Journalist attacked by violent mob

I don't think she was run over. But she was a proper person, which is why she protested the message of the nazis instead of supporting their rights.
 
An Enemy of the People?


Obviously not an enemy of nazis.

How has he tried to "incite violence" against anyone? By demonizing him, and legitimizing the violent attacks against him, are you not "inciting violence" yourself?


Did you read his article? The one that inspired Baylor's thread? How exactly did I "demonize" him? By pointing out that he is a lying hate mongerer?
 
Obviously not an enemy of nazis.

Did you read his article? The one that inspired Baylor's thread? How exactly did I "demonize" him? By pointing out that he is a lying hate mongerer?

The one in the Wall Street journal? Unfortunately I don't subscribe and it's hidden behind a paywall, so no.

As far as the charge that he supports Nazis, I'm not sure he actually does that.
Just because he doesn't like antifa doesn't mean he supports Nazis. Maybe he's just opposed to violent authoritarians in general, have you considered that?
 
The one in the Wall Street journal? Unfortunately I don't subscribe and it's hidden behind a paywall, so no.

As far as the charge that he supports Nazis, I'm not sure he actually does that.
Just because he doesn't like antifa doesn't mean he supports Nazis. Maybe he's just opposed to violent authoritarians in general, have you considered that?

I have considered and rejected that idea. He supports Nazis.
 
No, that's normal journalists according to people like Andy Ngo.

By lying about muslims. Serisously, it's been spelled out for you.

I've investigated the claims against him as much as I could. The Wall Street journal article is behind a paywall.

What has he said about Muslims that is a lie?
 
I already read that. Didn't see anything about inciting violence.
Poor reporting? Yeah. But not incitement to violence
 
I already read that. Didn't see anything about inciting violence.
Poor reporting? Yeah. But not incitement to violence

Did he say "Kill all muslims"? No.

Did he imply "If something isn't done, soon all of the West will be like this." Yes. "Would someone rid me of this meddlesome priest?"

The latter is read as a direct call to action by many extreme rightwingers, the same type of people Andy Ngo regularly hangs around in Portland.
 
They sure can be.

Pizzagate was just another wacky internet conspiracy theory, right up until the bullets started flying.

We will only be safe once some authority figure enforces Truth. Surely that could not end poorly. Maybe William Barr could be in charge of rounding up and prosecuting offenders.

I don't deny that 1A protects a lot of harmful speech. Conspiracy mongers, race-baiters, misogynists, and extremists of all varieties take full advantage of its protection to sow malicious thought.

It's a terrible law in that way. It's also the better than any known alternative.
 
We will only be safe once some authority figure enforces Truth. Surely that could not end poorly. Maybe William Barr could be in charge of rounding up and prosecuting offenders.

I don't deny that 1A protects a lot of harmful speech. Conspiracy mongers, race-baiters, misogynists, and extremists of all varieties take full advantage of its protection to sow malicious thought.

It's a terrible law in that way. It's also the better than any known alternative.

I'd say we have a better version than the 1A. We have free speech, but with clauses for prohibited speech. You are, for example, not allowed to say "Muslims are all animals" on facebook. That's a crime. As it should be.

And, despite having these laws, we are able to not drop down any slippery slopes.
 
They sure can be.

Pizzagate was just another wacky internet conspiracy theory, right up until the bullets started flying.

Some people are nuts. We can’t (shouldn’t) suspend free speech because of it.

Punish clear and present threats? Yes.
Punish libel and slander? Yes.
Punish having negative opinions? No.


A sanders supporter opened fire at a bunch of GOP Congressmen playing baseball. Should sanders be held responsible or his speech restricted? (Hint: no)
 
I'd say we have a better version than the 1A. We have free speech, but with clauses for prohibited speech. You are, for example, not allowed to say "Muslims are all animals" on facebook. That's a crime. As it should be.

And, despite having these laws, we are able to not drop down any slippery slopes.

I thought all human beings are animals? Are you suggesting Muslims aren't human? What a vile hate speech!
 
I thought all human beings are animals? Are you suggesting Muslims aren't human? What a vile hate speech!

If you're making a biological point, there's no realy need to specify that you're talking about Muslims. Our courts are fairly good at understanding this kind of nuance.
 
If you're making a biological point, there's no realy need to specify that you're talking about Muslims. Our courts are fairly good at understanding this kind of nuance.

How nice for you to have an understanding legal system to tell you how you can phrase your remarks.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom