Israeli democracy about to die

Perhaps you could consider Charlemagne (as invented by Prof Jones): "Let my armies be the rocks and the trees and the birds in the sky." Equally impossible, but why is that surprising in religion? It just promises that even the natural world will be on your side.

Charlemagne is not Hamas, and Hamas is CRAZY!

http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg56878.html

Hamas-Fatah fight spreads to upper lips in mustache war

Hamas has resumed its policy of shaving mustaches of political opponents to
humiliate them, Fatah officials said Wednesday.

Hamas resorted to this form of punishment in the past after arresting senior
Fatah representatives in the Gaza Strip, the officials said.

Hamas, for its part, accused the Palestinian Authority security forces of
shaving the beards of detained Hamas officials in the West Bank.

​

And these guys also say they're gonna kill jews until the rocks start talking :p

Your interpretation ignores the other parts, such as their quote from 60:8
http://www.sacred-texts.com/isl/quran/06002.htm

And that Jews and Christians can live in peace 'under the wing of Islam'.

No it doesn't.
It suggests they want an Islamic state.

No... actually, it says there is going to be war unless jews and christians agree to live under said Islamic state.

Go back and read it again, FG.

Still not genocide, so why do you want to pretend it is?

Genocide is such a simple concept for someone like yourself to be having this much trouble with it. The inclusion of the slavery option doesn't make it "not genocide". This is like saying the Holocaust wasn't wasn't genocide because Oskar Schindler was able to save many jews by convincing his masters the ones in his custody were good slaves. That's your logic in a nutshell.

Killing a million people and taking a million slaves doesn't make you not guilty of genocide, it makes you guilty of genocide and slavery.
 
Charlemagne is not Hamas, and Hamas is CRAZY!

http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg56878.html

Hamas-Fatah fight spreads to upper lips in mustache war

Hamas has resumed its policy of shaving mustaches of political opponents to
humiliate them, Fatah officials said Wednesday.

Hamas resorted to this form of punishment in the past after arresting senior
Fatah representatives in the Gaza Strip, the officials said.

Hamas, for its part, accused the Palestinian Authority security forces of
shaving the beards of detained Hamas officials in the West Bank.

​

And these guys also say they're gonna kill jews until the rocks start talking :p



No... actually, it says there is going to be war unless jews and christians agree to live under said Islamic state.

Go back and read it again, FG.



Genocide is such a simple concept for someone like yourself to be having this much trouble with it. The inclusion of the slavery option doesn't make it "not genocide". This is like saying the Holocaust wasn't wasn't genocide because Oskar Schindler was able to save many jews by convincing his masters the ones in his custody were good slaves. That's your logic in a nutshell.

Killing a million people and taking a million slaves doesn't make you not guilty of genocide, it makes you guilty of genocide and slavery.

They haven't killed a million people. They haven't taken slaves. They have not stated an intention to do such things.

One would think that you'd have enough ammunition limiting yourself to things they HAVE done. Why you have to make things up is beyond me.
 
They haven't killed a million people. They haven't taken slaves. They have not stated an intention to do such things.

One would think that you'd have enough ammunition limiting yourself to things they HAVE done. Why you have to make things up is beyond me.

How would that be relevant to a discussion of their stated goals?
 
Not yet, no.



Yes, they have. It's in the Hamas charter. Have you read it?

I think we've just discussed that. They want an Islamic state and your last post indicates that you don't know how to interpret the part you quoted:

And these guys also say they're gonna kill jews until the rocks start talking :p

[...] No... actually, it says there is going to be war unless jews and christians agree to live under said Islamic state.

[...] Killing a million people and taking a million slaves doesn't make you not guilty of genocide, it makes you guilty of genocide and slavery.

It doesn't say 'kill them all' and it doesn't say 'kill a million, take a million slaves'. But you're open to either interpretation.

It says 'fight them' and quotes a part of the Quran which praises justice towards those that didn't fight them because they are Muslims nor forced them from their homes. That was verse 60:8
http://www.sacred-texts.com/isl/quran/06002.htm

The Hamas charter has a clunkier translation, which I quoted earlier:
"As to those who have not borne arms against you on account of religion, nor turned you out of your dwellings, Allah forbiddeth you not to deal kindly with them, and to behave justly towards them; for Allah loveth those who act justly." (The Tried - verse 8)

Surely they want to be loved by God.
 
Firegarden,

That assumes that Hamas are purely altruistic and seek ONLY an islamic state and will leave the Jews alone in peace and everyone will live happily ever after. However, the Charter's bizarro antisemitic conspiracy theories like how Jews are responsible for every single war ever since at least 1789 (taking cues from David Duke to call them "Zionists" and Smedley Butler's War is a Racket), and have denied the Holocaust are strong indicators that these are just window dressing for Useful Idiots who think Israel is worse than the Nazis.

The Nazi Party didnt immediately kill all jews the moment they came to power, nor did they explicitly say "kill all jews", they just cloaked it in similar language to this.
 
Last edited:
And another thing. Why did Article 7 say "Jew" whenever "Israeli Soldier", or "Zionist" would have sufficed? Surely Hamas if they werent genocidal would have made that alteration. I could easily apply that charter to Rwanda, where one could substitute Hamas for Interahamwe and Jew for Tutsi
 
Last edited:
It says 'fight them' and quotes a part of the Quran which praises justice towards those that didn't fight them because they are Muslims nor forced them from their homes.

And the Hamas charter states that valid provocation for fighting is failure of kuffars (derogatory muslim epithet for non-muslims) to live under or agree to live under an Islamic theocracy.

Why is it that you insist on reading sections of Hamas charter as though they stand alone and exist in a vacuum? Why are you having as much difficulty with the concept of context are you are with "genocide"?
 
A- "The Israelis are planning genocide against the Arabs!!"

B- "How many Arabs have Israelis sent to gas chambers? None."

A- "Yeah, none. None yet."

Haven't been paying attention to the whole thread, have you Parky?

Where does the Israeli constitution specifically pledge itself to committing genocide as the Hamas charter does?
 
Where does the Israeli constitution specifically pledge itself to committing genocide as the Hamas charter does?

contrary to right-wing thought patterns, they don't get to re-define "genocide".

but anyways, please quote the section of the Hamas Charter that calls for the murder of all Jews or even all Israeli Jews.
 
contrary to right-wing thought patterns, they don't get to re-define "genocide".

but anyways, please quote the section of the Hamas Charter that calls for the murder of all Jews or even all Israeli Jews.

Pretty weak, Parky.

Hitler didn't kill all the jews. Hitler didn't even kill all european jews.

Contrary to Hamas apologist thought patterns, you don't get to re-define "genocide".
 
Haven't been paying attention to the whole thread, have you Parky?

Where does the Israeli constitution specifically pledge itself to committing genocide as the Hamas charter does?

It doesn't. Just as the Hamas charter doesn't.

Why is it that you insist on reading sections of Hamas charter as though they stand alone and exist in a vacuum? Why are you having as much difficulty with the concept of context are you are with "genocide"?

The irony is huge.
Not only have I shown that you have no consistency in how you interpret your own pet quote, but I have quoted other parts of the charter which make it clear that both of your interpretations are wrong
 

No, not Godwin.

Wikipedia said:
Godwin's law applies especially to inappropriate, inordinate, or hyperbolic comparisons of other situations (or one's opponent) with Hitler or Nazis or their actions. The law and its corollaries would not apply to discussions covering genocide, propaganda, eugenics (racial superiority) or other mainstays of Nazi Germany, nor, more debatably, to discussion of other totalitarian regimes, since a Nazi comparison in those circumstances may be appropriate

Violent anti-semitism are mainstays of both Nazi and Hamas ideology. Comparisons between Hamas and the Nazis are therefore not inappropriate, inordinate, or hyperbolic.

Bringing the Nazis into the discussion is especially appropriate given that one of Hamas historical forerunners, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem Amin Al-Hussayni had direct contact with Adolf Hitler and probably even exacerbated the Holocaust by getting Hitler to agree not to allow Europes jews to flee to what is now modern Israel. Furthermore, Hassan Al-Banna, the founder of the Muslim Brotherhood, which in turn is the parent organization to Hamas, also had contact with and was an admirer of Adolf Hitler.

This philosophical cross-breeding between Nazi, Palestinian nationalist and extremist Islamic ideologies arguably at least partially explains why the Hamas charter makes the specific threats of genocide against the jews that it does.

Wikipedia said:
Godwin's law itself can be abused, as a distraction, diversion or even censorship, that fallaciously miscasts an opponent's argument as hyperbole, especially if the comparisons made by the argument are actually appropriate.

That would be what you just did.

However, all of this is at best peripherally relevant to your flawed definition of genocide. The complete 100% extermination of a targeted group is not required to be considered genocide.
 
It doesn't. Just as the Hamas charter doesn't.

Correct on the former, wrong on the latter. 1 for 2, FG.

How about I make this easy on you? Why don't you just show me where the Israeli constitution use the word "kill" followed by the name or title of an identifiable minority?

Not only have I shown that you have no consistency in how you interpret your own pet quote,

And I demolished these claims.

but I have quoted other parts of the charter which make it clear that both of your interpretations are wrong

Already dealt with above. Including a slavery option doesn't make it not genocide.
 
FireGarden, are you seriously saying that it's not genocide because the text says "killing the Jews" instead of "killing ALL of the Jews"? Are you for real? :boggled:

If I write a document where I encourage my group to "fight and kill the negroes of America", but it be okay and not genocidal because I didn't write the word "all"? :rolleyes:

ok wacko....lets test your alignment with holocaust deniers and anti-semites.

In an all out war between Hamas and Israel....who do you think would win?


this should be amusing... :)

So it's okay to have desires for genocide, so long as you aren't military capable of carrying it out? What the FK?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom