Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

You sure you want to know? See here. The hated Breitbart site filed an FOIA request with the school and was able to obtain an email to the principal from the girl, dated Oct 1. If you look at the document, which I will attach, she also had an email exchange with a history teacher on September 17, where she expresses similar sentiments.

After Breitbart publicized the email on November 25, a couple of news outlets followed up, and the girl decided she was willing to speak out. Of course, only the conservative blogosphere is covering this. The liberal media can't let reality intrude on their comfortable narrative of bigoted Texans.

It seems odd to me that such an email could be obtained through FOIA.

Is that really part of the public interest? I suppose she wasn't a student, and no student was involved, so privacy laws wouldn't apply? I shudder to think that such private conversation could be gotten by court order.

It's not a huge deal, because I doubt she would be concerned about its revelation, but it's just odd.
 
Does it fit better with the comfortable narrative expressed by conservatives here that the girl had threatened to blow up the school, and was a clever, conniving terrorist who participated in a huge conspiracy with her brother and father to embarrass the school? Does the letter sound as if she would have expected the school to arrest her brother for a clock project, thus permitting a huge financial windfall for the family in a future suit?

I only dropped by to see if there was any change in the nature of this thread. I did notice that you have continued to participate even after indicating that you felt it had become boring. Well, I still find it boring and repetitive. I just could not resist noting how much this letter goes against the conservative take on the sister as a terrorist who had threatened the school. But like me, you may wish to consider a multi-level, anti-thread addiction problem. I will need to confess this post in front of the group on Sunday.
What letter are you referring to? The one cited by sunmaster14 was not written by the clock boy's sister.
 
It seems odd to me that such an email could be obtained through FOIA.

Is that really part of the public interest? I suppose she wasn't a student, and no student was involved, so privacy laws wouldn't apply? I shudder to think that such private conversation could be gotten by court order.

It's not a huge deal, because I doubt she would be concerned about its revelation, but it's just odd.

That's a good question. It's possible that the school could easily have withheld the letter if it wanted to. For obvious reasons, it probably didn't want to.
 
Does it fit better with the comfortable narrative expressed by conservatives here that the girl had threatened to blow up the school, and was a clever, conniving terrorist who participated in a huge conspiracy with her brother and father to embarrass the school? Does the letter sound as if she would have expected the school to arrest her brother for a clock project, thus permitting a huge financial windfall for the family in a future suit?

I only dropped by to see if there was any change in the nature of this thread. I did notice that you have continued to participate even after indicating that you felt it had become boring. Well, I still find it boring and repetitive. I just could not resist noting how much this letter goes against the conservative take on the sister as a terrorist who had threatened the school. But like me, you may wish to consider a multi-level, anti-thread addiction problem. I will need to confess this post in front of the group on Sunday.

I expect that when you finally understand what the letter is about, you'll see that it represents a major development. This whole clock boy saga, along with the accusations of Islamophobia against the Irving School District, will now go down the liberal media memory hole.
 
Took 'em a long time to dig her up.

I wonder why?

She wasn't "dug up" she came forward when all this happened and wrote a letter of support to the principle. Doesn't fit your narrative though, so I'm sure that info never got processed by your mind.
 
I'm not sure what the sister's bomb threat has to do with this. Is it evidence that she's the type of person who would induce her younger brother into baiting the authorities? Is it the type of experience needed to successfully orchestrate a baiting scheme? What?
 
She wasn't "dug up" she came forward when all this happened and wrote a letter of support to the principle. Doesn't fit your narrative though, so I'm sure that info never got processed by your mind.

Actually, it's simply of no matter to the discussion in the first place, which is about how various authorities treated Ahmed, not this other person.
 
I'm not sure what the sister's bomballegedthreat has to do with this. Is it evidence that she's the type of person who would induce her younger brother into baiting the authorities? Is it the type of experience needed to successfully orchestrate a baiting scheme? What?

Highlighted bit added - I don't think there is enough evidence to say that she made a threat, only that she was suspended for making a threat, and we know how the school reacted to an unrealistic, unintentional, hoax bomb.

Actually, it's simply of no matter to the discussion in the first place, which is about how various authorities treated Ahmed, not this other person.

This.
 
Actually, it's simply of no matter to the discussion in the first place, which is about how various authorities treated Ahmed, not this other person.

No, it is extremely relevant to the discussion. This whole saga only went viral because of the element of alleged Islamophobia. I think (hope) that everyone here would agree that if Ahmed were a white kid named Michael, and this still had happened to him, there would have been no invitation to the White House or any of the other goodies that Ahmed has received. Whenever this point is brought up, the typical liberal responds that a white kid named Michael wouldn't have been arrested and suspended in the first place. Well, the latest story undermines that argument substantially. In fact, it looks like the school has a substantial number of Muslim students, and it bends over backwards to make them feel welcome. Basically, this girl's story is strong evidence that the whole narrative which made the story go viral is absolute ********.

Here's a Google search of the news I did just now. Except for an extremely short blurb on the local CBS news web site (where it is clear that a reporter just sponged off other reports), there is no mention of this story on any mainstream media outlet or liberal web site. The bias in curation is truly disgusting. If you find out later that you slandered people, even unintentionally, I think it is a moral responsbility to unslander them later when new facts come out.
 
No, it is extremely relevant to the discussion. This whole saga only went viral because of the element of alleged Islamophobia. I think (hope) that everyone here would agree that if Ahmed were a white kid named Michael, and this still had happened to him, there would have been no invitation to the White House or any of the other goodies that Ahmed has received. Whenever this point is brought up, the typical liberal responds that a white kid named Michael wouldn't have been arrested and suspended in the first place. Well, the latest story undermines that argument substantially. In fact, it looks like the school has a substantial number of Muslim students, and it bends over backwards to make them feel welcome. Basically, this girl's story is strong evidence that the whole narrative which made the story go viral is absolute ********.

Here's a Google search of the news I did just now. Except for an extremely short blurb on the local CBS news web site (where it is clear that a reporter just sponged off other reports), there is no mention of this story on any mainstream media outlet or liberal web site. The bias in curation is truly disgusting. If you find out later that you slandered people, even unintentionally, I think it is a moral responsbility to unslander them later when new facts come out.

Welcome to the 21st century and the ongoing Death of Professional Journalism. The lack of archival of news by online output companies is very disturbing to me.
 
No, it is extremely relevant to the discussion.

No, it's really not. It's equivalent to that one black guy that recently wrote about how he had a real gun when pulled over by the cops, or Phylicia Rashad saying that Bill Cosby always treated her great. Even putting aside the problems with Breitbart, the simple problem is that this is confusing bigotry with raging lunacy. It doesn't change what happened in this case, it doesn't change the mayor's nonsense about Sharia Law coming to her town, and so it simply doesn't really address the topic.

(Also, refusing to take Breitbart's articles as true and well-researched isn't "hatred", it's simply noting their habit of publishing poorly-researched, and often maliciously edited, nonsense)
 
Last edited:
No, it is extremely relevant to the discussion. This whole saga only went viral because of the element of alleged Islamophobia. I think (hope) that everyone here would agree that if Ahmed were a white kid named Michael, and this still had happened to him, there would have been no invitation to the White House or any of the other goodies that Ahmed has received. Whenever this point is brought up, the typical liberal responds that a white kid named Michael wouldn't have been arrested and suspended in the first place. Well, the latest story undermines that argument substantially. In fact, it looks like the school has a substantial number of Muslim students, and it bends over backwards to make them feel welcome. Basically, this girl's story is strong evidence that the whole narrative which made the story go viral is absolute ********.

When it comes right down to it, the invitation to the White House isn't relevant either. The fact that the story went viral isn't relevant, either.

The motive in arresting Ahmed is somewhat relevant to the story, but not central to it. The central element of the story is that a kid who did a case mod of a clock was arrested. Is there any reason that the kid ought to have been arrested? Did he do anything worthy of arrest?

Some, indeed many, have put it down to racisim and/or Islamophobia, but there is no concrete evidence of this. I and some others have said that anti-intellectualism played a primary role, with Islamophobia possibly playing a secondary role, but there's no concrete evidence of this. There is no evidence at all of their motivation for this, because they haven't spoken of it except to say that he was "passive aggressive" and "not forthcoming". Since those aren't crimes, we are still left scratching our heads searching for answers to why he was arrested.

In the absence of such answers, people speculate, and that speculation is the source of the explanations of Islamophobia or anti-intellectualism.

And since we speculate, I will also do some more speculation, not on why Ahmed was arrested, but on why people defend that arrest. I suggest that Obama Derangement Syndrome plays a large role. Because Obama jumped in, he must be attacked, and whatever position that Obama takes must be attacked in every aspect. Not only must his rush to defense of Ahmed be attacked, but the suggestion that Ahmed suffered any injustice at all must be attacked. In order to attack the latter suggestion, it is necessary to justify the arrest itself. Therefore, the arrest of a kid everyone knew did not make a bomb, and everyone knew he went out of his way to make sure he did not make a bomb, is still somehow seen as justifying an arrest because.........what was it again? Well, whatever it was, it seems like made up BS. The real driver in defending that arrest seems like ODS. However, that's speculation on my part.
 
No, it's really not. It's equivalent to that one black guy that recently wrote about how he had a real gun when pulled over by the cops, or Phylicia Rashad saying that Bill Cosby always treated her great. Even putting aside the problems with Breitbart, the simple problem is that this is confusing bigotry with raging lunacy. It doesn't change what happened in this case, it doesn't change the mayor's nonsense about Sharia Law coming to her town, and so it simply doesn't really address the topic.

<snip>


Not to mention armed Islamophobes staking out the local mosque.

The most telling aspect of the mayor's anti-Sharia Law publicity stunt was the widespread approbation it received from the general populace there.
 
Last three posts: :rolleyes: Is it really impossible for anybody here to admit he was wrong about something?
 
It was ok when I did it because I wanted only to make fun of Richard Dawkin's social impediments.
 
No, it's really not. It's equivalent to that one black guy that recently wrote about how he had a real gun when pulled over by the cops, or Phylicia Rashad saying that Bill Cosby always treated her great. Even putting aside the problems with Breitbart, the simple problem is that this is confusing bigotry with raging lunacy. It doesn't change what happened in this case, it doesn't change the mayor's nonsense about Sharia Law coming to her town, and so it simply doesn't really address the topic.

(Also, refusing to take Breitbart's articles as true and well-researched isn't "hatred", it's simply noting their habit of publishing poorly-researched, and often maliciously edited, nonsense)

Wait, are you dropping any claim that the school acted improperly?

Because the lil inventer wants 15 million *********** dollars.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom