Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

It would only be hypocritical if you had some kind of universalist view where you didn't think citizens should be preferred to non-citizens. Is it hypocritical to care more for one's own children than other peoples? You only run into these problems if you have some universalist, rationalistic conception of your country where if it was OK for your ancestor to come, then there must be some "right" to do that and since rights are universal, the right must still exist.
I'm not sure your answer makes any sense. I of course care about U.S. citizens. But not to the exclusion of everyone else in the world (and part of your argument appears perilously close to the old "but think of the children!!" cliché). In any case, I hardly need to adopt a "universalist" view to recognize how hypocritical it would be for me to make immigration difficult for others, when I myself am a direct and relatively recent beneficiary of immigration.

That is generally not how it works. The conceptions of rights and your values are culturally specific to you and the culture you were brought up in. They are no more universal than the culture in Iran or China. The idea that you can be reasoned into a set of values is like imagining you can be reasoned into a religion... I'm sure it happens, but it is a rare event. Values aren't products of reason.
I don't agree. There are a core set of values and beliefs that are pretty much universal across cultures. Sure, there are plenty of differences. But there's enough common ground for people to interact successfully, irrespective of background. The USA after all is a nation of laws, and though they evolve and adapt to the times as required, they are meant to apply to everyone. Adhere to those laws and I don't care where you come from or what you look like, you're welcome to be my neighbor.
 
Last edited:
I personally dont care if the USA becomes majority Hispanic, through legal immigration and natural growth.

Bollocks.

ETA: I am, given that the threads you have recently started have been clear attempts to rehabilitate the fundamentally racist 'replacement theory', unconvinced that this is an honest statement of your beliefs.

I accept that I might be wrong.

ETA2: Do we really need two threads of this crap?

no, we don't.
 
Last edited:
It's much more like the latter. It's the claim that immigration is being used knowingly to turn the current majority into a minority whose ideas about what constitutes a just society will never again be allowed to be the dominant idea of the country. It's the replacement of one idea of the country by another through importing new citizens.


Suppose it was happening the other way and the immigrants were predominantly Ayn Rand and Pinochet fans and this was changing the country in a direction such that liberal politics would be in a permanent minority. Suppose further that this was being done by Trump. Would that be at all concerning?
Suppose pigs flew, wouldn't you regret not being allowed to own a bazooka?
 
So since the Chinese person and the Muslin from Iran probably can't/won't adopt American values they are in a sense cultural inferior to "us"?


I frequently hear complaints that immigrants these days don't assimilate into American culture "like they used to". I guess all those Chinatowns, Little Italys, Greektowns, and other ethnic communities in US cities are a completely new phenomenon.
 
Isn't it remarkable how frequently Protestants kids grow up Protestant, and Catholic kids grow up Catholic. Culture is the same. Irish, German and Dutch culture comes from the same cultural routes, at various distances of removal, that American culture originally came from.

Isn't it remarkable how many people have left the Churches, and how many more simply don't go anymore?
Atheism is at an all-time high, despite the fact hat most immigrants to the US come from deeply religious countries.

Cultural Change happens, and it's a fallacy to blame it on immigration, or assume that one could prevent it from happening.
 
It's weird that Evangelicals are worried about Replacement, given that the best thing that could possibly happen to them, according to their Beliefs, is to get Raptured, literally letting themselves get replaced on Earth by those less pious then them.
 
Isn't it remarkable how frequently Protestants kids grow up Protestant, and Catholic kids grow up Catholic. Culture is the same. Irish, German and Dutch culture comes from the same cultural routes, at various distances of removal, that American culture originally came from.

Isn't it remarkable how many people have left the Churches, and how many more simply don't go anymore?
Atheism is at an all-time high, despite the fact hat most immigrants to the US come from deeply religious countries.

Cultural Change happens, and it's a fallacy to blame it on immigration, or assume that one could prevent it from happening.

The replacement argument is about denying cultural change and rejecting the notion that cultures might share positive traits. The argument is that individuals and families are the slaves of their cultures.

I suspect the Protestants-grow-up-Protestant and Catholics-grow-up-Catholic line is a back handed way of inferring that immigrates to this country will spawn generations of decidedly un-assimilated families, thus destroying the fabric of the country.

The message is not that Christians will be Christians but that Muslims, latinos, blacks and Jews will, generations from now, be cancers on the American culture.

This canard ignores decades and decades of America's successful pluralistic society.

--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Isn't it remarkable how many people have left the Churches, and how many more simply don't go anymore?
Atheism is at an all-time high, despite the fact hat most immigrants to the US come from deeply religious countries.

Cultural Change happens, and it's a fallacy to blame it on immigration, or assume that one could prevent it from happening.

It’s also factually wrong to assume there is “a” culture that is shared by all the “native” population. Shutit is confusing “society” with “culture” (and vice-a-versa).
 
Isn't it remarkable how many people have left the Churches, and how many more simply don't go anymore?
Atheism is at an all-time high, despite the fact hat most immigrants to the US come from deeply religious countries.

Cultural Change happens, and it's a fallacy to blame it on immigration, or assume that one could prevent it from happening.

We were talking about whether people where reasoned in and out of their values. That is not what happens.
 
I'm not sure your answer makes any sense. I of course care about U.S. citizens. But not to the exclusion of everyone else in the world (and part of your argument appears perilously close to the old "but think of the children!!" cliché). In any case, I hardly need to adopt a "universalist" view to recognize how hypocritical it would be for me to make immigration difficult for others, when I myself am a direct and relatively recent beneficiary of immigration.
This is a universalist view. You see morality as being timeless and rationalistic and applying to all people and understood from the perspective of the individual. You think it's unfair that one system of rules for immigration existed 100 years ago that might have allowed somebody in, but now the descendents of people who came in want a different set of rules that would have kept out their ancestor. This is a very particular moral perspective coming out of a particular cultural tradition.

I don't agree. There are a core set of values and beliefs that are pretty much universal across cultures. Sure, there are plenty of differences. But there's enough common ground for people to interact successfully, irrespective of background. The USA after all is a nation of laws, and though they evolve and adapt to the times as required, they are meant to apply to everyone. Adhere to those laws and I don't care where you come from or what you look like, you're welcome to be my neighbor.
Let's pick an example. The first self evidence "truth" in the declaration of independence - "that all men are created equal". That comes out of the equality of souls in Christianity. It is a secularised version of a particular strand of a religious tradition. This self evidence truth has not been self evidence for most of the history of the west, and is certainly not self evident outside of that tradition.

One can certainly ask immigrants to agree to abide by the laws of the culture they are moving in to. Unless they adopt the cultural tradition that sits behind those laws and make them their own, they will in fact have a radically different conception of these things. That's how in the UK you can have only 18% of British muslims thinking homosexuality should be legal and 23% wanting Sharia law, 39% say wives should always obey their husbands. It is a different cultural tradition with different values.
 
This is a universalist view. You see morality as being timeless and rationalistic and applying to all people and understood from the perspective of the individual. You think it's unfair that one system of rules for immigration existed 100 years ago that might have allowed somebody in, but now the descendents of people who came in want a different set of rules that would have kept out their ancestor. This is a very particular moral perspective coming out of a particular cultural tradition.


Let's pick an example. The first self evidence "truth" in the declaration of independence - "that all men are created equal". That comes out of the equality of souls in Christianity. It is a secularised version of a particular strand of a religious tradition. This self evidence truth has not been self evidence for most of the history of the west, and is certainly not self evident outside of that tradition.

One can certainly ask immigrants to agree to abide by the laws of the culture they are moving in to. Unless they adopt the cultural tradition that sits behind those laws and make them their own, they will in fact have a radically different conception of these things. That's how in the UK you can have only 18% of British muslims thinking homosexuality should be legal and 23% wanting Sharia law, 39% say wives should always obey their husbands. It is a different cultural tradition with different values.

Racist does not understand the concept of "All are equal". More news at 11.
 
Let's pick an example. The first self evidence "truth" in the declaration of independence - "that all men are created equal". That comes out of the equality of souls in Christianity. It is a secularised version of a particular strand of a religious tradition. This self evidence truth has not been self evidence for most of the history of the west, and is certainly not self evident outside of that tradition.

One can certainly ask immigrants to agree to abide by the laws of the culture they are moving in to. Unless they adopt the cultural tradition that sits behind those laws and make them their own, they will in fact have a radically different conception of these things. That's how in the UK you can have only 18% of British muslims thinking homosexuality should be legal and 23% wanting Sharia law, 39% say wives should always obey their husbands. It is a different cultural tradition with different values.

Racist does not understand the concept of "All are equal". More news at 11.

Yes, what a cheap little debate trick. First we get a self serving story about the source of a phrase in the Declaration of Independence.

Then our poster digs up some unnotated polling results that suggest Muslims in the U.K. (not the U.S.) are so culturally out of step with mainstream U.K. culture that they can't obey U.K. law . . . .which doesn't include the Declaration of Independence.

-------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
The whole "White purity" thing, outside of just being horrible, isn't very practical if you step back and look at the numbers.

There's a graphic floating around the internet that shows a world map with a small circle that encircles only China, most of Indonesia, and India and points out that "More people live in this circle than outside it."

Even if you're a racist terrified of the world running out of white... I mean what do you plan on doing about it exactly? The numbers are what they are.
 
...snip..


Let's pick an example. The first self evidence "truth" in the declaration of independence - "that all men are created equal". That comes out of the equality of souls in Christianity. It is a secularised version of a particular strand of a religious tradition. ...snip....

A certain Mr T Paine would disagree with you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom