Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

I suspect the people in charge (CDC, WHO, etc) are avoiding "swine" in the name because of all the idiots killing pigs around the globe.


-

Yep.

http://health.asiaone.com/Health/News/Story/A1Story20090430-138488.html

While the new virus seems to be most heavily composed of genetic sequences from swine influenza virus material, it also has human and avian influenza genetic sequences, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta, US.

Government officials in Thailand, one of the world's largest meat exporters, have started referring to the disease as "Mexican flu".

An Israeli deputy health minister - an ultra-Orthodox Jew - said his country would do the same, to keep Jews from having to say the word "swine".

In the US, Secretary for Homeland Security Janet Napolitano and Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack went out of their way at a press conference in Washington DC on Tuesday to refer to the virus by its scientific name, as the "H1N1 virus".

"This is not a food-borne illness, virus - it is not correct to refer to it as swine flu because really that's not what this is about," Mr Vilsack said.

Similarly, in Europe, comes this push for a change in name.

"I would suggest that you call it 'novel flu virus'," said European Union Commission spokeswoman Nina Papadoulaki, "just to avoid the misunderstandings with the animal diseases because it costs a lot to the (meat) industry. In this case, we have human-to-human transmission, so it is a human virus, not an animal disease."


Asked whether the World Health Organisation (WHO) was making a similar change, she replied that she had "no information at this point". The WHO website still uses the term "swine flu".

"There is no need to agree on the name of a new virus," the commission spokeswoman said.
 
Good enough for me.

A possible theory #3 I've seen proposed is that it mostly lurks in a porcine reservior through the bright months (notice that I didn't say "warm months"; I personally like the explanation that increased exposure to sunlight is the biggest factor driving seasonality; not saying I can make the case; I just like it).

I don't really know a lot about how the WHO guys do their "track and predict" thing with flu viruses migrating around the globe, but it seems unlikely that they wouldn't have noticed that their work is THAT off.
But it's a funny old world, so I guess you never know.

About sunlight, do you have a proposed mechanism? Are you thinking vitamin D, or do you have an alternative hypothesis?
 
About sunlight, do you have a proposed mechanism? Are you thinking vitamin D, or do you have an alternative hypothesis?
Well, there does seem to be a growing body of evidence to support the role of vitamin D in immunity, but I don't see it necessarily being limited to that. For example, there is a well established link between exposure to light and seasonal affective disorder, and it can also be shown that depression can affect immune response. Who knows what else may be going on that we're not yet aware of? I'm pretty comfortable with just assuming that I'll probably be healthier and happier if I get out in the sunshine once in a while. Plus, it feels good. If a whole bunch of science comes along later to validate that approach, then that'll be a nice bonus, but I don't see much to be gained by waiting.
 
I'm pretty comfortable with just assuming that I'll probably be healthier and happier if I get out in the sunshine once in a while. Plus, it feels good. If a whole bunch of science comes along later to validate that approach, then that'll be a nice bonus, but I don't see much to be gained by waiting.

SUNLIGHT CAUSES SKIN CANCER

this is a proven fact
:p
 
Well, there does seem to be a growing body of evidence to support the role of vitamin D in immunity, but I don't see it necessarily being limited to that. For example, there is a well established link between exposure to light and seasonal affective disorder, and it can also be shown that depression can affect immune response. Who knows what else may be going on that we're not yet aware of? I'm pretty comfortable with just assuming that I'll probably be healthier and happier if I get out in the sunshine once in a while. Plus, it feels good. If a whole bunch of science comes along later to validate that approach, then that'll be a nice bonus, but I don't see much to be gained by waiting.
If I recall, the 'vitamin D affecting immunity' is an untested hypothesis, not an evidence based conclusion. Vitamin D deficiency affects the immune system so it has been proposed this mechanism might explain seasonal influenza (less sunlight in winter). It doesn't explain influenza being just as rampant in the tropics as it is in the temperate climates, however, so the hypothesis is flawed, IMO.

Perhaps it is worth testing, but just like the vitamin C craze, hoping for the magic immune response silver bullet is probably wishful thinking. These pathogens evolved to defeat our immune systems and they are good at doing so, even with healthy people.

Not that there is any big cost to getting a fair amount of sunlight, however. And there is always the possibility one is preventing Alzheimer's. ;)
 
If I recall, the 'vitamin D affecting immunity' is an untested hypothesis, not an evidence based conclusion.
I agree. It's a hypothesis that is being tested with evidence, and seems to be holding up fairly well so far, but getting all excited about it seems a bit premature at this point.

It doesn't explain influenza being just as rampant in the tropics as it is in the temperate climates, however, so the hypothesis is flawed, IMO.
The peaks in the tropics are far less pronounced and consistent than those further from the equator, but one of the things that makes the question: "why is seasonal flu seasonal?" such an interesting puzzle is that none of the proposed explanations is without some flaws.
 
I agree. It's a hypothesis that is being tested with evidence, and seems to be holding up fairly well so far, but getting all excited about it seems a bit premature at this point.
What "holding up"? I couldn't find anyone testing the hypothesis, only the one research paper proposing it.

Perhaps you've seen additional studies on the subject that go beyond speculating or looking at significant vitamin D deficiencies alone?

The peaks in the tropics are far less pronounced and consistent than those further from the equator, but one of the things that makes the question: "why is seasonal flu seasonal?" such an interesting puzzle is that none of the proposed explanations is without some flaws.
I don't agree they are "far less pronounced" however, even if they were, there is no evidence people in the tropics suffer less or milder influenza over all, which is what the hypothesis suggests should happen. The H1N1 pandemic which hit Mexico first is evidence against the vitamin D/sunlight hypothesis.
 
Last edited:
What "holding up"? I couldn't find anyone testing the hypothesis, only the one research paper proposing it.

Perhaps you've seen additional studies on the subject that go beyond speculating or looking at significant vitamin D deficiencies alone?
I believe the NIH is funding a study to see if supplementation of Vitamin D in African American's will decrease a multitude of illnesses that affect that population.
 
What about your random google search?

most of the links in the top ten describe studies that show how vitamin d is linked to improved immunity, if people are going to make ridiculous statements that this isn't the case then perhaps they could provide better evidence than those listed by the "random google search", further than that perhaps they can provide at least some evidence that suggests they actually know what they are talking about !!

:D
 
most of the links in the top ten describe studies that show how vitamin d is linked to improved immunity, if people are going to make ridiculous statements that this isn't the case then perhaps they could provide better evidence than those listed by the "random google search", further than that perhaps they can provide at least some evidence that suggests they actually know what they are talking about !!

:D
I'm sorry but not believing in random googled papers when YOU or myself haven't analyzed them is a tad bit...oh irresponsible isn't it? I reserve judgment until better evidence is presented. Sorry, I tend to care about QUALITY of evidence, not just quantity.
 
I'm sorry but not believing in random googled papers when YOU or myself haven't analyzed them is a tad bit...oh irresponsible isn't it? I reserve judgment until better evidence is presented.
odd, I have read them, which is how I know that they all relate to studies that support what you were saying. We're not talking about some quack doctors here (pun intended) but :-

1st link from a study by the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine
2nd link from a study by the University of Colorado Denver (UC Denver) School of Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) and Children's Hospital Boston.
3rd link from a study by Queen Mary's School of Medicine and Dentistry, London, and the Wellcome Trust Centre for Research in Clinical Tropical Medicine, Imperial College London
4th link from a study by the American Journal of Clinical nutrition

etc etc etc

theres only one "irresponsible" thing here and its your refusal to look at evidence that totally supports your position, this I find quite baffling, were you waiting for God to step down from heaven and endorse your posts in this thread or will the opinions of medical professionals who have studied vitamin D and its boosting effects on immunity be enough ?

I don't know you try to help someone and they totally go off on a tangent, free will has a lot to answer for eh
:D
Sorry, I tend to care about QUALITY of evidence, not just quantity.
When you just admitted that you haven't looked at the evidence I provided I think that claim is a bit moot don't you
;)
 
Last edited:
theres only one "irresponsible" thing here and its your refusal to look at evidence that totally supports your position, this I find quite baffling, were you waiting for God to step down from heaven and endorse your posts in this thread or will the opinions of medical professionals who have studied vitamin D and its boosting effects on immunity be enough ?
What exactly is my position on this? Have I stated it so far?
I don't know you try to help someone and they totally go off on a tangent, free will has a lot to answer for eh
:D
Sorry, google dumping is not "helping anyone", it is an attempt to look smart when you don't really have anything to offer.
When you just admitted that you haven't looked at the evidence I provided I think that claim is a bit moot don't you
;)
Yes. I'm actually going to take my time and read through a few papers before jumping to a conclusion based solely on someone google dumping some papers on me.
 
most of the links in the top ten describe studies that show how vitamin d is linked to improved immunity, if people are going to make ridiculous statements that this isn't the case then perhaps they could provide better evidence than those listed by the "random google search", further than that perhaps they can provide at least some evidence that suggests they actually know what they are talking about !!

:D
Google web site titles bear little relationship to actual research data. I already went this route and found the hypothesis about flu but very little else about actual research outcome.

BTW, a search of sites like PubMed are more useful if you are looking for research results rather than all the numerous sites that regurgitate the sound bites from a few poorly written news accounts of the studies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom