Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

If they're prioritising the elderly, I'll probably get it early too. If I take my mother to the vaccination clinic the nurse will do me too while she has me in her clutches - she always does. I got shot full of pneumococcal vaccine as well as seasonal flu in 2007 just because I was there. On the principal that having me sick wouldn't be too good for mother's wellbeing.

Rolfe.
 
No, you are taking it to an uninformed illogical conclusion.
What's illogical about it? Here is your statement again:

"In the case of pandemic flu vs seasonal flu, the number of cases was not the defining factor, the novelty of the strain was."

H5N1 is a novel strain, one which has demonstrated the ability to infect humans. Without making reference to the number of cases -- as you have already explicitly excluded that -- please answer this question: Why is H5N1 not a pandemic strain?
 
Dymanic, we've been through this before. I do not have the time to give you an education in epidemiology.

H5N1 is not currently presenting as an epidemic, let alone a pandemic. In reality, seasonal flu is pandemic every year though technically it is not called a pandemic.
 
Last edited:
What's illogical about it? Here is your statement again:

"In the case of pandemic flu vs seasonal flu, the number of cases was not the defining factor, the novelty of the strain was."

H5N1 is a novel strain, one which has demonstrated the ability to infect humans. Without making reference to the number of cases -- as you have already explicitly excluded that -- please answer this question: Why is H5N1 not a pandemic strain?

Actually, I see what your saying and that statement is kinda funny, when taken out of context. But in context it's clear what she meant. :p
 
If they're prioritising the elderly, I'll probably get it early too. If I take my mother to the vaccination clinic the nurse will do me too while she has me in her clutches - she always does. I got shot full of pneumococcal vaccine as well as seasonal flu in 2007 just because I was there. On the principal that having me sick wouldn't be too good for mother's wellbeing.

Rolfe.
Sorry Rolfe, You'll be last on the list (in theory).
Order goes: Me, other health care staff, pregnant women, everyone over 6months with a "risk" disease and the over 65s, all healthy young adults, all healthy middle age folk.
 
Last edited:
Sorry Rolfe, You'll be last on the list.
Order goes: Me, other health care staff, pregnant women, everyone over 6months with a "risk" disease and the over 65s, all healthy young adults, all healthy middle age folk.
Do you work for the health department? I can't remember which country you are in.

I'm expecting health care workers to be high on the list in the US, but I suspect the public heath is going to play gatekeeper here.

That's OK. Unless the over 55 group starts dying or Tamiflu resistance spreads quickly, I'm fine with letting the obese diabetic pregnant patients have the vaccine first.
 
Tabloid newspaper article

This sounds pretty risky - I hope nothing goes wrong.

In fact, the risks of getting Guillain Barre syndrome are greater from getting natural flu than they are from getting the vaccine.

This is an article from earlier this year.
The authors actually said:
"Although the occurrence [of GBS] is rare, it is by far more frequent than that following influenza vaccine... The benefit of large-scale influenza vaccination should also be considered as a means to protect against Guillain-Barre syndrome."

I also understand that although there was a rise in number of GBS cases following the swine flu vaccination programme, further analysis of the data showed that this rise above background was not statistically significant. Clearly the vaccine may be a risk, but this risk is presumably miniscule, and may be better than risking the disease. I wouldn't necessarily go as far as the authors of the article suggest (using vaccine to prevent GBS) unless we were in a scenario where natural infection (and its risks) became near inevitable. But with the current flu outbreak, that may well be the case.

We have become very used to seeing these ubiquitous arguments against vaccination from antivaxers everywhere. They consistently ignore evidence that demonstrates the real disease involves risks of several orders of magnitude higher than the vaccine.

Another point is that this batch of vaccine is not some "novel" experimental technological development. It merely consists of what manufacturers do every year, namely tweak the H and N antigens expressed in the usual and well-tested vaccine to match the current flu strain.
 
Last edited:
Sorry Rolfe, You'll be last on the list (in theory).
Order goes: Me, other health care staff, pregnant women, everyone over 6months with a "risk" disease and the over 65s, all healthy young adults, all healthy middle age folk.


I had heard that they were planning to do the elderly at the same time as they do the seasonal flu vaccine. If that's right, I presume they believe the two will be OK together?

(And if I know our practice nurse, "in theory" doesn't cut a lot of mustard.)

Rolfe.
 
The US government is treating it like its going to be.

My home town was remarkably one of the most corrupted under this flu, as it was reported on the news. Despite the apparent outbreak round this small area from the reasonably distanced source, which i believe was Mexico, it is amazing how either this virus dissipated or was controlled.
Controlling the virus seemed more likely as each week passed, concerning pragmatic tests made over a period of time, which revealed the dissipation more likely under terms of climate conditions.
 
My home town was remarkably one of the most corrupted under this flu, as it was reported on the news. Despite the apparent outbreak round this small area from the reasonably distanced source, which i believe was Mexico, it is amazing how either this virus dissipated or was controlled.
Controlling the virus seemed more likely as each week passed, concerning pragmatic tests made over a period of time, which revealed the dissipation more likely under terms of climate conditions.

Your post makes little to no sense to me.
 
(And if I know our practice nurse, "in theory" doesn't cut a lot of mustard.)

As long as she accepts the blame for misusing the vaccine when stocks run out for people at greater risk than the ones she has been vaccinating. ;)
 
I had heard that they were planning to do the elderly at the same time as they do the seasonal flu vaccine. If that's right, I presume they believe the two will be OK together?

(And if I know our practice nurse, "in theory" doesn't cut a lot of mustard.)

Rolfe.
You should be able to get seasonal flu vax at the same time as swine vax (assuming they are available and required). Advice is to give in different arms.
 
Okay. Let's look at this 1976 "vaccine fiasco". I see where the media did their usual lack of fact checking and reported deaths that weren't actually caused by the vaccine (like old people standing in line that died before they got the flu shot). Where is the evidence that even 1 persond died because of the vaccine back then? All I can see is that the vaccine turned out to be not necessary.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom