Israel to attack Iran to draw in USA?

Ahmedinajad is trying to impress the Islamic radicals by yelling about Israel. I believe he has no real intention to attack Israel. Its all PR.

Although, with all the talk about pre-emptive strikes by Israel or the USA, won't Iran soon have the right to attack Israel first to pre-empt the Israeli pre-emptive strike?

There is not real evidence of Iran wanting to make a bomb or having the ability to make a bomb. But there is real evidence that Israel insists this is happening and will attack Iran. Iran, like any other nation, has the right to protect its citizens from a possible attack by another state.
 
Iran is just blowing off steam with it threats to attack Israel. That seems to be the standard left wing viewpoint..unless it is one of out and out apporval of the destruction of Israel.

That's another strawman. Why do you believe things that just aren't true?
 
Ahmedinajad is trying to impress the Islamic radicals by yelling about Israel. I believe he has no real intention to attack Israel. Its all PR.

Although, with all the talk about pre-emptive strikes by Israel or the USA, won't Iran soon have the right to attack Israel first to pre-empt the Israeli pre-emptive strike?

There is not real evidence of Iran wanting to make a bomb or having the ability to make a bomb. But there is real evidence that Israel insists this is happening and will attack Iran. Iran, like any other nation, has the right to protect its citizens from a possible attack by another state.

Isn't Israel a much more credible threat, since they actually have nukes?
 
Ahmedinajad is trying to impress the Islamic radicals by yelling about Israel. I believe he has no real intention to attack Israel. Its all PR.

Although, with all the talk about pre-emptive strikes by Israel or the USA, won't Iran soon have the right to attack Israel first to pre-empt the Israeli pre-emptive strike?

There is not real evidence of Iran wanting to make a bomb or having the ability to make a bomb. But there is real evidence that Israel insists this is happening and will attack Iran. Iran, like any other nation, has the right to protect its citizens from a possible attack by another state.

Of course, Iran is known to be one of the more peaceful countries in the world. So what if it encourages the Hizbolah terrorists to attack Israel from Lebanon and has done so for many years both financially and with training.
So what if it calls for the destruction of Israel day in and day out.
It's Israel who is the evil one. Why not?

Your words show lack of knowledge and ignorance. Words Words Words but nothing factual to back it up.

Keep it up buddy.

Regards,
Yair
 
The President of Iran making idle threats against Israel is not a real threat. They will not have the ability to make a nuclear weapon for years. There are those in Israel who prefer to live with the illusion of a threat to justify their way of life.


Quite frankly, Parky. I really start to think that all of this is
lamentation from Israels side or just straightway paranoia.

There is no reason to Attack Israel with nuclear Weapons,
after all, the Temple Mount is one of Islam's holiest sites as
well since Muslims believe that Muḥammad rise to heaven
in Jerusalem.

So I guess it's rather a question of the nuclear monopoly
in the Middle East for Israel than the "wipe off the map
myth
".

But unfortunately, the Woo-Crowd always preferred Woo
over facts. So why not feed them with Propaganda-Myths
and Paranoia for the weak-minded? It worked in Germany
and America as well.

What do you think about that?
 
JoeEllison said:
Isn't Israel a much more credible threat, since they actually have nukes?
Sure, along with the united states and the U.K. Those are the three most evil countries aren't they? Poor old Iran, what does the world want from it? We should just let them be.
Such ignorance and naive.

Regards,
Yair
 
Sure, along with the united states and the U.K. Those are the three most evil countries aren't they? Poor old Iran, what does the world want from it? We should just let them be.
Such ignorance and naive.

Regards,
Yair

Wouldn't it be interesting if, when you quoted someone, you would comment on what they actually post, instead of just making things up? You've repeatedly attributed things to me that I've never said, and would never say. I'm asking you, nicely, to please stop doing that. It is extremely rude, and doesn't contribute to the discussion.
 
Of course, Iran is known to be one of the more peaceful countries in the world. So what if it encourages the Hizbolah terrorists to attack Israel from Lebanon and has done so for many years both financially and with training.

Hezbollah was formed to get Israel out of Lebanon. It's still there because it is popular in Lebanon.

Oh and look... Hezbollah and the MEK/PMOI as a bargaining chip between Washington and Tehran.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/newsnight/6272661.stm

So what if it calls for the destruction of Israel day in and day out.

The regime occupying Jerusalem will vanish from the page of time.
And that in a speech with the USSR as a comparison. A regime which fell from within. Like the Shah was toppled from within. Like Saddam was brought low by the people who raised him high in the first place.

In that context, it does not even imply an attack -- let alone an attack by Iran.




Evil is self-destructive.
Zionism will go the way of apartheid.
 
Isn't Israel a much more credible threat, since they allegedly have nukes?
Fixed that for you. I think the general consensus is that they do have nukes, but they've not admitted it and not allowed inspectors to verify.

Note that I said I would not be surprised if they did launch a strike against nuke sites in Iran. I never said I thought this was the right thing to do. And yes, WW sanctions against Israel would be a sound response.

And Israel would be right to expect the world to step in and protect it from a counter-strike. Just like Iran should expect the world to protect it from a counter-strike should it strike preemptively against Israel. Its in the world's best interest to PREVENT outright war. So, interestingly, whoever has the least to lose from int'l sanctions is more likely to launch a preemptive strike. In my book, thats Israel.

Iran may be years away from nuclear weapons, but if you are convinced they are developing them in order to attack you, why wait until they are 99% there? Again, I by no means support a strike on Iran, but I can understand the logic of fear behind it.
 
Of course, Iran is known to be one of the more peaceful countries in the world.
How many countries have been invaded by Iran since 1979? Consider the neighbourhood, with Sunni Afghanistan and Pakistan on their east and Iraq on their west. Iran been less agressive than Iraq under Saddam, more democratic than Pakistan under Mubarak and compared with the Taliban Iran is almost secular.

It's Israel who is the evil one.
The situation in the Middle-East is far too complicated to be expressed in "good vs evil" terms. All sides have made their hands dirty.
A better description is in the form of factions based on ethnicity, religion, nationality, beliefs, etc who each pursue their own interests and will ally with or turn against other factions based on convenience. With all the loyalty of a piranha invested toilet bowl, witness Iraq.
 
Iran may be years away from nuclear weapons, but if you are deluding yourself into believing they are developing them in order to attack you with very little evidence, why wait until they are 99% there? Again, I by no means support a strike on Iran, but I can understand the illogic of fear behind it.
Fixed that for you. :p:eek::jaw-dropp:covereyes

I have a hard time taking any of this seriously, after the Iraq debacle. I say we let the UN and IAEA do their jobs, we abide by the NPT while insisting that Iran do the same, and stop pretending that Iran doesn't have a right to have a non-weapons nuclear program. As long as they stay within the guidelines of international law(and not Bush's idiotic interpretation of it), no country has a right to invade, and the international community has a responsibility to prevent any strikes against Iran.
 
I am still trying to figure out why lefties hate Israel so much.

Actually it's easy for them to argue that they don't hate Israel, just their government's policies (kind of like they say about the US, particularly if it's their own country).

What is more interesting is why they so consistently make excuses for know terrorist supporting regimes (or pretend they are not).

I'm of the opinion that one should take leaders of countries at their word with regard to their intentions. These people seem to think that that's only valid if it agrees with their position, vague as it may be.
 
Iran may be years away from nuclear weapons, but if you are convinced they are developing them in order to attack you, why wait until they are 99% there? Again, I by no means support a strike on Iran, but I can understand the logic of fear behind it.
If Israel can attack Iran without fear of sanctions (because the US will veto them in the Security Council) and the US taking most of the heat for the attack because it is seen to support Israel and is geographically easier to hit by Iran, then Israel has little incentive to refrain from attack.
 
Evil is self-destructive.
Zionism will go the way of apartheid.

So Israel will just vote itself out of existence?
Boy,are you delusional.
But I will give Firegarden credit for being honest about wanting the destruction of Israel when most people who I think in their hearts of hearts want that dance around the issue.
 
Last edited:
Fixed that for you. :p:eek::jaw-dropp:covereyes
:)Paybacks are a*****!

I say we let the UN and IAEA do their jobs, we abide by the NPT while insisting that Iran do the same, and stop pretending that Iran doesn't have a right to have a non-weapons nuclear program. As long as they stay within the guidelines of international law(and not Bush's idiotic interpretation of it), no country has a right to invade, and the international community has a responsibility to prevent any strikes against Iran.
I agree with you 100%. But,I can also understand how Israel can have a different point of view given the rhetoric between the two countries. Nothing gives them a "right" to attack Iran. Still, I would not be surprised if they did given thats what they've done in the past. I may be pissed off, but not surprised.

This whole "Israel" thing really gets people riled up. I think I'll go over and say something about Israel in the Elvis thread.
 
Last edited:
Fixed that for you. :p:eek::jaw-dropp:covereyes
:)Paybacks are a*****!


I agree with you 100%. But,I can also understand how Israel can have a different point of view given the rhetoric between the two countries. Nothing gives them a "right" to attack Iran. Still, I would not be surprised if they did given thats what they've done in the past. I may be pissed off, but not surprised.

This whole "Israel" thing really gets people riled up. I think I'll go over and say something about Israel in the Elvis thread.
You go girl!

There IS something weird about the way people react when it comes to Israel... as though all reason flies out the window, and they can't see anything clearly about the situation. Not everything Israel does is perfect and wonderful and justified, and the fact that there are anti-semitic idiots who hate Israel doesn't justify people making equal-but-opposite idiots of themselves in defense of Israel.

Add Elvis into the mix, and someone could die!
 
Strange that nobody here has yet drawn any parallel with the almost certain reality that Saddam Hussein would have had a nuclear capability by the time of the Invasion of Kuwait, if not during the war with Iran, had Israel not destroyed it in 1981. Terrible thing those nasty Israelis did then, don't the apologists say?
 
There is no hard evidence that Iran is trying to develop a nuclear weapon. The only hard evidence we have is that they have 3,000 centrifuges running. Ahmedinajad time and time agains says they dont want a nuclear weapon and arent trying to make one. Israel, on the other hand, says that Iran is trying to make a nuke, but provides no evidence. Why exactly should we believe Israel and no Iran?

Without hard evidence that Iran is developing a nuclear weapon, Israel has NO RIGHT to attack Iran. If they have evidence, present it to the IAEA and the USA. If they dont..then stop beating the drums of war.

If it becomes clear in the next few months that Israel is about to attack Iran's nuclear facilities based on no evidence, then Iran has every right to strike at Israel's air force to prevent these attacks. Its called pre-emptive self defense.

Once again, what do we have more evidence of? Iran building a nuclear weapon...or Israel's desire to attack Iran over a possible nuclear weapon program?

Cleary we have more evidence of Israel's intention of attacking Iran.
 
Strange that nobody here has yet drawn any parallel with the almost certain reality that Saddam Hussein would have had a nuclear capability by the time of the Invasion of Kuwait, if not during the war with Iran, had Israel not destroyed it in 1981. Terrible thing those nasty Israelis did then, don't the apologists say?

Nobody is saying that. Can you find a post by anyone in this thread saying that?

In the future, you might try to differentiate between real people and real posts, and the strawmen that you seem to prefer attacking. Thanks in advance! :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom