John Edward and Allison Dubois on Oprah

Sigh, from Oprah's web site:

http://www.oprah.com/cgi-bin/poll0826_new.cgi

Results: What Do You Believe?
From the show: Do You Believe?

You've taken our poll—now tell us your stories. You might be featured in an upcoming show!

1. Do you believe in the supernatural?
Yes
93%

No
7%



Number of responses: 14771


2. Do you believe that sixth-sense abilities are real?
Yes
94.5%

No
5.5%



Number of responses: 14782


3. Do you believe human spirits can survive after death?
Yes
94%

No
6%



Number of responses: 14739


4. Do you believe it is possible for psychic mediums to see, hear and talk to the dead?
Yes
81.4%

No
7.9%

I'm not sure what I believe
10.7%



Number of responses: 14786
ETA: Arkan beat me to it...
 
Oh, and did you notice the heavy advertising about the reaction to her show last week on "The Secret". Sounds like more woo. She referred to it in today's program when discussing "vibrations" with Edward.
Yep. Noticed that, too.

The show is just pathetic.

As you and Arkan have pointed out, the poll results are sad but not terribly surprising. I put my token "no"s.
 
"Ok, Oprah just started off by describing us all as "vibrating energies"...."

We keep ours in a nightstand drawer. Oh, wait, you didn't mean that...

If only I was talking about the kind with batteries...
 
Do you mean was her name provided during the show? Yes.

Do you mean was her body recovered? Not yet.

Sorry if I misunderstood the question.

The former. Let's keep track of this, and follow up on it.

To Oprah. To DuBois. And to Randi.

I don't think that they're coming back to it since Oprah will next be checking out "what science says about psych abilities" next. This should be good. :rolleyes:

Next: Schwartz. :rolleyes:

Yes CF, I just watched it and he clearly stated that "well over 1,000 articles" in support of psychic ability have been published in "scientific journals such as Science and Nature". "But many scientists don't realize that".

I would really appreciate a video clip. :)

Next will be an email to Radin...

Yes.

Her name comes up from time to time in a lot of topics about psychics. And of course when the show Medium came out.

And may I humbly suggest this brilliant article? :D

That would be blatant self-promotion! :D
 
<snip>I would really appreciate a video clip. :)

Next will be an email to Radin...
<snip>
Bet they try say that "such as" meant "like" and not that they were naming names. Not that it won't be a good thing to try to nail them on. I just smell weasel in the air.
 
The former. Let's keep track of this, and follow up on it.

To Oprah. To DuBois. And to Randi.



Next: Schwartz. :rolleyes:



I would really appreciate a video clip. :)

Next will be an email to Radin...



That would be blatant self-promotion! :D

I didn't record it. I should have had the guys in the control room do it, but didn't think of it.

Isn't it repeated at 7PM on the east coast?
 
Where are our skeptics, though? During the paranormal/talk-show craze of the 1980s there was always someone from CSICOP bursting the balloons of true believers. Phillip Klass infuriated many during the alien abduction shows. Joe Nickell started laughing once when someone trance-channeled a spirit. Surely someone is coming along to take their place.

Edit: I wish I had recorded this. It would have given me something to rant about on my blog. Day late and a dollar short, yet again! ;)
 
Last edited:
I do have a recording of Dubois, but not edward. I should be able to put it on my computer and make it available if anyone is interested.
 
Agreed, but in addition I think it's important to remember that the advertisers are the main players in determining the quality of programs that are aired on TV. And what do the advertisers want? An audience that will actually be swayed by their commercials.

IMHO, this is the main explanation behind the poor quality of many television shows that are available, particularly the "free ones" on network TV. They don't reflect what most of the population would actually like to watch; they reflect what programs the advertisers are willing to pay for based on whom they think will be watching. They also reflect the advertisers preference for TV shows that they believe will put the viewers in an optimal mind frame to be influenced by commercials. Skeptical shows need not apply! ;)

I've just given you my opinion -- now here's some equally invalid anecdotal evidence. ;) I recall some newspaper articles back during fhe first Gulf War reporting that the networks were having trouble selling ad space for their coverage of the war. At the time, the networks had replaced their regular lineup of shows with special news coverage of the war 7 by 24. The advertisers who had already committed to the original lineup didn't want to pay for ad space on the special news coverage instead. They believed that they wouldn't have their target audience and even if they did, they wouldn't be in the "right frame of mind" after viewing the news instead of the regular television shows. The networks decided to continue with their special news coverage, but their ad revenues took a major hit.

Ben H. Badikian in his book, The Media Monopoly, gives a convincing argument about the adverse effect of commercials on the quality of radio and television programming available to the public. (The content of the book varies slightly by editions; IIRC I read the 6th one.)

My mom's company (which I do some consulting for) does optimization for the placement of adds. I think that their complaints about the change in programming has to do with the huge amount of work that goes into reaching a specific audience, and the amount that an add campaign can be derailed when the programming changes. Advertizers are more concerned with who is watching what than with what is being said on the program.

I do think that media is affected by adds and ownership. As a media consumer you have to realize that things like oprah exist in order to make money. That being said people today have more access to information than at any point in history. Forums like this one exist to make up for the silly rule8 that is shown on montel and oprah.
 
Not sure if stopophrah.com would work, it's hard to prove that she's anything but gullible.

Allison, however, has a TV show about her. She would be a great target, it would stop her lies and maybe stop a tv show designed to get people to believe.
 
Oh, I know about Dean. :)

Did he actually claim that his research into psychic ability had been peer reviewed in Science and Nature? Those two publications?

I believe we are actually speaking of Sunshine and Nature a nudist magazine. And I suspect that was "rear view", not "peer review". - but it's close enough for a woo.:D
 
Don't know if someone has answered this already:

The "Research Psychologist" was Dean Radin

The "skeptic's" name was Laura McMahon (think I jotted it down right). (ETA: She called herself a scientist and a humanist.)

Alison Dubois claimed she was studied for four years "in Arizona", IIRC. ( I wonder where? :rolleyes:)

Further edited to add: If anyone knows Laura McMahon, they should invite her to the forum.
 
Last edited:
I'm sure that this episode is waiting for me on the TiVo at home, and I'm looking forward to seeing it, but in re Oprah's woo: she had a show recently where people had survived experiences that are normally fatal (pardon my vagueness, I can't remember the details -- there were animal attacks, airplane crashes, stuff like that).

After one guy had told his story, Oprah shook her head sympathetically, and said, "I guess God still has some purpose for you here on Earth". The guy replied, "Actually, I don't believe in divine intervention. I credit my survival to amazing good luck, to the people who rescued me, and to the doctors who helped me heal". Oprah looked like she'd been slapped. She let out a few jabs over the remainder of the show that expressed her bewilderment and anger with this guy.
 
She sure as hell wasn't helpful catching The Baseline Killer or the Serial Shooter in her area.

Luke T.: Allison was "too busy" to help in that, I believe, and I know she claimed to be "too busy" to work on a missing-person case involving a local businesswoman's mother. Her remains were found in the desert months later about three miles from the closest predicted spot.
Joe and Allison used to be my neighbors. I was doing yard work one day when this woman drove by in a Lincoln Navigator and asked me whether I had seen a cat. Seems that theirs had disappeared as they were moving in.
Years later, when "Medium" came out, I realized it was *that* Allison. I wondered whey she didnt' use her psychic powers to find the cat.
(He turned up later among some empty boxes in the garage.)
 
If anyone wants to catch this, check your local listings. Each day's Oprah episode is replayed at 9pm EST in my market, I believe it is in many others as well.
 
Thanks! I know that I will try and catch it. I am not an Oprah watcher, so I don't know what time her show airs, but I'll find it. I just hope that I don't get too angry listening to John (first name synonomous with a toilet) McGee "Edward" and his smugness.


No matter where you are in the world, Oprah is on at 4pm local time.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom