Israeli democracy about to die

Because although you have no idea why it's wrong, it has to be wrong to make your worldview work, therefore it is wrong. Don't bother to find the bit two lines down where it says the other religions shouldn't compete for sovereignty and should let Islam take charge.

DC quoted the line:
Under the wing of Islam, it is possible for the followers of the three religions - Islam, Christianity and Judaism - to coexist in peace and quiet with each other.
And Sword_of_Truth answered:
No, actually, it doesn't.
And don't tell me I ripped that out of context. It is an absolute statement, and the highlighted "it" refers to the other highlighted "it". SoT claimed categorically that it isn't possible for Muslims, Christians and Jews to coexist in peace under an Islamic government. That's the kind of categorical statements I take issue with.
 
DC quoted the line:

And Sword_of_Truth answered:

And don't tell me I ripped that out of context. It is an absolute statement, and the highlighted "it" refers to the other highlighted "it". SoT claimed categorically that it isn't possible for Muslims, Christians and Jews to coexist in peace under an Islamic government. That's the kind of categorical statements I take issue with.

Sorry, you don't get to rip things out of context by telling people not to call you on it. That's the most hamhanded case of blatant misrepresentation I've seen you pull so far. "It" in that case obviously refers to the peaceful coexistence "under the wing of Islam" as put in Hamas's covenant, which is the context it was being discussed in, which has all the negative connotations you wish would get ignored.

Trying to cut the first part of the sentence he referred to, and pretend he was talking solely about whether peaceful coexistence is possible, ignoring the fact that it was discussing the wording of a specific article, is a clumsy context rip.

eta:
Sword_Of_Truth's actual post said:
No, actually, it doesn't. By "under the wing of islam" they mean that the three religions cannot coexist peacefully as equals. Christians and jews may continue to exist as christians and jews only if they proclaim islam as superior and accede to islamic control.

Otherwise, they'll just kill you.

the only part ddt quoted said:
No, actually, it doesn't.

ddt's strawman based on the above context rip said:
SoT claimed categorically that it isn't possible for Muslims, Christians and Jews to coexist in peace under an Islamic government.

So, yeah.... A poor attempt at sliminess.
 
Last edited:
Would that be the blonds, or maybe the left handed people?
Blather, blather, blather...

The study shows that there is "clearly a shared genetic common ancestry among geographically diverse populations consistent with oral tradition and culture ...and that traces back to the Middle East," said geneticist Sarah A. Tishkoff of the University of Pennsylvania, who was not involved in the study. "Jews have assimilated to some extent, but they clearly retain their common ancestry."
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/06/04/jews-genetics-make-them-a_n_600384.html
 
and still that doesn't sound like they want a holocaust.
but surely it also does not sound like a peacfull coexistance with Israel.
 
Originally Posted by WildCat
Jewish is an ethnicity as well as a religion, something many here conveniently "forget" when it suits them.

all 16 million Jews constitute one single monolothic ethnicity? fascinating.

what language...do all of these Jews speak?

what do all of these Jews look like?

what foods do these Jews eat?

where do these Jews live?

what form of Judaism do these Jews practise?

..the idea that Jews make up one ethnicity, is a joke. Even after the Holocaust and Zionism, Jews still make up at least 5 seperate ethnic groups. Some much larger than other, such as Ashkenazi verse Ethiopian verse Tat Caucasian, but still...there is not one single ethnicity known as "Jewish".
 
Last edited:
ddt,

Under Slavery, was it not possible for Master and Slave "to coexist in peace and quiet" on the Plantation?

Or Colonialism, did the Dutch and Indonesians not "coexist in peace in quiet?

And also "under the wing of Islam (namely, Hamas's warped interpretation)" suggests a supremacist ideology on par with Nazism.

Article 31 is just window dressing for useful idiots who consider Israel worse than Nazi Germany
 
Last edited:
I know where you're going with this. "There's no way a bunch of cave dwelling arabs could defeat the worlds most advanced military". I've heard this before, it's a common soundbite amongst holocaust deniers and anti-semites.

ok wacko....lets test your alignment with holocaust deniers and anti-semites.

In an all out war between Hamas and Israel....who do you think would win?


this should be amusing... :)
 
''If Jews all gather in Israel, it will save us the trouble of going after them worldwide.''
- Hizbullah General Secretary Hassan Nazrallah

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hassan_Nasrallah

wiki said:
Badih Chayban in his October 23, 2002 article in The Daily Star, Nasrallah said that "if [Jews] all gather in Israel, it will save us the trouble of going after them worldwide."[38] Charles Glass believes that the quotation was likely a fabrication, citing other published accounts of Nasrallah's speech that had no reference to the anti-Semitic comment, and statements by the editor-in-chief of the Lebanese newspaper which published the quotes, that questioned both the translation and the "agenda of the translator."[39]



"The Day of Judgement will not come about until Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews), when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say O Moslems, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him."

- Hamas Charter, Article 7

This has been brought up so many times. It does not say all Jews. The charter also says: "As to those who have not borne arms against you on account of religion, nor turned you out of your dwellings, Allah forbiddeth you not to deal kindly with them, and to behave justly towards them; for Allah loveth those who act justly." (The Tried - verse 8)
http://www.sacred-texts.com/isl/quran/06002.htm


ETA: Might as well link to the previous conversation

FireGarden said:
...its people here in Politics or Current Events who apperantly claim with complete seriousness "Oh, they aren't serious when they say they're going to kill us all."

Even this quote, given above,

Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Umar:

Allah's Apostle said, "You (i.e. Muslims) will fight wi the Jews till some of them will hide behind stones. The stones will (betray them) saying, 'O 'Abdullah (i.e. slave of Allah)! There is a Jew hiding behind me; so kill him.' "

Doesn't mean that all the Jews will be killed. It says: "You will fight the Jews until even the stones help you kill them". It says Jews will die in this fight. It doesn't say all Jews.

Add to that the parts of the Hamas charter which talk about living in peace, and the quote from the Quran which warns not to mistreat people who neither wage war upon Muslims nor throw them out of their homes -- it seems quite clear that the ideals being put forward are ones of fighting for their right to live in peace in their homes.

Their means of fighting includes terrorism. That doesn't mean they want to kill everybody. Even terrorists can have less genocidal aims.
 
Last edited:
Firegarden,

You seem to think that Hamas only want a world where everybody lives in equality. except, the extremely antisemitic sentiments expressed by their leadership and the charter itself ("Zionist" is a common dodge among antisemites, look at David Duke for example, or "Zionist occupied government", a term used by Neo Nazis).

And "under the wing of islam (in other words, their warped interpretation)" seems to suggest the choice of slavery or death, combined with the Religous supremacist sounding ideology of their predecessors in the Muslim Brotherhood.

and Article 7 is explicitly genocidal, as the previous link shows:

"The Day of Judgement will not come about until Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews), when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say O Moslems, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him. Only the Gharkad tree, (evidently a certain kind of tree) would not do that because it is one of the trees of the Jews."

Note: it does NOT say "Zionist Jews". It says The Jews plain and simple. Don't try the shtick of saying it's in the context of a war. By that standard, hitler wasnt antisemitic when he railed about the "judeo-bolshevik" USSR, nor was he genocidal by that logic.
 
Last edited:
Doesn't mean that all the Jews will be killed. It says: "You will fight the Jews until even the stones help you kill them". It says Jews will die in this fight. It doesn't say all Jews.

Uhhh... yes, actually, it does.

I'm surprised this has escaped your notice, this being a critical thinking/pro-science forum and all, but under the physical laws of this universe, trees and rocks don't talk.

So here is the Hamas charter in its simplest form:

We will kill members of ethnic group X until physically impossible condition Y is fulfilled.

They've set up a situation where they cannot stop killing jews until the supply of jews runs out.
 
Im pretty sure similar sleights of hand could have been used for a defence of the Interahamwe in Rwanda.
 
Uhhh... yes, actually, it does.

I'm surprised this has escaped your notice, this being a critical thinking/pro-science forum and all, but under the physical laws of this universe, trees and rocks don't talk.

So here is the Hamas charter in its simplest form:

We will kill members of ethnic group X until physically impossible condition Y is fulfilled.

They've set up a situation where they cannot stop killing jews until the supply of jews runs out.

Perhaps you could consider Charlemagne (as invented by Prof Jones): "Let my armies be the rocks and the trees and the birds in the sky." Equally impossible, but why is that surprising in religion? It just promises that even the natural world will be on your side.

Your interpretation ignores the other parts, such as their quote from 60:8
http://www.sacred-texts.com/isl/quran/06002.htm

And that Jews and Christians can live in peace 'under the wing of Islam'.

And "under the wing of islam (in other words, their warped interpretation)" seems to suggest the choice of slavery or death, combined with the Religous supremacist sounding ideology of their predecessors in the Muslim Brotherhood.

No it doesn't.
It suggests they want an Islamic state.

Also asked before:
FireGarden said:
Peace and quiet would not be possible except under the wing of Islam

You do know what this means, right?

Yes, it means they want an Islamic state.
That is different to wanting to kill all the Jews.
 
wow, i've heard of useful idiocy before, but this takes the cake.

in hamas's worldview "under the wing of islam" suggests that the other religions have to submit to Islamic state rule. Given that their brand of Jihadism isnt really that different from Saudi Arabia, i really doubt that Jews and Christians would be living with Muslims in equality with Wahabbists dominating their every move. This sort of theocracy is totalitarian as it puts one state religion above the other and in a supremacist worldview, and given Hamas' policies in the Palestinian authority as well as promotion of Holocaust Denial and antisemitism, i really doubt that they only want an islamic state.

Did Slaves not "coexist in peace" "under the wing of their masters?". It doesnt say coexist in equality. But Hamas' idea of peace would be to make a desert of the Jews and call it peace.

As for comparing a desire to kill jews with military metaphors, that is so full of errors that i dont even know where to start.

You have now officially gone into Skeptic Ginger territory.
 
Last edited:
Still not genocide, so why do you want to pretend it is?

what would you describe as what happened to the Helots under sparta? Did they not "coexist in peace" under the wing of the Spartans?

Genocide doesnt have to take place immediately, as in the Case of WW2, Bosnia or Rwanda. It can take place over a long time, as with what happened to the Amazon Indians in Brazil.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom