Israel to attack Iran to draw in USA?

Thanks for staying on topic. :D

me said:
Somewhat OT, but what is a FireGarden? Garden, or Garten in German, is sort of like a yard, or a back yard, in American usage.
I was trying to get a grip on relationship between handle and views on Israel, but seem to have gotten side tracked.

DR
 
You left out Azerbajain, which comes from the ancient Persian (Farsi) compound noun meaning "garden of burning flowers", a name resulting from the pre-1905 common spontaneous combustion of ever-released natural gas and oil fumes throught Azerbajain

That's interesting!
And no, nothing to do with why I chose the name.

Darth got that right with the Steve Vai reference.
I don't know why Vai chose the title for the album. The "concept" of the album is kind of like an autobiography -- the first track ends with a computerised whisper: "Hey. There are some things about me I think you should know. Now close your eyes and listen carefully." Then throughout the album Vai references various influences; even Prince at one point, which surprised me (track 13, btw "I want to tell you my secret... It's bad. Very, very bad.").

The FireGarden suite on the album is instrumental, and segues from Tim Rice's "Bangkok". Some of it sounds Indian, some heavy metal, and one part has a strummy piano -- possibly done by MIDI.
 
Last edited:
That's interesting!
And no, nothing to do with why I chose the name.

Darth got that right with the Steve Vai reference.
I don't know why Vai chose the title for the album. The "concept" of the album is kind of like an autobiography -- the first track ends with a computerised whisper: "Hey. There are some things about me I think you should know. Now close your eyes and listen carefully." Then throughout the album Vai references various influences; even Prince at one point, which surprised me (track 13, btw "I want to tell you my secret... It's bad. Very, very bad.").

The FireGarden suite on the album is instrumental, and segues from Tim Rice's "Bangkok". Some of it sounds Indian, some heavy metal, and one part has a strummy piano -- possibly done by MIDI.
I had a feeling it was that...
 
So there is something wrong with nations voting for independence/federalism/unity?
Yes or no: Should the citizens of the US, Canada, and Mexico be allowed to vote on whether or not all the oil in those 3 countries actually belongs entirely to the US? I vote yes! But can you see a problem here?

None of which will have as much control of the lives of Palestinians as the Israeli government has. That's the point.
Perhaps when the rockets stop flying and the bombs stop exploding in buses and cafes Israel won't feel so compelled to "control" them.

The issue is one of not giving citizens a right to vote on the government that controls their lives. That is not democracy.
Finally we agree! Since the Palestinians are not citizens of Israel they do not get to vote in Israeli elections.

If the West Bank and Gaza belong to Israel, then Israel operates a system of Apartheid. If those areas do not, then the remaining settlements are all illegal.
Nope. It is an occupied territory seized during a war, and is governed as such. And once the Palestinians decide to start acting like a civilized people instead of the large-scale Lord of the Flies scenario they're currently involved in they can live in their own prosperous state.

The past does matter.
Especially if you want a solution to the current problem rather than sling mud and demonise.
Big problem: The Palestinians want all of Israel. They'd be wise to take what they got (Gaza and the West Bank), but they apparently prefer endless war and suffocating poverty to living peacefully alongside Israel.
 
Yes or no: Should the citizens of the US, Canada, and Mexico be allowed to vote on whether or not all the oil in those 3 countries actually belongs entirely to the US? I vote yes! But can you see a problem here?

I want to emphasise this post.

In 1901 the seperate colonies in Australia united to form a single country after each colony voted in seperate referendums to join.
 
Yes or no: Should the citizens of the US, Canada, and Mexico be allowed to vote on whether or not all the oil in those 3 countries actually belongs entirely to the US? I vote yes! But can you see a problem here?

The thing your forgetting is that the US does not currently control the lives of Canadians and Mexicans. Israel has controlled the lives of Palestinians for 40 years without ever giving them a meaningful vote.

Nope. It is an occupied territory seized during a war, and is governed as such.

If it is an occupied territory, then the settlements are illegal.
 
The thing your forgetting is that the US does not currently control the lives of Canadians and Mexicans. Israel has controlled the lives of Palestinians for 40 years without ever giving them a meaningful vote.
Funny, the US has controlled Puerto Rico for much longer than that, and they can't vote in US elections even though they're US citizens...

If it is an occupied territory, then the settlements are illegal.
I'm not a fan of the settlements, but Israel pulled 100% of the settlers from Gaza and if anything the attacks from Gaza increased. Why should they think it would be any different if they pulled the settlers from the West Bank?
 
Funny, the US has controlled Puerto Rico for much longer than that, and they can't vote in US elections even though they're US citizens...

I hadn't heard of Puerto Rico before.
But according to wiki, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puerto_Rico#Political_status_within_the_United_States

Because it is not a state of the Union, federal elections are not held on the island, but everyone born in Puerto Rico is a US citizen and may vote in federal elections held in any state or incorporated territory as long as the citizen can claim residence in said state or incorporated territory.

Puerto Rico does participate in the internal political process of both the Democratic and Republican Parties in the United States, and delegates from the island vote in each party's national convention.

Not only that, they have a good deal more independence than the Palestinians.

I'm not a fan of the settlements, but Israel pulled 100% of the settlers from Gaza and if anything the attacks from Gaza increased. Why should they think it would be any different if they pulled the settlers from the West Bank?

You can hardly say that Gaza gained independence at that point. The international community doesn't regard the occupation as over:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/5122404.stm

In 2005, Israel pulled out the troops occupying Gaza, along with thousands of Jews who had settled in the territory. As far as Israel was concerned that was the end of the occupation.

However, that has not been accepted internationally as Israel still exercises exclusive control over most of Gaza's land borders, as well as its territorial waters and airspace.

Not to mention that Israel didn't even attempt to make it look like the pullout was a concession to Abbas. No attempt to make it look like negotiation had worked.

Not surprising, then, that some saw it as a victory for armed resistance.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom