Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

I guess my main question is something along the lines of, what does "replacement" actually look like? Is it some stranger who doesn't look like me showing up at my door some day and announcing in broken, heavily accented English that my property is now his and I need to get out? That is certainly what "replacement" implies, the physical removal of people from where they are now to some (most likely not as nice) elsewhere. Or is it more subtle than that, manifesting itself as more people voting for things such as universal health care and school spending?

I guess I'm not quite understanding what bad thing is supposed to happen at the end of all this. And if the answer is (as I suspect) something akin to "nothing super bad will happen, I just want to keep 'those people' out," then I suppose we have the answer to the OP question.
 
Last edited:
I guess my main question is something along the lines of, what does "replacement" actually look like? Is it some stranger who doesn't look like me showing up at my door some day and announcing in broken, heavily accented English that my property is now his and I need to get out? That is certainly what "replacement" implies, the physical removal of people from where they are now to some (most likely not as nice) elsewhere. Or is it more subtle than that, manifesting itself as more people voting for things such as universal health care and school spending?
It's much more like the latter. It's the claim that immigration is being used knowingly to turn the current majority into a minority whose ideas about what constitutes a just society will never again be allowed to be the dominant idea of the country. It's the replacement of one idea of the country by another through importing new citizens.

I guess I'm not quite understanding what bad thing is supposed to happen at the end of all this. And if the answer is (as I suspect) something akin to "nothing super bad will happen, I just want to keep 'those people' out," then I suppose we have the answer to the OP question.
Suppose it was happening the other way and the immigrants were predominantly Ayn Rand and Pinochet fans and this was changing the country in a direction such that liberal politics would be in a permanent minority. Suppose further that this was being done by Trump. Would that be at all concerning?
 
Not to beat a dead horse but replacement theory holds that native-born Americans are being replaced so as to permanently transform the landscape of the nation.

The Great Replacement Theory is one thing when stated as a hypothesis. But, the practical response to it is quite another thing.

The problem is that white nationalists and Nazis use the fear invoking theory as an excuse to shoot up anybody who isn't white, be they native born or not.

Be it the attack on the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh, the 2019 El Paso shooting or the latest Buffalo shooting the Great Replacement Theory gets used as a simple minded excuse to kill non-whites.

-------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
Suppose it was happening the other way and the immigrants were predominantly Ayn Rand and Pinochet fans and this was changing the country in a direction such that liberal politics would be in a permanent minority. Suppose further that this was being done by Trump. Would that be at all concerning?

Oh yeah, it would be concerning as hell. But my solution wouldn't be to make it harder to immigrate, because (let's face it) almost all of us living in the USA are the products of immigration -- it's just a question of how far back you want to go (in my case, a mere 2 generations). So I'm not going to be a hypocrite about it.

Instead, I'd work to enlighten people about why I think the values I support comprise the best direction for the country. If I am right, I think there's a pretty good chance people will come around eventually (I have a fair amount of faith in the basic decency of most humans, irrespective of background). If I'm not, maybe I'll learn something I wouldn't have, had I remained surrounded by like-thinking folks.
 
Italy and Germany have only existed since the 19th century; Germany has subsequently been split and re-unified; Ireland (by which I assume you mean the Republic and are leaving out the Six Counties) has only been an independent state for around a hundred years; France is a mish-mash of what was a bunch of disparate dukedoms and kingdoms (ask Bretons and Basques about how they feel being under the rule of a Parisian elite) and Alsace and Lorraine have gone back and forth between France and Germany; Lithuania has been through many forms, including being occupied by the Russians against their will on more than one occasion.

Not good examples of nations being unified for centuries...

Quibble, Italy was unified in the Roman Empire and always had a strong cultural connection even when politically seperated.
 
Not to beat a dead horse but replacement theory holds that native-born Americans are being replaced so as to permanently transform the landscape of the nation.

The Great Replacement Theory is one thing when stated as a hypothesis. But, the practical response to it is quite another thing.

The problem is that white nationalists and Nazis use the fear invoking theory as an excuse to shoot up anybody who isn't white, be they native born or not.

Be it the attack on the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh, the 2019 El Paso shooting or the latest Buffalo shooting the Great Replacement Theory gets used as a simple minded excuse to kill non-whites.

-------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.

Or n the case of the Tree of Life, non Christian.
It is interesting how in the post couple of years, the Christian Natinalists have pretty much dropped the "Judeo/CHristian ethics" routine in favor of out and out Christian, and I have no doubt they will soon insert "Protestent Christian" into the equation.
 
https://www.washingtonpost.com/poli...ent-theory-is-ignorant-both-broadly-narrowly/

‘Great replacement theory’ is ignorant both broadly and narrowly

Let’s quickly dispatch with the purported plot at the heart of the conspiracy theory. It, too, can be segmented into degrees. One speculates that some secretive cabal of elites is drawing immigrants to the United States to get their votes. It’s often framed in anti-Semitic terms, in part because it’s popular among neo-Nazis. There’s no point in walking through a specific debunk since anyone who adheres to it will not be influenced by rational argument.

While President Biden’s view of immigration is certainly less hostile than Trump’s, the administration kept in place a rule, over objections from key Democratic constituencies, that allowed the government to quickly deport people who crossed the border. Vice President Harris explicitly told Central American migrants not to come to the United States.

As you might expect, the federal government tracks this data. In 2020, 625,400 people were naturalized as U.S. citizens. (Of those newly naturalized immigrants, about 1 in 8 were from Mexico.) That’s compared with 3.6 million babies born in the country — native-born Americans all. That’s a ratio of 5.8 native-born babies to 1 new American from naturalization. If we look only at those of voting age (since you must be both a citizen and 18 to vote in federal elections), the gap is wider: In 2020, about 4.2 million U.S. residents turned 18.

-------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
Oh yeah, it would be concerning as hell. But my solution wouldn't be to make it harder to immigrate, because (let's face it) almost all of us living in the USA are the products of immigration -- it's just a question of how far back you want to go (in my case, a mere 2 generations). So I'm not going to be a hypocrite about it.
It would only be hypocritical if you had some kind of universalist view where you didn't think citizens should be preferred to non-citizens. Is it hypocritical to care more for one's own children than other peoples? You only run into these problems if you have some universalist, rationalistic conception of your country where if it was OK for your ancestor to come, then there must be some "right" to do that and since rights are universal, the right must still exist.

Instead, I'd work to enlighten people about why I think the values I support comprise the best direction for the country. If I am right, I think there's a pretty good chance people will come around eventually (I have a fair amount of faith in the basic decency of most humans, irrespective of background). If I'm not, maybe I'll learn something I wouldn't have, had I remained surrounded by like-thinking folks.
That is generally not how it works.The conceptions of rights and your values are culturally specific to you and the culture you were brought up in. They are no more universal than the culture in Iran or China. The idea that you can be reasoned into a set of values is like imagining you can be reasoned into a religion... I'm sure it happens, but it is a rare event. Values aren't products of reason.
 
Last edited:
It would only be hypocritical if you had some kind of universalist view where you didn't think citizens should be preferred to non-citizens. Is it hypocritical to care more for one's own children than other peoples? You only run into these problems if you have some universalist, rationalistic conception of your country where if it was OK for your ancestor to come, then there must be some "right" to do that and since rights are universal, the right must still exist.

Since non-citizens can't vote in the U.S. one has to ask what your point is?

. . .The conceptions of rights and your values are culturally specific to you and the culture you were brought up in. They are no more universal than the culture in Iran or China. The idea that you can be reasoned into a set of values is like imagining you can be reasoned into a religion... I'm sure it happens, but it is a rare event.

Oh? Is the point that a Chinese person or a Muslim can't understand or adopt American values because they are "the other"?

-------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
Since non-citizens can't vote in the U.S. one has to ask what your point is?
I don't see how this relates.

Oh? Is the point that a Chinese person or a Muslim can't understand or adopt American values because they are "the other"?
I suppose everybody can adopt them, the question is do they adopt them? If for some reason I moved to Afghanistan, I am sure I would in some sense be capable of adopting the Taliban's values, but I'm not sure that I really would.

We aren't talking about theoretical models of immigration, we are talking about actual immigration.
 
I don't see how this relates.

So "we" are going to be replaced by non-voting, non-citizens? How does that work?

I suppose everybody can adopt them, the question is do they adopt them? If for some reason I moved to Afghanistan, I am sure I would in some sense be capable of adopting the Taliban's values, but I'm not sure that I really would.

So since the Chinese person and the Muslin from Iran probably can't/won't adopt American values they are in a sense cultural inferior to "us"?

And if being so doesn't it seem likely that some folks would figure they can just shoot 'em?

-------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
So "we" are going to be replaced by non-voting, non-citizens? How does that work?
You've misunderstood the point I was replying to. It was about how it was hypocritical for Americans to make it hard for immigrants to come to America.

So since the Chinese person and the Muslin from Iran probably can't/won't adopt American values they are in a sense cultural inferior to "us"?

And if being so doesn't ii seem likely that some folks would figure they can just shoot 'em?
You need to respond to what people say rather than make up positions for them. That's how arguments and debates work. Otherwise you're just playing with yourself.
 
You need to respond to what people say rather than make up positions for them. That's how arguments and debates work. Otherwise you're just playing with yourself.

Well, what is your position, besides telling others what to say?

So far it seems to be that there is some sort of cultural magic that gets passed down from one American generation to another and that Chinese and Iranians (as opposed to the Irish, Germans and the Dutch) can't grasp that magic.

-------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Well, what is your position, besides telling others what to say?

So far it seems to be that there is some sort of cultural magic that gets passed down from one American generation to another and that Chinese and Iranians (as opposed to the Irish, Germans and the Dutch) can't grasp that magic.
Isn't it remarkable how frequently Protestants kids grow up Protestant, and Catholic kids grow up Catholic. Culture is the same. Irish, German and Dutch culture comes from the same cultural routes, at various distances of removal, that American culture originally came from.
 
Last edited:
Well, what is your position, besides telling others what to say?

So far it seems to be that there is some sort of cultural magic that gets passed down from one American generation to another and that Chinese and Iranians (as opposed to the Irish, Germans and the Dutch) can't grasp that magic.

Isn't it remarkable how frequently Protestants kids grow up Protestant, and Catholic kids grow up Catholic. Culture is the same. Irish, German and Dutch culture comes from the same cultural routes, at various distances of removal, that American culture originally came from.

So naturalized citizens should adopt not only the magic American cultural values but those of the European countries from which they came?

Funny how they didn't put that in the oath of citizenship:

"I hereby declare, on oath, that I absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereignty, of whom or which I have heretofore been a subject or citizen; that I will support and defend the Constitution and laws of the United States of America against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I will bear arms on behalf of the United States when required by the law; that I will perform noncombatant service in the Armed Forces of the United States when required by the law; that I will perform work of national importance under civilian direction when required by the law; and that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; so help me God."

-------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
I personally dont care if the USA becomes majority Hispanic, through legal immigration and natural growth.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom