John Edward and Allison Dubois on Oprah

I'm very disappointed. Oprah is not being skeptical at all. She let Edward explain away why he only gets letters of names and not whole names and that he can sense "vibrations".
 
Does anyone know if this Allison Dubois character actually works with law enforcement? The information I find only says that she claims to work with them.
What a disappointment
 
I only caught the first part before I had to leave - Edward's first reading was brutal. The two things he said that 'confirmed' for the guest that he was talking to her sister were classic cold reading (that she wasn't always called by her first name, Kim, but by a nickname) and potential hot reading (her dead sister's middle name, which I am confident he could have discovered before the reading given that the sister had died under circumstances where it wasn't certain if she committed suicide or was murdered).

The nickname thing was particularly bad, since he just said something like 'I'm getting the sense you don't always get called Kim' (does someone have a tape to confirm?) and the guest leapt to fill in the blanks that her sister used to call her 'KimmyBear' or whatever it was. He didn't even specify it was her sister who had used the nickname! AUGH.
 
I'm very disappointed. Oprah is not being skeptical at all. She let Edward explain away why he only gets letters of names and not whole names and that he can sense "vibrations".

I feel like I've traveled back in time to 1988. I nodded off reading and woke up to Oprah on the tube interviewing vibrating psychics, the same as I did nearly 20 years ago.

Sheesh! She still just as credulous as ever. And she even invoked the name of Jeanne Dixon.
 
Ok. I couldn't resist the temptation to check this out.

Allison was talking about a teenager who disappeared and "went out on a limb" (to use her words) that the girl's body would be recovered within two weeks. I'll admit that that seems like a gutsy move. However, I would be more impressed if, later in the show, she was interviewed again two weeks later to discuss what happened (if anything).
 
Ok. I couldn't resist the temptation to check this out.

Allison was talking about a teenager who disappeared and "went out on a limb" (to use her words) that the girl's body would be recovered within two weeks. I'll admit that that seems like a gutsy move. However, I would be more impressed if, later in the show, she was interviewed again two weeks later to discuss what happened (if anything).

Was the girl identified?
 
Was the girl identified?

Do you mean was her name provided during the show? Yes.

Do you mean was her body recovered? Not yet.

Sorry if I misunderstood the question.

I don't think that they're coming back to it since Oprah will next be checking out "what science says about psych abilities" next. This should be good. :rolleyes:
 
Does anyone know if this Allison Dubois character actually works with law enforcement? The information I find only says that she claims to work with them.
What a disappointment

She sure as hell wasn't helpful catching The Baseline Killer or the Serial Shooter in her area.
 
Ok. I couldn't resist the temptation to check this out.

Allison was talking about a teenager who disappeared and "went out on a limb" (to use her words) that the girl's body would be recovered within two weeks. I'll admit that that seems like a gutsy move. However, I would be more impressed if, later in the show, she was interviewed again two weeks later to discuss what happened (if anything).

Yeah, I thought the same thing. I hope that Oprah follows-up on that in two weeks. I doubt it though.

Also, later in the segment, she worked with a couple who lost a sister or daughter (I'm sorry, I'm work and couldn't follow it all) and it seemed like during the 20-questions bit that she taped with the couple (that the Oprah show edited heavily), Dubois tried to suggest that she was getting a message from "beyond" that they read a book about a bug to the deceased when she was alive. However, the couple wasn't able to put any meaning to that. So Dubois went out the next day and bought a children's book about a bug at the hotel's gift shop and gave it to them as a gift from the deceased! She forced a meaning from that "miss" by suggesting that it was actually a message from the beyond to buy that book as a gift.
 
Last edited:
That was so lame.

The one "skeptic" that they had to rebut the supposed scientist had no credentials (that I saw) and was completely ineffective. Am I surprised? No. I would have been had it been otherwise.
 
Did he actually claim that his research into psychic ability had been peer reviewed in Science and Nature? Those two publications?

Yes CF, I just watched it and he clearly stated that "well over 1,000 articles" in support of psychic ability have been published in "scientific journals such as Science and Nature". "But many scientists don't realize that".

et tu Oprah?
 
That was so lame.

The one "skeptic" that they had to rebut the supposed scientist had no credentials (that I saw) and was completely ineffective. Am I surprised? No. I would have been had it been otherwise.

Yes, the only thing under her name was "Skeptical of Psychics" or some such nonsense.

Oprah did indicate that she would have a poll on her website and I am sure there is a message board there for those that may be interested in visiting it.
 
Oh, and did you notice the heavy advertising about the reaction to her show last week on "The Secret". Sounds like more woo. She referred to it in today's program when discussing "vibrations" with Edward.
 
"Ok, Oprah just started off by describing us all as "vibrating energies"...."

We keep ours in a nightstand drawer. Oh, wait, you didn't mean that...
 
I'm going to be ill
You've taken our poll—now tell us your stories. You might be featured in an upcoming show!

1. Do you believe in the supernatural?
Yes 93%
bar.gif

No 7%
bar.gif

Number of responses: 15002

2. Do you believe that sixth-sense abilities are real?
Yes 94.6%
bar.gif

No 5.4%
bar.gif

Number of responses: 15012

3. Do you believe human spirits can survive after death?
Yes 94%
bar.gif

No 6%
bar.gif

Number of responses: 14971

4. Do you believe it is possible for psychic mediums to see, hear and talk to the dead?
Yes 81.5%
bar.gif

No 7.9%
bar.gif

I'm not sure what I believe 10.6%
bar.gif

Number of responses: 15015

5. After watching this episode of the The Oprah Winfrey Show, did your opinions on this subject matter change?
Yes 10%
bar.gif

No 90%
bar.gif

Number of responses: 14488

6. If you have ever visited a psychic medium to try to communicate with a dead relative, was it a successful experience?
Yes 39.8%
bar.gif

No 60.2%
bar.gif

Number of responses: 9506


ETA:
This means:
Q1: ~13952 of 15002 said "Yes"
Q2: ~14472 of 15012 said "Yes"
Q3: ~14073 of 14971 said "Yes"
Q4: ~12237 of 15015 said "Yes"
Q5: ~13039 of 14488 said "No"
Q6: ~5723 of 9506 said "No"
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom