Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Ahmeds intent was not known when the police were brought. Something about his answers probably made the police not sure about his intent. His family has chosen not to allow other facts to released that could have shed light on this matter.


This keeps getting repeated. I'd like to know more about it.

I suspect that a lawyer's advice has something to do with it. It will all come out in the civil suit anyway, so it isn't particularly relevant to anything. Just another avenue for bigots to cast unfounded aspersions.

If any kid of mine were in a similar predicament and the school wanted permission to release records I'd probably consent ... as long as they released all the similar records for all of the parties involved in the event.

My guess is they probably wouldn't want to do that, and when refusing they would portray it as me refusing to let the records be released.

We still do not really know his intent unless we can read minds.

You do not have to buy into the "fantastical narrative" to believe it is possible it was his intent to cause a hoax.


Lots of things are possible. The possibilities are not all equally likely.

In this case he repeated asserted that it wasn't a bomb. Any attempt to portray that as trying to fool people into thinking it was a bomb becomes rather ridiculous on that basis alone.

Don't ask what is possible because that is a meaningless question. Many things are possible.

It's possible that all the adults in the school were suddenly, simultaneously stricken with debilitating paranoia, and when the cops got there they caught it from the teachers and staff.

Ask what is likely.

It is likely that when asked what it was he told them it was a clock ... because it was a clock. It is likely that the adults involved were unsatisfied with that answer, for whatever reason.

It is likely that their reactive behavior continued to escalate because they were unsatisfied with the answer. They didn't really care if it was true or not. They weren't receiving the proper (in their minds) amount of deference subservience.

All of that is far more likely than the idea of a diabolical teen crafting a multi-level con intended to trap teachers, admins, and cops into behaving stupidly enough to create the basis for a lawsuit.

If he did, then he deserves every cent he can get. Because that would be nothing short of awesome.

But not likely.
 
Last edited:
*Puts on criminal defense attorney hat.*

<snip>

(1) Knowingly: Ahmed had to know he was building a hoax bomb. Since he was building a clock, that point fails.

That makes no sense. First of all, he didn't build a clock. He built, well, something, which was composed of some clock guts and a pencil box (with the desiccant packet still inside, weirdly enough). That something looks like either a bomb or the infrastructure to a bomb, for a great many people who aren't nearly as smart, evidently, as some of Ahmed's defenders in this thread. Yes, if he were to painstakingly construct a clock out of a kit that required skill and dozens of hours of work, then, yes, you might have a point that building a hoax bomb was not his main goal. But he didn't do that. What he did takes a few minutes and no skill at all.

(2) With intent to use the hoax bomb: Ahmed didn't intend to use the hoax bomb. He intended to show his teacher something he made. Unless you want to argue that "showing it to his teacher" is the same as using it. However, the entire phrase is "use the hoax bomb," which indicates that the use for the item must be as a hoax bomb.

Actually, the only reason you think that Ahmed intended to show his teachers (or did in fact show the engineering teacher) is that he has said so himself. I don't think this has been confirmed by anybody else. More importantly, however, it is not clear what the police knew or were told before, during or after they arrested Ahmed. Remember, in the end, the police decided not to charge Ahmed, so obviously they concluded that he did not intend to use a hoax bomb. But they may have been led to suspect he did so earlier.

(3) Make another believe...: Ahmed never told anyone it was a hoax bomb. He told everyone it was a clock, including his teacher, the principal, and the police.

Here's where you may try putting on your police investigator's hat instead of your defense attorney's hat. Once the device has been confiscated, of course he's going to deny it was a hoax bomb. What he might have said, or intended to say, to his classmates is unknown. Note that protestations of innocence by a suspect are usually taken with a grain of salt because, well, they seem to happen with near 100% probability, regardless of guilt. I imagine the police are rather skeptical in this regard. Otherwise, they would have to believe that the prisons are overflowing with innocents who were just minding their own business.

There may be probable cause to ask why Ahmed ruined a clock (and how much did he ruin it if the alarm still went off..?) But when it comes to probable cause for building a hoax bomb, not even close.

Well, a bunch of police thought there was probable cause. I know police aren't thought of very highly these days, but I'm inclined to give them the benefit of the doubt until there is more information than just Ahmed's side of the story. I predict that the lawsuit goes precisely nowhere, by the way. If so, that will be evidence that probable cause existed, since arrests without probable cause are illegal.


<snip>

If Ahmed intended to perpetrate a hoax, he could have. All he had to do was leave the clock sitting somewhere unattended. Someone finds a ticking device, and instant bomb threat.

Maybe he was intending to do that. We just don't know. More importantly, we don't know what the police knew at the time.
 
<snip>

How do you know he did intend for it to go off? Is that the only possible reason he could have had for plugging it in?

Well, he not only plugged it in, he set a time on the clock. Not sure what that means, but I don't think it was quite as accidental as you imply. See his interview with al Jazeera here.
 
No it hasn't. Certainly not since the actual event itself started, putting aside for now what was known after it went viral. The police interrogated him specifically to find out why he brought the device to school, and they claimed that he was being passive-aggressive. If all he said was that the device was a clock and kept repeating that, then I can see why they would consider him to be hiding something.
Let's start with the relevant quote from the original news article on this incident:

WFAA said:
Officers said Ahmed was being "passive aggressive" in his answers to their questions, and didn't have a "reasonable answer" as to what he was doing with the case. Investigators said the student told them that it was just a clock that he was messing around with.

"We attempted to question the juvenile about what it was and he would simply only say it was a clock. He didn't offer any explanation as to what it was for, why he created this device, why he brought it to school," said James McLellan, Irving Police.

Unfortunately, until the suit goes to trial and a recording of his questioning is made public (hopefully one was made and not subsequently erased) we don't know how the questioning went. But as has been pointed out by others in this forum, telling the truth and remaining silent while being questioned are not illegal.

If Ahmed was very nervous and anxious after being arrested, handcuffed, and taken to the police station, I can see why he might not be very forthcoming, nor even able to formulate a coherent explanation along the lines of "I did a case mod because I wanted to see if I could do it." (Speculation: maybe he was able to formulate such a response, but for some reason didn't say it out loud because in his mind it was patently obvious.) (More speculation: by the time he ended up in the police station, maybe he figured talking wasn't helping his situation, so he chose not to talk. Perhaps not the best move, but he could have been very scared and really didn't know what to do.)

For example, if Ahmed had an urgent need to know what time it was, a watch or a phone would have been more practical.
Except, perhaps, at night in your bedroom. Which is where he may have intended to keep it after showing it at school. In my opinion, the point of this little exercise was, for him, to see if he could move the clock's innards into a new home and still have it work after.

No, I don't buy into that fantastical narrative. I only think the school officials acted appropriately, and the police may or may not have. I don't believe that it is obvious that the police should not have believed that Ahmed's intent was to perpetrate a hoax.
Your last sentence is where we have a disagreement. Ahmed said it was a clock, and it looked like a clock and worked like a clock. Ergo, it's a clock. As for motive, in my mind wanting to try out a case mod was reason enough for doing a case mod.

I'm sorry, but the "case mod" was idiotic. Ahmed is 14 years old, not 7. It is not unreasonable to suspect that he was up to something a little more sophisticated.
This looks like an example of a counter-effect noticed by Dunning and Kruger in their paper Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One's Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments
Dunning & Kruger said:
Although our emphasis has been on the miscalibration of incompetent individuals, along the way we discovered that highly competent individuals also show some systematic bias in their self appraisals. Across the four sets of studies, participants in the top quartile tended to underestimate their ability and test performance relative to their peers, Zs = -5.66 and -4.77, respectively, ps < .0001.
Another way to put this is people who are really good at doing things often forget that others who haven't invested time and effort into learning a certain skillset aren't very good at doing it. It appears you're assessing his case mod as something you would expect from an adult experienced with using tools, instead of from an adolescent trying something out. Different people have different levels of capability, experience, and access to tools.

My father designed and built model steam engines that can run under their own power. I can't do that, partly because I don't have access to a lathe or milling machine and partly because I haven't invested the required years into using them and learning how steam engines work. I can, however, do some really cool things with computers at the operating system level.

My partner, by contrast, can barely handle a screwdriver and needs friends to assist him with even the simplest of computer tasks such as connecting his phone to a WiFi network. And he's a mature adult, not a teenager.
 
There you go!

To further explain, out of court admissions against self interest are admissible, out of court claims that are in a party's self interest are not admissible to prove the fact asserted.

As such, not only are they given no weight, they are not admissible.

By the way, I already pointed out that a perp's claim of innocence is as common as it is worthless.

So endeth the lesson.

You're unqualified to be giving such 'lessons'.

You appear to have forgotten that the daughter was never convicted of a crime, and in this 'reasoning' of using court rules her suspension isn't what is on trial. That is being used as evidence to convict the family of their conspiracy, so to speak. In establishing character and motive, the fact that someone maintains their innocence is admissible.

And your 'reasoning' is more absurd that I originally thought. None of the statements are in court yet! Using the fact that the claim hasn't been made in court to dismiss the claim is just a convenient framing for you, but it is nonsense. I hope for your sake you don't actually think anyone would take that handwave seriously. The only reason to invoke it is to dismiss the possibility she didn't make threats.

You know who else claims to be innocent? Innocent people.
 
I think that a lot of people who were inclined to be sympathetic to Ahmed's situation became much less so when the $15 million lawsuit got filed. I know I did. Yes, the school overreacted, and surely an apology was due to Ahmed for the way he was treated. But it wasn't worth $15 million.

I am no fan of our overly litigious culture, but it is the American way.

I don't know that there is any penalty imposed for asking fhor a ridiculous level of damages. I wish there were, but there aren't.

I think the kid was wronged, but has already received more than adequate compensation. I know I've never gotten an invitation to the White House.
 
You're unqualified to be giving such 'lessons'.

You appear to have forgotten that the daughter was never convicted of a crime, and in this 'reasoning' of using court rules her suspension isn't what is on trial. That is being used as evidence to convict the family of their conspiracy, so to speak. In establishing character and motive, the fact that someone maintains their innocence is admissible.

And your 'reasoning' is more absurd that I originally thought. None of the statements are in court yet! Using the fact that the claim hasn't been made in court to dismiss the claim is just a convenient framing for you, but it is nonsense. I hope for your sake you don't actually think anyone would take that handwave seriously. The only reason to invoke it is to dismiss the possibility she didn't make threats.

You know who else claims to be innocent? Innocent people.

Oh for cripes sakes, are you serious? The point was that they were made out of court! That is the whole basis for why admissions against self interest are considered admissible as an exception to the hearsay rule. No wonder you think it is absurd, you have no *********** idea what we are talking about.

He calls basic rules of evidence "nonsense." Face palm....
 
Oh for cripes sakes, are you serious? The point was that they were made out of court! That is the whole basis for why admissions against self interest are considered admissible as an exception to the hearsay rule. No wonder you think it is absurd, you have no *********** idea what we are talking about.

He calls basic rules of evidence "nonsense." Face palm....


You're failing English again. I didn't call rules of evidence nonsense, I called your invoking them selectively as nonsense.

If you want to follow court rules, stop talking, because this isn't a court. If you're going to try to follow court rules outside of a court, you need to allow for such common sense accommodations as knowing that all these statements are out of court. If you're not willing to do that, but will speculate while claiming to follow court rules, then you're not discussing this in good faith.

But then again, you never were.
 
Having trouble with English again? Careful, you might misuse a word and people can dismiss you as you have people who don't know to use 'creation' instead of 'invention'. Careful with 'trademark' and 'copyright'.

You only give any weight to the 'admission against self interest' and cite court standards. They don't only give weight to those.
.

You're failing English again. I didn't call rules of evidence nonsense, I called your invoking them selectively as nonsense.

If you want to follow court rules, stop talking, because this isn't a court. If you're going to try to follow court rules outside of a court, you need to allow for such common sense accommodations as knowing that all these statements are out of court. If you're not willing to do that, but will speculate while claiming to follow court rules, then you're not discussing this in good faith.

But then again, you never were.

Oh dear, he claims to lecture us on what courts do, but after getting nuked from orbit about what courts actually do, suddenly he tells me to "stop talking" about what courts do.

everything you are arguing is utter nonsense.
 
Originally Posted by tsig View Post
It looked like a timer that might be found on a bomb.

Only in the eyes of Hollywood. I keep saying this and no one seems to pay attention; most improvised explosive devices these days rarely if ever use timers. More often than not they use pressure switches, or some type of wire connection that can be pulled from a distance. Or a simple deadman's switch for your typical suicide bomber, where all they have to do is press a button and BOOM. Timers on the other hand are not as reliable as these simpler methods and can fail in unexpected ways. I can understand the teachers not being aware of this fact, necessarily, but the police, assuming their training is at all competent, would be trained to recognize explosive devices.

And yet it was a timer. Ahmed himself used it as one, setting it of to trigger a beeper during class

I keep saying this and no one seems to pay attention;

It's given all the attention it deserves

[Analogy]Most phones rarely, if ever, use handsets connected by wire through a rotary dialer to the landline. More often than not they use a wireless handset with integral keypad. I can understand most people being unaware that a rotary dial phone will still make phone calls [/Analogy]

(but they will)
 
Oh dear, he claims to lecture us on what courts do, but after getting nuked from orbit about what courts actually do, suddenly he tells me to "stop talking" about what courts do.

everything you are arguing is utter nonsense.


What are you on about now? You're the one who cited court standards as why you were dismissing her claim. Then you hide behind not actually being a court for dismissing her claim, when those things couldn't be claimed in court because we're not a court.

Courts would take her claim into account because they could be made in court. That isn't hearsay then. You're just playing a stupid game now. You want to hide behind court rules then leave things out because we're not a court? That's disingenuous nonsense.

Don't pretend I was wrong about court rules when you're the one selectively choosing this bizarre scenario where you want to act like a court but not be a court.

So yes, you want to be a court? Stop talking. This isn't how courts behave.

EDIT: 'Nuked from orbit' is the new 'BOOM HEADSHOT!'.
 
Last edited:
What are you on about now? You're the one who cited court standards as why you were dismissing her claim. Then you hide behind not actually being a court for dismissing her claim, when those things couldn't be claimed in court because we're not a court.

Courts would take her claim into account because they could be made in court. That isn't hearsay then. You're just playing a stupid game now. You want to hide behind court rules then leave things out because we're not a court? That's disingenuous nonsense.

Don't pretend I was wrong about court rules when you're the one selectively choosing this bizarre scenario where you want to act like a court but not be a court.

So yes, you want to be a court? Stop talking. This isn't how courts behave.

EDIT: 'Nuked from orbit' is the new 'BOOM HEADSHOT!'.

:eye-poppi

It is my fault, I tried to explain basic rules of hearsay, not only do you not understand them, you appear incapable of doing so.

Sister admitted that she was suspended for making a threat. That is called an admission against interest. admissible and very credible

Sister claimed she was innocent. That is not admissible if made out of court and is utterly self serving and not credible if made in court.

I hope I dumbed that down sufficiently for you?

"stop talking!" The sign of the true skeptic.:rolleyes:
 
:eye-poppi

It is my fault, I tried to explain basic rules of hearsay,

No, you didn't.

not only do you not understand them, you appear incapable of doing so.

I understand just fine. Your argument is intellectually dishonest.

Sister admitted that she was suspended for making a threat. That is called an admission against interest. admissible and very credible

Sister claimed she was innocent. That is not admissible if made out of court and is utterly self serving and not credible if made in court.

You're not a court. She's not in court (currently). If you want play at being a court, then you have to play that the statements are made in court in order to be even a little intellectually honesty. You used the fact that the statements weren't made in court (and can't be because they aren't currently in court) as a reason to dismiss it. This is nonsense. Oh, and the claims aren't in court because real officials haven't found enough evidence justifying any court, so your entire exercise is already wrong. Court rules say you have no case to even hear. Case not even dismissed; case not brought.

By your own reasoning, the only statements of the family you will allow are statements against their own interests. It's no accomplishment to conclude they're manipulating everyone in that case. It's still nonsense.

I hope I dumbed that down sufficiently for you?

"stop talking!" The sign of the true skeptic.:rolleyes:

Alright 'nuked from orbit'. Stop talking if you want to be a court because there is no case there. Way to fail English again. The point isn't that you should actually stop talking (though I wouldn't object), but that your play-day of pretend court has that fatal flaw in it and you shouldn't hide behind it any longer.

When someone says, 'lead, follow, or get out of the way,' do you really think they're telling you to get out of the way? 'If' statements have options, and you reducing it to 'stop talking' is a lie.
 
<snip>
Sister admitted that she was suspended for making a threat.


No. She didn't. She admitted she was suspended because someone accused her of making a bomb threat.

These two things are not the same.

That is called an admission against interest. admissible and very credible


Since she didn't say that the point is moot, but what you are talking about is statements made out of court being referred to in court.

Sister claimed she was innocent. That is not admissible if made out of court and is utterly self serving and not credible if made in court.


Relieved of prejudicial embellishment, you are admitting here that if she made the statement while in court it would be admissible.

I hope I dumbed that down sufficiently for you?


You may have succeeded in dumbing it down enough for you to understand (quite an achievement), IF you bother to actually read ... and grasp ... what you wrote.

"stop talking!" The sign of the true skeptic.:rolleyes:


In your case "Stop digging." might be a more appropriate caution.
 
Officers said Ahmed was being "passive aggressive" in his answers to their questions, and didn't have a "reasonable answer" as to what he was doing with the case. Investigators said the student told them that it was just a clock that he was messing around with.

"We attempted to question the juvenile about what it was and he would simply only say it was a clock. He didn't offer any explanation as to what it was for, why he created this device, why he brought it to school," said James McLellan, Irving Police.
:boggled:

Lesson number 1. Never tell the police the truth - they won't believe you.

No wonder they had to handcuff him, he assaulted them with a passive aggressive answer!
 
No, they don't agree. How can you know all that when the records are sealed?

You got a rock in a hat?

I have publicly available statements from both the kid and the police, as well as the behavior of the school administrators (um, they thought it was a bomb and yet didn't evacuate the school?). In the case of the handcuffing, we have a photo. And all of these things have been discussed repeatedly on this thread, and in nearly every public discussion on the subject.
 
That makes no sense. First of all, he didn't build a clock. He built, well, something, which was composed of some clock guts and a pencil box (with the desiccant packet still inside, weirdly enough).

The point of the statute is that he had to KNOWINGLY be building a hoax bomb. That isn't what he did. He was building a clock. Whether you want to call it a clock or not does not really matter for the purposes of the statute. The first prong of the hoax bomb statute fails because he did not knowingly build a hoax bomb.

That something looks like either a bomb or the infrastructure to a bomb,

Moot point, because other people's perceptions are not important for the knowingly aspect of the statute. All that matters there is Ahmed's thoughts, and he thought he was making a clock.

Yes, if he were to painstakingly construct a clock out of a kit that required skill and dozens of hours of work, then, yes, you might have a point that building a hoax bomb was not his main goal.

Not under the law. The law requires him to know he was making a hoax bomb.

But he didn't do that. What he did takes a few minutes and no skill at all.

Again, so? How much effort he put in does not matter for the purposes of the statute.


Actually, the only reason you think that Ahmed intended to show his teachers (or did in fact show the engineering teacher) is that he has said so himself.

I believe both the teacher and the principal have said he showed it to his teacher. I could be wrong on that, though.

However, that is not what the statute says. To fall under the statute, Ahmed had to intend to use the device he built as a hoax bomb. Also, remember that Ahmed does not have to prove his innocence. The state must prove his guilt. He stated it was a clock, and maintained that claim. If you want to argue that it was a hoax bomb, show some evidence he intended to use the device as a hoax bomb.

More importantly, however, it is not clear what the police knew or were told before, during or after they arrested Ahmed.

They questioned him and he told them repeatedly it was a clock. That is what the police knew.

Remember, in the end, the police decided not to charge Ahmed, so obviously they concluded that he did not intend to use a hoax bomb.

The statute was posted above with the statement that Ahmed's actions fall under the statute. I was pointing out why the statute is not applicable to him.

Here's where you may try putting on your police investigator's hat instead of your defense attorney's hat.

Defense attorneys do investigation. How do you think we find witnesses for our side?

Well, a bunch of police thought there was probable cause. I know police aren't thought of very highly these days, but I'm inclined to give them the benefit of the doubt until there is more information than just Ahmed's side of the story.

Some police are great people. Some are not. I know some who I would trust implicitly. I also defended a case where my client was pulled over for "driving while black." Saying "the police had to have cause" doesn't really mean anything.
 
And yet it was a timer. Ahmed himself used it as one, setting it of to trigger a beeper during class



It's given all the attention it deserves

[Analogy]Most phones rarely, if ever, use handsets connected by wire through a rotary dialer to the landline. More often than not they use a wireless handset with integral keypad. I can understand most people being unaware that a rotary dial phone will still make phone calls [/Analogy]

(but they will)

Okay, let's just ignore the (possibly) only person in the thread who has any experience with improvised explosive devices and move on with vilifying a 14 year old boy who "clearly" must be up to SOMETHING bad despite all the evidence to the contrary. :rolleyes:

The reason I keep stressing that point of mine that you're handwaving away is because it goes to the notion that the police apparently believed Ahmed was going to use the clock for something nefarious, if their questioning of him is any indication, and they should have known better. We also don't know that Ahmed deliberately set off the alarm on his case-modded clock; it's entirely possible that he plugged it in and didn't realize the alarm was set. It's also possible, I will freely admit, that he did set it off deliberately; the only thing that no one in here can answer in regards to that possibility thought is WHY? I have yet to see a single coherent possibility put forward as to why Ahmed would deliberately set off the alarm on his case-mod. Regardless of ANYTHING though; the police especially should have been aware of explosive devices and what they resemble and don't resemble and should therefore have been fully aware that Ahmed's clock was not in any way dangerous. Disruptive, possibly, but not dangerous, and therefore they should not have treated him like a criminal, handcuffed him, and questioned him without a parent or guardian present after he asked for them.
 
Okay, let's just ignore the (possibly) only person in the thread who has any experience with improvised explosive devices and move on with vilifying a 14 year old boy who "clearly" must be up to SOMETHING bad despite all the evidence to the contrary. :rolleyes:

The reason I keep stressing that point of mine that you're handwaving away is because it goes to the notion that the police apparently believed Ahmed was going to use the clock for something nefarious, if their questioning of him is any indication, and they should have known better. We also don't know that Ahmed deliberately set off the alarm on his case-modded clock; it's entirely possible that he plugged it in and didn't realize the alarm was set. It's also possible, I will freely admit, that he did set it off deliberately; the only thing that no one in here can answer in regards to that possibility thought is WHY? I have yet to see a single coherent possibility put forward as to why Ahmed would deliberately set off the alarm on his case-mod. Regardless of ANYTHING though; the police especially should have been aware of explosive devices and what they resemble and don't resemble and should therefore have been fully aware that Ahmed's clock was not in any way dangerous. Disruptive, possibly, but not dangerous, and therefore they should not have treated him like a criminal, handcuffed him, and questioned him without a parent or guardian present after he asked for them.

Lets ignore the only person in the thread who appears to have read the statute.... :rolleyes:

the test is not what an expert in improvised explosions believes... further, for example, under the hoax bomb statute an empty briefcase can be a hoax bomb.

But the police should know that an empty briefcase was not in any way dangerous. :rolleyes::rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom