Israeli democracy about to die

Thunder

Banned
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
34,918
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/ml_israel_palestinians

The Israeli Cabinet today passed an amendment to the Citizenship Law, requiring all NON-JEWS who want to become citizens, to swear allegiance to Israel as a Jewish and a democratic state. Jews who become citizens would not have to make such a pledge.

The day this passes by the full Knesset, is the day Israeli democracy dies.
 
Certainly not a good development but hardly anything near the proclamation that Israeli democracy will end, any more then the US Pledge of Allegiance is the end of US Democracy because it excludes atheists
 
Certainly not a good development but hardly anything near the proclamation that Israeli democracy will end, any more then the US Pledge of Allegiance is the end of US Democracy because it excludes atheists

if the Pledge of Allegiance was a requirement for ONLY new citizens who were non-Christian, and it included "the United States of America is a Christian state", it would indeed be a very bad sign for America's democracy.

I only hope and pray that the Israeli Supreme Court can and will strike down this law, once it is eventually passed by Knesset, as being racist and discriminatory against non-Jews.
 
For Thunder, everyday is Hyperbole Day.

and what would your reaction be, if Canada suddenly required all non-Christian immigrants to swear allegiance to Canada, as a Christian nation, when they become citizens?
 
Call us when Israel starts offering the choice of forced conversion, dhimmi status or death.

Funny, I am not familiar with any modern day Islamic state which offers the choice of forced conversion, dhimmi status, or death.

I call strawman.
 
I must agree with Thunder on this one - I have no strong objection to "oaths", if there are really deemed necessary, that necessity being another issue. But, in keeping with secular democracy, the wording quoted of this oath is biased to say the least, and therefore poorly constructed.
 
I must agree with Thunder on this one - I have no strong objection to "oaths", if there are really deemed necessary, that necessity being another issue. But, in keeping with secular democracy, the wording quoted of this oath is biased to say the least, and therefore poorly constructed.

nevermind the fact that ONLY non-Jewish immigrants to Israel, have to say the oath. Jews who move to Israel and become citizens, do not have to make this oath.

this alone, is discrimination against non-Jews, regardless of the wording of the oath.
 
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/ml_israel_palestinians

The Israeli Cabinet today passed an amendment to the Citizenship Law, requiring all NON-JEWS who want to become citizens, to swear allegiance to Israel as a Jewish and a democratic state. Jews who become citizens would not have to make such a pledge.

The day this passes by the full Knesset, is the day Israeli democracy dies.

Is this Israel’s version of the Nuremberg Laws?
 
Is this Israel’s version of the Nuremberg Laws?

well, then I would assume you would be all for it.

though part of me wishes Israel would indeed pass some laws officially restricting the rights of non-Jews. this would expose Israeli racism to the world, and right-wing Zionists would have no choice but to realize what Israel had become.

...or they would just make more excuses.

though, a loyalty oath ONLY for non-Jewish immigrants, really is a step in this direction. Foreign Minister Lieberman wanted this oath to be required of ALL existing Israeli citizens, and take away citizenship from anyone who refused to take the oath. that...would have been interesting.
 
Last edited:
Certainly not a good development but hardly anything near the proclamation that Israeli democracy will end, any more then the US Pledge of Allegiance is the end of US Democracy because it excludes atheists

This post is actually on topic.

The difference is that no one has to say the Pledge of Allegiance. It's also not targeted only at non-Christians, nor does it say anything about recognizing the US as a Christian nation.
 
Jewish is an ethnicity as well as a religion, something many here conveniently "forget" when it suits them.
 
This post is actually on topic.

The difference is that no one has to say the Pledge of Allegiance. It's also not targeted only at non-Christians, nor does it say anything about recognizing the US as a Christian nation.
A naturalized citizen of the US *must* perform the Oath of Allegience, which does contain "so help me God". Not exactly the same thing, but still the US does require such an oath, an oath that contains religious overtones.
 
A naturalized citizen of the US *must* perform the Oath of Allegience, which does contain "so help me God". Not exactly the same thing, but still the US does require such an oath, an oath that contains religious overtones.
There are alternative oaths they can take if they object to that one on religious grounds.
 
A naturalized citizen of the US *must* perform the Oath of Allegience, which does contain "so help me God". Not exactly the same thing, but still the US does require such an oath, an oath that contains religious overtones.

you dont need the part about that fantasy thingy god. Israel needs also an alternative version for atheists.
 
A naturalized citizen of the US *must* perform the Oath of Allegience, which does contain "so help me God". Not exactly the same thing, but still the US does require such an oath, an oath that contains religious overtones.

If true, there's still a major difference in that it's not targetted only at people who don't belong to a certain ethnic and/or religious group and it doesn't require recognition of the US as officially belonging to one religion and/or ethnicity.
 
US Oath of Allegiance said:
Oath

"I hereby declare, on oath, that I absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state or sovereignty, of whom or which I have heretofore been a subject or citizen; that I will support and defend the Constitution and laws of the United States of America against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I will bear arms on behalf of the United States when required by the law; that I will perform noncombatant service in the armed forces of the United States when required by the law; that I will perform work of national importance under civilian direction when required by the law; and that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; so help me God."

Note: If you provide enough evidence that your religious training and beliefs prevent you from saying certain language within the Oath of Allegiance, see the link to the right for instructions for taking a modified oath in Chapter 5 of A Guide to Naturalization.
http://www.uscis.gov/portal/site/us...nnel=dd7ffe9dd4aa3210VgnVCM100000b92ca60aRCRD

Apparently, pacifists need not apply for US citizenship.

Interesting also that new citizens must renounce their citizenship in other countries, but a person born overseas to American parents can have dual citizenship, as well as those born here who then become citizens of other countries.

Double-standard! I am livid and outraged! :mad:
 
Feel free to start your own thread if that's what you want to talk about.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom