Journalist attacked by violent mob

A tiny group of nutcases go out and bash another tiny group of nutcases and in their minds, they are saving the world from nazism.


There is no point in addressing the rest of your post beyond this, because this is so profoundly wrong that it makes everything else you posted here gibberish.

Antifa is not a tiny group of nutcases going out and committing street violence. That is only a very, very, very small fraction of the number of people who identify as antifa, or who fall until the antifa umbrella. The tip of a much larger iceberg.

"Antifa" merely means "anti-fascist". That's it. Antifa(csist). Anyone who engages in activism to oppose fascism is antifa. Whether that's protesting against fascist rallies in the streets, sitting behind a computer and outing fascists (a popular activity for disabled people who can't go out into the streets), organizing get-out-the-vote programs, assisting with campaigns for progressive and other anti-fascist politicians, pressuring local politicians into taking action against fascists, reporting on the activity of fascist organizations and police support for fascists, all of these are antifa activities. The attempt to tar all of them with the brush of a tiny fraction who engage in direct action and occasionally take things a bit too far, says far more about you and your worldview than it does about them.
 
There is no point in addressing the rest of your post beyond this, because this is so profoundly wrong that it makes everything else you posted here gibberish.



Antifa is not a tiny group of nutcases going out and committing street violence. That is only a very, very, very small fraction of the number of people who identify as antifa, or who fall until the antifa umbrella. The tip of a much larger iceberg.



"Antifa" merely means "anti-fascist". That's it. Antifa(csist). Anyone who engages in activism to oppose fascism is antifa. Whether that's protesting against fascist rallies in the streets, sitting behind a computer and outing fascists (a popular activity for disabled people who can't go out into the streets), organizing get-out-the-vote programs, assisting with campaigns for progressive and other anti-fascist politicians, pressuring local politicians into taking action against fascists, reporting on the activity of fascist organizations and police support for fascists, all of these are antifa activities. The attempt to tar all of them with the brush of a tiny fraction who engage in direct action and occasionally take things a bit too far, says far more about you and your worldview than it does about them.
Exactly just like democratic republic just means North Korea is a democratic republic
 
Did he say "Kill all muslims"? No.

Did he imply "If something isn't done, soon all of the West will be like this." Yes. "Would someone rid me of this meddlesome priest?"

The latter is read as a direct call to action by many extreme rightwingers, the same type of people Andy Ngo regularly hangs around in Portland.

If you squint hard enough, anything is incitement. Words are violence brah.


It's called, "plausible deniability".

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=336883
 
Exactly just like democratic republic just means North Korea is a democratic republic

There ya go, again.

Are you denying that antifa is a larger movement than just the skirmishers? That'd be pretty thick. While you're at it with yet another horrible analogy, do you deny that the words Democratic and Republic actually have known definitions? Are all Republics dictatorships? All Democracies? All Democratic Republics?

Or are you just poisoning the well?
 
It's called beating him up because of what he's "saying" before someone else gets beaten up "because" of what he's "saying".

I think if you really are concerned about stochastic terrorism, then you absolutely must send a clear message that this kind of political violence is never acceptable.

On that scale, the comments of several posters in this thread weigh far heavier than anything we've seen here from Andy Ngo.
 
Yes, he does. He couches it in terms of "protecting freedom of speech". He also contributes to the demonization of the enemies of the extreme right, thus contributing to radicalization. Hell, the Nazis themselves see Shapiro as a useful tool in their recruitment efforts, despite him being Jewish, or possibly because of it. It's all about being "crypto".

ETA: Here's an article explaining where Shapiro lies on the radicalization spectrum.

Shapiro is less of a recruiter for terrorists than a lot of posters here. Lots of people here demonize the other side and conflate different groups into an existential threat requiring immediate extra-legal violent action. But they haven’t morphed into the fascists they despise, no sir!
 
Yes, he does. He couches it in terms of "protecting freedom of speech". He also contributes to the demonization of the enemies of the extreme right, thus contributing to radicalization. Hell, the Nazis themselves see Shapiro as a useful tool in their recruitment efforts, despite him being Jewish, or possibly because of it. It's all about being "crypto".

ETA: Here's an article explaining where Shapiro lies on the radicalization spectrum.

“She then moved on to writings by Ben Shapiro and articles on Breitbart which bridged the gap to the notorious white supremacist and anti-Semitic propaganda site Stormfront.”

I call bull ****. Shapiro doesn't bridge any gap to antisemitism. It's laughable on its face. This is a smear job, an attempt to use guilt by association. The tell is that it never even mentions a single thing Shapiro actually said. You wouldn't accept this level of logic to blame Bernie Sanders for James Hodgkinson, why should we accept it here?
 
I've been saying that all along

Not about yourself, you haven't.

and yet you and others continue to excuse the fascists white supremacists and engage in false equivalency fallacies.

Andy Ngo isn't a fascist white supremacist. And you're actually excusing actual violence, you're in no position to lecture me.
 
It's depressing - but entirely predictable (and even predicted!) - that some of the same people who were just assuring us a bit of political egging is as far as it goes, are now excusing political head-clubbing.
 
It's depressing - but entirely predictable (and even predicted!) - that some of the same people who were just assuring us a bit of political egging is as far as it goes, are now excusing political head-clubbing.


Or "It's only actual NAZIs" to "NAZI adjacent", to "slightly to the right of Che".

Been said countless times before, but it's no longer about acceptable/unacceptable behavior, but acceptable/unacceptable targets. And the line for who is considered to be Fair Game gets pushed further and further along.
 
Or "It's only actual NAZIs" to "NAZI adjacent", to "slightly to the right of Che".

Been said countless times before, but it's no longer about acceptable/unacceptable behavior, but acceptable/unacceptable targets. And the line for who is considered to be Fair Game gets pushed further and further along.

Yep, also predicted. I bet there are a lot of posts in the egging thread that haven't aged well at all.

Where do you come down on the idea of having a civil discussion about what "nazi" actually means, before we go about cracking skulls?
 
Or "It's only actual NAZIs" to "NAZI adjacent", to "slightly to the right of Che".

Yes there is a big difference between a table of 10 nazis and one of their friends and a table of 11 nazis. It would be like thinking that just because the unite the right rally was put on by white supremacists and organized by them that there weren't fine people there to support the confederacy and its view that the role of the negro is to be subservient to the white. Thats history there.
 
Look when you deal with journalists you are supposed to do it in proper ways like with a bone saw. That is how you deal with enemies of the people and that is the kind of action all conservatives will quietly support. Good to see the enemies of the american people get what they have coming to them.
 
It is starting to make sense: Andy Ngo isn't a real journalist, he is "fake news" and an "enemy of the people" and something "ought to be done about it". Also Jews and Asians we don't like are NAZIs.
You're right theprestige, the milkshake apologists are unsurprisingly head clubbing apologists.
 
Yep, also predicted. I bet there are a lot of posts in the egging thread that haven't aged well at all.

Where do you come down on the idea of having a civil discussion about what "nazi" actually means, before we go about cracking skulls?


I think drawing the line at actual incitement before curtailing speech is a sound idea. I also think there is an interesting discussion to be had about when a political principal or official policy of a party (a lot of alliteration ...) crosses the line into incitement (vs. merely being objectionable, or odious absent actual implementation). Trouble is I have zero faith that that sort of nuance is at all possible on ISF right now. Never mind the issue of 'on a scale of 1-10 I'd draw the line at a 3, you would draw at 5', there's far too much of people treating another's "3" as if it were an "8".
 
I'd say we have a better version than the 1A. We have free speech, but with clauses for prohibited speech. You are, for example, not allowed to say "Muslims are all animals" on facebook. That's a crime. As it should be.

And, despite having these laws, we are able to not drop down any slippery slopes.

I'm going to guess you are talking about the UK?

Don't worry you are already half down it. I don't trust a government that doest trust me with a locking multitool. You may want a Gouverneur to act like your parent I don't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom