Journalist attacked by violent mob

It's not as dystopic as you seem to think. I'd say you'd like it if you tried it.

Oh, I definitely wouldn't. I'm far too obstreperous and quintessentially American. People telling me I can't say things really makes me want to say them. Controlling speech triggers my revolutionary instincts.
 
If anybody deserves a punch in the head...
How would you finish that sentence, dann? Still tryna figure out if you’re advocating vigilantism or not, here at ISF.


I have considered and rejected that idea. He supports Nazis.
Where can we find Ngo doing this in print? I’ve mostly encountered him on Twitter, haven’t seen what you’re talking about.


Did he imply "If something isn't done, soon all of the West will be like this." Yes. "Would someone rid me of this meddlesome priest?"


The latter is read as a direct call to action by many extreme rightwingers, the same type of people Andy Ngo regularly hangs around in Portland.
The latter isn’t an actual quote of what Ngo wrote, though.


As far as I can tell, it isn’t even a reasonable paraphrase.


It would be rather helpful here if you were to actually quote what Ngo wrote or said which makes you conclude that he hopes to incite violence against some group or another.


I'd say we have a better version than the 1A. We have free speech, but with clauses for prohibited speech. You are, for example, not allowed to say "Muslims are all animals" on facebook. That's a crime. As it should be.
I don’t think that is actually a crime where Ngo lives, but I would also be surprised to learn that he wrote anything remotely resembling that.
 
HWhere can we find Ngo doing this in print? I’ve mostly encountered him on Twitter, haven’t seen what you’re talking about.

Dunno. In my opinion he's one of the people along the path to radicalization. Loads of people there, like Jordan Peterson and Ben Shapiro. All support Nazis.

The latter isn’t an actual quote of what Ngo wrote, though.


As far as I can tell, it isn’t even a reasonable paraphrase.

Hence why I wrote "implied".

It would be rather helpful here if you were to actually quote what Ngo wrote or said which makes you conclude that he hopes to incite violence against some group or another.

I don't know what he intends. I only know what the effects of articles such as his are.

I don’t think that is actually a crime where Ngo lives, but I would also be surprised to learn that he wrote anything remotely resembling that.

And that it wouldn't be a crime is problematic, and exemplifies the problem of the American fetishization of free speech.
 
In my opinion he's one of the people along the path to radicalization. Loads of people there, like Jordan Peterson and Ben Shapiro. All support Nazis.

Are there any right-of-center public figures who don't "support Nazis," as you understand it?
 
Are there any right-of-center public figures who don't "support Nazis," as you understand it?

Plenty. Washington post is a right of center publication that isn't known for supporting Nazis, as an example.

ETA: You said "figures", sorry.

John McCain was such a person.
Mitt Romney, at least most of the time.
Justice John Roberts is another example. Not without faults, but not a Nazi supporter.

Etc.
 
Last edited:
And that it wouldn't be a crime is problematic, and exemplifies the problem of the American fetishization of free speech.

Setting aside for the moment that you're wrong about it being a bad thing that such speech isn't criminalized, the fact is that it's not. And since it's not, since it's legal, Andy Ngo is not committing any crime, and deserves the full protection of the law. It's a far greater problem that you and so many others can't recognize this than that Andy can say mean things.
 
Setting aside for the moment that you're wrong about it being a bad thing that such speech isn't criminalized, the fact is that it's not. And since it's not, since it's legal, Andy Ngo is not committing any crime, and deserves the full protection of the law. It's a far greater problem that you and so many others can't recognize this than that Andy can say mean things.

I mean, he can't say mean things if his jaw is wired shut from being clubbed in the streets by masked vigilantes. Laws are only important when they are expedient.

/s
 
For my opinion?
OK, well of course, everyone's entitled to their own opinion. But it seems to me that "He supports Nazis" is a statement of fact. If you're saying that's an objective fact, I think that asking for evidence is a fair response.
They sure can be.

Pizzagate was just another wacky internet conspiracy theory, right up until the bullets started flying.

Actually, I do agree with you about Pizzagate. Maybe there's some common ground here? I really despise the Alex Joneses of the world and I wouldn't consider him to be a legitimate journalist by any stretch of the imagination. (I wouldn't, however, endorse physical violence against him, even though he is a loathsome person.) Is Andy Ngo comparable to Alex Jones though? I haven't seen that. Even if he were, we are still a society of laws, and you can't just go doing vigilante justice because you think someone is a real stinker.

The ACLU famously has fought for the free speech rights of some very despicable people, right?
 
I mean, he can't say mean things if his jaw is wired shut from being clubbed in the streets by masked vigilantes. Laws are only important when they are expedient.

/s

He wasn't clubbed in the street. The guy who was actually clubbed in the street was an anti-fascist and the clubbers where Proud Boys.
 
OK, well of course, everyone's entitled to their own opinion. But it seems to me that "He supports Nazis" is a statement of fact. If you're saying that's an objective fact, I think that asking for evidence is a fair response.

It's my opinion, which I have expanded upon a bit in later posts.

Actually, I do agree with you about Pizzagate. Maybe there's some common ground here? I really despise the Alex Joneses of the world and I wouldn't consider him to be a legitimate journalist by any stretch of the imagination. (I wouldn't, however, endorse physical violence against him, even though he is a loathsome person.) Is Andy Ngo comparable to Alex Jones though? I haven't seen that. Even if he were, we are still a society of laws, and you can't just go doing vigilante justice because you think someone is a real stinker.

Well, you can, but you should then face punishment for it. As you say, a society of laws.

The ACLU famously has fought for the free speech rights of some very despicable people, right?

Not anymore, as I understand it. They got burned in Charlottesville.
 
Are there any right-of-center public figures who don't "support Nazis," as you understand it?

George W Bush never endorsed nazis. He is a war criminal sure but he always made a stand against that kind of hate.

Does Forbes still count as right wing or has the center moved passed them so they are now left wing?
 
George W Bush never endorsed nazis. He is a war criminal sure but he always made a stand against that kind of hate.

Does Forbes still count as right wing or has the center moved passed them so they are now left wing?

Hell, ol' saint Ron never supported Nazis. He was all kinds of problematic and likely a massive racist, but I doubt he'd support Nazis.
 
The ACLU famously has fought for the free speech rights of some very despicable people, right?

Yes in the past. The problem is of course that was when no one liked nazis. Now we have a president who calls white supremacists calling for the deaths of jews as they walk past a synagogue during Shabbat fine people.
 
Justice John Roberts is another example. Not without faults, but not a Nazi supporter.

The guy who ruled in favor of systemically closeting transgender troops is less Nazi than the guy who got all huffy about pronouns? Um, ok.
 
The guy who ruled in favor of systemically closeting transgender troops is less Nazi than the guy who got all huffy about pronouns? Um, ok.

I don't know who the second guy is.

Holding immoral right wing views isn't the same as supporting Nazis. That's why I separate Roberts out from that lot. I don't think Roberts should be on the SCOTUS, but he's not a Nazi supporter then way I see Andy Ngo, Jordan Peterson or Ben Shapiro.
 
Neither did Shapiro.

Yes, he does. He couches it in terms of "protecting freedom of speech". He also contributes to the demonization of the enemies of the extreme right, thus contributing to radicalization. Hell, the Nazis themselves see Shapiro as a useful tool in their recruitment efforts, despite him being Jewish, or possibly because of it. It's all about being "crypto".

ETA: Here's an article explaining where Shapiro lies on the radicalization spectrum.
 
Last edited:
Yes, he does. He couches it in terms of "protecting freedom of speech". He also contributes to the demonization of the enemies of the extreme right, thus contributing to radicalization.

Whereas John Roberts doesn't talk about protecting freedom of speech even for the far-right?

I'm asking for a useful bright line here, since standing up for free speech is pretty much mainstream in the U.S.
 
Whereas John Roberts doesn't talk about protecting freedom of speech even for the far-right?

I'm asking for a useful bright line here, since standing up for free speech is pretty much mainstream in the U.S.

There isn't a useful bright line right now. This is virgin soil. Research is on going. I edited my last post with an article about the role Shapiro and people like him play in radicalizing young white men into becoming white supremacist terrorists.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom