Journalist attacked by violent mob

Yes he does. If you read the statement you would know the answer to this question.



Read the statement.

Right.. got it.

I just couldn't understand it after the first coupla passes.

Just to check I've got it right. He went to film the far right groups attacking peaceful, I assume, "activists" so that he could subsequently propagandize this action by hopefully finding a victim or two who had carried out some nefarious act on behalf of activists previously. Once identified, he would profit by appearing on national media and doxxing and harassing said victims. He was, for a given value of successfully, successfully shut down.

Assuming I've unravelled this correctly, the players on either side of this sideshow have got be the biggest ******* dickheads in the US and elsewhere currently. What a ******* joke.
 
Why should I have to answer a post that came later in my post to Bouncing Betty?

Well, it was part of a response to a response that you were involved in and might have shown a willingness to debate honestly rather than hint "why do you hate muslims".
 
Nuance works fine.

How about this: We disallow all practices that would be illegal under domestic law?

I don't think anyone has ever asked for anything more than that.

Like assault not in self defense?

I agree ship the Antifa folks somewhere.
 
I don't understand this statement.



Who are the armed men being referred to?

Is it RCA openly stating that they were armed with the intention to attack activists or the other way round?

If it is the former then wouldn't the active suppression of the reporting of such physical attacks be something one would would find in a fascist or communist state?

The "armed men" presumably refers to the antifa guys and "activists" would be the proud boys??
 
Attacking journalists is a feature of antifa, not a bug
https://jessesingal.substack.com/p/its-insane-were-having-a-debate-over
Taylor Lorenz, a journalist for The Hill, was punched in the side of the head while live-streaming the aftermath of a fatal attack on anti-fascist protesters in Charlottesville, Virginia.
Dave Minsky — an independent journalist and photographer who freelances for Reuters, Vice, the Miami New Times and the Santa Barbara News-Press — was beaten by masked protesters on August 27, 2017, while covering an anti-fascist protest in Berkeley, California
A CBS 6 photojournalist had to be taken to the emergency room after he was struck in the back of the head by an anti-fascist protester, the channel reported on August 13, 2017.
A reporter for local North Carolina TV station WLOS was assaulted while live-streaming a peaceful anti-racist demonstration in Asheville, North Carolina, on August 13, 2017.
Mike Kessler was covering a demonstration in Berkeley, California, when a group of protesters stole his camera and phone and attempted to break them.
Leigh Martinez, a freelance reporter for KTVU, was covering an anti-fascist protest in Berkeley, California, on August 27, 2017
 
A second 2020 democratic hopeful, Eric Swalwell, has condemned the attacks:
I don’t agree with much of what @MrAndyNgo ever says. But that’s not the point. He should not be harmed for his views and his attackers should be prosecuted. *And Congress should pass my Journalist Protection Act, which makes it a federal crime to assault or batter a journalist.
Sadly, it seems like we need a Journalist Protection Act.
 
Yeah, no. That's really not what's going on, at all. Antifa isn't actually protecting anyone from anything. Certainly no one was protected from violence by beating up Andy Ngo.


You're definitely wrong about that. And artificially restricting the context to one single person is a logical fallacy when the issue is far larger than one alt.right propagandist.

On America's Streets, Antifa's Militant Anti-fascism Isn't Terrorism - It's Self-defense

Excerpt:
As a sociologist, I have been formally studying militant anti-fascism for well over a decade. In this formal research, I interviewed both militant and non-militant anti-fascist activists and conducted ethnographic research with formal antifa groups. I have spent time in meetings, observing activism, and engaging in the culture of anti-fascism.

What I found in my interviews and experiences is that militant anti-fascists experience tangible and immediate threats from fascists and respond out of a practical need to defend themselves from those threats.

For most people, fascist activism and organizing are abstractions removed from their daily lives; images on television and news reports, cartoonish villains. For the antifa activists whom I researched, fascists represented an intense and immediate threat.

Many militant anti-fascists become involved in this form of activism because aspects of their identity are directly targeted by fascist violence; they are queer, transgender, gender non-conforming, people of color, Jews, Muslims, Sikhs, and certainly identified in ways that intersected across these categories.

For them, anti-fascism was a means of ensuring their safety from a movement that threatens their very existence and venerates violence as the highest form of action. Even the antifa activists who identify as cis heterosexual white males are the targets of fascist violence as "race" and "gender" traitors.


It's easy to dismiss direct action against fascists when you're not the ones they're targeting for assault and murder.
 
You're definitely wrong about that. And artificially restricting the context to one single person is a logical fallacy when the issue is far larger than one alt.right propagandist.

On America's Streets, Antifa's Militant Anti-fascism Isn't Terrorism - It's Self-defense

Excerpt:



It's easy to dismiss direct action against fascists when you're not the ones they're targeting for assault and murder.

Unbelievable. Sucker punching a gay minority with weaponized gloves is an act of "self defense"
 
I disagree. Leftists not engaging in this sort of violence only means they become victims, because the right sure as hell won't stop. Doesn't stop them winning elections either, so that excuse is right out the window.

Leftists don't defend themselves. Leftists aren't victims. Leftists engage in violence because their ideology requires them to engage in violence. Killing millions of my fellow citizens cannot happen without violence and killing billions of my fellow citizens is the heart and soul of socialist philosophy--it's what socialism is all about. That is why demonstrations where antifa show up always end in bloodshed.
 
Right.. got it.

I just couldn't understand it after the first coupla passes.

Just to check I've got it right. He went to film the far right groups attacking peaceful, I assume, "activists" so that he could subsequently propagandize this action by hopefully finding a victim or two who had carried out some nefarious act on behalf of activists previously. Once identified, he would profit by appearing on national media and doxxing and harassing said victims. He was, for a given value of successfully, successfully shut down.

Assuming I've unravelled this correctly, the players on either side of this sideshow have got be the biggest ******* dickheads in the US and elsewhere currently. What a ******* joke.
That's pretty much what I figured from the statement, and I agree wholeheartedly with your conclusion.
 
Seems to me that fascists, whether left or right, are always able to paint themselves as perpetual victims and their violence as self defense.
 

What absolute rubbish. Aggressors justify their aggression by claiming that it's actually "self defense". They seek out these conflicts and instigate them. What they don't seem to understand is that their own actions, their own "resistance" fuels the very thing they claim to oppose. You think attacking Andy Ngo was a propaganda victory for antifa or for the so-called fascists?
 
For the record, I support ANTIFA both implicitly and explicitly. Carry on.
 
Who's doing this?

And why is it wrong to allow people to bring their culture to a multi-cultural melting pot? That's how it's always been. Why should muslims be excluded?
So you support executing gay men and women by throwing them off tall buildings?
 
Surely it depends on what cultural practices are imported? One can presumably be worried about honor killings, homophobia etc?

Honor killings, subjugating women, mutilating genitalia, homophobia, hell, even human sacrifice must be celebrated in a multicultural utiopia. Only small minded bigots would disagree.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom