Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

The interesting thing about the Academy is that is is a chance to study the spread in a closed system. So far, it seems that, with the caveats you brought up, it has only 'caught' about 1 percent.

It's only the frosh and a few selected upperclassmen who are selected as trainers. The rest of the classes are on summer leave or are at various military assignments until classes start again in the fall.

On July 16, 103 cases confirmed, 193 possible cases since the beginning.
http://www.krdo.com/Global/story.asp?S=10718878

Looks more like about 6-7% to me.
 
Last edited:
No mention of fatalities, I presume zero?

Either way, it's not enough to scare so many people into duct taping their homes that I'd want to go buy more duct tape futures.

In fact, I think I'll sell the ones I'm holding. Any takers? ;)
 
Last edited:
Yes, zero.

And, no, I have no use for used duct tape; I've got plenty of my own. :)
 
Without wanting to talk this particular outbreak down or the concern about a new strain, the average annual deaths from "regular" flu are about 36,000 in the US. OK, figures are difficult to come by and sometimes a bit nebulous, but a comparison.

End of April
I'm not ignoring all the previous posts, but that's the reality. "Bird" and "Swine" flu are novel new strains, but while pandemic, don't look to be as wide spread as "regular" flu.

Don't get me wrong, I think it was responsible to plan to contain this, but the subsequent panic, just as with Avian Flu, was driven OTT by the media in my opinion, and many people have become blase about it because of media over-egging.
H1N1v (new name is now H1N1v for variant) flu deaths weren't recognized during the bulk of the seasonal flu count that you are comparing.

The problem here is you are comparing two fractions with different denominators. Wait until the end of flu season in the southern hemisphere and then compare the total H1N1v deaths to average seasonal flu deaths. In addition, compare the total deaths from each group in people under age 50 since that is a disturbing aspect of the H1N1v.

Only then are we going to have comparable denominators.
 
Last edited:
Half of which are in Victoria, for whatever reason.

I'm not all that worried, should I be?
Depends. How old are you? Do you have significant others that are children or young adults? Is your sig. other pregnant, (if you have one)? Do you have access to Tamiflu?
 
Victoria has the highest per capita rate in the world, but it seems to be sparing the outer eastern suburbs where I live. :)

I'm not sure of the reason. Perhaps they're looking for it more, or perhaps it's just bad luck.....
Or perhaps it is a simple matter of timing and Melbourne just hasn't been hit yet.
 
A study in Australia has apparently shown that nearly all people with flu like symptoms at the present time have swine flu. .

Can you find that again?

Here in the US, it looks like just this week H1N1v just completely outcompeted (eliminated) "regular H1N1".

http://www.cdc.gov/flu/weekly/

(you can look through past weeks here)
http://www.cdc.gov/flu/weekly/fluactivity.htm

I know it's summer here, but we should have some of the old H1N1 still floating around, I think?
 
Where do you see it being that much more active than previous years?
Flu is assumed to be virtually non-existant during the summer, so the answer to your question is every place in the northern hemisphere where it is currently active. CDC doesn't usually even maintain surveillance through the off season. Because of the pandemic, they are doing surveillance, and are getting the occasional hit on a "seasonal" strain, but with considerable emphasis on "occasional". Nobody knows whether this is what would be seen if they maintained surveillance every summer. It's called "seasonal influenza" for a reason. There are a number of competing theories as to just why it is seasonal, but the evidence that it IS seasonal is incontrovertible; you can even see the trend become more pronounced with increased distance from the equator.
 
H1N1v (new name is now H1N1v for variant) flu deaths weren't recognized during the bulk of the seasonal flu count that you are comparing.
That's my fault for not giving my source.
The article I got those numbers from was, Regular flu has killed thousands since January. I should have stated that I was giving this as an example of media coverage, the topic at this particular point in the thread, rather than stating this *was* the reason and those were the numbers.
The problem here is you are comparing two fractions with different denominators. Wait until the end of flu season in the southern hemisphere and then compare the total H1N1v deaths to average seasonal flu deaths. In addition, compare the total deaths from each group in people under age 50 since that is a disturbing aspect of the H1N1v.

Only then are we going to have comparable denominators.
Again, because of my poorly worded post, I've confused the point. Being, that
Originally Posted by portlandatheist
Amazing. 37,000+ people now in the US that have caught H1N1 flu, 211 deaths and still following a strong growth curve yet it no longer holds much interests to us, either in the media or here at JREF. Strange how quickly we adjust and how fleeting novelty can be.
Mine was an example of just the sort of media coverage now coming out - but my post came across as my opinion/research on the actuality.
 
Flu is assumed to be virtually non-existant during the summer, so the answer to your question is every place in the northern hemisphere where it is currently active.
I've never seen any compelling evidence that flu was completely eliminated during the summer.
Did you look at the flu and pneumonia hospitalizations graph, that shows this summer's overall activity being similar to past years? If we have an unusual amount of flu going around, shouldn't it probably be higher?
 
Things look grim. It is summer and I've admitted 10 patients(3 to the ICU) within the last 2 weeks for H1N1 related illnesses. Over 90% of Stanford University Medical Center Influenza A admissions are H1N1 positive and the current data from Kaiser Permanente is over 50% H1N1.

I'm dreading this winter.
http://cdc.gov/h1n1flu/update.htm
 
Last edited:
I've never seen any compelling evidence that flu was completely eliminated during the summer.
There are essentially two theories. One is that the virus persists at low levels during the summer. The other is that it migrates back and forth across the equator. Either way, it can be considered "virtually nonexistant" during the off season, though not necessarily "completely eliminated".

Did you look at the flu and pneumonia hospitalizations graph, that shows this summer's overall activity being similar to past years?
Did you notice that on one of those graphs, entries for previous years do not extend beyond about week 20 at all?
 
Things look grim. It is summer and I've admitted 10 patients(3 to the ICU) within the last 2 weeks for H1N1 related illnesses. Over 90% of Stanford University Medical Center Influenza A admissions are H1N1 positive and the current data from Kaiser Permanente is over 50% H1N1.

I'm dreading this winter.
http://cdc.gov/h1n1flu/update.htm

Look on the bright side: with so much H1N1 going around in the summer, less people will catch it in the winter than if it had totally vanished.
 
There are essentially two theories. One is that the virus persists at low levels during the summer. The other is that it migrates back and forth across the equator. Either way, it can be considered "virtually nonexistant" during the off season, though not necessarily "completely eliminated".
I would call it "extremely low prevalence compared to flu season."
I was more or less sold on theory #1 by the research on flu season in pigs which demonstrated that for them, it's definitely theory #1. Seems that it would, more likely than not, be the same for humans.

Did you notice that on one of those graphs, entries for previous years do not extend beyond about week 20 at all?

Yes. But they do still collect samples.
They report the summer findings in the first report of the new season.
Like here:

http://www.cdc.gov/flu/weekly/weeklyarchives2006-2007/weekly40.htm

From week 21 through week 39 (weeks ending May 21 – September 30), WHO and NREVSS laboratories tested 20,909 specimens for influenza and 541 (2.6%) were positive. Of the positive results, 111 (20.5%) were influenza A (H1) viruses, 3 (0.6%) were influenza A (H3) viruses, 195 (36.0%) were influenza A viruses that were not subtyped, and 232 (42.9%) were influenza B viruses. More than half (56%) of these isolates were tested from mid-May through late June, when 4.0% of specimens tested were positive for influenza. Activity continued to decline through late August, when 1.4% of specimens tested were positive for influenza. Isolates were reported from all surveillance regions** during the summer.
 
What happened to "S-OIV" (swine origin influenza virus) H1N1??
Did I blink?
There are 2 official names, I chose the shorter one for convenience. From ProMed:
Date: Mon 6 Jul 2009
From: an official source [edited]

The following information relates to the question of the proper
nomenclature for the current pandemic strain of influenza A (H1N1) as
discussed in "Influenza A (H1N1) - worldwide (83): antiviral
resistance 20090705.2417".

For common reference to the virus and the disease, WHO, OIE & FAO are
now officially using "pandemic (H1N1) 2009" (e.g. there were 2378 new
confirmed cases of pandemic (H1N1) 2009 reported...) and "pandemic
(H1N1) 2009 virus." Some documents remain with previous designations
and are in the process of being changed over.

The designation "(H1N1)v" is being used for the individual isolate
nomenclature (e.g. A/California/7/2009(H1N1)v).

I suspect the people in charge (CDC, WHO, etc) are avoiding "swine" in the name because of all the idiots killing pigs around the globe.


-
 
I would call it "extremely low prevalence compared to flu season."
Good enough for me.

I was more or less sold on theory #1 by the research on flu season in pigs which demonstrated that for them, it's definitely theory #1.
A possible theory #3 I've seen proposed is that it mostly lurks in a porcine reservior through the bright months (notice that I didn't say "warm months"; I personally like the explanation that increased exposure to sunlight is the biggest factor driving seasonality; not saying I can make the case; I just like it).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom