Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

<snip>

Your last sentence is where we have a disagreement. Ahmed said it was a clock, and it looked like a clock and worked like a clock. Ergo, it's a clock. As for motive, in my mind wanting to try out a case mod was reason enough for doing a case mod.

It didn't look like a clock to me. This is precisely where I think Ahmed's defenders are being disingenuous. Social media exploded with the meme that Ahmed's invention was obviously a clock, and that the idiots down in Irving, Texas would be suspicious of virtually any clock. The problem was that the device was not obviously a clock. Almost nobody other than electronics whizzes, looking at that thing without the benefit of the hindsight, would identify it as a clock. Furthermore, I think I have made a plausible case that it wasn't even a clock. It was a bunch of working clock parts in a box, which is not the same thing.

This looks like an example of a counter-effect noticed by Dunning and Kruger in their paper Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One's Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments

Another way to put this is people who are really good at doing things often forget that others who haven't invested time and effort into learning a certain skillset aren't very good at doing it. It appears you're assessing his case mod as something you would expect from an adult experienced with using tools, instead of from an adolescent trying something out. Different people have different levels of capability, experience, and access to tools.

I believe today, as do the Irving police, that Ahmed did not intend to build a hoax bomb. I think rather he intended to deceive his teachers into believing he was an electronics whiz (there may have been an element of self-delusion involved). The Dunning-Kruger effect you cite actually works in favor of my support of the police here (or at least my reluctance to denounce them). If they suffered from this effect, they too may have believed that Ahmed couldn't be telling the truth because the device looked hardly worth inventing for its own sake.
 
The point of the statute is that he had to KNOWINGLY be building a hoax bomb. That isn't what he did. He was building a clock. Whether you want to call it a clock or not does not really matter for the purposes of the statute. The first prong of the hoax bomb statute fails because he did not knowingly build a hoax bomb.



Moot point, because other people's perceptions are not important for the knowingly aspect of the statute. All that matters there is Ahmed's thoughts, and he thought he was making a clock.



Not under the law. The law requires him to know he was making a hoax bomb.



Again, so? How much effort he put in does not matter for the purposes of the statute.

You seem to be shifting the goal posts. I have never argued that Ahmed was guilty. I have only argued that the police could have had probable cause to arrest him. They cannot read his mind after all, and they didn't know then much of what they and we know today. And we don't know, even today, what they knew then. As I pointed out again above, the device Ahmed constructed seems pointless. It is natural to be suspicious of such a device, as well as the person who made it and brought it to school. It does seem like a bit of an overreaction that an arrest was made, but I would withhold judgment (and defend the police from premature slander) until the other side of the story is known.

I believe both the teacher and the principal have said he showed it to his teacher. I could be wrong on that, though.

I could be wrong too, but I do remember thinking it odd that there was never anything published about the engineering teacher or his side of the story. There has also never been any commentary from anybody else in the community, including Ahmed's classmates. Really, aside from a couple of short official statements from the school and the police, 100% of the story comes from Ahmed and his family. Actually, thinking about it now, I find that very strange.

However, that is not what the statute says. To fall under the statute, Ahmed had to intend to use the device he built as a hoax bomb. Also, remember that Ahmed does not have to prove his innocence. The state must prove his guilt. He stated it was a clock, and maintained that claim. If you want to argue that it was a hoax bomb, show some evidence he intended to use the device as a hoax bomb.

Once again, I am not arguing that it was a hoax bomb. I am arguing that the police may have had probable cause to believe it was a hoax bomb. There is a world of difference between making a legitimate arrest and convicting somebody of a crime.
 
The police interrogated him specifically to find out why he brought the device to school

"Why did you bring that clock to school?"

Totally a legitimate use of law enforcement ressources.

and they claimed that he was being passive-aggressive.

Maybe he should've kissed their boots.

If all he said was that the device was a clock and kept repeating that, then I can see why they would consider him to be hiding something.

Yeah, he should've lied instead. Stupid kid.
 
Sunmaster14 asserted:
I'm sorry, but the "case mod" was idiotic. Ahmed is 14 years old, not 7. It is not unreasonable to suspect that he was up to something a little more sophisticated.

Please share with us the objective metric you have used which determines this work does not represent the naive actions of an arbitrary unsophisticated 14 year old.

Seriously, because if you guys are gonna keep dragging the goalposts over to this strawman you could at least prove you're stuffing the strawman correctly.


Your subjective analyisis is subjective.
 
This is getting ridiculous. It wasn't a bomb, and it wasn't a hoax bomb, which is a non-bomb intended to appear as a bomb, but it may be intended to appear as a hoax bomb? How many turtles is that?

Ah, there was a typo. Please take the word "hoax" out of my statement. I meant to write that "It is if you intend for people to think it is a bomb."
 
Sunmaster14 asserted:


Please share with us the objective metric you have used which determines this work does not represent the naive actions of an arbitrary unsophisticated 14 year old.

Seriously, because if you guys are gonna keep dragging the goalposts over to this strawman you could at least prove you're stuffing the strawman correctly.


Your subjective analyisis is subjective.

I refer you to my discussion of 14 year olds here. I have a 14 year old son, by the way, so I am quite up-to-date on what 14 year old boys are like.
 
Do you think it looked like a bomb? Which part looked like explosives?

It looked like something designed to resemble a fake, movie bomb to me, not a real one. That being said, it didn't look like a clock to me, and it was certainly possible that it was the infrastructure of a real bomb. Explosives for a bomb do not have to be added until the end. Usually you want to get all of the circuitry done first, and make sure the arming circuit works. Putting the explosives in before the arming mechanism is verified has probably led to many terrorists blowing themselves up prematurely.

In any case, plastic explosives can be shaped into any form and can be camouflaged. Explosives could have been hidden in the desiccant packet underneath the netting in the corner. They could have been stuck behind the large LED display. Or they could have been shaped to form the lining of the box itself.
 
I refer you to my discussion of 14 year olds here. I have a 14 year old son, by the way, so I am quite up-to-date on what 14 year old boys are like.

{eta: quote added for clarity}


I do to, and I was a 14 year armed with a screwdriver and dangerous to warranties myself.

I would not expect all 14 year olds from all cultural and educational backgrounds to exhibit uniform and identical level of technical sophistication.


My subjective analysis is that Ahmed's Clock is 100% consistent with a very early point of technology exploration. He's just barely in the functional description stage, passing out of a stage sometimes called "cargocult" understanding.

My Objective observation is at what he created resembles, because form follows function, any number of benchtop electronics objects made, varyingly, for kids, alarm company salesmen, microcomputer hardware developers and institutional learning facilities. As such, his "clock invention" is useful, not as a packaged piece of consumer stuff with all the interesting bits hidden away under Tupperware but a research object. With the circuit boards held safely in the box he can plug it in and start poking it with a multimeter.
 
Last edited:
{eta: quote added for clarity}


I do to, and I was a 14 year armed with a screwdriver and dangerous to warranties myself.

I would not expect all 14 year olds from all cultural and educational backgrounds to exhibit uniform and identical level of technical sophistication.


My subjective analysis is that Ahmed's Clock is 100% consistent with a very early point of technology exploration. He's just barely in the functional description stage, passing out of a stage sometimes called "cargocult" understanding.

My Objective observation is at what he created resembles, because form follows function, any number of benchtop electronics objects made, varyingly, for kids, alarm company salesmen, microcomputer hardware developers and institutional learning facilities. As such, his "clock invention" is useful, not as a packaged piece of consumer stuff with all the interesting bits hidden away under Tupperware but a research object. With the circuit boards held safely in the box he can plug it in and start poking it with a multimeter.

That's fine, and maybe Ahmed will turn into a fine engineer some day. He certainly seems to have the motivation. But the context here, as I pointed out above, is what was it reasonable for the police to think? If the police were reasonably handy themselves or were familiar with 14 year old boys who were reasonably handy, they might have been skeptical that the device was just an experiment or a case mod. It's one of those things where the less you know, the more suspicious you are (because you're too ignorant to know that it's not a bomb), and the more you know the more suspicious you are (because you can't believe that a 14 year old would think that stuffing a clock in a box was worth bringing to school).
 
That's fine, and maybe Ahmed will turn into a fine engineer some day. He certainly seems to have the motivation. But the context here, as I pointed out above, is what was it reasonable for the police to think? If the police were reasonably handy themselves or were familiar with 14 year old boys who were reasonably handy, they might have been skeptical that the device was just an experiment or a case mod. It's one of those things where the less you know, the more suspicious you are (because you're too ignorant to know that it's not a bomb), and the more you know the more suspicious you are (because you can't believe that a 14 year old would think that stuffing a clock in a box was worth bringing to school).

Awesome goal post move! Smoothly executed, and you made it looked like I helped you. Well done. 5 internet points for you!
 
Awesome goal post move! Smoothly executed, and you made it looked like I helped you. Well done. 5 internet points for you!

I think he was just humoring you, the question under the statute is of course not whether the police (or some other expert) knew that the hoax bomb was dangerous, or hell whether the hoax bomb was dangerous (although ironically this one was due to its electrocution risk not its explosive risk) but rather the intent of the perp.

This is all plainly laid out in the statute and in this thread.
 
We have two alarm clocks plugged in 27/7 in our bedroom. One for me, one for Mrs. qg.

On occasion (more than a few occasions :o) either one of these has been known to go off when it wasn't intended.

Sometimes it was because we forgot to turn the alarm all the way off and simply hit the "stop" button, leaving it to go off the next day. Unintended.

In the case of one of them, one of our cats has learned that if she stands her paws in enough spots it will turn on the radio and get us up to feed her. Sometimes while doing that she manages to engage the slider switch which turns on the alarm. And later it will go off. Unintended.

How do you know he did intend for it to go off? Is that the only possible reason he could have had for plugging it in?

I did not say I knew he intended for it to go off, that's your straw man, I said he knew it would not have gone off if he had not plugged it in.

What your and your wife's' troubles with alarms and the cat's antics have to do with this I will leave as an exercise for the reader unless you are suggesting a cat was the culprit.:jaw-dropp
 
Lets ignore the only person in the thread who appears to have read the statute.... :rolleyes:

Completely ignoring the point by point analysis I made of the statute...

the test is not what an expert in improvised explosions believes... further, for example, under the hoax bomb statute an empty briefcase can be a hoax bomb.

It could, if that was the intent of the person with the empty briefcase.

It didn't look like a clock to me.

Which is lovely. You aren't everyone.

Furthermore, I think I have made a plausible case that it wasn't even a clock. It was a bunch of working clock parts in a box, which is not the same thing.

Which is more than a lot of 14-year olds could do. It is masterwork? Nope. Is it something interesting? Yes, if you are interested in electronics.

I think rather he intended to deceive his teachers into believing he was an electronics whiz (there may have been an element of self-delusion involved).

Self-delusion I can agree with. The first time anyone creates something, there is a level of pride. But which is the better option - encouraging a kid's creativity (even if the first attempts are...less than optimal), or shutting the kid down by saying the first attempt is crap and he'll never get better?

You seem to be shifting the goal posts. I have never argued that Ahmed was guilty.

You were addressing my analysis of the statute, which is how I was addressing the answer. You've also been supporting the police, which gave the impression that you think he could be guilty. I am sorry if I read the wrong conclusion.

I have only argued that the police could have had probable cause to arrest him.

And this is where we differ, though I grant I am looking at this as a defense attorney, so assuming innocence of the accused. ;)

More facts (which will come out eventually) will answer a lot of things. One thing that is definitely an issue is that he was questioned without his parents (or an attorney) present. (A big no-no with juveniles.) The other thing that makes me question the officer's probable cause is that at no time was the clock treated as a bomb, and the (assumed) fact that Ahmed always said it was a clock. If he really did show the clock to the teacher, then that indicates that his intent from the start was not to pretend it was a bomb, but to show his (budding?) electronics work. A simple question to the teacher would have resolved everything. ("Did Ahmed show you his contraption?" "Yes, he said it's a clock. Rather rough, but he's just starting out." or "No, I didn't know anything about the thing until you asked me just now.")

They cannot read his mind after all,

No, but some basic investigation can go a long way. This all happened during the school day, so it would have been simple to page the teacher in question to the office and ask him what he knew about the device.

That, in my opinion, is where the police officers made their mistake. It appears (for now, with what we know) that they made an assumption and ran with it, rather than actually investigate.

and they didn't know then much of what they and we know today.

They knew what Ahmed told them. Basic police work says to follow up on a suspect's story. The people involved were all there at the school.

As I pointed out again above, the device Ahmed constructed seems pointless.

To you. To him, it could be priceless.

I could be wrong too, but I do remember thinking it odd that there was never anything published about the engineering teacher or his side of the story.

The school staff may have been told not to speak to the media.

There has also never been any commentary from anybody else in the community, including Ahmed's classmates.

Nothing reported. That doesn't mean they aren't talking, just that nothing has made it to the press.
 
Completely ignoring the point by point analysis I made of the statute...

You did what?

*Puts on criminal defense attorney hat.*

There are three key words/phrases in that statute.

(1) Knowingly: Ahmed had to know he was building a hoax bomb. Since he was building a clock, that point fails.

"analysis" is a bit of a stretch, wouldn't you agree?

But you are correct that I did ignore it. If I wanted to listen to some perp's defense lawyer giving a closing argument I'd go to 26th and Cal.
 
I did not say I knew he intended for it to go off, that's your straw man, I said he knew it would not have gone off if he had not plugged it in.


Here is what you said.
How do you know what he intended? If he didn't want it to go off he wouldn't have plugged it in.


​
You clearly suggested that you have some idea of what he intended.

Unless that was just a truism, and a meaningless comment.
What your and your wife's' troubles with alarms and the cat's antics have to do with this I will leave as an exercise for the reader unless you are suggesting a cat was the culprit.:jaw-dropp


The anecdote was intended as an example of ways an alarm could go off unintended for perfectly harmless reasons.

I'm sorry that that escaped you, but I can't help you with you refusal to comprehend.

Or your pointless snark.
 
Last edited:
You did what?



"analysis" is a bit of a stretch, wouldn't you agree?

But you are correct that I did ignore it.


Which seems to be your standard policy when confronted with inconvenient facts you are unable to refute.

If I wanted to listen to some perp's defense lawyer giving a closing argument I'd go to 26th and Cal.



And then this sort of derisive comment, which you seem to think is some sort of internet-point-winning substitute.

It isn't.

It just makes you look sillier.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom