Israel to attack Iran to draw in USA?

Originally Posted by Elind
Reasonableness is as reasonableness says. Presumably you too think that 911 was inevitable since the US is an evil bully?
It is not their right according to the agreements they have ratified under non proliferation treaties. Ever hear of that? In fact they still maintain that stance, notwithstanding the waiver you give them, not to mention the trust you show.
No, the goal is defend those being threatened. If you think Israel is making veiled threats against Iran, not to mention the US or (surprisingly) France, just because they want to kick some ass......well, never mind the rest.




I'm going to also ask you to stop creating falsehoods about what I've posted. In the interest of polite and rational discussion, please limit your comments to what I actually post, and not things that you imagine I must believe.

Seriously, you are doing yourself and everyone else a disservice by refusing to engage this discussion fairly and honestly. Please, can you try to respect that we are all trying to have a civil discussion, whether we agree on the issue or not?

Which of the above was a falsehood? Address the points and don't get your knickers in a knot because I don't like your analysis. We are debating along with another who does hold that opinion about 911. It sounded like you were of like mind, but if not on that issue, I apologize for the sarcasm on that point.

The other points I made were in direct response to yours and call for a reposte, not a whine.
 
Which of the above was a falsehood? Address the points and don't get your knickers in a knot because I don't like your analysis. We are debating along with another who does hold that opinion about 911. It sounded like you were of like mind, but if not on that issue, I apologize for the sarcasm on that point.

The other points I made were in direct response to yours and call for a reposte, not a whine.

I'm going to ask one more time that you conduct yourself in an honest and adult manner.
 
Well I think the increase of security at our airports and at pretty much every place of mass gathering and at our borders is a change in our way of life, created by one attack.

Exactly, all of the bolded are the result of terrorism. That's what terrorism does, it creates terror.
Here's the thing: we can choose to react that way, or choose not to react that way. The terrorists have no power over us that we don't give them.

I don't buy the "we can't help it" argument... we can do better, and we SHOULD do better. Otherwise... wait for it... THE TERRORISTS WIN!! :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Here's the thing: we can choose to react taht way, or choose not to react that way. The terrorists have no power over us that we don't give them.

We regular people can do that, but as far as governments, businesses and transport agencies, they have to take into consideration terrorist attacks now. That's their job. If they didn't increase the security they would be morally reprehensible. That's what 9/11 changed, they cannot deny the possibility anymore. They did change our way of life in a way.
 
We regular people can do that, but as far as governments, businesses and transport agencies, they have to take into consideration terrorist attacks now. That's their job. If they didn't increase the security they would be morally reprehensible. That's what 9/11 changed, they cannot deny the possibility anymore. They did change our way of life in a way.

Minor increases in security, most of which have been kind of stupid, isn't exactly impressive change... and that's kind of a good thing, don't you think? Politicians being idiots to satiate the needs of cowards to feel the illusion of perfect safety... not such a good thing.
 
We regular people can do that, but as far as governments, businesses and transport agencies, they have to take into consideration terrorist attacks now. That's their job. If they didn't increase the security they would be morally reprehensible. That's what 9/11 changed, they cannot deny the possibility anymore. They did change our way of life in a way.


No. The Woo's changed their lives. I still live exactly in the
same world as it was pre-9/11 in terms of fears or paranoia.

And even if the Governments job includes to protect us, this
also includes wise foreign politics to avoid blowbacks and to
reduce a probable threat of terrorism. Not playing GI-Joe and
making things worse.

But I still don't get your point - I guess you're simply scared.
 
Minor increases in security, most of which have been kind of stupid, isn't exactly impressive change... and that's kind of a good thing, don't you think? Politicians being idiots to satiate the needs of cowards to feel the illusion of perfect safety... not such a good thing.

Well, I wouldn't call the new measures minor, security has been beefed up pretty much everywhere, and money is being spent for it considerably, but yes it's a good thing that things have kept on as usual regardless of these measures.

But if there are more attacks, these measures could become more and more cumbersome, and that's what terrorism is counting on. So yes, terrorism is a threat to our way of life.

I'm not talking about those doomsday scenarios, which are of course highly hypothetical (but still possible) and mostly used by politicians to scare people ...
 
Does the US even have the means and capacity to attack Iran? I mean, they're already knee-deep in Iraqi mud right now...
Conventionally? Sure — if you mean an attack by airpower. If I was in Iran and heard that a large flight of B-2 Stealth Bombers had taken off from the U.S., I'd be very nervous. If you mean a ground assault, then I'd say no, it doesn't look like the U.S. has the additional capacity to mount that kind of operation at present.
 
Conventionally? Sure — if you mean an attack by airpower. If I was in Iran and heard that a large flight of B-2 Stealth Bombers had taken off from the U.S., I'd be very nervous. If you mean a ground assault, then I'd say no, it doesn't look like the U.S. has the additional capacity to mount that kind of operation at present.


Funny thing is: What if Iran marches into Iraq after getting
attacked by the US. Or even funnier - marching into Israel if
they attack them? Gee - one must love all these blockheads.

:popcorn2
 
Only you Oliver finds this funny.


Why not? It's real life comedy - at it's best.
popc%5B1%5D.gif

And this guy sums it up:

 
What if Iran marches into Iraq after getting
attacked by the US.
They would be slaughtered by US airpower in the open. More likely they increase support for the insurgency in Iraq (even if Iran doesn't, the attacks themselves will) and perhaps attack shipping in the Gulf.
If Iraq is not yet a lost cause, it will be if Iran is attacked.
 
No. The Woo's changed their lives. I still live exactly in the
same world as it was pre-9/11 in terms of fears or paranoia.

And even if the Governments job includes to protect us, this
also includes wise foreign politics to avoid blowbacks and to
reduce a probable threat of terrorism. Not playing GI-Joe and
making things worse.

But I still don't get your point - I guess you're simply scared.

I understand you comparing the current situation to something like the 'threat' of communism (Which I presume you are doing), but however exciting and immediatly similar any coincidences may be, they really are not comparable.

The figurehead is an ex-billionare on the run from the most powerful nation on Earth, and the 'threat' of communism happened after the heroic and justified wars against facism, fought in the name of individual freedom. Your average commie had a lot more to stand up to in an ideological sense. After incredibly unpopular ventures like Vietnam and Iraq, both which advocated freedom, I think the threat is entirely different, and a lot stronger.
 
I understand you comparing the current situation to something like the 'threat' of communism (Which I presume you are doing), but however exciting and immediatly similar any coincidences may be, they really are not comparable.

The figurehead is an ex-billionare on the run from the most powerful nation on Earth, and the 'threat' of communism happened after the heroic and justified wars against facism, fought in the name of individual freedom. Your average commie had a lot more to stand up to in an ideological sense. After incredibly unpopular ventures like Vietnam and Iraq, both which advocated freedom, I think the threat is entirely different, and a lot stronger.


No, I think the commie-propaganda was exaggerated as well
because the lemmings tend to fall for it and vote in favor of
their fears.

After all - the Islam is a friendly religion and doesn't care about
what race Muslim members are - not even in case of evil Americans
like Malcolm X. And killing of innocent people is a sin within the
Quran - even if some nuts are ignoring this fact and blow them-
selves up.

But if America and Israel somehow manages to make this a
Religious War - and they're both very good at it as far I see
it, then it's going to be a pretty nasty party all over the
World - including Terrorism on a "never seen before" scale.

How on God's green earth did America end up in Iraq - instead
doing something about Al Qaida and go home?

U n f r i g g i n b e l i e v a b l e . . .
popc%5B1%5D.gif
 
Last edited:
At least someone is enjoying the show.


Of course I do - what else can someone do about the Idiocy
of the infamous three parties involved whining all day long about
each other.

Sorry, but the Irony is almost hilarious...
popc%5B1%5D.gif
 
First of all, Islam is not a religion.

After all - the Koran is a friendly religion

:confused:What is this 'Koran'? Sounds like a great religion to me!

And killing of innocent people is a sin within the
Quran - even if some nuts are ignoring this fact and blow them-
selves up.



Not really. It is all down to interpretation, and you are somewhat arrogant to claim jurisdiction over what it actually meant back in 500AD.

'Innocent' to the Islamists means anyone who is Muslim. Several sources seem to back this up, and you see, any place that is Bilad al-Kufr is deemed as not 'innocent' because it does not subject to the last book of God, and the 6th pillar. Seeing how the Caliphate has gone walkies, the entire world is Bilad al-Kufr, and is thus, declaring war on Islam. Thus, they are legitimate targets by the teachings of the early verse I believe you are quoting.

So no, they are not simplistic 'nuts' and are not ignoring the texts.

How on God's green earth did America end up in Iraq - instead
doing something about Al Qaida and go home?

Your easy going ways about how to get rid of Al Qeada worries me.
 
Last edited:
...I don't think Israel would be dumb enough to do a false flag
operation or something like that. They probably will just destroy
Iran's Nuclear Facility the same way they destroyed Saddam's
Nuclear Power plant:


I like how you say "just," as if this would be a walk in the park.

The simple fact that Iran is twice as far away as Iraq means that such an attack would have to involve the US as well. I don't think Israel has anything capable of flying all the way to Iran and back.

Not to mention that their welcome reception would be very different from what they saw in Iraq.

Or what the international reaction to the US condoning (yes, even turning a blind eye counts) an attack like that would be.
 
First of all, Islam is not a religion.

:confused:What is this 'Koran'? Sounds like a great religion to me!

Not really. It is all down to interpretation, and you are somewhat arrogant to claim jurisdiction over what it actually meant back in 500AD.

'Innocent' to the Islamists means anyone who is Muslim. Several sources seem to back this up, and you see, any place that is Bilad al-Kufr is deemed as not 'innocent' because it does not subject to the last book of God, and the 6th pillar. Seeing how the Caliphate has gone walkies, the entire world is Bilad al-Kufr, and is thus, declaring war on Islam. Thus, they are legitimate targets by the teachings of the early verse I believe you are quoting.

So no, they are not simplistic 'nuts' and are not ignoring the texts.

Your easy going ways about how to get rid of Al Qeada worries me.


Well - do you believe the good old Al Qaida Gang related
to 9/11 still exists?

Or are we talking about Copycats?

And if we talk about Copycats - how the heck will you
ever be able to fight them unless you create Democracies
all over the Middle-East which would do this Job? (as
successful as in Pakistan, for example)

So how do you create Democracies all over the ME if
people don't really want it in most cases - force them?

Oh man, I really would love to read the US-Strategy-Guides
about "how to safe the world" - especially if Presidents get
their orders from the almighty Crackpot.
 
Last edited:
I like how you say "just," as if this would be a walk in the park.

The simple fact that Iran is twice as far away as Iraq means that such an attack would have to involve the US as well. I don't think Israel has anything capable of flying all the way to Iran and back.

Not to mention that their welcome reception would be very different from what they saw in Iraq.

Or what the international reaction to the US condoning (yes, even turning a blind eye counts) an attack like that would be.


I'm sure Israel is trying everything to keep their Monopoly
and they're surely also planning already.

But either way - the results of any intervention could be
fatal. Especially if all this turns into a holy war. You may
remember what happened in the Iraq-Iran war in which
Iranians died in masses with the Quran in their pockets.

In this case people probably should really start to worry,
because this scenario could mean that all hell will break
loose.

Awesome. No Hollywood author could make this stuff up.
popc%5B1%5D.gif

(ETA: Okay ... Ron Hubbard could.)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom