Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Seems "true" Replacement Theorists believe there is an attempt at white genocide, by means of non-white immigration, inter-racial marriages, low birth rate amongst white couples, etc. Obviously its silly.

But what if Replacement Theory is about politics rather than race?

What if there is a not so secret attempt to turn Red states purple and even Blue, by means of illegal immigration and eventual amnesty which provides citizenship and voting rights to tens of millions of illegals?

There is some basis for such a theory. There is some basis for thinking that one of the agendas of liberal attitudes towards illegal immigration on the southern border is to bring in lots of folks from communities that traditionally vote Blue and use them to help swing elections.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news...hispanic-votes-to-turn-texas-purple/81224392/

Majority of Hispanics vote Democrat. Everyone knows this. Not too crazy to see how amnesty and voting rights for 13 million illegals could definitely help turn some Red states purple, especially of the folks who gave them their amnesty and voting rights are Democrats.

Is this paranoid thinking? Democrats would never dare think of such a hush-hush strategy to win national elections? I dont think it is. I myself am a Democrat and could definitely see this as being a long-term goal of refusing to do hard core enforcement at the border. Obviously building a border barrier would make such a goal harder, which I believe is partially why there was such anger at the idea of Trump's wall. Although the Democrats did almost give Trump his wall, in exchange for DACA, which Trump refused.

Highlighting mine...

I seriously doubt that, given the nature of the threads you are starting...
 
Yes, what a cheap little debate trick. First we get a self serving story about the source of a phrase in the Declaration of Independence.

Then our poster digs up some unnotated polling results that suggest Muslims in the U.K. (not the U.S.) are so culturally out of step with mainstream U.K. culture that they can't obey U.K. law . . . .which doesn't include the Declaration of Independence.

-------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.


A good place to look at understanding British society and how attitudes have changed over very recent times (and if it's in my adult years it is still recent times you young whippersnappers!) : https://www.bsa.natcen.ac.uk/latest...-30/personal-relationships/homosexuality.aspx It's part of the British Social Attitudes survey that's been tracking social issues since 1983.

And of course it paints a picture that is much more complex than shuttit's simplistic proclamations.
 
I read a book by a guy called Walker Conner called Ethnonationalism: The Quest for Understanding. He's supposed to be the founder of nationalism studies. It's a while now, but my recollection is that he thinks for a nation to exist, you need some kind of shared national story, probably an origin story, that frames the people of the nation within the context of the nation. It's subjective, so it doesn't really matter what the actual ethnic origins of the people are, so long as they buy into their common identification as a nation and a people.

The US is a bit unique in that it genuinely is a nation of immigrants. What unites the US into a nation is the shared identification into this origin story of coming to the land of hope and opportunity and working their way up. You don't have to go back that far to find immigrants deliberately not passing on their native language to make sure their children were "American". What would destroy the US as a nation would be if large numbers of people stopped identifying with that origin story. What you then have is a whole bunch of different peoples from widely different cultures contending with each other.

He points out that most peoples never get a nation.

One of the big things in the book is the distinction between state, country and nation.

Highlighting mine...

Isn't it a nation of illegal immigrants? I don't believe you were invited in...
 
Let's pick an example. The first self evidence "truth" in the declaration of independence - "that all men are created equal". That comes out of the equality of souls in Christianity. It is a secularised version of a particular strand of a religious tradition. This self evidence truth has not been self evidence for most of the history of the west, and is certainly not self evident outside of that tradition.

Hilarious. Aside from ignoring the Greek philosophical traditions of Cynicism and Stoicism which most emphatically did accept the so-called "equality of souls". (Althought what the hell is a "soul".)

I should point out that this tradition of the "equality of souls", exists in both Judaism and Islam. Further the notion that some sort of equality exists among Humans also exists in the Confucian traditions of China and East Asia, to say nothing of Buddhism.

It is interesting to note that in Hinduism the notion of the "equality of souls", does not exist, after all that is the philosophical basis of the caste system. Despite that India has adopted fairly successfully Western style Democracy etc. So this idea of "equality of souls" doesn't seem to be essential to Western Style Democracy etc.

I should also point out that the doctrine of "equality of souls" and "all men are created equal" doesn't prevent the estblishment of systems of legal oppression and equality.

The Cynics and the Stoics despite their beliefs had no problem with slavery, serfdom or autocratic rule in general. They just thought of different justifications etc., for them.

Christianity, Islam and Judaism had no problems for centuries with slavery, serfdom etc., either. In fact in Chrstianity, Islam and Judaism th ideal form of government for century upon century was Autocratic Monarchy, which was felt to mirror the rule of God of the Universe, so of course was therefore ideal.

A basic principle in those three religions, believed by many, was what really counted was the life after death and your life here was not very important so in the grand scheme of things the fact you werer a slave or serf etc., didn't really matter, it was all unimportant compared to the life to come. Thus - Shut up and obey the powers that be. (Of course this idea was most definetly not confined to those three religions.)

Interestingly in Confucian China there was generally more social mobility than in Christian Europe, Islam for quite sometime, a lot of it due to the meritocrachy principles in Confucianism, which taught "Gentlemen" are educated into being "Gentlemen" not born that way. (The Chinese Examination system was also an outgrowth of this mentality.)

As for this:

One can certainly ask immigrants to agree to abide by the laws of the culture they are moving in to. Unless they adopt the cultural tradition that sits behind those laws and make them their own, they will in fact have a radically different conception of these things. That's how in the UK you can have only 18% of British muslims thinking homosexuality should be legal and 23% wanting Sharia law, 39% say wives should always obey their husbands. It is a different cultural tradition with different values.

Aside from pointing out that certain other groups within British society, (Evangelicals, Christian Fundamentalists), have similar ideas about female subordination, homosexuality etc., and the establishment of religious laws has laws of the state.

In the US it is even more extreme, in the sheer number of Christian Fundamentalists who want the establishment of what amounts to a Theocracy and the establishment of "Biblical Law", which has large similarities to notions of Sharia Law domination. (It also appears that in some US states a majority of Republicans support the banning of inter-racial marriage also along with something like "Biblical Law".) (I could also mention groups within the US like the Amish and Hutterrites.)

With that in perspective the "fact" that 23% of British Muslims want established Sharia Law and 39% want wives to always obey husbands doesn't worry me unduly. (It also means 77% of Brtish Muslims do not support the establishment of Sharia Law and 61% don't support the notion that wivesshould always obey their husbands.)

In 1950 just how many in Britain would have wanted Homosexuality legal? Less than half I would say, and what would their response have been to the other questions?

So in some respects modern British Muslims are two generations off.
 
I honestly believe that one of the goals of very loose immigration rules, and rules being poorly enforced, and rules being easily ignored, is to increase the Democrat voting base in many possible swing states. Texas is one. Florida may be another.

Its why they want to give statehood to Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. Its not a secret. It would likely mean 4 new Democrat Senators.

Now, dilute and further reduce the white majority? Naa. I see no reason to believe that. There's no reason to achieve such a thing. It makes no difference.
 
Would he? I am doubtful. If he did, he would have been wrong.

You honestly believe that the idea that all people are equal was invented by Christianity? And that those who don't agree with that contention are wrong?
 
Hilarious. Aside from ignoring the Greek philosophical traditions of Cynicism and Stoicism which most emphatically did accept the so-called "equality of souls". (Althought what the hell is a "soul".)
Yes, early Christian ideas came out of older Greek ones that come from Bachus cults.

I should point out that this tradition of the "equality of souls", exists in both Judaism and Islam. Further the notion that some sort of equality exists among Humans also exists in the Confucian traditions of China and East Asia, to say nothing of Buddhism.
And yet, you then have other ideas that men have their place in the great chain of being. You have ideas that some are chosen by God to be saved, and others are not. Did medieval european society believe that all men were equal in an Earthly sense, I do not think that they did. The earliest I can think of those examples breaking free from the equality of the soul, though I'm sure there are earlier examples, is in the aftermath of the English Civil War. I didn't say that ideas regarding equality were unique to this particular thread of Western thought. It is not a universal concept though.

It is interesting to note that in Hinduism the notion of the "equality of souls", does not exist, after all that is the philosophical basis of the caste system. Despite that India has adopted fairly successfully Western style Democracy etc. So this idea of "equality of souls" doesn't seem to be essential to Western Style Democracy etc.
Well, they were occupied by the British for quite a while. Does the average Indian believe "all men are created equal" in the American sense? It's quite a subversive doctrine. All societies are hierarchical to some degree and form an aristocratic class. The idea that we are all equal is a constant call to upend the hierarchy.

I should also point out that the doctrine of "equality of souls" and "all men are created equal" doesn't prevent the estblishment of systems of legal oppression and equality.
It is really helpful to have your system of government legitimised by the beliefs of the society. When they clash for any length of time, it is a sign that the ruling regime is on the way out.

The Cynics and the Stoics despite their beliefs had no problem with slavery, serfdom or autocratic rule in general. They just thought of different justifications etc., for them.
Sure, equality of souls is not the same as Earthly equality. Plus, Greek society would have collapsed had they tried for Earthy equality and indeed did collapse at about the time that these ideas arrived on the scene.

Christianity, Islam and Judaism had no problems for centuries with slavery, serfdom etc., either. In fact in Chrstianity, Islam and Judaism th ideal form of government for century upon century was Autocratic Monarchy, which was felt to mirror the rule of God of the Universe, so of course was therefore ideal.
Yes. Liberal truths are not self evident.


Aside from pointing out that certain other groups within British society, (Evangelicals, Christian Fundamentalists), have similar ideas about female subordination, homosexuality etc., and the establishment of religious laws has laws of the state.
Yes. And?

In the US it is even more extreme, in the sheer number of Christian Fundamentalists who want the establishment of what amounts to a Theocracy and the establishment of "Biblical Law", which has large similarities to notions of Sharia Law domination. (It also appears that in some US states a majority of Republicans support the banning of inter-racial marriage also along with something like "Biblical Law".) (I could also mention groups within the US like the Amish and Hutterrites.)
Maybe. I don't know what the point of showing me this is other than to reinforce the idea that different cultural traditions can persist for long periods of time and be deeply and profoundly incompatible. That is my point.

With that in perspective the "fact" that 23% of British Muslims want established Sharia Law and 39% want wives to always obey husbands doesn't worry me unduly. (It also means 77% of Brtish Muslims do not support the establishment of Sharia Law and 61% don't support the notion that wivesshould always obey their husbands.)
It doesn't really mean that. Most are ambivalent about it.

In 1950 just how many in Britain would have wanted Homosexuality legal? Less than half I would say, and what would their response have been to the other questions?
Oh, certainly... these kinds of liberalisations are typically done against public sentiment. Is there a single path that all cultures go down? Muslims in Britain will see our society and embrace it? Maybe. That doesn't seem to have happened with evangelicals in the US.

So in some respects modern British Muslims are two generations off.
Maybe. You seem to think that there is some inevitable direction that cultures move in. Yet evangelicals don't seem to have moved in that direction. Why would we think Muslims will move in that direction in a couple of generations when evangelicals haven't?
 
...Its why they want to give statehood to Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. Its not a secret. It would likely mean 4 new Democrat Senators.

Then can you explain the fact that former presidents Gerald Ford and George H.W. Bush both supported statehood for P.R., as well as the likes of Mitt Romney, Rick Scott, Marco Rubio, and Jeb Bush, all Republicans in good standing? And if it would be such a slam dunk for the Democrats, why hasn't it already happened, since it plays so well into their "agenda" and would pay off instantly (as opposed to waiting years while immigrants gain citizenship and start voting)?

As for the U.S.V.I., I was unaware that there was anything resembling a serious active initiative to grant them statehood, at least not within the past 30 years or so. Who, exactly, is pushing that idea these days?

(Kind of surprised you didn't mention D.C., although perhaps that would be harder to disguise as an "immigration" issue as opposed to plain ol' racism.)
 
I honestly believe that one of the goals of very loose immigration rules, and rules being poorly enforced, and rules being easily ignored, is to increase the Democrat voting base in many possible swing states. Texas is one. Florida may be another.

Its why they want to give statehood to Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. Its not a secret. It would likely mean 4 new Democrat Senators.

Now, dilute and further reduce the white majority? Naa. I see no reason to believe that. There's no reason to achieve such a thing. It makes no difference.

"If we let brown people vote we'll never win elections!"

Yeah, we know.
 
You honestly believe that the idea that all people are equal was invented by Christianity? And that those who don't agree with that contention are wrong?
The line of thought that runs through Paine comes from particular schools of thought and dogmas in Christianity. You see these ideas in radical protestants during the English Civil War period. There are then earlier forms of it going back further. Ideas of equality before the law and so on have a long tradition predating liberalism, the enlightenment and all the rest of it.
 
One of the biggest troll tactics in the last few years has acting like "fairness" isn't a concept that can exist outside of which side gets an advantage, leading to this kind of insane...

"Your side will win if the system if fair/not insane, my side will win if the system is unfair/insane, so ergo ipso facto you wanting a fair system is the exact same thing logically, morally, and legally as you just wanting your side to win."

... argument. That's why Republicans basically started arguing "If you don't let us suppress voters it's just an unfair advantage given to the Democrats" a while back.

If you can only win at chess by cheating at chess, demanding that you don't cheat at chess is not the same as not letting you win at chess, no matter how much spin you put on it.
 
Last edited:
"If we let brown people vote we'll never win elections!"

Yeah, we know.


Well, when a party goes out of the way to kiss the rears of a group and promise them the world...and then also happens to want to increase the size of that demographic...well, you know, there just might be a link.
 
Last edited:
Well, when a party goes out of the way to kiss the rears of a group and promise them the world...and then also happens to want to increase the size of that demographic...well, you know, there just might be a link.

If one makes extra vague claims and accusations it might just look like there is an actual point. :)
 
"Everyone is secretly just as horrible as me, they are just hiding it" must be a comforting fact for horrible people to believe.
 
"Everyone is secretly just as horrible as me, they are just hiding it" must be a comforting fact for horrible people to believe.

That is probably as comforting as the "My group is morally superior to those with opposing political views" line of thinking.
 
...Ideas of equality before the law and so on have a long tradition predating liberalism, the enlightenment and all the rest of it.

And predating Christianity by several centuries. So to credit Christianity with creating the concept of equality and justice is not only very incorrect, it's laughably ironic given the church's millennia-long history of intolerance of other viewpoints.
 
That is probably as comforting as the "My group is morally superior to those with opposing political views" line of thinking.

"Your group feels morally superior because they are not as hateful as my group and I don't like that!!!!!"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom