Islam's war on freedom

Never said otherwise.

Read a book. Google is your friend. Why should I have to educate you?

Funny that the self same people get up in arms when cartoons are drawn of Mohammad.

That's a lie. I do speak out against Christianity and my government. I do write letters to the editor. I am active.

Again, that's a lie.

So, all you have left is to attack me with lies?

how many protested the cartoons?
how many protested terrorism in the Name of Islam?

you have numbers?

you are active? not enough, i never saw you protesting on the street.
and look, you do not even want to impeach Bush.............
but you think you can Judge Islam and demand things from Moslems........
you should read sme books about Islam, mabye then you know what you are talking about.
 
BTW, I've started threads criticizing my government for recent curtailments of free speech. I'm not demanding anything of the UN that I'm not demanding of my own government.
 
you are active? not enough...
I don't mind you critisizing me. I don't mind you asking me to be more active. I don't mind debating the merits of impeaching Bush. Start a thread.

Critisizm is a good thing. I've told you over and over I welcome your critisizm of America.

We all need to speak out more. I agree. I'm with you on that one. I don't think impeaching Bush will do anything but tear America apart and cost a lot of money but if it happens we will survive. If that is what people want, their pound of flesh then fine. But, who is going to punish the Islamic leaders that murder their citizens and won't let them have free speech? Who will punish the Muslim men raping young girls? Who will punish the clericks that talk poor people into strapping on bombs? Who will punish those engaged in honor killings?

You are still making the wrong argument. Tu Quoque is fallacy and poor form.

Here's a hint, two wrongs don't make a right. America makes mistakes but we have freedom of speech, due process and the rule of law.

I would like Islamic nations to have the same.
 
Last edited:
I hate moral equivalence.

Everything doesn't have to be balanced out. For you to constantly try to find a counter-example to even things out is an invalid form of debate.

This discussion is about Islam getting special treatment at the UN HRC because of certain people's hyped sensibilities. Stick to the topic.
It's also Tu Quoque and rather childish.
 
I don't mind you critisizing me. I don't mind you asking me to be more active. I don't mind debating the merits of impeaching Bush. Start a thread.

Critisizm is a good thing. I've told you over and over I welcome your critisizm of America.

We all need to speak out more. I agree. I'm with you on that one. I don't think impeaching Bush will do anything but tear America apart and cost a lot of money but if it happens we will survive. If that is what people want, their pound of flesh then fine. But, who is going to punish the Islamic leaders that murder their citizens and won't let them have free speech? Who will punish the Muslim men raping young girls? Who will punish the clericks that talk poor people into strapping on bombs? Who will punish those engaged in honor killings?

You are still making the wrong argument. Tu Quoque is fallacy and poor form.

Here's a hint, two wrongs don't make a right. America makes mistakes but we have freedom of speech, due process and the rule of law.

I would like Islamic nations to have the same.
i want that Islamic Nations get what the people in those country want, not what i want.
 
I did, nothing of factual relevance and reputable source comes up.

Right. Because "factual relevance" and "reputable source" is where you get to move your goalposts. This is another reason I'm hesitant. Here's a list for you of names you can cross-reference:
  • David Hager - appointed by GWB under much scrutiny, mostly because of his biblical literalistic views; has actually suggested prayers useful for getting rid of a headache or menstrual cramps.
  • Richard H. Carmona - appointed by GWB; unlike Hager, Carmona complained that he was silenced by the administration on health issues for topics that were not in line with the administration, like abstinence-only education instead of information on contraceptives, which happens to be a cause almost solely championed by the Religious Right.
  • David Barton - openly dominionist/reconstructionist author and founder of a reconstructionist group in Texas; was involved heavily in the RNC campaigning for 2004
  • Marvin Olasky - advisor to GWB in his Texas campaigns; coined the term "compassionate conservative" and is also the one who supposedly gave GWB the initiative to focus on faith-based organizations over secular ones for addressing problems (something GWB still does, notably with reference to AIDS assistance in Africa).

But to your other question about whether such people are representatives to the UN: not yet, but they're working on that, too. Check out this program for an example of what I mean.

Also, I notice that you switched argument over whether there was any implied intolerance or insult within the thread-- to which I pointed out two examples-- and instead are attacking the implication that there may be Christian extremism in the US. Do you think the examples I gave were relevant? Do you honestly feel there aren't elements of Christianity that could equally be considered fundamentalist in US politics? I only asked because you skipped right over that part of what I was saying, which happened to be the most meaningful part of what I was trying to convey. I'm more concerned with the undermining nature of the religious political fundamentalists than I am about violent religious fundamentalists because violence is open, easy to identify, and eventually loses momentum. The political movements are more threatening in the long run because they tend to influence the politics into their moral structure instead of one separated from their religion-- if you think Saudi Arabia or Egypt is not a political climate you'd feel comfortable in, I don't see why addressing a movement that is trying to establish a similar theocratic basis in government is less bad than a bunch of violent revolutionaries trying to take over by force. Whether by force or by political coup, freedom is what gets lost.

If there is any language of mine that you find offensive I will hapily address it and appologize if that is appropriate.

I'm not against Muslims. I'm against religious fanaticism and I'm very concernd about Islam at this time. I don't think that is unfounded and I think it demonstrable that many who are Islamic are moving to reduce critisicm of Islam and I can't think of a worst thing to do in modern western civilization.

I think Muslims should join us in the 21st century and not us join them in the bronze age.

Emphasis mine. Do you see what you did there?
 
Emphasis mine. Do you see what you did there?
Yes. There is a real problem as I've documented throughout this thread.


“Naming Rights” From Natural History magazine © Neil deGrasse Tyson

At no time since the eleventh century has the scientific influence of the Islamic world been equal to what it enjoyed the preceding four centuries. The late Pakistani physicist Abdus Salam, the first Muslim ever to win the Nobel Prize, lamented:
There is no question [that] of all civilizations on this planet, science is the weakest in the lands of Islam. The dangers of this weakness cannot be overemphasized since honorable survival of a society depends directly on strength in science and technology in the conditions of the present age.​

​
Islam has not revealed itself, in large part, conducive to enlightenment. To the extent that that offends people I'm sorry. However I think the criticism isn't without merit and I think the actions of the UN take us away from enlightenment and not toward it. I think religion is the greatest threat to the enlightenment and Islam is of particular concern.

Religion isn't based in empirical knowledge and in fact it is often anti-empiricism. I think there is a valid fear that Islam can leads us back toward bronze age beliefs and not toward modernity.​

I stand by that and my hope is a sincere one. If Islam can survive and embrace modernity then I'm fine with that. But let's move away from superstition and barbarism.​
 
Last edited:
I think Muslims should join us in the 21st century and not us join them in the bronze age.

21st century was till now dominated by War and occupation of 2 countrys, unbelivalbe number of deaths. by double standards and an USA that is running amok. Poverty and greed.

im not so sure if i want also the moslems to play the 21st century game.....

i hope no Islamic country will make up lies about WMD's and invade other people country. oh wait, they dont have to make up lies about WMD's, we are full of WMD's.....
 
what i see here is not an Atheist that is concerned about specific points in Islam, i see an Atheist that wants the rest of the world to become Atheists.
 
21st century was till now dominated by War and occupation of 2 countrys, unbelivalbe number of deaths. by double standards and an USA that is running amok. Poverty and greed.
By every standard the mortality rate has decreased for every time period. Infant mortality, hunger, starvation, etc., etc.

Muslims are fleeing their countries to live in the west. NOT the other way around.

im not so sure if i want also the moslems to play the 21st century game.....
What's wrong with freedom and improved quality of life? Isn't that why Muslims are fleeing to The UK and Scandinavian countries in droves?

You are still off topic.
 
Last edited:
By every standard the mortality rate has decreased for every time period. Infant mortality, hunger, starvation, etc., etc.

Muslims are fleeing their countries to live in the west. NOT the other way around.

What's wrong with freedom and improved quality of life? Isn't that why Muslims are fleeing to The UK and Scandinavian countries in droves?

You are still off topic.

as they are moslems, it is oc not Sharia laws that makes them leave their country, and also War cant be one of the reasons, as it is a violent religion or a religion that leads to violence, they should love it in iraq and afghanistan.

i know several people that left the west to work in Dubai.

my point actually is, we should again have more respect for eachothers beliefs. also we atheists should respect other people beliefs. i want also that other respect my Atheist belief.

the 21st Century is not know for a risen moral standard, in contrary......
not far to go till WW3, humanity is insane once again.
 
There are none so blind as those who will not see.

i can imagen the religeus people here on JREF thinking , look at those blind atheists, wanting all the rest to join in in their blindness.
 
i want that Islamic Nations get what the people in those country want, not what i want.
Yes, that's what I said. I want them to have freedom. You and I want the same thing. Sadly Theocratic dictatorships aren't very conducive to freedom which is why many Muslims are moving to Europe, the UK and Scandinavian nations like Denmark.
 
i can imagen the religeus people here on JREF thinking , look at those blind atheists, wanting all the rest to join in in their blindness.
????

What?

I'm calling for freedom of speech. I'm calling for debate. I'm calling for the right to desent. I'm calling for human rights.

How the hell is that blind?
 
Yes, that's what I said. I want them to have freedom. You and I want the same thing. Sadly Theocratic dictatorships aren't very conducive to freedom which is why many Muslims are moving to Europe, the UK and Scandinavian nations like Denmark.

why pointing out UK and scandinavia?
they also go to Germany Belgium, Switzerland, France.

but what do they flee from, Islam or Politics?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom