Israel to attack Iran to draw in USA?

Thunder

Banned
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
34,918
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20920341/site/newsweek/

This is not from Prisonplanet. This is not from Stormfront. This is from Newsweek.

This is identical to the conspiracy claims about the USS Liberty. That Israel attacked the Liberty in order to bring in an American response against Egypt.

If this does occur, or if this was even an actual plan, it would confirm many conspiracists theories about Israel. This would be a very very bad thing.

If the Israeli governmant contemplated or has plans for a limited attack on Iran in order to instigate an Iranian retaliation, therefore provoking a massive American response, then maybe Israel really does not deserve our friendship, aid, defense..of any kind.
 
I seriously doubt israel would strike iran with the intention of starting a war. Thats dumb beyond comprehension.

But, I would not be very surprised if they did strike Iran - they've done similar things before. They could strike nuke facilities under the reasonable claim that it is a defensive action intended to keep nuclear weapons out of the hands of a sworn enemy. They would not do this with the intention of drawing the USA into war, but they would certainly have the expectation that the US and the rest of the world would protect them from certain retaliation.
 
It takes atleast 50,000 nuclear centrifuges to enrich uranium to weapons grade. They supposedly have 3,000 running. The UN thinks this may be an exaggeration.

How exactly is Israel under immediate threat from a nuclear Iran?

Why is it the responsibility of the American people to defend Israel from an Iranian retaliation against an unprovoked pre-emptive strike by Israel? Since when are the American people obliged to defend their "friends" when they act insane?
 
I seriously doubt israel would strike iran with the intention of starting a war. Thats dumb beyond comprehension.

But, I would not be very surprised if they did strike Iran -.....

In the real world, striking a country usually causes a war. Strange, that.
 
It takes atleast 50,000 nuclear centrifuges to enrich uranium to weapons grade. They supposedly have 3,000 running. The UN thinks this may be an exaggeration.
No.


How exactly is Israel under immediate threat from a nuclear Iran?

You don't read the news much do you? Hint - horse's mouth.

Why is it the responsibility of the American people to defend Israel from an Iranian retaliation against an unprovoked pre-emptive strike by Israel? Since when are the American people obliged to defend their "friends" when they act insane?

Preemptive is considered smart in most rational circles when the alternative is to wait for the inevitable first.

Unprovoked?:eye-poppi

Please read your newspapers, or at least use Google News.
 
If Israel attacks Iran, shouldn't the rest of the world enact sanctions against Israel? Isn't that what we normally do when one country attacks another without provocation?
 
In the real world, striking a country usually causes a war. Strange, that.

I hate to nitpick what you just said, but it may be worth mentioning that this is not the case.

The US has attacked countries and not had it start a war. Israel has attacked Iraq, Syria, etc and not started wars.

It seems the key thing is attacking someone who's military would not stand a fair chance against your own.

In the case of Iran and Israel, Iran is already fighting a proxy war with Israel through terrorism. It would be hard for Iran to fight a conventional war with Israel due to geography.

Destroying Iran nuclear capabilities would probably not provoke a conventional war but may provoke military responses of a smaller nature.
 
The President of Iran making idle threats against Israel is not a real threat. They will not have the ability to make a nuclear weapon for years. There are those in Israel who prefer to live with the illusion of a threat to justify their way of life.
 
If Israel attacks Iran, shouldn't the rest of the world enact sanctions against Israel?
Yes, I agree, the rest of the world should. The rest of the world would, but it will be vetoed at the UN by the USA

Isn't that what we normally do when one country attacks another without provocation?

Only to certain selected countries (read "rogue states"). We're still waiting for the sanctions against the USA and the UK for attacking Iraq without provocation
 
I hate to nitpick what you just said, but it may be worth mentioning that this is not the case.

The US has attacked countries and not had it start a war. Israel has attacked Iraq, Syria, etc and not started wars.
Let me repost Gurdur's statement with the relevant qualifier bolded:

In the real world, striking a country usually causes a war. Strange, that.
"Usually" does not mean "always."
 
The President of Iran making idle threats against Israel is not a real threat.
If Iran's threats against Israel should be taken seriously as an excuse for Israel to strike, then aren't Israel's threats to strike Iran a good reason for Iran to strike first? If it is valid for one, why is it not valid for the other?

I think it is not a valid excuse for EITHER country.
 
It seems the key thing is attacking someone who's military would not stand a fair chance against your own.
Unless their government can hit you back through other than direct military means. And even if the government doesn't dare, their people are likely to form underground organisations that will.
 
Israel attack Iran?

I honestly think we have enough problems without attacking Iran.

So excuse me while I lol....
 
parky76 said:
The President of Iran making idle threats against Israel is not a real threat. They will not have the ability to make a nuclear weapon for years. There are those in Israel who prefer to live with the illusion of a threat to justify their way of life.
parky76, what do you make of Iran's constant calls for the destruction of Israel? Are you in favor? Are you against? Should Iran keep calling for the destruction of Israel?

Just curious.

Thanks,
Yair
 
parky76, what do you make of Iran's constant calls for the destruction of Israel? Are you in favor? Are you against? Should Iran keep calling for the destruction of Israel?

Just curious.

Thanks,
Yair

Iran is just blowing off steam with it threats to attack Israel. That seems to be the standard left wing viewpoint..unless it is one of out and out apporval of the destruction of Israel.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom