Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

At least for the past five years, Mexico has established nationwide seasonal flu vaccination campaigns targeted at "at risk" population groups, i.e. children 6 to 36 months old, senior citizens, and people with weakened immune systems. The most recent vaccination seasonal flu vaccination campaign ended this past February, and also included children ages 3 to 9, and adults with diabetes, renal failure and cardiovascular problems. The estimated number of vaccinations administered by the National Health System was 8.2 million; I do not have the numbers for those administered by private doctors.

Those are pretty good numbers, so in answer to Ivan's question which started all that, it would seem that 'flu vaccinations in Mexico are probably as high an any other nation.

Funnily enough, kids here are hardly ever given 'flu jabs, so you're probably a jump ahead of us.
 
As far as I understand it, the swine flu is in no danger of killing any more people than regular flu. Please, I really wish the media outlets would stop fear-mongering and show me some other news. I'm really tired of watching shots of mexican's with masks on. The swine flu is a harmless little virus that got out of hand IN ONE COUNTRY.
So 35,000 deaths a year in the US alone from regular flu doesn't mean much?

Unless this strain is LESS deadly than regular (seasonal flu) there will more deaths than usual for 2 reasons: it could infect a much larger portion of the population and there is no vaccine.

and less deaths for one reason: The availability of antiviral drugs to treat it.

It's much too early to predict the resulting number of deaths.

This doesn't mean there's evidence this pandemic will cause severe morbidity and mortality. But by the same token, assuming it won't based on such a pittance of data is foolish wishful thinking.

Can't we have a, "we don't know yet", without people interpreting that to mean scaremongering?
 
Still not confirmed.. yet. I wonder what will happen with my job. I'm a field tech., I visit a LOT of companies throughout the day..
I was out today working with 8 doctors who have been out on the front lines. The unconfirmed cases are highly probable. They are confirmed H1N1 and confirmed untypeable. There's not much doubt at this point.

Here's the latest for King County as of the end of the day, Thursday 04/30/09:
There are ten probable cases of swine flu in King County including*:

* a male child of Seattle who was hospitalized and is improving
* a male in his 20s from Seattle, not hospitalized and improving
* a woman in her 30s from Seattle, not hospitalized and improving
* April 29, 2009 news release for details on the above 3 cases: Probable swine flu (H1N1) in King County
* April 30, 2009 news release: New information leads to seven-day closure for Madrona K-8

*7 additional probable cases in King County as of 4/30/09, 3:30 pm. Public Health is investigating and will provide more information on this page as it becomes available.

There was a news conference this morning and there is a probable case in Snohomish county (just north of Seattle). It is a pediatrician whose family members are also all ill and who worked all day Monday and became ill that night.

I don't know the timing of her family's symptoms or where she was exposed.

Also, a notice to parents of students at Western WA U in Bellingham says there are a handful of possible cases among the students not yet officially announced. Could be they have flu but haven't yet been determined to be untypeable. The Whatcom County Public Health site says only one specimen was sent to the state lab for typing. It's possible the student health sends their specimens to the state lab without the county being timely informed.

That's what the Snohomish Public Health site suggests in their county update.
Snohomish County residents are two of the state’s probable cases of H1N1. “Probable” means that the laboratory results at state level are not yet confirmed by US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Currently the CDC is the only public health lab in the country that can positively identify this virus....

...The Everett Clinic announced today that one of their part-time staff, a physician, also is a probable case.
 
Last edited:
I was out today working with 8 doctors who have been out on the front lines. The unconfirmed cases are highly probable. They are confirmed H1N1 and confirmed untypeable. There's not much doubt at this point.

Here's the latest for King County as of the end of the day, Thursday 04/30/09:


There was a news conference this morning and one of the probable cases is a pediatrician whose family members are also all ill and who worked all day Monday and became ill that night.

I don't know the timing of her family's symptoms or where she was exposed.

Also, a notice to parents of students at Western WA U in Bellingham says there are a handful of probable cases among the students not yet officially announced. Could be they have flu but haven't yet been determined to be untypeable.

It'll be interesting, thats for sure. I've been watching the news for more information on King County, since that may affect my job. My company has pandemic plans, including 'Mandatory quarantine of affected areas'. Whatever that may mean.
 
Rather than start a new thread, I'll just ask in this one:

Here in Phoenix we had two schools each with one child being diagnosed with swine flu. The schools have been closed for a week. What's the reasoning and/or benefit?
 
The Grauniad has just updated their figures from the lastest WHO Update issued today - to 168, even though the WHO update clearly states,
"Mexico has reported 97 confirmed human cases of infection, including seven deaths. "

ETA: I've emailed the Grauniad pointing out their error and asking their source for 168 reported deaths due to Swine Flu
There's not an error, there is confusion in how to interpret what is meant by WHO confirmed case.
 
Latest info from Mexico:

260 confirmed cases, 12 confirmed fatalities (no new deaths, but a result of more cases being analyzed).
 
Rather than start a new thread, I'll just ask in this one:

Here in Phoenix we had two schools each with one child being diagnosed with swine flu. The schools have been closed for a week. What's the reasoning and/or benefit?
Reasoning is it can interrupt sustained transmission from student to student. You let all the current illness in any kids already infected run it's course without infecting another child who otherwise would have then infected another child and you never get a handle on it.

It only works when there are a few isolated cases. It's like putting out spot fires. No one knows how effective this tactic is since it hasn't been tried before.

If the conflagration gets going in the community, you may see an expansion to closing lots of places all at once like Mexico is trying to do.
 
No one is immunized for this strain of virus.

There is no vaccine yet.

It's new.....get it....read the details.
TA didn't say anything different. You have to reread his post. It was confusing but he meant: this time, no vaccine and the average stats we see for flu are with vaccine.
 
Last edited:
I doubt vaccinations are big in Mexico.....
I think that would be a false assumption.

Some of you guys really have the wrong picture of Mexico. While there is a lot of poverty and rural areas may differ from a first world country, Mexico is pretty much in between a first and third world country. There is a HUGE middle class in Mexico. They have pretty similar lives as any modern country.

Rather than a peasant class, think more blue collar middle class lifestyle and maybe a little less 'whole neighborhoods of Microsoft upper income yuppies'.
 
Last edited:
Reasoning is it can interrupt sustained transmission from student to student. You let all the current illness in any kids already infected run it's course without infecting another child who otherwise would have then infected another child and you never get a handle on it.

It only works when there are a few isolated cases. It's like putting out spot fires. No one knows how effective this tactic is since it hasn't been tried before.

If the conflagration gets going in the community, you may see an expansion to closing lots of places all at once like Mexico is trying to do.

Where do they think these kids are going to be for the next week? How many parents can stay home with their kids (I know at least one was an elementary school)? I'm betting aftercare programs are going to put on extra staff to hold these kids during the day. Some will go to work with the parents. Others will stay with extended family or friends. There will be lots of trips to the malls.

Seems to me like the disease is going to be spread around to even more locations. I'm no expert in the field - I'm just making an armchair guess.

On a side note my 18 month old got pretty sick this week (ear infection, croup). The pediatrician's office was swamped. Normally if I call, I get a live person and an appointment that same day. This time I was on hold for almost 10 minutes. I had to wait several hours to get a call back from the triage nurse. I got an appointment for the next day. Apparently there's a lot of swine flyu panic out there.
 
I'm sure someone could find the vaccine usage in Mexico. [edit: I see indeed empeake has provided some numbers] But in lieu of that here is a related source you can draw some conclusions from:

Sanofi-aventis invests €100 million in New facility in Mexico to produce seasonal and pandemic influenza vaccine
“By building this new facility, sanofi-aventis is proud to contribute to the strengthening of Mexico’s health infrastructure and is eager to support Mexico’s exemplary commitment to public health through influenza immunization and pandemic readiness”, said Chris Viehbacher. “This investment illustrates sanofi-aventis’ local approach to global health. This facility will benefit public health in Mexico and the Latin American region, in the context of influenza pandemic preparedness”.
It appears that the vaccines to be produced are intended for local consumption. This article was dated March 9 and the "pandemic" vaccine they are referring to is for the H5N1 bird flu. That it was only 2 months ago is sheer coincidence.

That is unless you are in to Big Pharma CTs. ;)
 
Last edited:
Where do they think these kids are going to be for the next week? How many parents can stay home with their kids (I know at least one was an elementary school)? I'm betting aftercare programs are going to put on extra staff to hold these kids during the day. Some will go to work with the parents. Others will stay with extended family or friends. There will be lots of trips to the malls.

Seems to me like the disease is going to be spread around to even more locations. I'm no expert in the field - I'm just making an armchair guess.

On a side note my 18 month old got pretty sick this week (ear infection, croup). The pediatrician's office was swamped. Normally if I call, I get a live person and an appointment that same day. This time I was on hold for almost 10 minutes. I had to wait several hours to get a call back from the triage nurse. I got an appointment for the next day. Apparently there's a lot of swine flyu panic out there.
I didn't say the school closures were a well thought out plan.

Sorry to hear about your baby.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by The Atheist
I doubt vaccinations are big in Mexico.....
I think that would be a false assumption.

Some of you guys really have the wrong picture of Mexico. While there is a lot of poverty and rural areas may differ from a first world country, Mexico is pretty much in between a first and third world country. There is a HUGE middle class in Mexico. They have pretty similar lives as any modern country.

Rather than a peasant class, think blue collar middle class lifestyle.

Pardon the intrusion, but The Atheist was referring specifically to flu immunizations in Mexico, in response to a previous post by Ivor The Engineer (#57). The posting perhaps was not very clear, since I also got the impression that it had to do with the overall health prevention scheme. This debate was cleared up in post #75, #78, #80, and #81.
 
There is strong evidence that this year's vaccine isn't protective, but I don't think anyone has reason to be certain that some previous flu infection (s?) aren't protective. We only very recently started paying attention to what all, precisely, was floating around.

I'm anxiously awaiting info on the close contact attack rate, though. From the news reports, it seems like sometimes the close contacts get sick, too, and sometimes they don't.

If virtually no one has any immunity to it, NY should have overflowing hospitals soon, right? Err...or should have last month, if most of these "new" cases are a reflection of what was going on weeks ago?
They will. Given the rapidity of spread, I give it about 3 weeks tops if the current pattern holds.

"Weeks ago?" The first US cases were only diagnosed ~the 24th. And the NY outbreak started on the 20th with the peak which drew attention to it on the 23rd.

You are seeing a logarithmic curve here. The first week or two the curve is more flat. But then it skyrockets. It's all a matter of numbers when you keep doubling something. In 10 days cases have gone from a couple isolated cases in three states to over 100 in a dozen states.

Maybe I should start a predictions thread and we can see what happens.
 
Last edited:
I saw something on the news tonight about how health officials in Mexico seem to be indicating that the swine flu appears to have plateaued there. Any comments?
 
I heard that in Egypt the government is using this H1N1 viral illness as an excuse to kill all the pigs in the country, even though they aren't confirming that any of the pigs there are spreading the disease to humans. This will hurt non-muslims who have pig farms.

http://story.canadastandard.com/index.php/ct/9/cid/e974f944f2e7496e/id/495641/cs/1/

Cheap shot.

And yeah, far more people are killed by the regular seasonal flu bug, so why all the fuss about this flu bug?

I want to rant about the usual stupid media tunnel vision, but the WHO and CDC are also making a big deal out of it.
 
Last edited:
That is unless you are in to Big Pharma CTs. ;)

Big Pharma is the runner-up in the conspiracy theory craze in Mexico (you should read the emails I have seen). #1, heads and shoulders above the rest, is that this is just a government plot to distract the population from the economic and unemployment problems, avert political protests, cover up other healthcare inadequacies, project an false image of unity, hide the fact that the Pentagon is taking over the Mexican armed forces, and help people forget about the recent embarrassing losses by the national soccer team, among other things. (OK, the last one is fake, but fits in well).

Then we have the Big Pharma theory, headed by Sanofi-Aventis and their evil plans to build the vaccine plant in Mexico (of course, no mention of the fact that it will take four years to finish it, and by then we will all be dead and the epidemic/pandemic will have passed). The "proof": Big Pharma has had "economic difficulties" in the past two years. Of course, they do not mention that the largest pharmaceutical companies had total net incomes in excess of 5 billion dollars each in 2008.

Third, the G-7/World Bank/IMF/Obama conspiracy, that claims that the epidemic is a sinister plot to reap profits and improve global economy. One textual quote from one of the emails: "If you can't create wars, you create illnesses (this will jump start the global economy)".
 
How are we supposed to get Tamiflu now? Because of the earlier "news blackout" people hoarded the stuff here. The sherrif's office had to escort the personal batches to the clinic here and they are only supposed to be for the doctor and nurses
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom