can work to change bad behavior for the better, but they have to have enough teeth to make them hurt.

It always puzzles me (not really :p) that conservatives are so enthusiastic about being tough with penalties when they are applied to groups they despise but so much less so when the penalties start striking closer to home, like the misbehavior of authority.
 
Last edited:
Man, a lot of people really are pissed that a little boy is seeking compensation for being treated terribly. That really is sad.
 
You mean, except for the fact that intent has to be established before any part of the hoax bomb statute begins to apply?

And the fact that at no time did the kid do or say anything to any of the people with whom he interacted which can in any way be twisted into claiming he was trying to make someone think it was a bomb?

Other than those facts?

:eye-poppi

The first one is a conclusion of law and thus not a fact, and is silly because they were INVESTIGATING whether the law applied.

The second is your conclusion, and your increasingly strident declarations of your conclusion do not make it a fact.

How you can seriously assert those are facts is beyond me but good luck with all of that.
 
Instead the assertion seems to be that with diabolical, genius level manipulation they succeeded in getting all of the officials involved, teachers, admins, cops, to behave so stupidly ... in concert and in sequence ... to give them the opportunity to bring this suit.

If they're that cunning, they deserve the money.
 
No you didn't.

Please reread what I wrote. I explained the legal terms and then applied those terms to the situation at hand. That is how statute analysis is done in the court system. My law school called it the IRAC (Issue, Rule, Analysis, Conclusion), though I've hear it referred to with different acronyms.

To use it here:
Issue: Whether Ahmed's actions constitute bringing a hoax bomb to school.
Rule: This is the statute, which you provided.
Analysis: This is where the elements of the rule are applied to the fact pattern. It involves breaking down the terms and phrases, defining them, and then deciding whether the applicable facts fall under the each element.
Conclusion: This is taking each part the analysis from the above step and looking at it as a whole. Since we are looking at a criminal statute, all elements must be met for the accused to be guilty. Several of the elements were not met (including the major elements of "knowledge" and "intent"), which means the charge fails.

I conceded to sunmaster14 above that my analysis is based on the fact pattern that we currently have. Time may show that that fact pattern is wrong and that Ahmed did have knowledge that he was building a hoax bomb and intended to use it as a hoax bomb. However, I stand by my statements that too many things in that scenario do not add up in my mind. (Ahmed not actually using the hoax bomb. Police not speaking to the engineering teacher.)

The first one is a conclusion of law and thus not a fact, and is silly because they were INVESTIGATING whether the law applied.

No, actually, "knowledge" and "intent" are both conclusions of fact. Did Ahmed know or not know that he was building a hoax bomb, and did he intend to use the bomb?

The second is your conclusion,

Conclusions based on the my analysis of the fact pattern as presented and applied to the applicable statute. Conclusions based on the kind of analysis I do in real life. Am I an expert defense attorney? Much as my ego hates to admit it, no. But I am a defense attorney, and it is my job to take fact patterns and apply them to the statute under which my client is charged. Sometimes that involves pounding the table, but there's many situations where either the law or the facts are on my side. This seems to be a situation where I would have the facts.

As I said several posts ago (and repeated above), my analysis is based only on the fact pattern presented.
 
Please reread what I wrote. I explained the legal terms and then applied those terms to the situation at hand. That is how statute analysis is done in the court system. My law school called it the IRAC (Issue, Rule, Analysis, Conclusion), though I've hear it referred to with different acronyms.


No, actually, "knowledge" and "intent" are both conclusions of fact. Did Ahmed know or not know that he was building a hoax bomb, and did he intend to use the bomb?

Well lets take a gander at that shall we?

*Puts on criminal defense attorney hat.*

There are three key words/phrases in that statute.

(1) Knowingly: Ahmed had to know he was building a hoax bomb. Since he was building a clock, that point fails.

*Puts on criminal defense attorney hat.*: Seems very clear that "defense counsel hat on" means you are not really "analyzing" anything, you are advocating a position. Those are two different things, your law school should have mentioned that. Nothing wrong with being an advocate, but don't blow smoke up our skirts and claiming you are "analyzing" anything.

But we press on...

(1) Knowingly: Ahmed had to know he was building a hoax bomb. Since he was building a clock, that point fails. ; Ok, my reply is ..... record player screeching noise.... wait a minute.... Since he was building a clock, What the hell happened to Issue, Rule, Analysis, Conclusion??? It is clear that you forgot about that and leapt right to CONCLUSION.

HE WAS BUILDING A CLOCK. Oh well, defense counsel declared it so it MUST be so. We don't need no stinking 'rule' and certainly no analysis .

And that is where I rolled my eyes and basically ignored everything else.

By the way?

No, actually, "knowledge" and "intent" are both conclusions of fact. Did Ahmed know or not know that he was building a hoax bomb, and did he intend to use the bomb?

that is not what he said and that is not what I was replying to. Please read more closely next time.
 
This is something that so many people don't seem to understand.

A bomb is illegal.
A hoax bomb is illegal.
A thing that appears like it might be a hoax bomb is not illegal. There's no law against hoax hoax bombs.

Yes, that second "hoax" matters.

I hope you realize you're carrying on an analysis of a typo.
 
You mean, except for the fact that intent has to be established before any part of the hoax bomb statute begins to apply?

And the fact that at no time did the kid do or say anything to any of the people with whom he interacted which can in any way be twisted into claiming he was trying to make someone think it was a bomb?

Other than those facts?

You don't know that. You really only know Ahmed's side of the story so far. There are usually two sides to a story, especially in cases where somebody is arrested.
 
<snip>

And at 5% of a single year's budget for the city I don't consider the initial number to be particularly excessive. It has to be enough to get them to change their behavior or it won't do any good at all.

Lawsuits can work to change bad behavior for the better, but they have to have enough teeth to make them hurt.

Well, actually they're asking for compensation for the emotional damage to Ahmed, most of which, if there is any at all, was inflicted by Ahmed himself and his family by going public so aggressively. As yet, however, they have not filed a lawsuit. They are only threatening to. I doubt that they will actually. A lawsuit opens the floodgates to discovery and exposes the family to further humiliation. If there was a reasonable chance of getting a significant settlement, then it might be worth it, but I think their case for damages is pretty weak. Ahmed looks to have gained rather than lost from the whole thing, and he's on record as saying that the experience was "pretty cool." So even if the police are proved to have made an illegitimate arrest, there is no claim upon which relief can be granted.

It always puzzles me (not really :p) that conservatives are so enthusiastic about being tough with penalties when they are applied to groups they despise but so much less so when the penalties start striking closer to home, like the misbehavior of authority.

Do you have any examples? I can't think of any off the top of my head.
 
"...going public so aggressively..."


Yeah, gods forbid someone post a family item of interest on Facebook.

Dude, little tiny spark blew up and went viral. A few hours later they responded with Ahmed's video. That's pretty much all they did. The Internet blew up around them on it's own internal motivation.
 
"...going public so aggressively..."


Yeah, gods forbid someone post a family item of interest on Facebook.

Dude, little tiny spark blew up and went viral. A few hours later they responded with Ahmed's video. That's pretty much all they did. The Internet blew up around them on it's own internal motivation.

My memory is a little different. I thought they went straight to the media, as well as to CAIR. Regardless, it takes two to tango when it comes to publicity like this. If there was a media interview that the family or Ahmed turned down, I would be flabbergasted. Well, other than interviews with right-wing propaganda outlets like Fox :rolleyes:.
 
It looked like something designed to resemble a fake, movie bomb to me, not a real one. That being said, it didn't look like a clock to me, and it was certainly possible that it was the infrastructure of a real bomb.

As someone who grew up in a household full of electronics, it looks like it could be a clock to me, or any number of hacked together devices that kids playing with electronics build.

Explosives for a bomb do not have to be added until the end. Usually you want to get all of the circuitry done first, and make sure the arming circuit works. Putting the explosives in before the arming mechanism is verified has probably led to many terrorists blowing themselves up prematurely.

so without the explosives it's not a bomb.

In any case, plastic explosives can be shaped into any form and can be camouflaged. Explosives could have been hidden in the desiccant packet underneath the netting in the corner. They could have been stuck behind the large LED display. Or they could have been shaped to form the lining of the box itself.

oh good grief. So you assume that it might have explosives hidden in it somewhere? Why? Because his name is Mohammed?
 
Form follows function. Function does not follow form. Ahmed's Clock was a random appliance a curious person with a screwdriver took apart at some point. Him? Maybe, maybe not. My mom used to buy me random crap at thrift stores to keep me busy. Generally tearing things down results in an object not returning to service. Parts get lost, case halves get stepped on, screws fall down a heat vent.

Ahmed managed to return to the thing to some level of service. Pictures I've seen show solder rework. One comment, something he said in his video, suggested the display was only partially functional. Once a kid has soldered a wire back to the board he realizes holding things still prevents the solder joints from getting messed up again. He screwed it into a non-conductive box. And in the morning he was still excited by this little victory and took it to a teacher.

Form follows function, function does not follow form. A teacher held on to he's box for some time, apparently, before concluding the object represented some form of danger that required "procedures."

Lack of imagination and understanding BY ADULT EDUCATIONAL PROFESSIONALS misidentified the object and reacted appropriately to the only thing their limited imagination could conceive for a kid mounting a circuitboard to a toolbox.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom