Israel to attack Iran to draw in USA?

There is no hard evidence that Iran is trying to develop a nuclear weapon. The only hard evidence we have is that they have 3,000 centrifuges running. Ahmedinajad time and time agains says they dont want a nuclear weapon and arent trying to make one. Israel, on the other hand, says that Iran is trying to make a nuke, but provides no evidence. Why exactly should we believe Israel and no Iran?

Without hard evidence that Iran is developing a nuclear weapon, Israel has NO RIGHT to attack Iran. If they have evidence, present it to the IAEA and the USA. If they dont..then stop beating the drums of war.

If it becomes clear in the next few months that Israel is about to attack Iran's nuclear facilities based on no evidence, then Iran has every right to strike at Israel's air force to prevent these attacks. Its called pre-emptive self defense.

Once again, what do we have more evidence of? Iran building a nuclear weapon...or Israel's desire to attack Iran over a possible nuclear weapon program?

Cleary we have more evidence of Israel's intention of attacking Iran.

Everything you posted seems pretty reasonable to me. The entire world should jump down Iran's throat to prevent them from creating nuclear weapons. However, creating a non-weapon based nuclear program is within Iran's rights, and to attack them for their legal nuclear program is something that the world should also jump to prevent.

The goal should be that no one attacks anyone else... right?
 
The amount of ignorance here is overwhelming.
It's like we're living in two different worlds.

1. Iran calls for the destruction of Israel. Is that peaceful?
2.
FireGarden said:
Hezbollah was formed to get Israel out of Lebanon. It's still there because it is popular in Lebanon.
Hezbolah attacked Israel last year in August. You might have forgotten this or didn't know it. It kidnapped an Israeli soldier from within Israel. This is what started the second Lebanon War. Is that peaceful?
3. Iran fainances and trains Hezbolah terrorists which are wrecking hevoc in Lebanon as well and going against its own government forcefully. Is that peaceful?
4. If it weren't for Israel, the whole western world would have needed to deal with a nuclear Iraq today. How about small nuclear bombs in suitcases carried by suicide terrorists into the world trade center? When Iran has this capability, it will do the same and if you think otherwise, well good luck. It'll be too late for "I told you so" when that happens. I admit, Israel will be the first to be struck by Iran but then the rest of the world will be next. Doesn't sound too peacefull does it?
5. Have you seen documentaries on what's happening inside Iran to women? They are like garbage there with basically no rights at all. And what happens to those opposing the government? They dissapear. Have seen the footage. Maybe you guys should too. Sounds peacefull doesn't it?
6.
egslim said:
How many countries have been invaded by Iran since 1979? Consider the neighbourhood, with Sunni Afghanistan and Pakistan on their east and Iraq on their west. Iran been less agressive than Iraq under Saddam, more democratic than Pakistan under Mubarak and compared with the Taliban Iran is almost secular.
You make me laugh with your logic. You think that invasion of other countries is the only way to show non peaceful ways? Look at the above 5 statements I wrote.
7.
JoeEllison said:
As long as they stay within the guidelines of international law(and not Bush's idiotic interpretation of it), no country has a right to invade, and the international community has a responsibility to prevent any strikes against Iran.
I wish that could happen but may I remind you that the internation community HAS already, many times, demanded that Iran stop their nuclear research which at first Iran accepted only to be found guilty of lying to the world and continuing their research. Then they said they would not stop their goal of achieving nuclear weapon. That's a country which you guys so much want to trust.

Oh dear fellow JFERs. I can only comfort you that Israel won't let that happen and hopefully the sane world will not either.

Regards,
Yair
 
Elind said:
Strange that nobody here has yet drawn any parallel with the almost certain reality that Saddam Hussein would have had a nuclear capability by the time of the Invasion of Kuwait, if not during the war with Iran, had Israel not destroyed it in 1981. Terrible thing those nasty Israelis did then, don't the apologists say?
I did write about it but in the process you got it first.

Regards,
Yair
 
Does the US even have the means and capacity to attack Iran? I mean, they're already knee-deep in Iraqi mud right now...
 
What is more interesting is why they so consistently make excuses for know terrorist supporting regimes (or pretend they are not).
I consider myself a rightwing hawk, but it would be delusional to believe the rest of the world is made up of doves.

Therefore if a nation is attacked (militarily, diplomatically or economically) I expect them to retaliate proportionally, in whatever way they can. And of course "proportionally" is subject to interpretation, especially if you believe the most effective response is a tenfold one (to teach 'm).

If you attack a nation that is incapable of effective military, diplomatic or economic retaliation, expect them to respond with terrorist methods. That's reality. Arguing about the morality of it all is pointless, and ignoring it delusional.
 
I consider myself a rightwing hawk, but it would be delusional to believe the rest of the world is made up of doves.

Therefore if a nation is attacked (militarily, diplomatically or economically) I expect them to retaliate proportionally, in whatever way they can. And of course "proportionally" is subject to interpretation, especially if you believe the most effective response is a tenfold one (to teach 'm).

If you attack a nation that is incapable of effective military, diplomatic or economic retaliation, expect them to respond with terrorist methods. That's reality. Arguing about the morality of it all is pointless, and ignoring it delusional.
It is also pretty pointless to say "they are EVIL!! They hate us for our freedoms!! Their leaders are madmen who will take over the whole world unless we stop them!!"

Hyperbole and overblown rhetoric don't advance our knowledge or ability to cope with the realities on the ground.
 
parky76 said:
There is no hard evidence that Iran is trying to develop a nuclear weapon. The only hard evidence we have is that they have 3,000 centrifuges running. Ahmedinajad time and time agains says they dont want a nuclear weapon and arent trying to make one. Israel, on the other hand, says that Iran is trying to make a nuke, but provides no evidence. Why exactly should we believe Israel and no Iran?
This reminds me of this thread: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=67802
But Ahmedinajad said so, so it must be true. Naive.

So everyone believes that Iran is making a nuclear weapon but you guys don't:

http://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/world/iran/nuke.htm

http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,430649,00.html

and from the new yorker: http://www.newyorker.com/archive/2006/04/17/060417fa_fact

American and European intelligence agencies, and the International Atomic Energy Agency (I.A.E.A.), agree that Iran is intent on developing the capability to produce nuclear weapons.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/08/01/AR2005080101453.html


But he said it, so it must be true...

Even after 9/11 you guys haven't learned anything about world terror. Let us Israelis teach you what we have learned since we need to deal with it everyday. Listen for a change and stop acting in ignorance.
Israel is not as bad as you think it is. You just need to open your eyes and learn from past events.

Regards,
Yair
 
Nobody is saying that. Can you find a post by anyone in this thread saying that?

In the future, you might try to differentiate between real people and real posts, and the strawmen that you seem to prefer attacking. Thanks in advance! :D

Obviously I was referring to the imaginary people who haven't drawn the analogy, as it seems a reasonably accurate one to me. Clearly you are not imaginary.:D
 
You make me laugh with your logic. You think that invasion of other countries is the only way to show non peaceful ways? Look at the above 5 statements I wrote.
You failed to define peacefulness, let alone how to measure it. More importantly, I showed Iran behaves better than three of its neighbours. Iran is no Sweden, but neither is it surrounded by Norway, Denmark and Finland.

The Mossad is renowned for its clandistine operations in foreign countries, including assasination. And Iran supports factions that conduct clandestine operations against Israel. Most Middle Eastern countries seem to be involved in clandestine operations, if not the government than through private organizations and persons (Saoudi Arabia).
 
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20920341/site/newsweek/

This is not from Prisonplanet. This is not from Stormfront. This is from Newsweek.

This is identical to the conspiracy claims about the USS Liberty. That Israel attacked the Liberty in order to bring in an American response against Egypt.

If this does occur, or if this was even an actual plan, it would confirm many conspiracists theories about Israel. This would be a very very bad thing.

If the Israeli governmant contemplated or has plans for a limited attack on Iran in order to instigate an Iranian retaliation, therefore provoking a massive American response, then maybe Israel really does not deserve our friendship, aid, defense..of any kind.


Even if this is true...

1110746f6db53e8e86.jpg


...I don't think Israel would be dumb enough to do a false flag
operation or something like that. They probably will just destroy
Iran's Nuclear Facility the same way they destroyed Saddam's
Nuclear Power plant:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osiraq

@Chillzero: Copyrightz by me :p
 
Everything you posted seems pretty reasonable to me.
Reasonableness is as reasonableness says. Presumably you too think that 911 was inevitable since the US is an evil bully?


The entire world should jump down Iran's throat to prevent them from creating nuclear weapons. However, creating a non-weapon based nuclear program is within Iran's rights, and to attack them for their legal nuclear program is something that the world should also jump to prevent.

It is not their right according to the agreements they have ratified under non proliferation treaties. Ever hear of that? In fact they still maintain that stance, notwithstanding the waiver you give them, not to mention the trust you show.

The goal should be that no one attacks anyone else... right?

No, the goal is defend those being threatened. If you think Israel is making veiled threats against Iran, not to mention the US or (surprisingly) France, just because they want to kick some ass......well, never mind the rest.
 
We have however learned about governments lying about the threat of WMD's as an excuse to start a war.

Yeah, and we've also learned about the utter non-threat of terrorism to our way of life.
 
Reasonableness is as reasonableness says. Presumably you too think that 911 was inevitable since the US is an evil bully?
It is not their right according to the agreements they have ratified under non proliferation treaties. Ever hear of that? In fact they still maintain that stance, notwithstanding the waiver you give them, not to mention the trust you show.
No, the goal is defend those being threatened. If you think Israel is making veiled threats against Iran, not to mention the US or (surprisingly) France, just because they want to kick some ass......well, never mind the rest.

I'm going to also ask you to stop creating falsehoods about what I've posted. In the interest of polite and rational discussion, please limit your comments to what I actually post, and not things that you imagine I must believe.

Seriously, you are doing yourself and everyone else a disservice by refusing to engage this discussion fairly and honestly. Please, can you try to respect that we are all trying to have a civil discussion, whether we agree on the issue or not?
 
There is no hard evidence that Iran is trying to develop a nuclear weapon. The only hard evidence we have is that they have 3,000 centrifuges running.

not to mentioned refined fuel coming from our friends the Russians; but frankly, your expertise doesn't carry too much weight with me on such matters.

Ahmedinajad time and time agains says they dont want a nuclear weapon and arent trying to make one. Israel, on the other hand, says that Iran is trying to make a nuke, but provides no evidence. Why exactly should we believe Israel and no Iran?

You have a highly selective mind, or something in that nature. You accept that little twerp's assurances on this, while ignoring his threats to eliminate Israel eventually?

Without hard evidence that Iran is developing a nuclear weapon, Israel has NO RIGHT to attack Iran. If they have evidence, present it to the IAEA and the USA. If they dont..then stop beating the drums of war.

I'll send them a note to make sure to check with your evidence first.:mad:

If it becomes clear in the next few months that Israel is about to attack Iran's nuclear facilities based on no evidence, then Iran has every right to strike at Israel's air force to prevent these attacks. Its called pre-emptive self defense.

Interesting. So you do understand and support the concept of preemptiveness?

Once again, what do we have more evidence of? Iran building a nuclear weapon...or Israel's desire to attack Iran over a possible nuclear weapon program?

Once again. See above.

Cleary we have more evidence of Israel's intention of attacking Iran.

Clearly, as in through a glass, darkly.
 
What do you mean?

I mean exactly what I said. Terrorism hasn't changed anything significantly for the vast majority of us. 9-11 is the worst they've done on American soil... and if that's what I'm supposed to be afraid of, I'll skip it, and thanks a bunch. It was wrong and horrible and tragic, but it also had no chance of doing any real damage to America as a whole.

The fear and panic and cowardice about terrorism does much more harm that any terrorist has ever done.
 
*snip* The fear and panic and cowardice about terrorism does much more harm that any terrorist has ever done.


Exactly what I think as well. Maybe the WooClan will understand
that some day. Otherwise the Terrorists archived their goal to
scare the hell out of people.
 
I mean exactly what I said. Terrorism hasn't changed anything significantly for the vast majority of us. 9-11 is the worst they've done on American soil... and if that's what I'm supposed to be afraid of, I'll skip it, and thanks a bunch. It was wrong and horrible and tragic, but it also had no chance of doing any real damage to America as a whole.

Well I think the increase of security at our airports and at pretty much every place of mass gathering and at our borders is a change in our way of life, created by one attack.

The fear and panic and cowardice about terrorism does much more harm that any terrorist has ever done.
Exactly, all of the bolded are the result of terrorism. That's what terrorism does, it creates terror.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom