Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

Pardon the intrusion, but The Atheist was referring specifically to flu immunizations in Mexico, in response to a previous post by Ivor The Engineer (#57). The posting perhaps was not very clear, since I also got the impression that it had to do with the overall health prevention scheme. This debate was cleared up in post #75, #78, #80, and #81.
Did you miss my edit in post 93? "[edit: I see indeed empeake has provided some numbers] "
 
How are we supposed to get Tamiflu now? Because of the earlier "news blackout" people hoarded the stuff here. The sherrif's office had to escort the personal batches to the clinic here and they are only supposed to be for the doctor and nurses
Really? That sucks. There seems to be issues with Tamiflu here as well.
 
Big Pharma is the runner-up in the conspiracy theory craze in Mexico (you should read the emails I have seen). #1, heads and shoulders above the rest, is that this is just a government plot to distract the population from the economic and unemployment problems, avert political protests, cover up other healthcare inadequacies, project an false image of unity, hide the fact that the Pentagon is taking over the Mexican armed forces, and help people forget about the recent embarrassing losses by the national soccer team, among other things. (OK, the last one is fake, but fits in well).

Then we have the Big Pharma theory, headed by Sanofi-Aventis and their evil plans to build the vaccine plant in Mexico (of course, no mention of the fact that it will take four years to finish it, and by then we will all be dead and the epidemic/pandemic will have passed). The "proof": Big Pharma has had "economic difficulties" in the past two years. Of course, they do not mention that the largest pharmaceutical companies had total net incomes in excess of 5 billion dollars each in 2008.

Third, the G-7/World Bank/IMF/Obama conspiracy, that claims that the epidemic is a sinister plot to reap profits and improve global economy. One textual quote from one of the emails: "If you can't create wars, you create illnesses (this will jump start the global economy)".

Swine flu source spawns wild theories
Dead pigs in China, evil factory farms in Mexico and an Al Qaeda plot involving Mexican drug cartels are a few wild theories seeking to explain a deadly swine flu outbreak....

...And in Mexico reports in at least two newspapers focused on a factory farm run by a subsidiary of global food giant Smithfield Foods. Some of the rumors mentioned noxious fumes from pig manure and flies -- neither a known vector for flu viruses.
But the medical community is tiptoeing around the pig farm issue in a less than objective way in print anyway.

The virus has now been clearly established to be a reassorted swine influenza with components that have all been circulating in pigs since the 90s. Pig farms mean crowded pigs, a clear hazard for a reassortment event. The flies and fumes could be a red herring, but the outbreak began near a large pig farm where locals obviously work.

Yet a number of reliable sources are really playing down the connection since supposedly according to the corporate owners, none of the pigs have been ill. That may or may not be true. Why would any scientist take a person's word for it that has a reason not to want his farm to be the source of the virus? And the government claims they did testing and found nothing. The Mexican government is well known to be subject to the influence of a bribe.

It walks like a pig and talks like a pig.

I can understand the position given the nonsense of Egypt slaughtering pigs and people being afraid to eat pork. But it is still annoying to see evidence ignored for political reasons.
 
Last edited:
Why wouldn't it be? We aren't talking Bangladesh here. :rolleyes:

No we're not, we're talking about Mexico, a country which I know little about and so was asking for confirmation that influenza vaccine uptake was as high as TA was assuming it to be. Empeake has provided lots of information without feeling the need to add put-downs in his/her post.
 
They will. Given the rapidity of spread, I give it about 3 weeks tops if the current pattern holds.

"Weeks ago?" The first US cases were only diagnosed ~the 24th. And the NY outbreak started on the 20th with the peak which drew attention to it on the 23rd.

You are seeing a logarithmic curve here. The first week or two the curve is more flat. But then it skyrockets. It's all a matter of numbers when you keep doubling something. In 10 days cases have gone from a couple isolated cases in three states to over 100 in a dozen states.

Maybe I should start a predictions thread and we can see what happens.

That should be exponential curve.:)
 
You are seeing a logarithmic curve here. The first week or two the curve is more flat. But then it skyrockets. It's all a matter of numbers when you keep doubling something. In 10 days cases have gone from a couple isolated cases in three states to over 100 in a dozen states..

exponential growth may well prove a poor model here, given that it is late spring in the northern hemisphere. didn't the 1917 event have multiple maxima, smaller blip early in the year, larger blip in the fall which was much more deadly for europe? (i am asking here: i do not have a citation handy)


Maybe I should start a predictions thread and we can see what happens.

great idea.

Even odds global "new cases per week" will be far from exponential over the next months, and if it so then 2:1 it will have multiple maxima.
 
Not enough to be scared.....certainly enough to be concerned and do a little prep and thinking.
I agree. I have to say, it's starting to look more and more like this thing is going to fizzle with the onset of summer (in the Northern Hemisphere anyway) -- that is, unless the virus suddenly becomes more aggressive. I'm betting that the basic reproductive number is not much above 1. If that's true, not only will it not go exponential, it'll do good to hold its own against the measures that are being implemented to limit its spread. Here's an analogy: Drop a single drop of ink into a gallon of water. It will spread, and molecules of ink will eventually make their way to every area of the vessel -- but the amount of ink will remain the same. If this thing is not infecting new hosts faster than the already-infected hosts are recovering, then the total number of virions is not increasing.

I'm holding off on getting scared until fall. For now.
 
Did you miss my edit in post 93? "[edit: I see indeed empeake has provided some numbers] "

It seems that I was typing my post at the time you made the edit. I did not notice it until about half an hour later, when I checked the forum again. I definitely would not have made the post had I seen it.
 
So 35,000 deaths a year in the US alone from regular flu doesn't mean much?

Death by flu and pneumonia is consistently in the top ten along with heart disease, cancer, stroke, accidents, diabetes, and alzheimer's. Somehow, though, they don't start off every newscast with fifteen minutes of people dying in hospitals of such things.

The swine flu may be a novel form of flu, but it requires no more concern or attention than regular flu.
 
The swine flu may be a novel form of flu, but it requires no more concern or attention than regular flu.
The point you're missing is this: Seasonal flu affects roughly 5 to 15 percent of the population, causing roughly 36,000 deaths. Pandemic influenza may affect 25 percent of the population or more, so you'd potentially be looking at five times the number of deaths or more, even if the case fatality rate were the same as with seasonal flu.
 
I agree. I have to say, it's starting to look more and more like this thing is going to fizzle with the onset of summer (in the Northern Hemisphere anyway) -- that is, unless the virus suddenly becomes more aggressive. I'm betting that the basic reproductive number is not much above 1. If that's true, not only will it not go exponential, it'll do good to hold its own against the measures that are being implemented to limit its spread. Here's an analogy: Drop a single drop of ink into a gallon of water. It will spread, and molecules of ink will eventually make their way to every area of the vessel -- but the amount of ink will remain the same. If this thing is not infecting new hosts faster than the already-infected hosts are recovering, then the total number of virions is not increasing.

I'm holding off on getting scared until fall. For now.

I'm not freaking out presently, but only because there's no evidence this is worse than regular flu.

Have you read the new MMWR report about the NY school outbreak?

http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm58d0430a1.htm

On April 23, DOHMH was notified of approximately 100 cases of mild (uncomplicated) respiratory illness among students at an NYC school (high school A) with 2,686 students and 228 staff members. During April 23--24, a total of 222 students visited the school nursing office and left school because of illness. Given initial reports on April 24 of what was later determined to be a large S-OIV outbreak in Mexico, DOHMH decided to rapidly mobilize staff members to go to high school A to collect nasopharyngeal swabs from any symptomatic students.

On April 26, seven of the nine specimens collected on April 24 by DOHMH were identified by CDC as S-OIV.

Illness onset dates ranged from April 20 to April 24; 10 (23%) of the patients had illness onset on April 22, and 28 (64%) had illness onset on April 23


On April 26, DOHMH launched enhanced surveillance for self-reported ILI among all students, staff members, and family members of persons at high school A via an online survey. Students and staff members were recruited via e-mail messages with a link to the survey, followed by daily reminder e-mails. Active surveillance at the school was impractical because a decision was made by DOHMH and the school principal not to reopen the school for the start of the new school week, April 27. Complete data from this ongoing survey are not yet available, but preliminary results indicate widespread influenza-like symptoms, with hundreds of students and many staff members reporting symptoms that met the case definition for ILI.

I just don't see a basic reproductive number of one creating hundreds of infections within a few days like that. This is more like regular flu school outbreaks.
 
Death by flu and pneumonia is consistently in the top ten along with heart disease, cancer, stroke, accidents, diabetes, and alzheimer's. Somehow, though, they don't start off every newscast with fifteen minutes of people dying in hospitals of such things.

The swine flu may be a novel form of flu, but it requires no more concern or attention than regular flu.

How is it possible you can't see the difference?

If normal 'flu years put hospitals under strain - as they do, year in, year out - how will having 5 - 10 times more people needing hospital treatment not be a disaster, because that is exactly what will happen if the disease is left to run unchecked.

No immunity = vastly more people get it than usual.
 
It seems that I was typing my post at the time you made the edit. I did not notice it until about half an hour later, when I checked the forum again. I definitely would not have made the post had I seen it.
Gosh, no worries. I typed my post before I saw yours.
 
...
The swine flu may be a novel form of flu, but it requires no more concern or attention than regular flu.
Which should get way more attention than it does.

The difference is with 'regular' flu, there is a pre-season vaccine and some herd immunity that slows its spread. The health care system and stockpiles of flu meds and face masks are also at less risk of shortages during 'regular' flu season.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom