Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

odd, I have read them, which is how I know that they all relate to studies that support what you were saying. We're not talking about some quack doctors here (pun intended) but :-...
You read the news account or the study? Think science news is any more reliable than current event news?

2nd link from a study by the University of Colorado Denver (UC Denver) School of Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) and Children's Hospital Boston....
For example, I looked at this study previously: http://www.medindia.net/news/Vitamin-D-Boosts-Immunity-Prevents-Colds-Flu-Study-47873-1.htm
the association between vitamin D and respiratory infections, people with the lowest blood vitamin D levels reported having significantly more recent colds or cases of the flu
. The risks were even higher for those with chronic respiratory disorders, such as asthma
and emphysema. The report appears in the February 23 Archives of Internal Medicine.
Here's the actual report: Association Between Serum 25-Hydroxyvitamin D Level and Upper Respiratory Tract Infection in the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey
Results The median serum 25(OH)D level was 29 ng/mL (to convert to nanomoles per liter, multiply by 2.496) (interquartile range, 21-37 ng/mL), and 19% (95% confidence interval [CI], 18%-20%) of participants reported a recent URTI. Recent URTI was reported by 24% of participants with 25(OH)D levels less than 10 ng/mL, by 20% with levels of 10 to less than 30 ng/mL, and by 17% with levels of 30 ng/mL or more (P < .001). Even after adjusting for demographic and clinical characteristics, lower 25(OH)D levels were independently associated with recent URTI (compared with 25[OH]D levels of ≥30 ng/mL: odds ratio [OR], 1.36; 95% CI, 1.01-1.84 for <10 ng/mL and 1.24; 1.07-1.43 for 10 to <30 ng/mL). The association between 25(OH)D level and URTI seemed to be stronger in individuals with asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (OR, 5.67 and 2.26, respectively).
Low serum 25(OH)D is associated with many conditions including depression which is also associated with increased risk for infection. This study only supports the hypothesis in question but doesn't test it. In fact, if I recall, it was cited in the paper as support for the hypothesis about seasonal flu and vitamin D.

But again, no one is questioning the hypothesis deserves to be tested. I'm only saying that an untested hypothesis should not be cited as if it were tested.
 
Last edited:
What exactly is my position on this? Have I stated it so far?
Was I posting the link in response to something you said ?
no
Sorry, google dumping is not "helping anyone", it is an attempt to look smart when you don't really have anything to offer.
Really, then what is ignoring evidence given freely ?
an attempt to look dumb ?
Yes. I'm actually going to take my time and read through a few papers before jumping to a conclusion based solely on someone google dumping some papers on me.
don't believe a word of it, you allready jumped to the conclusion that the google links had nothing to offer before you read any,
thats not taking your time, its just being willfully ignorant

still please carry on, I can see that a genius like you doesn't need anyones help or evidence, but please do let me know when you get to the clinical trials stage all on your own won't you
:rolleyes:

on another note I'm prompted to ask you if you have any experience of swine flu at all outside what you've read in the tabloids
 
Last edited:
You read the news account or the study? Think science news is any more reliable than current event news?

For example, I looked at this study previously: http://www.medindia.net/news/Vitamin-D-Boosts-Immunity-Prevents-Colds-Flu-Study-47873-1.htmHere's the actual report: Association Between Serum 25-Hydroxyvitamin D Level and Upper Respiratory Tract Infection in the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination SurveyLow serum 25(OH)D is associated with many conditions including depression which is also associated with increased risk for infection. This study only supports the hypothesis in question but doesn't test it. In fact, if I recall, it was cited in the paper as support for the hypothesis about seasonal flu and vitamin D.

But again, no one is questioning the hypothesis deserves to be tested. I'm only saying that an untested hypothesis should not be cited as if it were tested.

interesting that you would post that part but totally ignore the conclusion
Conclusions Serum 25(OH)D levels are inversely associated with recent URTI. This association may be stronger in those with respiratory tract diseases. Randomized controlled trials are warranted to explore the effects of vitamin D supplementation on RTI.

please look up some of the longer words in a dictionary if they are giving you trouble.
:p

Vitamin D is essential for good health in humans, are you ignoring that or ignorant of it, or are you having trouble working out the connection between health and immunity ?

heres another completely random google dump that won't help you at all
http://www.google.co.uk/search?sour...8&rlz=1T4GGLL_en-GBGB316GB316&q=Serum+25(OH)D
:rolleyes:
 
The H1N1 pandemic which hit Mexico first is evidence against the vitamin D/sunlight hypothesis.
Well, not so fast. First of all, my response to Kelly's question was intended to acknowledge that vitamin D does not represent the sum total of all the possible physiological effects sunlight might have on a human, so I wouldn't be so quick to slash them together like that. For example, some of the investigation into the seasonality of seasonal flu has focused on photoperiod -- which does not depend on direct exposure to sunlight in order to exert an influence. (Hold the counterexamples; I've already noted that all of the hypotheses have their flaws).

But, whether it's vitamin D or photoperiod or something else, if something related to sunlight is the critical factor then this strain didn't really start breaking the rules until several months after it began (in early April at least, and probably quite a number of weeks before that).

Not only that, but we are dealing with a pandemic strain here, a distinction implicit in the use of the term "seasonal influenza" to differentiate the two. Just as interesting a puzzle as: "why is seasonal flu seasonal in nature?" is its counterpart: "why is pandemic influenza NOT seasonal in nature?" Surely no satisfactory explanation for seasonality will ever be achieved if we're obligated to toss the whole thing out the first time a pandemic strain comes along and refuses to conform.
 
Really, then what is ignoring evidence given freely ?
an attempt to look dumb ?
Please stop projecting your nonsense onto others. I have not ignored "evidence", I have ignored your link dump.
don't believe a word of it, you allready jumped to the conclusion that the google links had nothing to offer before you read any,
thats not taking your time, its just being willfully ignorant
As I said, stop projecting your nonsense onto others. I'm not you. Unlike you, Mr Google, I am actually doing an actual literature search and not just vomiting links.

I don't jump to conclusions based on someone's vomiting of links. Reading through a few of your primary links shows them to be animal studies, news reports or from woo-sites. I will read and conclude things at my own time and not have someone with a preconceived conclusion force them onto me.

I apologize but analyzing papers is does take actual work.
still please carry on, I can see that a genius like you doesn't need anyones help or evidence, but please do let me know when you get to the clinical trials stage all on your own won't you
Your derision of Clinical Trials as conclusive evidence is your problem. Like I said, I care about quality of studies.
on another note I'm prompted to ask you if you have any experience of swine flu at all outside what you've read in the tabloids
Yes.

Sorry bucko but I haven't made any conclusion on Vit D and the Immune system as of yet so I'm not playing your pathetic game.
 
I do, the fact that you are searching for one particular study which proves that vitamin d is beneficial to the immune system when there have been hundreds of studies that proved that going back decades is all the proof I need that
1) you don't know what youre discussing
2) you think you do know what youre discussing
3) noone will be able to prove anything to you that you haven't proved yourself

this is why I said earlier to let me know when you get to the clinical trials stage all on your own, I posted links to some very well regarded medical institutions and journals reporting on studies by august bodies such as those and you called it "animal studies, news reports or from woo-sites."
clearly the only woo round here is masquerading as your intellect, I'm guessing you've never studied medicine at any level but like to think you'd have been a famous surgeon if you had, listen up, you aren't so please attempt to stop acting like one.

The actual idea that you are discussing vitamin d and sunlight in a thread about swine flu as if it is somehow relevant is so ludicrous and bizzare anyway that I worry about your sanity.

:p
 
I do, the fact that you are searching for one particular study which proves that vitamin d is beneficial to the immune system when there have been hundreds of studies that proved that going back decades is all the proof I need that
1) you don't know what youre discussing
2) you think you do know what youre discussing
3) noone will be able to prove anything to you that you haven't proved yourself
You COULD have actually posted a few of those studies but then instead of "educating" others you decide to play smart-ass. Hey, whatever strokes your ego.
this is why I said earlier to let me know when you get to the clinical trials stage all on your own,
Sorry, not my field of study or interest. I'll let my colleagues at Stanford do the research.
I posted links to some very well regarded medical institutions and journals reporting on studies by august bodies such as those and you called it "animal studies, news reports or from woo-sites."
clearly the only woo round here is masquerading as your intellect,
The irony. Sorry, bucko I'm not the one making grandiose claims and pretending to be an expert.
I'm guessing you've never studied medicine at any level but like to think you'd have been a famous surgeon if you had, listen up, you aren't so please attempt to stop acting like one.
I'll let the other posters who know who I am and what I do, laugh at you for a bit. :cool:
The actual idea that you are discussing vitamin d and sunlight in a thread about swine flu as if it is somehow relevant is so ludicrous and bizzare anyway that I worry about your sanity.
You must have missed the topic where Seasonal Flu may be linked to Vitamin D and the review that I posted that Vit D may be effective in the treatment of Influenza.
 
I apologize up front for thinking again, but here it comes:

In the latest vax thread, we saw charts showing how the death rates from many infectious disease dropped incredibly in the 40s and 50s. The cause was probably better treatments, including antibiotics. AAand, all of these huge scary predicted pandemics are always compared to the Swine Flu that predates the mentioned improvements in care.

In the mean time we have had better care for the sick, better sanitation in our societies, better antibiotics, improved diets...

Or maybe WWII exposed everybody everywhere to enough germs to give the whole world total immunity? And the state of modern travel is our booster shots.

I guess I am thinking those huge pan/epi-demics are a thing of the past. The Swine Flu, Bubonic Plague... was then, this is now.

Is there a "cultural anthropo-immuno-ologist" in the house?
 
I apologize up front for thinking again, but here it comes:

In the latest vax thread, we saw charts showing how the death rates from many infectious disease dropped incredibly in the 40s and 50s. The cause was probably better treatments, including antibiotics. AAand, all of these huge scary predicted pandemics are always compared to the Swine Flu that predates the mentioned improvements in care.

In the mean time we have had better care for the sick, better sanitation in our societies, better antibiotics, improved diets...

Or maybe WWII exposed everybody everywhere to enough germs to give the whole world total immunity? And the state of modern travel is our booster shots.

I guess I am thinking those huge pan/epi-demics are a thing of the past. The Swine Flu, Bubonic Plague... was then, this is now.

Is there a "cultural anthropo-immuno-ologist" in the house?
Part of the issue you're going to run into is quick lack of resources.

In a mass epidemic, we may have the knowledge and tech but do you have enough doctors, nurses, respiratory techs, tamiflu, antibiotics and even ventilators available? One of the primary problems that occurs with influenza is respiratory failure from pneumonias. My hospital is one of the biggest in the area and we have 30 ventilators available. At any one time half are being used. Imagine if we need to intubate hundreds of patients. We don't have the space, staff or machines to do so.

As much as the the US government has stockpiled tamiflu and even ventilators, there is going to be a breaking point.

BTW: US hospitals run at about 90% to 110% capacity. There is no surge capacity.
 
Last edited:
interesting that you would post that part but totally ignore the conclusion
Marduk, you don't seem to get what I said. I didn't ignore the conclusion at all. The conclusion in the study is that a relationship exists. But they did not show that there was causation. For that, we need further research.

please look up some of the longer words in a dictionary if they are giving you trouble.
:p
You seem to be the one here having trouble. Maybe this will help: Distinguishing association from causation

Vitamin D is essential for good health in humans, are you ignoring that or ignorant of it, or are you having trouble working out the connection between health and immunity ?
Answer: none of the above.

heres another completely random google dump that won't help you at all
http://www.google.co.uk/search?sour...8&rlz=1T4GGLL_en-GBGB316GB316&q=Serum+25(OH)D
:rolleyes:
Is there a point here?
 
BTW: US hospitals run at about 90% to 110% capacity. There is no surge capacity.

Which seems to be adequate for the current swine flu pandemic, and the AIDS epidemic, and the SARS epidemic, and Ebola, and Bird flu, and MRSA and....

All of which were supposed to decimate the world, ruin our culture, kill children THINK OF THE CHILDREN!

Anyhow, something has changed. My guess is that world travel is a mixed bag. Along with exposure to more diseases came immunity to more diseases.
Greater herd immunity.


ETA: how could I forget flesh eating bacteria.
 
Which seems to be adequate for the current swine flu pandemic, and the AIDS epidemic, and the SARS epidemic, and Ebola, and Bird flu, and MRSA and....
Uh, you do realize that a system working at overcapacity is a recipe for disaster don't you?

The surge after the Swine Flu panic led to multiple steps taken to compensate for the surge in patient volume. There was no sudden increase in critically ill patients. If it did, badness would have ensued.

AIDs was a slower epidemic and HAS overwhelmed medical care in Africa.
SARS did overwhelm healthcare in Asia. Many medical personnel died. How Singapore handled such an epidemic is a case study on how such an epidemic system is handled. They deployed their army to help and enforced strict quarantines.
MRSA is widespread and is leading to signficantly more infections in the community.

I could go on but "it's enough" is not a very appropriate mindset for something you don't want to play catch up with.
All of which were supposed to decimate the world, ruin our culture, kill children THINK OF THE CHILDREN!
Do you see the CDC, WHO or medical personnel saying this? What are these organizations actually saying?
Anyhow, something has changed. My guess is that world travel is a mixed bag. Along with exposure to more diseases came immunity to more diseases.
Greater herd immunity.
Uh, herd immunity requires widspread immunity from either endemic illness or vaccinations so...no.
ETA: how could I forget flesh eating bacteria.
What about it? I treated someone just died from it last month.
 
Well, not so fast. First of all, my response to Kelly's question was intended to acknowledge that vitamin D does not represent the sum total of all the possible physiological effects sunlight might have on a human, so I wouldn't be so quick to slash them together like that. For example, some of the investigation into the seasonality of seasonal flu has focused on photoperiod -- which does not depend on direct exposure to sunlight in order to exert an influence. (Hold the counterexamples; I've already noted that all of the hypotheses have their flaws).

But, whether it's vitamin D or photoperiod or something else, if something related to sunlight is the critical factor then this strain didn't really start breaking the rules until several months after it began (in early April at least, and probably quite a number of weeks before that).
You've lost me here. Mexico does not lack sunlight in the winter. So lack of sunlight is not likely to be the sole explanation for flu's seasonality. If it was, then we should see very little influenza in the tropics. In reality, there is a school of thought that influenza strains emerge from tropical regions before moving to temperate climates.

The Global Circulation of Seasonal Influenza A (H3N2) Viruses
Antigenic and genetic analysis of the hemagglutinin of ~13,000 human influenza A (H3N2) viruses from six continents during 2002–2007 revealed that there was continuous circulation in east and Southeast Asia (E-SE Asia) via a region-wide network of temporally overlapping epidemics and that epidemics in the temperate regions were seeded from this network each year. Seed strains generally first reached Oceania, North America, and Europe, and later South America. This evidence suggests that once A (H3N2) viruses leave E-SE Asia, they are unlikely to contribute to long-term viral evolution. If the trends observed during this period are an accurate representation of overall patterns of spread, then the antigenic characteristics of A (H3N2) viruses outside E-SE Asia may be forecast each year based on surveillance within E-SE Asia, with consequent improvements to vaccine strain selection.


Not only that, but we are dealing with a pandemic strain here, a distinction implicit in the use of the term "seasonal influenza" to differentiate the two. Just as interesting a puzzle as: "why is seasonal flu seasonal in nature?" is its counterpart: "why is pandemic influenza NOT seasonal in nature?" Surely no satisfactory explanation for seasonality will ever be achieved if we're obligated to toss the whole thing out the first time a pandemic strain comes along and refuses to conform.
Seasonal flu is pandemic in a sense. The term is relative, not an absolute term. It means we are seeing something in the infection pattern that is not typical. In the case of flu the difference is in the novelty of the strain in a population which lacks immunity.
 
I apologize up front for thinking again, but here it comes:

In the latest vax thread, we saw charts showing how the death rates from many infectious disease dropped incredibly in the 40s and 50s. The cause was probably better treatments, including antibiotics. AAand, all of these huge scary predicted pandemics are always compared to the Swine Flu that predates the mentioned improvements in care.

In the mean time we have had better care for the sick, better sanitation in our societies, better antibiotics, improved diets...

Or maybe WWII exposed everybody everywhere to enough germs to give the whole world total immunity? And the state of modern travel is our booster shots.

I guess I am thinking those huge pan/epi-demics are a thing of the past. The Swine Flu, Bubonic Plague... was then, this is now.

Is there a "cultural anthropo-immuno-ologist" in the house?
No but I can dispel your mythical conclusion worldwide pandemics are a thing of the past with one name: HIV-AIDS.
 
Which seems to be adequate for the current swine flu pandemic, and the AIDS epidemic, and the SARS epidemic, and Ebola, and Bird flu, and MRSA and....

All of which were supposed to decimate the world, ruin our culture, kill children THINK OF THE CHILDREN!

Anyhow, something has changed. My guess is that world travel is a mixed bag. Along with exposure to more diseases came immunity to more diseases.
Greater herd immunity.


ETA: how could I forget flesh eating bacteria.
Actually, now that you mention it, the USA 300 strain of MRSA is a current ongoing pandemic. SARS very nearly was one. Plague is treatable with antibiotics and not many people live in the conditions which led to past plague pandemics.

Ebola would have to undergo a total transformation and while that isn't likely, if the Ebola-Reston virus jumped to the human species it could be very bad.

As for "supposed to decimate the world", don't confuse news media ignorance with actual public health and infectious disease expert opinion on these organisms.


Greater herd immunity is not going to help when novel organisms emerge. Nor will antibiotics help if the emerging pathogen is either resistant or a virus.

I also think herd immunity is going to far less important than a highly mobile population when considering the risk of the next pathogen with pandemic potential.



Forgot to add drug resistant TB as posing a pretty big current worldwide threat.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom