Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

I miss the days when all evil wasn't defended with a bland, glib, meaningless appeal to some truism.
 
And predating Christianity by several centuries. So to credit Christianity with creating the concept of equality and justice is not only very incorrect, it's laughably ironic given the church's millennia-long history of intolerance of other viewpoints.
I didn't say that Christianity invented these concepts.
 
I didn't say that Christianity invented these concepts.

Really? You didn't post the following?

The first self evidence "truth" in the declaration of independence - "that all men are created equal". That comes out of the equality of souls in Christianity. It is a secularised version of a particular strand of a religious tradition.

My mistake then.
 
I miss the days when all evil wasn't defended with a bland, glib, meaningless appeal to some truism.


And I miss the days when self-loathing whites didn't actively lobby for, and practically demand the dilution and eradication of their own race. All we can do is reminisce, I suppose. Time marches on.
 
Last edited:
One thing we can rely on: If a racist is angry enough, we can be sure he tells us what is really going on in his mind. Exhibit A:


And I miss the days when self-loathing whites didn't actively lobby for, and practically demand the dilution and eradication of their own race. All we can do is reminisce, I suppose. Time marches on.
 
One thing we can rely on: If a racist is angry enough, we can be sure he tells us what is really going on in his mind. Exhibit A:


It's a sign of the times when the concept of preserving or defending your own race is considered "racism". Oddly, this only seems to apply to whites, however. Hmmm. :con2:
 
Last edited:
And I miss the days when self-loathing whites didn't actively lobby for, and practically demand the dilution and eradication of their own race. All we can do is reminisce, I suppose. Time marches on.

Yes, it's definitely a real problem for white supremacists that not that many white people subscribe to their insane racial purity anxieties and are perfectly happy to comingle, genetically and socially, with non-whites.

I don't see how they can overcome this without authoritarian state power.
 
Being a white American Male myself, I must say I'm quite fond of many aspects of our culture. But the people who worry most about "replacement" seem to want to return us to a fictitiously sanitized version of the unjust, intolerant society we ourselves replaced. Laws and proposals for the censoring of libraries, the corruption of science, the reversal of enlightened attitudes on sexual practices and reproductive rights, the abolition of environmental protection, voter suppression, even interracial marriage, on and on....the rhetoric of violence and hatred and venom and outright racism gathered under the head of the "culture war:" that's not aimed at the immigrants. It's aimed at ourselves. Of course those hordes of fertile immigrants are a part of the problem, because they seek opportunity, freedom and democracy, and those are the very things our replacement fear-mongers are trying to crush.

The replacement theory is a struggle of the worst elements of a culture against its own evolution. If immigrants pose a threat to that, good. It can't come too soon.
 
It's a sign of the times when the concept of preserving or defending your own race is considered "racism". Oddly, this only seems to apply to whites, however. Hmmm. :con2:

The "white race" was never in danger
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove breach of rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Most of us don't give one single tiny crap if other people have the same melanin content as us.

"White" isn't part of my identity anymore than my blood type is.
 
It's a sign of the times when the concept of preserving or defending your own race is considered "racism".

Because, at the end of the day, it isn't really the race that anyone really wants to preserve or defend. Race, after all, is a pretty meaningless concept, a few trivial physical differences that convey no advantages or superiority to anyone. Instead, what people want to preserve is the privileged position their race bestows upon them in societies that historically have favored them. There's also an element that, disappointed with their lot in life but unwilling to accept their own responsibility for it, blame others for preventing them from achieving the success they feel they deserve.

The dynamic these days seems to be that the first group -- the historically privileged -- are afraid they're going to get knocked off their perch if the playing field ever gets leveled, so they pander to the second group -- those who haven't been able to make it in life -- by telling them it's all the fault of the other guys coming here and taking away what should rightfully be yours. Thus you have two groups that at face value have little in common -- the haves and the have nots -- allied against a common enemy based on race. Shake well and presto! you got things like "replacement theory." Bad enough on its own, but when the less tightly wrapped take it too seriously and start shooting up places, it becomes a lot less funny.
 
Most of us don't give one single tiny crap if other people have the same melanin content as us.

"White" isn't part of my identity anymore than my blood type is.


Interestingly, many blacks (and other non-whites)) feel differently. For example:

Most black adults say race is central to their identity and feel connected to a broader black community
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-ta...-feel-connected-to-a-broader-black-community/

Some would say this is because whites are being conditioned to not care about their race, or even to feel shame about it. I imagine this is touched on in "Replacement Theory".
 
Last edited:
It's a sign of the times when the concept of preserving or defending your own race is considered "racism". Oddly, this only seems to apply to whites, however. Hmmm. :con2:

The only race I am aware of is Homo Saipan, are we talking about Replacing them with Lizard People, You know GwB was going tobuild the Trans American Hwy so he could Replace all the Democratic Pro Choice voters with Latino Pro Life Voters right?
These conspiracy theories are as dumb as they are Old.
 
I would suppose if one's race has a history of segregation, bias, unfair treatment, housing discrimination, and if your parents have to tell you as a kid how to avoid being shot down by the cops for no reason, etc. etc. maybe it's no surprise that for you, race is more important than it is for those who need never think about it.

Of course in the newly bleached America some are promoting, it should be impermissible to talk about those things. How dare a minority think like a minority?

Getting back to the original question of what merits might lie in "replacement theory," I am thinking there is a pretty simple solution, and it is this. I propose that any theory or scheme or vision in which the question of interracial marriage is on the table as anything but an affront to humanity that should be avoided at all costs...that theory is automatically disqualified.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom