John Edward and Allison Dubois on Oprah

I have been looking for another reason to fuel my Oprah hate, it has been a little low lately.

Thank you for letting me know this.



Just think, with the power that Oprah commands, what she could do to these creeps if she had a good head for reasoning and well directed morals.

A person like her could ruin these shmucks, instead, she is making them.

Bitch.
 
I don't watch Oprah either and I have never seen her with a psychic so I don't really know how skeptical she will be, but I am not hopeful.

I know that she took apart James Frey, the author of A Million Little Pieces, but I think the reason was mainly because he made her and her reading list look bad, not because of any altruistic defence of Truth.

And as has been pointed out, there is absolutely no indication that she plans to include anyone with the skeptical position. That doesn't bode well for a balanced presentation. Dubois has the show Medium to hawk and Edwards his books so I expect a big love-fest. I don't think his show is on TV anymore, is it?

I don't know for sure how far in advance she tapes these programs, but I don't think it's much in advance. Therefore, I have hope that the Hornbeck case will be a topic of discussion.

But then again, I'm not 100% correct. My Spirit Guide get's his signals crossed at times.

ETA: Based on the additions by Vampire and Katana, I predict Woo-mania today at 4PM! If I'm right, do I get the $1M?

It might surprise some here that Oprah isn't known in most areas of the planet.

M.
 
Just think, with the power that Oprah commands, what she could do to these creeps if she had a good head for reasoning and well directed morals.
Her power flows from her audience, not the other way around. She has no power to turn millions of silly twits into sentient beings. If she tried, she'd be in retirement lickety-split.
 
Her power flows from her audience, not the other way around. She has no power to turn millions of silly twits into sentient beings. If she tried, she'd be in retirement lickety-split.

The influence that she has over those silly twits is quite more powerful than you think...My sister is a big oprah watcher, I have seen this first hand.

Every book she mentions gets on the national best sellers list, every diet she suggest is tried by her dieting following, every movie and tv show she suggests gets a mad spike in ratings...

I would think that every psychic/con she busts would inspire her auidence not to trust them as well...
 
The influence that she has over those silly twits is quite more powerful than you think...My sister is a big oprah watcher, I have seen this first hand.

Every book she mentions gets on the national best sellers list, every diet she suggest is tried by her dieting following, every movie and tv show she suggests gets a mad spike in ratings...

I would think that every psychic/con she busts would inspire her auidence not to trust them as well...
There's a difference though. The ways she exerts influence does not challenge the core belief systems of her audience. She's popular and powerful because she's simpatico with her audience. They all believe in psychics or spirituality or other woo stuff (I don't mean literally all of them, of course). If Oprah were to give a fair shot to skepticism about all the woo she parades into her studio, it would be of very little interest to her audience, and would put a fair lot of them right off watching Oprah. Telling her audience to read Toni Morrison isn't challenging them much. Is Oprah still recommending the classics, or did that little experiment go the way of the Dodo?
 
Her power flows from her audience, not the other way around. She has no power to turn millions of silly twits into sentient beings. If she tried, she'd be in retirement lickety-split.

Agreed, but in addition I think it's important to remember that the advertisers are the main players in determining the quality of programs that are aired on TV. And what do the advertisers want? An audience that will actually be swayed by their commercials.

IMHO, this is the main explanation behind the poor quality of many television shows that are available, particularly the "free ones" on network TV. They don't reflect what most of the population would actually like to watch; they reflect what programs the advertisers are willing to pay for based on whom they think will be watching. They also reflect the advertisers preference for TV shows that they believe will put the viewers in an optimal mind frame to be influenced by commercials. Skeptical shows need not apply! ;)

I've just given you my opinion -- now here's some equally invalid anecdotal evidence. ;) I recall some newspaper articles back during fhe first Gulf War reporting that the networks were having trouble selling ad space for their coverage of the war. At the time, the networks had replaced their regular lineup of shows with special news coverage of the war 7 by 24. The advertisers who had already committed to the original lineup didn't want to pay for ad space on the special news coverage instead. They believed that they wouldn't have their target audience and even if they did, they wouldn't be in the "right frame of mind" after viewing the news instead of the regular television shows. The networks decided to continue with their special news coverage, but their ad revenues took a major hit.

Ben H. Badikian in his book, The Media Monopoly, gives a convincing argument about the adverse effect of commercials on the quality of radio and television programming available to the public. (The content of the book varies slightly by editions; IIRC I read the 6th one.)
 
Last edited:
Hey, I'm not saying that The Honeymooners were still on the air when I was born, but I love classic comedy and you can't get much more classic than the Kramdens.
 
My gf is a big believer in a lot of things woo and she was watching this load of ummmm errrr crud when I came home for lunch.

It was more of the same old drivel - Alison claiming that she helps law enforcement solve crimes, and she talks to people's dead relatives. Thankfully I missed the segment with John Edward, but I can guess as to what he was saying. They also had a Dean ( I cannot remember his name at this moment) pushing his book and making claims that all of the woo he had written about was peer reviewed and published in such journals as Science and Nature.

Oprah at least had someone from the skeptic community providing some sanity, but of course she was only give 15-20 seconds to speak.

All in all, it was a load of bunkum and yesterday's show was also bad. She had a Dr Mehmet Oz on and he was giving advice. Seemed mostly harmless yet common sense until he went in to "energy healing" and chakras and such.

Sigh.
 
Last edited:
They also had a Dean Radin ? pushing his book and making claims that all of the woo he had written about was peer reviewed and published in such journals as Science and Nature.

I beg your pardon?
 
This Dean fellow claims that all of his research into psychic ability was real and peer reviewed. Sorry that I could not remember his name correctly, I will try and go to Oprah's site and get the author's name.
 
Ok, Oprah just started off by describing us all as "vibrating energies"....

This ain't going to go well.
 
Agreed, but in addition I think it's important to remember that the advertisers are the main players in determining the quality of programs that are aired on TV. And what do the advertisers want? An audience that will actually be swayed by their commercials.

IMHO, this is the main explanation behind the poor quality of many television shows that are available, particularly the "free ones" on network TV. They don't reflect what most of the population would actually like to watch; they reflect what programs the advertisers are willing to pay for based on whom they think will be watching. They also reflect the advertisers preference for TV shows that they believe will put the viewers in an optimal mind frame to be influenced by commercials. Skeptical shows need not apply! ;)

I've just given you my opinion -- now here's some equally invalid anecdotal evidence. ;) I recall some newspaper articles back during fhe first Gulf War reporting that the networks were having trouble selling ad space for their coverage of the war. At the time, the networks had replaced their regular lineup of shows with special news coverage of the war 7 by 24. The advertisers who had already committed to the original lineup didn't want to pay for ad space on the special news coverage instead. They believed that they wouldn't have their target audience and even if they did, they wouldn't be in the "right frame of mind" after viewing the news instead of the regular television shows. The networks decided to continue with their special news coverage, but their ad revenues took a major hit.

Ben H. Badikian in his book, The Media Monopoly, gives a convincing argument about the adverse effect of commercials on the quality of radio and television programming available to the public. (The content of the book varies slightly by editions; IIRC I read the 6th one.)
Thank you for this insight. I hadn't realized the impact of advertising on content quality. This helps to explain something that has been bothering me a lot -- the poor quality of network and cable news. I don't mean just that they spend a lot of time covering stuff like Anna Nicole Smith, but also that when they cover real news, they talk about it in such a way that leaves out salient facts, details, explanation, context. It's not like it would take any more time than it takes to utter gibberish to really lay it out clearly. They also have one after another of these 1 hour news shows on the cable news channels, during which they give about 3 minutes of time to each topic, most of that taken with interviewing other journalists/pundits.

I can see how the advertisers would favor the viewers that appreciate this presentation over something more cogent, like The News Hour with Jim Lehrer.
 
This Dean fellow claims that all of his research into psychic ability was real and peer reviewed. Sorry that I could not remember his name correctly, I will try and go to Oprah's site and get the author's name.

Oh, I know about Dean. :)

Did he actually claim that his research into psychic ability had been peer reviewed in Science and Nature? Those two publications?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom