Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

Professor Sir Liam Donaldson, the government's chief medical adviser, said: "Phase five indicates that WHO considers a global pandemic to be imminent, whereas at phase four a global pandemic is not inevitable. A change to phase five is a signal to countries' governments to ramp up their pandemic preparations – which we are already doing. We have been planning for a situation like this for some years. The preparations we have in place and are continuing to make will help to ensure we respond well in the event of a pandemic."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/apr/29/swine-flu-pandemic-threat-level-five
 
Hmm. The page is going completely doolally in my normal IE version. I just tried it in a different IE version I have access to on a thin client, and that is working fine. Dunno what the older version is playing at.

Rolfe.
 
And in our neck of the woods, the honeymoon couple have been sent home as they are better and no further positives have been reported. There is however one probable in Glasgow, relating to another newly-returned tourist I think.

Rolfe.
 
As far as I understand it, the swine flu is in no danger of killing any more people than regular flu. Please, I really wish the media outlets would stop fear-mongering and show me some other news. I'm really tired of watching shots of mexican's with masks on. The swine flu is a harmless little virus that got out of hand IN ONE COUNTRY.
 
As far as I understand it, the swine flu is in no danger of killing any more people than regular flu.
What you don't seem to understand is "yet"........

Regular flu rarely kills young people in their prime - this one has.
This is related to the 1918 virus and that also killed people in their 20s very quickly....within 24-36 hours.
The first wave of the 1918 virus was mild....
Then came the the second wave........

That's the concern........if somewhere in SE Asia this mild virus which spreads easily and quickly combines with H5 which kills 60% of its victims despite best medical treatment available....then we have problem.
H5 does not transmit between human easily if at all.

The current H1 could mutate to kill as the 1918 virus did - or it could combine with H5....there is no way of knowing until it runs its course.
If it dies out without hitting pandemic - the chances of mutation or combination with another strain is lessened so each country trying to contain is worthwhile.

If you DON'T think taking precautions against a potential of some 60 million deaths worldwide...I'd re-examine your risk assessment memes.....:garfield:

This is how it works....the worry is that pigs are excellent recombinant factories....and there a lot of pigs and they hang around with birds and humans.

http://www.andhranews.net/Technology/2009/April/30-Avian-study-3413.asp
 
Last edited:
The WHO is saying that there have only been 7 swine flu deaths worldwide that it recognizes, not 150.

Very interesting development (as long as it is not another writer goofing up).
 
As far as I understand it, the swine flu is in no danger of killing any more people than regular flu. Please, I really wish the media outlets would stop fear-mongering and show me some other news. I'm really tired of watching shots of mexican's with masks on. The swine flu is a harmless little virus that got out of hand IN ONE COUNTRY.

What you seem to be missing is that even if it's no worse than annual 'flu, it will still kill a hell of a lot more people than usual, because a lot more people will get it. Current figures are deaths with a population where the vulnerable are largely immunised - regarding OECD countries - and with no immunological protection, lots of those people will die.

Hardly a "harmless" virus.
 
The WHO is saying that there have only been 7 swine flu deaths worldwide that it recognizes, not 150.

Very interesting development (as long as it is not another writer goofing up).
The Grauniad has just updated their figures from the lastest WHO Update issued today - to 168, even though the WHO update clearly states,
"Mexico has reported 97 confirmed human cases of infection, including seven deaths. "

ETA: I've emailed the Grauniad pointing out their error and asking their source for 168 reported deaths due to Swine Flu
 
Last edited:
What you seem to be missing is that even if it's no worse than annual 'flu, it will still kill a hell of a lot more people than usual, because a lot more people will get it. Current figures are deaths with a population where the vulnerable are largely immunised - regarding OECD countries - and with no immunological protection, lots of those people will die.

Hardly a "harmless" virus.

Is that actually the case for Mexico?
 
Is that actually the case for Mexico?
I don't know how flu vaccine uptake in Mexico compares to that in the U.S. I'd guess that it's not as good, but I don't feel like chasing that down at the moment. But keep in mind that the vax isn't the only way to aquire immunity. Getting the flu will do the trick just as well (maybe even better -- if you survive it -- because there is more to wild virus than what is in the vaccine). Lower vaccine uptake would (presumably) mean that more people are likely to have immunity from previous infection. If it is true that the CFR is higher in Mexico (and the sample size is not nearly large enough to make that determination), it might be hard to explain it simply in terms of immunological history. Statistical artifact looks like the best bet at this point, though I still say that population density, air quality, and altitude in Mexico City may play a role.
 
Yes, I realise that. There's also some speculation as to whether or not the H1N1 virus in the current vaccine offers some protection from the "new" H1N1.

All in all, lots of speculation, not many facts.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom