John Edward and Allison Dubois on Oprah

My mom's company (which I do some consulting for) does optimization for the placement of adds.

Cool.

I think that their complaints about the change in programming has to do with the huge amount of work that goes into reaching a specific audience, and the amount that an add campaign can be derailed when the programming changes. Advertizers are more concerned with who is watching what than with what is being said on the program.

I partially agree with you. :) Yes, advertisers are primarily concerned with who is watching. However, each television show is targeted and monitored for drawing a specific demographic --- which is controlled by network advertising and mostly ... program content. Additionally, there are studies that show that watching some types of TV shows can lull viewers into a quasi-hypnotic state. This is not unique to TV. Listening to music, playing video games, enjoying some beer or wine with friends, and other activities also has the same effect. It can be argued that people seek out opportunities to put ourselves into a semi-hypnotic state as a relaxing technique. Not all TV shows put most viewers into that same quality of hypnotic state, this is determined by each program's style and …. content. Not all advertisers are willing to pay for "spots" in shows that don't have that effect. The news special that covered the first Gulf War 7 by 24 is a good example. The advertisers couldn’t seriously argue that their demographics of choice weren't watching -- everyone was watching! But the frame of mind that most of the viewers were in was definitely different than it would normally be for any of the regular television programming. As a result the advertising would not have the same effect and as a result the advertisers didn't want to pay.

I do think that media is affected by adds and ownership. As a media consumer you have to realize that things like oprah exist in order to make money.

No argument from me and no argument from Badikian. Badikian makes a good case that most people would be better off if they paid directly for the programming of their choice instead of paying indirectly. He argues that the public pays indirectly by reimbursing the advertisers for their advertising expense by paying higher prices for the goods that they buy. This would eliminate the side effect of poor programming. Arrgghh -- he writes better than I do. If you have time, check out the book.

But I strongly believe that in an alternate universe where there is less advertiser funded programming and more subscription or "pay as you go" programming, the Sylvia Browne's and John Edwards' of the world would have much less public exposure.

To bring this post back a little closer to the thread's topic -- in an advertiser supported medium, if it wasn't Oprah, it would be somebody else. Oprah's influence is limited to the area of influence created by the advertisers with our (the public) cooperation. They are the ones that really drive program content. Another poster in another thread (I think Luke T.) found poll surveys that showed that only a minority (about 10% (?)) of Americans believe in the paranormal ( in the form of psychics, etc). OK, that is still too high but based on daytime talk shows and evening shows like Medium , one would think its higher, right? That's because it's easy to forget that mass media content (when it only has a few outlets like 3 national networks ) is driven more by the advertisers then by the general public. Advertisers will not fund programming unless it delivers them the audience that they want. Most advertisers prefer easily influenceable people. Ergo -- you have shows like Oprah , Montel Williams featuring Sylvia Browne once a week (?), and The Medium. Shows like the MythBusters, Bullsh!t!, News with Jim Lehrer hour end up on cable and public television.

That being said people today have more access to information than at any point in history. Forums like this one exist to make up for the silly rule8 that is shown on montel and oprah.

Agreed! But this is not due to large business and advertising. ISPs started off as a mom and pop businesses -- that's no longer the case, but despite some large business' lobbying efforts to raise the cost of internet access in the USA -- it is still accessible for many people. Many forums, blogs, local community or targeted community ad pages (similar to Craig's List), web sites, etc. are not affiliated with big business or commercials and are used by people to find and share very targeted information and entertainment. It's never been easier. The mass media saw this coming by the way and didn't like it one bit. I still remember how in the early '90s many newspapers tried to scare their readers away from the Internet. OK, I'm getting off topic... :)
 
Last edited:
To bring this post back a little closer to the thread's topic -- in an advertiser supported medium, if it wasn't Oprah, it would be somebody else. Oprah's influence is limited to the area of influence created by the advertisers with our (the public) cooperation. They are the ones that really drive program content. Another poster in another thread (I think Luke T.) found poll surveys that showed that only a minority (about 10% (?)) of Americans believe in the paranormal ( in the form of psychics, etc). OK, that is still too high but based on daytime talk shows and evening shows like Medium , one would think its higher, right? That's because it's easy to forget that mass media content (when it only has a few outlets like 3 national networks ) is driven more by the advertisers then by the general public. Advertisers will not fund programming unless it delivers them the audience that they want. Most advertisers prefer easily influenceable people. Ergo -- you have shows like Oprah , Montel Williams featuring Sylvia Browne once a week (?), and The Medium. Shows like the MythBusters, Bullsh!t!, News with Jim Lehrer hour end up on cable and public television.

I think that what you are saying is in essence correct, but this connection comes from tv stations trying to create shows that get ratings. Advertizers don't dictate content, they just vote with their feet if you will, and they are interested in buying expposure to specific groups. Some demographics are more valuable than others. Little wonder that one of the most valuable are impressionable people who will believe anything.

I also agree that directly paying for content is the way to go. Itunes and Tivo are making that more and more of a reality. I just hope that kucinich's media reform ideas don't go anywhere.
 
I would really appreciate a video clip. :)

Next will be an email to Radin...

Radin did not claim any of his research had been published in peer reviewed journals.

There was a skeptical scientist in the audience that Oprah kept talking to. The skeptic said, "None of this evidence has been backed up or peer reviewed or published or had physical data against it. There's no ability to measure the energy."

Radin said, "I just want to respond to the idea of a lack of peer review evidence. That's completely false. Actually there's well over a thousand experiments that have been published in peer reviewed scientific journals, including some of the top like Science and Nature that most scientists are simply unaware of. Within this realm there are many, many studies that are peer reviewed and published."


Radin also spouted a bunch of QM b.s. that has become popular with the woo crowd. A psychologist, for chrissakes.

And Oprah came across as a complete creduloid.

And my own prediction was correct. Neither JE nor Dubois did a reading of an audience member. The entire show was testimonials from people who they had given readings to in the past. Plus the reading Dubois gave of a current case.

As for her "going out on a limb" about predicting the missing teenager's body would be found in two weeks. The suspect has been arrested and is in custody and is awaiting trial. The missing teen's jacket had been found in a dumpster with "bullet-like holes" in it.

To repeat, a suspect is in custody.

Dubois said the body would be found near a city limits sign, that she had been choked into unconsciousness before the "final impact". She said the police should look for a "barbeque" or something that looks like a hibachi that evidence had been burned on.

She said the struggle had started in a vehicle and then moved onto the ground and that she could see the embankment she had been rolled down.

The missing girl is named Jackie Hartman. She was last seen when she was dropped off at one in the morning to meet a man she had met two weeks earlier.

Dubois said it was a date rape gone bad and that the perpetrator considers it partly the victim's fault for fighting back. :rolleyes:

It would be nice to know when the show was taped to see if the two weeks has passed.

The missing girl's aunt was there and Oprah asked her if she believed Dubois.

"Yes. Yes I do. And we're going to find out. I'm so thankful. Thank you very much."
 
Last edited:
Oprah is soliciting skeptics on her site who saw the show. She wants to hear from them to maybe appear on her show.
 
And yes, Oprah plugged Dubois' latest book.

I am totally psychic. 100 percent accuracy!
 
Here you go, Claus:

Many people are skeptical of psychic ability, and others want scientific proof. Dean Radin, the author of Entangled Minds: Extrasensory Experiences in a Quantum Reality, says he, too, was skeptical at first, but now he thinks it's clear that some psychic abilities exist. "What they suggest is that experience is entangled, is interconnected among people," Dean says.

Dean says there are more than 1,000 experiments concerning psychic phenomena that have been published in peer-reviewed scientific journals, and that many scientists are simply unaware of them. Allison even participated in a study for four years at a university in Arizona. "Science is made into very deep specialties. You know about your one area, but you may not know what's happening in the next area," Dean says.

Both Allison and Dean say psychic abilities are like having an extra talent. Dean compares having psychic abilities to being a phenomenal athlete, like Tiger Woods. "Some people have very different skills, and mediums like Allison are able to do things that the rest of us can do to a very small extent, but they can do it more reliably," he says.

"I see mediums like—there are canines that can hear a whistle that human beings can't hear. There are some people who can hear on a level that other people can't hear," Allison says. "We just hear at a higher level."

Do you believe in the supernatural? Do you believe Allison and John can really speak to the dead?
Slide 11

See? QM b.s.! From a shrink!

"You know about your one area, but you may not know what's happening in the next area."

Irony!
 
Last edited:
I just completed Oprahs poll "What Do You Believe?" on her website.

I feel I just wasted 8 seconds of my life. :covereyes
 
I'm going to be ill


ETA:
This means:
Q1: ~13952 of 15002 said "Yes"
Q2: ~14472 of 15012 said "Yes"
Q3: ~14073 of 14971 said "Yes"
Q4: ~12237 of 15015 said "Yes"
Q5: ~13039 of 14488 said "No"
Q6: ~5723 of 9506 said "No"

To me this poll explains why Oprah and her producers don't want to look at this stuff critically. It will turn off her viewers. That may be why Randi was misled; they didn't want to let him make a convincing case against woo, because it would not make the viewers happy. In some ways I have a lot of respect for Oprah, but in other ways not so much. This is a commercial show and the goal is to get as many eyes as possible, and this often involves pandering to the audience.

I've noticed that there is a tiny percentage of really good, intelligent programming on TV, and it usually gets weak ratings. People like crap.
 
And no mention of Science and Nature either.

Okie doke...

I am not sure if I misunderstand, but...Luke is right that he did not stat HIS research had been published in peer reviewed journals, but he DID say that research proving psychic ability had been published in peer reviewed journals such as Science and Nature.

So there was mention of those two journals.

Just wanted to clarify that. Worth an email to Mr. Radin asking for specific citations, no?
 
The only highlight in those poll numbers (and it's so tiny that it can hardly be called a "highlight"), is that the only question with significantly lower approval ratings of psychic abilities is the last question, which is the only one directed at people who have personally dealt with them.

I say, give Oprah/Allison the benefit of the doubt and assume the show was taped 2 days ago (I know in reality it was taped before that). Give them 12 more days, then everyone should take to contacting the show as much as possible to see if she's been found. I somehow doubt Oprah would do a follow up on it with a negative result, since she's obviously so supportive on the episode.
 
I am not sure if I misunderstand, but...Luke is right that he did not stat HIS research had been published in peer reviewed journals, but he DID say that research proving psychic ability had been published in peer reviewed journals such as Science and Nature.

So there was mention of those two journals.

Just wanted to clarify that. Worth an email to Mr. Radin asking for specific citations, no?

"Such as" can mean two things: "Like" and "Two of the journals are Science and Nature".

I need a transcript.
 
I'm afraid to see a clip of this drivel; my stomach has been bothering me all morning anyway.

Here is the link to Oprah's email, in case anyone would like to express their disgust. I just wrote to them:

Email Oprah
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom