Israeli democracy about to die

Doesn't US law have provisions for conscientious objectors?

Interesting also that new citizens must renounce their citizenship in other countries, but a person born overseas to American parents can have dual citizenship, as well as those born here who then become citizens of other countries.

Double-standard! I am livid and outraged! :mad:
When I read the text closely, it doesn't say renouncing their citizenship, only renouncing their allegiance. Some countries don't even allow you to renounce your citizenship. But if this were the case, I'd think double standard too.

I was in a Dutch court session last week where witnesses were interviewed. Swearing in was like this:
Judge: Are you religious?
Witness: Yes, Catholic.
Judge: Do you take the oath ("so help me God") or the promise ("I promise that")?
Witness: The promise.
Not fair! Religious people get a choice how to take their oath, atheists don't get a choice. :D ;)
 
Jewish is an ethnicity as well as a religion, something many here conveniently "forget" when it suits them.

Either way, it's discrimination - ethnic discrimination or religious discrimination. I don't think a discussion which of those is "worse" is very fruitful.

For the purpose of the OP, it's obvious from the quoted article that "Jewish" is to be taken as it is in the Law of Return, i.e., either ethnic as in the Nuremberg Laws, or religious as to Orthodox standards.

The measure is certainly worrying. It also shows how mainstream parties can get tainted with such extreme nationalistic views. It isn't the end of Israeli democracy, but then, who am I to complain about exaggerated titles?
 
Doesn't US law have provisions for conscientious objectors?
Not to become a new citizen apparently.

When I read the text closely, it doesn't say renouncing their citizenship, only renouncing their allegiance. Some countries don't even allow you to renounce your citizenship. But if this were the case, I'd think double standard too.
It does say "which I have heretofore been a subject or citizen". Whether or not some other country doesn't allow it is irrelevant, the US considers newly naturalized citizens no longer citizens of another country.

I was in a Dutch court session last week where witnesses were interviewed. Swearing in was like this:

Not fair! Religious people get a choice how to take their oath, atheists don't get a choice. :D ;)
I don't think the "so help me god" part even happens much in US courts, it's y in Hollywood movies. Certainly not around my part of the country.
 
Not to become a new citizen apparently.
It says "I will bear arms ... when required by law", so if the law gives an option for conscientious objection, that seems covered.

I don't think the "so help me god" part even happens much in US courts, it's y in Hollywood movies. Certainly not around my part of the country.
Interesting. AFAIK, offering the choice is standard in Holland. Considering that only about half of the population still considers itself Christian in some way, the "so help me God" is on its way out.
 
It says "I will bear arms ... when required by law", so if the law gives an option for conscientious objection, that seems covered.
Even conscientious objectors are required to peform at least in noncombatant military roles if drafted.
 
Either way, it's discrimination - ethnic discrimination or religious discrimination. I don't think a discussion which of those is "worse" is very fruitful.

Ethnic is worse in my opinion, but I agree -- both are bad enough. I'm curious how Israeli law defines "Jewish" though. It's something I've tried and failed to figure out.
 
Ethnic is worse in my opinion, but I agree -- both are bad enough.
I have a friend who became an Irish citizen simply because his grandfather was from Ireland, and he spent 2 weeks in Ireland on vacation.

Bam! Irish citizen.

How is this not ethnic discrimination?

Israel was created as a refuge for the Jewish disapora, and for good reason. I have no problems with them keeping it as such.
 
Ethnic is worse in my opinion, but I agree -- both are bad enough. I'm curious how Israeli law defines "Jewish" though. It's something I've tried and failed to figure out.

Obviously, here, "Jewish" is linked to who is considered Jewish under the "Law of Return". Everyone who has one Jewish grandparent is considered Jewish under that law - mirroring the Nuremberg laws which prosecuted those same people. Furthermore, everyone who has converted to Judaism under Orthodox rules is considered Jewish, as early on, the Israeli state has delegated the authority to judge over conversions to the Orthodox rabbinate to placate the orthodox crowd.
 
I have a friend who became an Irish citizen simply because his grandfather was from Ireland, and he spent 2 weeks in Ireland on vacation.

Bam! Irish citizen.

How is this not ethnic discrimination?

"From Ireland" is not an ethnicity. Having vacationed in Ireland is not an ethnicity.
 
I have a friend who became an Irish citizen simply because his grandfather was from Ireland, and he spent 2 weeks in Ireland on vacation.

Bam! Irish citizen.

How is this not ethnic discrimination?

Israel was created as a refuge for the Jewish disapora, and for good reason. I have no problems with them keeping it as such.


I see no problem with heritage citizenship offers. I have lots of friends with an Irish passport via the grandparent route, and a couple with Romanian citizenship the same way (by parent, not grandparent). By doing so, they are able to live and work anywhere in the EU that they please.
 
Obviously, here, "Jewish" is linked to who is considered Jewish under the "Law of Return". Everyone who has one Jewish grandparent is considered Jewish under that law - mirroring the Nuremberg laws which prosecuted those same people.

But what determines whether their grandparent is Jewish? Religion, ethnicity or is it either/or?
 
But what determines whether their grandparent is Jewish? Religion, ethnicity or is it either/or?


According to the relevant authorities for the purpose of this discussion -- it's ethnicity and it's inherited through the mother only.
 
I see no problem with heritage citizenship offers.
As long as it's not too egregious. I see no problem at all with parents. Grandparent is borderline IMHO, as the ties to the land then become quite small and more sentimental of a past that's already gone. But, e.g., Germany for a long time still offered citizenship to Volga Germans or Transsylvanian Germans, whose ancestors had emigrated around 1700.

But what determines whether their grandparent is Jewish? Religion, ethnicity or is it either/or?
Good question. I never quite understood that part of the Nuremberg laws either, as the definition is recursive and you'd have to go back to Noah's sons to settle the question. :D Again, a mix AFAIK, but conversions to Judaism weren't very frequent in 19th/20th Century Germany.
 
I see no problem with heritage citizenship offers. I have lots of friends with an Irish passport via the grandparent route, and a couple with Romanian citizenship the same way (by parent, not grandparent). By doing so, they are able to live and work anywhere in the EU that they please.
Mostly, my friend uses his Irish passport to try to pick up women in bars.

He has a prepared script he uses to hit on women that is painful to watch. On rare occasions it even works... :p
 
I think that mosts of these oaths are burdened with too many details.

Afaik there is no oath in Germany when you become a citizen.

My oath as German military officer was:

"I swear to serve the Federal Republic of Germany loyally and to defend the laws and the freedom of the German People valiantly. [So help me God.]"

Last sentence is optional. Everything said in a few words. Perfect imho.

Conscripts make the same, but "swear" is changed to "pledge"

I made the same oath again (without the "valiantly") when I became a civil servant.

One size fits all... :cool:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom