Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

There's also some speculation as to whether or not the H1N1 virus in the current vaccine offers some protection from the "new" H1N1.
That may be, but not much of that speculation is coming from the virologists. They're pretty much in agreement that there won't be any significant protection from either previous vaccination or previous infection.
 
I presume that the numbers dead in mexico that the guardian gives are suspected swine flu rather than confirmed. They split the number of cases up that way, but not number of deaths.
 
Is that actually the case for Mexico?

You seem to have two notions mixed up - I doubt vaccinations are big in Mexico.

In the developed world, they are, and we still get deaths annually. If five times more people get this than annual 'flu, you'd think probably five times as many deaths would occur.
 
That may be, but not much of that speculation is coming from the virologists. They're pretty much in agreement that there won't be any significant protection from either previous vaccination or previous infection.

There is strong evidence that this year's vaccine isn't protective, but I don't think anyone has reason to be certain that some previous flu infection (s?) aren't protective. We only very recently started paying attention to what all, precisely, was floating around.

I'm anxiously awaiting info on the close contact attack rate, though. From the news reports, it seems like sometimes the close contacts get sick, too, and sometimes they don't.

If virtually no one has any immunity to it, NY should have overflowing hospitals soon, right? Err...or should have last month, if most of these "new" cases are a reflection of what was going on weeks ago?
 
Intentionally or unintentionally, the media typically lacks perspective in reporting on catastrophes, diseases, etc. Regarding swine flu:

There is one confirmed US death (a boy with other "complications") so far.

Now, here is the daily average mortality by some selected causes in the US:

Car Accidents: 122
Other Accidents: 158
Homicide and firearm injury: 165

That's a small proportion of the 6,706 daily deaths (year 2002 figures) in the US. To provide some perspective, I chose the above causes because they are generally not related to aging and disease. So, if we add up all those figures and multiply by 365 we get 162,425 annual deaths out of a total of nearly two and a half million deaths per year.
We have a very long way to go for this swine flu to become a serious concern for most of us.
That is not to say that effective measures should not be taken by governments to prevent a pandemic. I am saying that the media coverage lacks perspective.
 
I'm anxiously awaiting info on the close contact attack rate, though.
Me too. And the incubation period. Once we know those, we'll know a lot more about what we're dealing with here. I suspect that so far, the basic reproductive number is not much above one; the average person is passing the virus on to one other person, and a few are passing it on to more than one. The case numbers keep rising, but they don't subtract the number who have recovered and are no longer contagious. What counts is: how many people are contagious right now. (Have I said that already? I think I have).

If virtually no one has any immunity to it, NY should have overflowing hospitals soon, right?
Not necessarily. Transmissibility is not a property that resides exclusively with either pathogen or host, but which emerges out of the interaction between them.
 
New update:

http://www.cdc.gov/media/transcripts/2009/t090430.htm

Today I'm reporting 149 confirmed cases in The United States. We have 11 affected states with confirmed cases. There are many more states that have suspect cases, and we'll be getting additional results over time. In New York, there are 50 cases. Texas, 26. California, 14. Again, I'd refer you to the CDC website where you'll be able to find all of this information. The new state is South Carolina, which has 10 confirmed cases. Two in Massachusetts, one in Kansas, one in Arizona, one in Nevada, one in Ohio. In the future, I think what I'll do is give you the overall number and refer you to the website. The age of cases is 16 years with a range of 22 months to 81 years. The most recent case onset that we have confirmed is April 26th. The majority of onset cases appear to be after April 18th. Six of the confirmed cases have been hospitalized, including the unfortunate case we reported yesterday of the child in Texas who passed away.

eta:
and another mmwr is on the way. Maybe it'll have info on the attack rate.

We continue to work with the World Health Organization, Pan American Health Organization, and we're working in part with the tri-national team in Mexico. Later this afternoon, we'll be publishing an article in the MMWR that is summarizing some of the data coming out of Mexico. That's being reviewed still by the various groups that are authors to that. Those include the World Health Organization, Pan American Health Organization, Mexico and the United States. So that will provide additional information on the situation in Canada.
 
Last edited:
Great news!

Currently there's a 96% chance* you will not end up in hospital and a better than 99.3% chance** you will not die from Swine flu even if you do contract it.

:)




*Based on 6 cases out of 149 being hospitalised in the US.

**Based on 1 (already sick) person out of 149 dying in the US.
 
I presume that the numbers dead in mexico that the guardian gives are suspected swine flu rather than confirmed. They split the number of cases up that way, but not number of deaths.
Nah - it was the first number quoted "by the Mexican government" in the media - and then just never corrected, even though follow up reports show that the number was reduced to 20 after initial laboratory tests.

The W.H.O. updates never gave a number of this magnitude. Started at zero on their first Update on 24 April.
 
The numbers are still too small.
We may need to wait a week or so to make sensible statistics.
 
You know, there really is a middle ground between running around in panic and saying there is no problem.
 
Great news!

Currently there's a 96% chance* you will not end up in hospital and a better than 99.3% chance** you will not die from Swine flu even if you do contract it.

:)




*Based on 6 cases out of 149 being hospitalised in the US.

**Based on 1 (already sick) person out of 149 dying in the US.

And you also have to figure that "a lot" (no idea what %) of people don't go to the doc for flu. So your current estimates are probably a worst case scenario estimate.
 
You seem to have two notions mixed up - I doubt vaccinations are big in Mexico.

Vaccinations are big in Mexico, perhaps more so than in the U.S. First of all, they are mandatory for all children under the age of 5, and you can't get a kid into any school (public or private) or government day-care center if their National Immunization Record does not show the vaccinations are up to date. There is no getting around this based on personal or religious beliefs, as far as I know.

Starting this year, all people that are members of the government and government-related health institutions, must also have a National Immunization Record, regardless of their age. There will be four types of new immunization records, based on the population group: teenagers, men and women of reproductive age, women only, and senior citizens (over 60 years old). These records will be mandatory to receive health benefits.

Also, each year there are several national immunization campaigns, and vaccines are provided free of charge to all who need them.
 
Last edited:
Influenza vaccinations rather than childhood ones.

At least for the past five years, Mexico has established nationwide seasonal flu vaccination campaigns targeted at "at risk" population groups, i.e. children 6 to 36 months old, senior citizens, and people with weakened immune systems. The most recent vaccination seasonal flu vaccination campaign ended this past February, and also included children ages 3 to 9, and adults with diabetes, renal failure and cardiovascular problems. The estimated number of vaccinations administered by the National Health System was 8.2 million; I do not have the numbers for those administered by private doctors.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom