John Edward and Allison Dubois on Oprah

Sorry about my previous poat, has anyone got a video clip of this, its hard to judge without seeing it.
 
"Such as" can mean two things: "Like" and "Two of the journals are Science and Nature".

I need a transcript.


I regret I didn't have my video card write a transcript from the closed captions for free yesterday. Buying Oprah transcripts is a bit pricey at $15.95 each.
 
Last edited:
There have been thousands of scientific experiments done on psychic phenomena. I'm aware of this. Many have had their results published. I'm aware of this. Some of these publications are respected scientific journals "like" Science and Nature. I'm aware of this. In fact respected scientific journals that actually are "Science" or "Nature" have carried articles regarding the apparence of paranormal phenomena. I know because I've read some of them. However I see one fact missing from all this. Did he actually say that those experiments demonstrated that the woo claims were in any way substantiated? The only ones I've read have in respected scientific periodicals discussed issues such as statistical missunderstanding, confirmation bias etc.

Talking of confirmation bias, if one did believe in paranormal phenomena and desperately needed to find material to support this belief one could possibly read some of these articles and subconciously cherry phrases that seemed to support that belief.
 
It would be interesting to find out when that show was taped. Jackie Hartman went missing Jan. 29, I believe -- can't tell from our Arizona Republic archives from home, and I'll be darned if I'm paying for it -- and the suspect was arrested the next day. This is from memory on editing those stories, but I believe blood evidence was found in the car.
Regardless, here we are on Feb. 16, and it has been two weeks since she went missing. The family fears the worst, but they have been scouring the desert for her with volunteers. Very similar to that other missing person case, but that's to be expected. When you live in the desert, people will dump a body in the desert. If you're in Louisiana, it would be a swamp. On the coast, in the water.
Anyone could make up DuBois' scenario, and do. They work for shows like "Law and Order" or "CSI."
 
I'm very disappointed. Oprah is not being skeptical at all. She let Edward explain away why he only gets letters of names and not whole names and that he can sense "vibrations".

I am really disappointed in Oprah. The woman does some good stuff with her (ugh!) billions. That she credits woo with being anything other than BS comes as somewhat of a shock.

I guess money corrupts, and untold money corrupts beyond comprehension...

M.
 
I think that what you are saying is in essence correct, but this connection comes from tv stations trying to create shows that get ratings. Advertizers don't dictate content, they just vote with their feet if you will, and they are interested in buying expposure to specific groups. Some demographics are more valuable than others. Little wonder that one of the most valuable are impressionable people who will believe anything.

I also agree that directly paying for content is the way to go. Itunes and Tivo are making that more and more of a reality. I just hope that kucinich's media reform ideas don't go anywhere.


If you change this line:
"tv stations trying to create shows that get ratings"

to:
"tv stations trying to get ratings with programming that appeals to the emotions and doesn't spark the intellect, and will deliver a very specific demographic to the advertisers"

then I'll agree with you. ;)

High ratings alone are not enough. Otherwise we will just have to agree that we disagree.

But to misquote an old song, 1 out of 3 ain't bad and as you said we do agree that direct pay is the way to go. However, I'd like to see that occur where there's a lot of competition --that's part of the reason why I like Kucinich's ideas on media reform.
Link: http://kucinich.us/issues/media_reform

Although I read it quickly, I think I agree with most of his other ideas in this area also. However, I’ll need to read what the other side has to say before I make up my mind. Some of it has already been the law before it was dismantled, I think mostly by the FTC under one or two Republican administrations. My memory is failing me on this point and I don't have time to research it now.

If you want to discuss this more over in Politics I'd be happy to give it a shot. And I've no doubt that others will join in. :)
 
I uploaded the segment where Oprah has Dean Radin on. I recommend watching it with a tension sheet handy.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PPIiUtlwj98

Thanks, FFed!

So the actual quote from Radin is:

"there's well over a thousand experiments that have been published in peer-reviewed scientific journals, including some of the top like Science and Nature that most scientists are simply unaware of. Well, within this realm there are many, many studies that are peer-reviewed and published".

ETA: He seems he does mean that the scientific journals he refers to include Science and Nature. And by mentioning them I would think he means that the articles provide evidence in support of psychic abilities.
 
Last edited:
??????? Is that an exact quote?!?!
Robert, if I remember correctly, she did preface the very last bit of what she said (including the date rape part) by saying something like "now this is just my opinion" and Oprah said "so this is just your opinion then?"

I think that would be her out...it wasn't something she sensed psychically.

Maybe someone that can watch the video and confirm my memory.
 
"Such as" can mean two things: "Like" and "Two of the journals are Science and Nature".

I need a transcript.

Dude, I taped it. What I wrote above is exactly what Radin said.

Radin said, "I just want to respond to the idea of a lack of peer review evidence. That's completely false. Actually there's well over a thousand experiments that have been published in peer reviewed scientific journals, including some of the top like Science and Nature that most scientists are simply unaware of. Within this realm there are many, many studies that are peer reviewed and published."
 
Robert, if I remember correctly, she did preface the very last bit of what she said (including the date rape part) by saying something like "now this is just my opinion" and Oprah said "so this is just your opinion then?"

I think that would be her out...it wasn't something she sensed psychically.

Maybe someone that can watch the video and confirm my memory.

She prefaced it with that stuff because there is a suspect in custody. So just like a news reporter, they have to say "alleged".

She starts out talking generally about how she "head taps" a criminal, meaning she gets into his head. She brags twice in the show that she wants to be a criminal's "worst nightmare".

So she's babbling on about getting "head taps" and works her way back onto the missing teen's case:

Dubois: ...but I already know who he is from being in his head. I've already felt his motive. I've already felt if it was a sexually motivated crime. I believe in this particular case, and I guess I have to speak as that it's my opinion-

Oprah: Okay.

Dubois: -that the alleged, you know, perpetrator-

Oprah: Right.

Dubois: -that the motive was, it was a date rape gone wrong. That how I see it as. That it was something that got out of control, and I believe that the perpetrator that perpetrated the crime in question blamed her partially for this taking place because if she hadn't fought him, there wouldn't have been such a struggle, and he wouldn't have had to kill her.

Oprah: That's what you believe?

Dubois: Yes.


Exact words, minus the occasional "uh" and "um" here and there.
 
And just to spin up those in the know, there is this gem.

Oprah: So Miss Skeptic. What your name?

Audience Member: Laura.

*Laura laughs*

Oprah: Laura. Laura, our scientist skeptic, what'd you want to say?

At this point, they put the woman's name on the screen. Laura McMahon with a subtitle "Says she is skeptical about psychic mediums".

Laura: I wanted to know if you keep track of how many times you're right and how many times you're--

At this point, Dubois interrupts. She was ready for this one.

Dubois: I know it's important to you scientists keeping track.

Dubois laughs. Oprah laughs. I guess Radin is wired, because you can hear him laughing offscreen.

Dubois: Actually, I spent four years in a laboratory being studied by scientists in, at a university in Arizona. So they kept track of every hit and every miss. You better believe. And they published it in academic journals. So I spent four years putting it out there, and after four years I realized there are some people that aren't gonna get it, and they're not gonna believe, and I have to be okay with that. But I did dedicate four years of my life to trying to help science find a reason for why people like me do what we do.

*commercial break*

Freaking Schwartz!
 
Last edited:
Money. Prestige. Appearances on Oprah, LKL, etc.

That's why people like her do what they do.

Duh!
 
That would be Gary Schwartz. Although I thought he repudiated her, or vice versa.

pdate: May 1, 2006.

Allison DuBois has had a falling out with Schwartz.

For four years, Schwartz tested DuBois in his lab. He came out with a book last October called The Truth About Medium: Extraordinary Experiments with the real Allison DuBois of NBC's Medium and other Remarkable Psychics. There used to be photo of DuBois with Schwartz and his psychic buddy Laurie Campbell on DuBois's website. Not any more. There is now an "editorial" lambasting Schwartz for his duplicity. DuBois writes:

... I do not endorse Dr. Gary Schwartz. I was disappointed to find out that the four years that I spent in the lab for "science" are, in my view, being misused by Dr. Schwartz -- even after I expressed my disapproval.

How about that! That's the four years she mentioned on Oprah!

Gary says that I asked him to write a book about me which is a figment of his imagination. I actually asked him to NOT write a book about me which his publisher Hampton Roads is well aware of since they were served by my attorney before it released....He points to an e-mail from a year ago that he cut and pasted and only shows part of the e-mail trying to make the argument that I said I'd endorse his book.

Participating in lab studies with Dr. Schwartz was never to be a for-profit venture. I always understood that we were participating in scientific studies to help us and the world gain a better understanding of our abilities. Several of our "sitters" in the lab, unknown to many of the mediums, turned out to be writing their own books. In turn, Dr. Schwartz wrote forewords for those books or was mentioned in them. I was promised complete confidentiality and anonymity in how Dr. Schwartz and the University would report the results of these studies. Needless to say, I as well as other mediums were surprised to find our participation in the lab featured in so many other books.

Now that is the height of hypocrisy. Dubois has a forward for HER book, Don't Kiss Them Goodbye, written by Schwartz! She has attempted to hide that fact. But thanks to the Wayback Machine, we have it.

This is the foreword to my up and coming book, "Don't Kiss Them Goodbye". The foreword is written by Dr. Gary E. Schwartz, Ph.D. of the Human Energy Systems Laboratory at The University of Arizona.

http://web.archive.org/web/20040202055258/www.allisondubois.com/background.html

You can read Schwartz' foreword at that link.

To continue:
As DuBois found out the hard way, Gary Schwartz does not do science the way it is supposed to be done. For example, in 2001 he and Linda Russek published a paper in the Journal of the Society for Psychical Research entitled “Evidence of Anomalous Information Retrieval Between Two Research Mediums: Telepathy, Network Memory Resonance, and Continuance of Consciousness.” The actual experiment used three sitters but only the results with sitter George Dalzell (GD) were reported in the published paper. No explanation is given as to why two-thirds of the data disappeared. (He omits inclusion of all his data in other published studies, as well.) The medium was Laurie Campbell. She was blind to the selection and identities of the sitters, but GD knew who Laurie was and knew that she might be a reader. He is also a medium who had a book coming out on the evidence for the continued existence of his “dear friend” with the unusual name of Michael who had died.

In any case, Dalzell said he asked four ghosts (“departed hypothesized co-investigators”) to come to the reading. Part of the success of the reading would be judged by how many of these ghosts were identified by Campbell. They concluded that all four made contact with Campbell: Michael (dear friend), Alice (an aunt), Bob (father), Jerry (close friend). One problem with the design was that Dalzell confirmed that he’d invited just these four ghosts after the reading. Schwartz writes: “It is unfortunate we did not think to have GD write down the names of the people invited 24 hours before the reading, and have this document notarized.” To add insult to injury, all the data that dazzles Schwartz is validated by GD himself.

http://skepdic.com/refuge/funk44.html

Dubois has also taken down the statements from her that are quoted above. But The Wayback Machine strikes again! http://web.archive.org/web/20060520210018/http://www.allisondubois.com/news.html

About the part I bolded, it is true. Schwartz only publishes pieces of his "studies", with promises the rest will be forthcoming. But it never is. I have found that out for myself while writing for Skeptic Report and just for my own curiosity over the years.

Gary Schwartz is a complete creduloid. And he has no concept of how to conduct a double blind study. Dubois played him like a fiddle.

I will again recommend this article. I worked hard on it and it shows exactly how Schwartz and Dubois worked together.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom