Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

That is a curious question, before I answer, I have to know what are your credentials in the field of asking for credentials in the field of law?

HA! No, just *********** with you, a silly question deserves a silly response.

By the way, anytime you want to focus on the argument and not the arguer would be all right by me.


Your arguments can be evaluated based on your knowledge and experience. Since you do not seem to be able to offer any facts which contradict the explanations offered by BardKesnit I was simply wondering if you had any other basis for challenging his educated, professional explanation with your opinions.

From your response I'm guessing the answer is no.

That's fine. You're entitled to your own opinion.

Of course, as the saying goes, you aren't entitled to your own facts.
 
Your arguments can be evaluated based on your knowledge and experience. Since you do not seem to be able to offer any facts which contradict the explanations offered by BardKesnit I was simply wondering if you had any other basis for challenging his educated, professional explanation with your opinions.

From your response I'm guessing the answer is no.

That's fine. You're entitled to your own opinion.

Of course, as the saying goes, you aren't entitled to your own facts.

HI! You seem to be having a huge problem with the difference between facts and opinions, much like "bard" was with analysis/advocate. You see, he was arguing a position based on his opinions and conclusions regarding disputed facts. I'd be happy to help explain it further, but having already done so you did not seem that appreciative and you also seem to be addicted to making arguments by bare assertion.

By the way? I gotta give you a 10 out of 10 on the truther-o-meter for your nonsense explanation for your "R U a Lawyer" "argument."

RU A Lolyer! :thumbsup::D:thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
I hope you realize you're carrying on an analysis of a typo.

No, I'm not. We have had lots and lots of variations on it. "It looked like it might be a hoax bomb." "They thought it was a hoax bomb." "They knew it wasn't a bomb, but they thought it looked like a hoax bomb."

No. Things don't "look like hoax bombs". Or, if they do, they aren't hoax bombs. They're hoax hoax bombs. In order to be a hoax, the thing has to be presented in such a fashion that someone is meant to believe it was the thing that is being hoaxed.

It could indeed be a hoax hoax bomb. In fact, if the truth be told, I think it was a hoax hoax bomb. I think he knew very well that people would freak out, not because it was a bomb, and not because they thought it was a bomb, but because they would think that he had built something that looked like something intentionally built to resemble a fake bomb.

And that's not illegal.


And I don't know whether or not he did that, but I think it's possible. If he did, it was what was referred to a long way back as "trolling". He wanted to expose their reaction when he took something that wasn't a bomb, and wasn't a good imitation of a bomb, but even after he told them it was a clock, and they could examine it and see that it was a clock, they would still freak out. They did. He was right. Furthermore, it isn't illegal to do so.
 
It is the "Amhed's side of the story" which the police reported.

What else do you have to add?

The police didn't arrest him right away. They interrogated him first. Apparently that interrogation made them suspicious enough to arrest him. They have only said that he was passive-aggressive and wouldn't say more than that the device was a clock. I think if we had more detail, we could better judge whether they had probable cause for an arrest. I don't think police take arresting 14 year kids lightly. And, to tell you the truth, I think the fact that Ahmed was a Muslim made it less likely that he would be arrested, not more likely. At least I bet that would be the case in my neck of the woods, where "affinity" groups are all the rage, so that kids from underprivileged minorities can have some safe space from the privileged white kids (who are taught to be good "allies").
 
No, I'm not. We have had lots and lots of variations on it. "It looked like it might be a hoax bomb." "They thought it was a hoax bomb." "They knew it wasn't a bomb, but they thought it looked like a hoax bomb."

No. Things don't "look like hoax bombs". Or, if they do, they aren't hoax bombs. They're hoax hoax bombs. In order to be a hoax, the thing has to be presented in such a fashion that someone is meant to believe it was the thing that is being hoaxed.

It could indeed be a hoax hoax bomb. In fact, if the truth be told, I think it was a hoax hoax bomb. I think he knew very well that people would freak out, not because it was a bomb, and not because they thought it was a bomb, but because they would think that he had built something that looked like something intentionally built to resemble a fake bomb.

And that's not illegal.


And I don't know whether or not he did that, but I think it's possible. If he did, it was what was referred to a long way back as "trolling". He wanted to expose their reaction when he took something that wasn't a bomb, and wasn't a good imitation of a bomb, but even after he told them it was a clock, and they could examine it and see that it was a clock, they would still freak out. They did. He was right. Furthermore, it isn't illegal to do so.

Well, if he did indeed troll the school and police with a hoax hoax bomb, then I think their response was appropriate. They trolled him back by pretending that they were going to charge him with a crime. The handcuffs probably weren't even real.
 
Does Texas have a law about hoax hoax hoax bombs?

I think a hoax hoax hoax bomb would be a piece of paper with the word "bomb" on it. Or perhaps "gub." Of course, that would get most kids suspended from school, but probably not an invitation to the White House.
 
Well, if he did indeed troll the school and police with a hoax hoax bomb, then I think their response was appropriate. They trolled him back by pretending that they were going to charge him with a crime. The handcuffs probably weren't even real.

Well, except, they didn't. Because what they did was real. It wasn't a hoax, and it wasn't a hoax of a hoax.

And the lawsuit is neither a troll nor a hoax.
 
No, I'm not. We have had lots and lots of variations on it. "It looked like it might be a hoax bomb." "They thought it was a hoax bomb." "They knew it wasn't a bomb, but they thought it looked like a hoax bomb."

No. Things don't "look like hoax bombs". Or, if they do, they aren't hoax bombs. They're hoax hoax bombs. In order to be a hoax, the thing has to be presented in such a fashion that someone is meant to believe it was the thing that is being hoaxed.

It could indeed be a hoax hoax bomb. In fact, if the truth be told, I think it was a hoax hoax bomb. I think he knew very well that people would freak out, not because it was a bomb, and not because they thought it was a bomb, but because they would think that he had built something that looked like something intentionally built to resemble a fake bomb.

And that's not illegal.


And I don't know whether or not he did that, but I think it's possible. If he did, it was what was referred to a long way back as "trolling". He wanted to expose their reaction when he took something that wasn't a bomb, and wasn't a good imitation of a bomb, but even after he told them it was a clock, and they could examine it and see that it was a clock, they would still freak out. They did. He was right. Furthermore, it isn't illegal to do so.



Diabolical!
 
Maybe I'm out of step with current culture but I don't value spending ten minutes watching an angry idiot yell opionions at his laptop. I made it all the way to 49 seconds of that one only by grinding my teeth.

.

Also, I disagree 100% with the conclusion. For many and various reasons I've voiced many times in this very thread. No presentation of uninformed opinions will change my analysis of Ahmed's project as a naive work by a naive and technically unsophisticated experimenter. What he created resembles a bench-rugged electronics experimenter kit far more than it does a "bomb" or "hoax bomb" in my view, based on being an experimenter myself.
If you refuse to spend a few minutes watching the video, your disagreement with the conclusion is meaningless. It shows that you decided early on to take a dogmatic position and there's no reason to discuss it further with you.
 
If I posted a link to a 430 page document, claiming it supported my position without providing any specifics as to the argument or my own views, is it an obligation of anyone seeking to refute my position to read the 430 page document?
Nope.

But you also can't claim the 430 page document is incorrect if you don't read enough of it to reasonably evaluate it. Watching 49 seconds of a 10 minute video doesn't pass that test.
 
Last edited:
Nope.

But you also can't claim the 430 page document is incorrect if you don't read enough of it to reasonably evaluate it. Watching 49 seconds of a 10 minute video doesn't pass that test.


How much is "enough"? You are suggesting that 8% isn't.

I've read a lot of books. Often I have read books which weren't very good all the way through.

I have not often had to read very far into a book before its quality (or lack thereof) became apparent. Finishing it generally only vindicates the initial assessment.

With some rare exceptions a handful of pages is sufficient. Eight percent is way more than sufficient. I'll finish them because I'm stubborn that way, and because "Who knows?', it might get better.

It rarely does.

Same thing is true with videos, movies, etc. If I cannot be convinced that what I am watching is worth my time after having watched nearly a tenth of it then I probably won't be convinced by the time I reach the end.

Life is short. Why waste too much time on the obvious?
 
Last edited:
.


If you refuse to spend a few minutes watching the video, your disagreement with the conclusion is meaningless. It shows that you decided early on to take a dogmatic position and there's no reason to discuss it further with you.

I'm sorry to be unclear, but I'll clarify. No video of "angry man yelling opinions at his laptop" thus far in my entire lifetime has ever contained enough factual information to merit viewing. Ever. If you want me to change my opinion that Ahmed's Clock is a naive work by a naive experimenter, present factual information that
1) show he is less naive than he appears
2) demonstrate how his work qualitatively or quantitatively differs from a naive project by a naive experimenter.
3) has actual proof the various dots connected are actual dots and actually conect - such as the waffles about his sister


I reject the video because it's crap.

I reject the conclusions of the video (i don't need to watch the whole thing to see where he's going) not because of the video or my refusal to watch it but because the contention (them a-rabs is up to sumpin, I tell ya) is crap.
 
It was a hoax because Ahmed said "Look at this cool clock I built". He didn't build a clock.

At most, that would be him trying to trick his teachers into thinking more favorably of him, a variant of academic cheating, and would be a strange thing to call a hoax. In the context of this thread, we're talking about whether or not his intent was to bait the school authorities into acting the way they did.
 
Took 'em a long time to dig her up.

I wonder why?

You sure you want to know? See here. The hated Breitbart site filed an FOIA request with the school and was able to obtain an email to the principal from the girl, dated Oct 1. If you look at the document, which I will attach, she also had an email exchange with a history teacher on September 17, where she expresses similar sentiments.

After Breitbart publicized the email on November 25, a couple of news outlets followed up, and the girl decided she was willing to speak out. Of course, only the conservative blogosphere is covering this. The liberal media can't let reality intrude on their comfortable narrative of bigoted Texans.
 

Attachments

You sure you want to know? See here. The hated Breitbart site filed an FOIA request with the school and was able to obtain an email to the principal from the girl, dated Oct 1. If you look at the document, which I will attach, she also had an email exchange with a history teacher on September 17, where she expresses similar sentiments.

After Breitbart publicized the email on November 25, a couple of news outlets followed up, and the girl decided she was willing to speak out. Of course, only the conservative blogosphere is covering this. The liberal media can't let reality intrude on their comfortable narrative of bigoted Texans.
Does it fit better with the comfortable narrative expressed by conservatives here that the girl had threatened to blow up the school, and was a clever, conniving terrorist who participated in a huge conspiracy with her brother and father to embarrass the school? Does the letter sound as if she would have expected the school to arrest her brother for a clock project, thus permitting a huge financial windfall for the family in a future suit?

I only dropped by to see if there was any change in the nature of this thread. I did notice that you have continued to participate even after indicating that you felt it had become boring. Well, I still find it boring and repetitive. I just could not resist noting how much this letter goes against the conservative take on the sister as a terrorist who had threatened the school. But like me, you may wish to consider a multi-level, anti-thread addiction problem. I will need to confess this post in front of the group on Sunday.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom