Israeli democracy about to die

Oscar Wilde (I think) said that the press' chief role is to say "Lord Jones died" to people who had no idea Lord Jones ever lived.

Similarly, I am quite surpirsed to discovered Thunder (or Parky) now considers Israeli democracy "about to die", considering that, based on his posts, he never believed for a moment Israel -- you know, that racist evil colonialist Apartheid Palestinian-killing illegtimiate settlement -- ever WAS a democracy.

As for the law itself, I think it's rather silly. It is not sillier than oaths that exist elsewhere, such as in the USA, but what's the point?

It's a bit like those lists you get to fill in as a foreigner on the plane on the way to the USA: Are you an escaping Nazi war criminal? Are you planning to engage in terrorist acts against the USA? Are you carrying drugs forbidden by law? Etc. Did anybody, in the history of those form's existence, EVER tick the "yes" box?
 
Israel considers all Jews to be automatically to have a right to a citizenship, as it is the Jewish state. The reason the law only asks for non-Jews for a pledge is the same reason that you only have to fill in those "are you now, or have you ever been" questionarries in immigration if you are not a USA citizen.

As for the law of return being the same as the Nuremberg laws: this is so on purpose. The idea is that if someone was Jewish enough for the Nazis to prosecute, he should be Jewish enough for the Jewish state to welcome.
 
Thunder's actually right here. Especially when Israel claims to be a secular state, and at the same time claims to be a Jewish state. If Israel is a secular state, then it cannot be a Jewish state; if it is a Jewish state, it cannot be a secular state. If we're working by ethnicity here, then calling it the Ashkenazi, Mizrahi, and Sephardic State would be more appropriate.
 
Last edited:
Thunder's actually right here. Especially when Israel claims to be a secular state, and at the same time claims to be a Jewish state. If Israel is a secular state, then it cannot be a Jewish state; if it is a Jewish state, it cannot be a secular state. If we're working by ethnicity here, then calling it the Ashkenazi, Mizrahi, and Sephardic State would be more appropriate.


It can't be some of both? Are the definitions for Jewish state and secular state enshrined in the friggin' bible or something?
 
I only hope and pray that the Israeli Supreme Court can and will strike down this law, once it is eventually passed by Knesset, as being racist and discriminatory against non-Jews.
Who do you pray to?
 
The obligation to act morally is not removed by being able to point out that someone else is not acting morally.

Right... so call me when Israel starts executing people for failing to convert to judaism.

I'm not losing sleep over the political equivalent of jaywalking.
 
This anti-semitic whinging (yes, it is anti-semitic, deal with it) ignores the larger picture.

Israel is surrounded on all sides (except for the sea) by entities which have pledged themselves to a repeat of the Holocaust, the extermination of the jewish people. It's only natural for a state in Israels situation to ask of its citizens that they pledge to oppose the extermination of the jewish people. This proposed citizenship oath isn't a step back from Israeli democracy, it is an affirmation of it.

If people don't like this development, they should work on getting Hamas, Hizbullah and the Palestinian Authority to change their charters first.
 
Egypt and Cyprus wants to repeat the Holocaust? :eek:

Cute. But given given that he specified the entities, most people aren't going to play along and pretend he said "all countries that surround Israel..." rather than "Israel is surrounded by countries that..." Your word twisting fails.
 
Cute. But given given that he specified the entities, most people aren't going to play along and pretend he said "all countries that surround Israel..." rather than "Israel is surrounded by countries that..." Your word twisting fails.

And I said "entities", not "countries". :)
 
Hamas and Hizbollah want to repeat the Holocaust? :eek:

To the extent that they can be convinced that it happened once already, yes.

Otherwise, they want to be the first (in their minds) to carry out a mass extermination of the jews.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom