sunmaster14
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2014
- Messages
- 10,017
<snip>
Your last sentence is where we have a disagreement. Ahmed said it was a clock, and it looked like a clock and worked like a clock. Ergo, it's a clock. As for motive, in my mind wanting to try out a case mod was reason enough for doing a case mod.
It didn't look like a clock to me. This is precisely where I think Ahmed's defenders are being disingenuous. Social media exploded with the meme that Ahmed's invention was obviously a clock, and that the idiots down in Irving, Texas would be suspicious of virtually any clock. The problem was that the device was not obviously a clock. Almost nobody other than electronics whizzes, looking at that thing without the benefit of the hindsight, would identify it as a clock. Furthermore, I think I have made a plausible case that it wasn't even a clock. It was a bunch of working clock parts in a box, which is not the same thing.
This looks like an example of a counter-effect noticed by Dunning and Kruger in their paper Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One's Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments
Another way to put this is people who are really good at doing things often forget that others who haven't invested time and effort into learning a certain skillset aren't very good at doing it. It appears you're assessing his case mod as something you would expect from an adult experienced with using tools, instead of from an adolescent trying something out. Different people have different levels of capability, experience, and access to tools.
I believe today, as do the Irving police, that Ahmed did not intend to build a hoax bomb. I think rather he intended to deceive his teachers into believing he was an electronics whiz (there may have been an element of self-delusion involved). The Dunning-Kruger effect you cite actually works in favor of my support of the police here (or at least my reluctance to denounce them). If they suffered from this effect, they too may have believed that Ahmed couldn't be telling the truth because the device looked hardly worth inventing for its own sake.
