Is Mainstream Skepticism turning into Fanaticism?

Ironically, the avatar was made to mock and ridicule a UFOlogist. :D


No, I don't think it's a "finish him" at all.
We can (and regularly do) engage with people for many pages, providing reams of evidence to support our positions, to be faced with someone who doesn't accept any of it and only provides hand waving and anecdote to refute it.
This can only go on for so long before it becomes very repetitive.
So some of us like to break up the monotony with a few gags, cartoons or a copy of Squid Fishing Monthly.
These things don't stop discussion, if the opponent brings fresh new evidence, we look at that seriously before another round of repetition and a bit more mocking.

The way I see it, rightly or wrongly, if people are going to present things which are ridiculous, after they have been reasonably, logically and/or scientifically show to be ridiculous, they will attract ridicule. :)

Slamming, punching and kicking rarely occur here in my experience. Just light mockery and sarcasm.
 
A decent example. If I may, however, just point out what I mean?
I understand this is just a hypothetical discussion example, but do you agree with the following?

Instead of "prove to us that it does", wouldn't the better response from a true sckeptic better be reflected as:
"I do not need to, because thermite can do that. Just like Explosives can. Just like an Airplane flying into it can. It is not the question whether it CAN or CANNOT, but rather DID IT, or DID IT NOT?
The only way to show this is by showing the presence of thermite.
Upon all testing done, no such presence was found. Neither was the presence of explosives.
The presence we did, however, find in abundance - was airplane parts and exhausted fuel residue.
If there are crumbs in the plate, it is NOT reasonable to think that Jello was eaten..."

Pretty much every approach has been tried with thermite believers, for the better part of six years.

I do not doubt that the rest of the conversation example would transpire to the same exact end.
I completely agree with the premise that woos, conspiracy theorists, and their kin are far too often irrational and emotional.
My question, one skeptic to another, is:
"Do you think it's ethical for us to resort to the same tactics (lowblows, outbursts, dismissive, arrogant, etc) just to win the argument?"

I don't think that there is anything like a 'resort to the same tactics'. There are certainly many, many occasions when skeptics are pushed over the edge by totally boneheaded trolling and know-nothingism.

After a while, on some issues, familiarity breeds extreme contempt. But it is patently ridiculous to treat all ideas with equal good grace when some of them have been refuted over and over and over.

What we may now be witnessing is a form of collective argument fatigue on the internet. Many of the issues discussed here have been debated for the better part of 20 years, they have a rich legacy of information resource websites, and still people refuse to do the proper thing and digest the information that is readily available.

Moreover, the woos doing the arguing now - i.e. the ones that show up here - are also, as I have put it before, the products of evolution; they are often like drug-resistant bacteria, having perfected the art of trolling over the same period of time. If the bacteria are drug-resistant, then napalm is a better bet than penicillin.
 
The sorts of responses that comes of wholly uncouth, is more frequently of the 1-line nature as example: "Really?! We doing this **** AGAIN now?!"

Variations included, I saw that one response from 3 different people in one thread, with 9 other responses backing it up.

Because you have to understand that is what we were saying because that is pretty much all we have left to say to these people.

Do you have any idea how many "You won't know everything, therefore Woo" discussions we've had on this forum? How many times we've sat and explained in the simplest language we can why "Solipsism doesn't mean you get to make crap up" over and over and over and over and over and over to Woo Slingers, Woo Apologist, and people that think rationality is evil because it disagrees with their pet delusion?

You keep telling us to be nicer, engage them in rational discourse, trying to treat them as intellectual equals. These are all nice, if somewhat naive, ideas but the thing you have to remember is we have already done that to hell and back and it got us nowhere.

I've done the nice thing. I've done the reasonable thing. I've done the calm step by step breaking down of the rational reasons why X does not equal Y. I've typed out long, detailed posts loaded with linked references. I've extended the courtesy of treating Woo Slingers like my intellectual equal time and time again. I've slung benefit of the doubt at them time and time again. I've given them, both as a group and as equals, second and third and fourth and 27th chances to stop being crazy for just a moment and talk like they've got enough neurons in their skill to fire off a proper synapse.

And it has either come back to bite me in the ass or accomplished nothing every single time. I'm sick of trying to be rational with people only to watch them drag the discussion down into either intentional trollish stupidity or clueless beyond the hope of help babbling nonsense.

The point I, and not to speak for other posters but from the looks of it I'm not alone, am trying to make is I'm not going to go through the same steps everytime a new Woo Slinger makes a wall of text word salad appeal to Solipsistic special pleading post if I already know how the story is going to end.

Show me something different, and I'll show you something different. It's that simple.
 
Because you have to understand that is what we were saying because that is pretty much all we have left to say to these people.

Do you have any idea how many "You won't know everything, therefore Woo" discussions we've had on this forum?
How many times we've sat and explained in the simplest language we can why "Solipsism doesn't mean you get to make crap up" over and over and over and over and over and over to Woo Slingers, Woo Apologist, and people that think rationality is evil because it disagrees with their pet delusion?

You keep telling us to be nicer, engage them in rational discourse, trying to treat them as intellectual equals. These are all nice, if somewhat naive, ideas but the thing you have to remember is we have already done that to hell and back and it got us nowhere.

I've done the nice thing. I've done the reasonable thing. I've done the calm step by step breaking down of the rational reasons why X does not equal Y. I've typed out long, detailed posts loaded with linked references. I've extended the courtesy of treating Woo Slingers like my intellectual equal time and time again. I've slung benefit of the doubt at them time and time again. I've given them, both as a group and as equals, second and third and fourth and 27th chances to stop being crazy for just a moment and talk like they've got enough neurons in their skill to fire off a proper synapse.

And it has either come back to bite me in the ass or accomplished nothing every single time. I'm sick of trying to be rational with people only to watch them drag the discussion down into either intentional trollish stupidity or clueless beyond the hope of help babbling nonsense.

The point I, and not to speak for other posters but from the looks of it I'm not alone, am trying to make is I'm not going to go through the same steps everytime a new Woo Slinger makes a wall of text word salad appeal to Solipsistic special pleading post if I already know how the story is going to end.


Show me something different, and I'll show you something different. It's that simple.

Spoilered middle of quote just for keeping it a lil shorter.

See, it is not so much the discussion ending in such a response, that concerns me.
Yes, I do realize that some topics have been beaten so many times that it doesn't even resemble the original any longer.
Yes, I do realize that some woos would just keep going on and on and on and on. And when they are finally done, magically someone else starts a new thread with the same thought/claim.

What I also realize is that for us to claim high ground thinking, it seems rather contradictive to then just immediately jump the poor fella and mob him to submission.

I know human patience has it's limits.
And if it is the case that your patience on a certain poster/topic/claim has worn out... why not instead keep quiet until you do have the rationality of mind back in your grasp to engage the person on a HUMAN LEVEL.

"Sorry Jeff, this exact topic has been discussed in full in a thread named "xxxxxxxxx". Should be over in the "yyyyyyyyyyy" section somewhere. If you believe that something was missed or overlooked in that discussion, feel free to return with such information."

Imo, a far more sensible response than "OH WTF?! AGAIN WITH THIS?! ARE YOU ****IN SERIOUS?!?!"
 
I don't agree that we're someone being unreasonable or not treating people "on a human level" when we simply cut through all the crap and call them on their Woo from the get go instead of following the scripts they obviously have in their head.

Against woo I can do nothing but claim the intellectual high ground. Worrying about the moral high ground I'll leave for people that... well for people that worry about that sort of thing.

I have no desire to keep extending these babbling fools common courtesy over and over only to have to thrown back in my face, crumpled into a bunch of braying nonsense.

Nor do I agree that I have any obligation to follow some sort of "If you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all rule." The rules of this board and of my own moral code, such as it is, requires me to be polite and civil, not nice.

I have no obligation to let Woo slide past me unnoticed.

What you have to understand is this is not a discussion am I in for fun or for laughs. The questions of why people insist upon continuing to believe in, defend, and spread Woo is one that I feel actually matters. It is not something I feel I can shelf until such time as the Woo Slingers finally decide to start acting like human beings.
 
We have brains and it annoys me when I see woos refusing to use them.
 
Nor do I agree that I have any obligation to follow some sort of "If you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all rule." The rules of this board and of my own moral code, such as it is, requires me to be polite and civil, not nice.

To me, this statement is at the heart of what I am saying.
Miscommunicated, perhaps, by me -

I wholeheartedly agree. I do not ask people to be "nice" above and beyond all.
Polite and Civil on the other hand I do find as much a requirement in engaging believers as is presenting the truth.

Sadly, in as much as I could gather (as noted earlier in this thread), you do conduct yourself exactly as you say.
With exception to that one outburst in this thread.

(broader scope incoming, not attack on you JoeBentley)

But can you at least see where I come from with this?
How is calling someone a troll, closet believer, idiot, ignoramus, etc serving the purpose of opening debate?
How is any of that considered civil?
How is any of that considered polite?

Above all... how in sweet heaven's nipple are you about to convince me that insulting and rude behaviour is REQUIRED AND INTELLIGENT, as well as a CONTRIBUTING factor in a discussion with ANYBODY, woo or otherwise?

And yes, parnassus, looking at you...
 
How is calling someone a troll, closet believer, idiot, ignoramus, etc serving the purpose of opening debate?
How is any of that considered civil?
How is any of that considered polite?
If you see any of that, you should report it. It's the little triangle with the exclamation point at the bottom left of each post.
 
To me, this statement is at the heart of what I am saying.
Miscommunicated, perhaps, by me -

I wholeheartedly agree. I do not ask people to be "nice" above and beyond all.
Polite and Civil on the other hand I do find as much a requirement in engaging believers as is presenting the truth.

Sadly, in as much as I could gather (as noted earlier in this thread), you do conduct yourself exactly as you say.
With exception to that one outburst in this thread.

(broader scope incoming, not attack on you JoeBentley)

But can you at least see where I come from with this?
How is calling someone a troll, closet believer, idiot, ignoramus, etc serving the purpose of opening debate?
How is any of that considered civil?
How is any of that considered polite?

Above all... how in sweet heaven's nipple are you about to convince me that insulting and rude behaviour is REQUIRED AND INTELLIGENT, as well as a CONTRIBUTING factor in a discussion with ANYBODY, woo or otherwise?

And yes, parnassus, looking at you...

Your writing is playful, sometimes vivid, conversational but sometimes stilted, sometimes wordy. You use odd formatting. Strange Spoiler tages. You sometimes use big words incorrectly -- such as using exemplary as an adverb. Often you exaggerate for effect, such as when you say people are being "mobbed into submission". You use all-caps for emphasis. Sometimes your word-choices are correct enough but unidiomatic -- such as saying contradictive instead of the more usual contradictory. And so forth.

The good writers here -- Myriad, Slingblade, Blobru, R. Mackey, ConspiRaider, Hokulele, and many others -- all have their own styles and distinctive voices. They know how to use the language for best effect.

"Best effect" is what's easiest to read and most persuasive, but it's also what jumps off the page. It requires a little more effort to write than spontaneous prose, and it requires a little revision. 'First thought' is not always 'best thought', even for Jack Kerouac.

I'm not claiming to be a consistently good writer. Instead, I'm saying that your writing would be more persuasive if you toned it down a little and re-wrote, cutting out unnecessary words. Pithy writing can seem curt, so there's always a balance between sounding friendly enough and being clear, concise, and punchy. Use formatting in standard ways.

The best writers here have their own styles, and I hope you find yours.

I say this after wading through some of your writing, having to make more effort than I think should be necessary.
 
re you about to convince me that insulting and rude behaviour is REQUIRED AND INTELLIGENT, as well as a CONTRIBUTING factor in a discussion with ANYBODY, woo or otherwise?

If this is thread is simply some long, drawn out attempt to make me admit that sometimes someone can be both skeptical and a jerk, well /thread because I will readily do so.

But I honestly don't get your broader angle here and pardon me for being blunt but it's fairly obvious you have one. As a group, either on this board or just in general, skeptics are not particularly uncivil or mean spirited enough to warrant a "calling out." For every skeptic that's reached his breaking point and finally snapped there's a dozen Woo Slingers that already started out there.

I am not exactly getting why you created a thread calling out the small percentage of skeptics that, fully admit, can occasionally make a trip to incivility land instead of the large percentage of Woo Slingers that live there.

You almost seems to be making a parallel version of the "But you can't know everything!" copout but making it a question of morality instead of intellectualism.

"But skeptics aren't nice all the time either!" is A) Obviously and patently true and B) Even less meaningful then pointing out they we aren't right all the time and C) n point no one has ever argued.
 
Last edited:
But can you at least see where I come from with this?
How is calling someone a troll, closet believer, idiot, ignoramus, etc serving the purpose of opening debate?How is any of that considered civil?
How is any of that considered polite?

.

The accusations come after the opening debate . And usually initiated by the troll or woo who accuses us of being to stupid to understand their argument.
 
Thank you for he compliments, as well as advice.
English is not my primary language, but I try.

If this is thread is simply some long, drawn out attempt to make me admit that sometimes someone can be both skeptical and a jerk, well /thread because I will readily do so.

But I honestly don't get your broader angle here and pardon me for being blunt but it's fairly obvious you have one. As a group, either on this board or just in general, skeptics are not particularly uncivil or mean spirited enough to warrant a "calling out." For every skeptic that's reached his breaking point and finally snapped there's a dozen Woo Slingers that already started out there.

I am not exactly getting why you created a thread calling out the small percentage of skeptics that, fully admit, can occasionally make a trip to incivility land instead of the large percentage of Woo Slingers that live there.

You almost seems to be making a parallel version of the "But you can't know everything!" copout but making it a question of morality instead of intellectualism.

"But skeptics aren't nice all the time either!" is A) Obviously and patently true and B) Even less meaningful then pointing out they we aren't right all the time and C) n point no one has ever argued.

My apologies if it comes off as such.
My intent?
Hmmm... Ok.

Some dude makes claim.
Some skeptic refutes laim.
Another skeptic asks for evidence.
Third skeptic joins the fray, insulting, belittling and degrading the poster, topic, and even sunshine itself.
OP dude gets mad.
Third skeptic jumps back in with more insults, veiled thinly in-between vague statements such as "know your stuff" "know your place" "you're an idiot" "get lost"
Remaining skeptics rejoice in having "sure showed him" and continue to ridicule.
A few more skeptics enter and try to engage.

Sadly - at that point the case is already lost, because Mr. 3 over there already put the OP in such an extremely (understandably) defensive stance, that no constructive debate at this point could possibly exist.

What I am saying, is not that people can be ******** sometimes. What I am saying (at least within this context on these forums) is that even those that aren't, very often place (undeservedly) too high reverence on those that do so.
 
Some dude makes claim.
Some skeptic refutes laim.
Another skeptic asks for evidence.
Dude says that skeptic is too dumb and closed minded Third skeptic joins the fray, insulting, belittling and degrading the poster, topic, and even sunshine itself.
OP dude gets mad.
Third skeptic jumps back in with more insults, veiled thinly in-between vague statements such as "know your stuff" "know your place" "you're an idiot" "get lost"
Remaining skeptics rejoice in having "sure showed him" and continue to ridicule.
A few more skeptics enter and try to engage.

You forgot the highlighted bit.
 
I think putting onus on the skeptics for making constructive debate possible when faced with the zerg rush of braying nonsense we have to put up with is unreasonable.

And you make the false assumption that constructive debate is always the point. With that tiny percentage of Woo Slingers the remain capable of such a thing I happily will do so until the cows come home and then debate the cows if necessary.

But when someone starts a topic and obviously has no desire to engage in anything resembling rational discourse, and yes after a while me and other posters have learned to recognize this on the rare occasions they don't just flat out admit it, then I will simply point out how donkey porking stupid their statement is in order to keep their ridiculous nonsense marginalized lest someone else mistake their babbling for something coherent.

You seem to be making the mistaken assumption that every time a skeptic and a Woo Slinger interact it is for the purpose of trying to convert the Woo Slinger. I do try this on occasions, mainly because the literally throughout the last decade and a half I have spent arguing for rationality the at best 2 or 3 times I've been able to pull someone out of Woo are among the proudest in my life, but learned a long, long, long, long time ago that such attempts prove futile practically every single time. 99 times out of a 100 arguing with a Woo Slinger is like trying to teach a cat to snorkel by giving it written directions, in that it doesn't matter how clear your instructions are.

What we are doing the other 99% of the time isn't attempts to argue people away from their positions, very few people that go to Woo are intellectually capable of being drug back out. What we are doing is keeping their arguments intellectually marginalized.
 
Last edited:
Talking of cows, how are we supposed to respond to Bjarne, in another thread he constantly says that we are as stupid as cows. How can you have a reasoned debate with a woo who believes in his insane contracting space theory?
 
I'm mostly polite here, i.e., ball-less, but in real life, I am frequently asked by wooish friends, what I think of crop circles or on board electrolysis units for gas mileage, etc.
I remain polite and tell them what I know, or point out how the website they refer to is utterly without peer review and is mostly selling a dubious product.

Invariably, I get yelled at for the service. Occasionally, they don't speak to me for a year or more. The irony is that they seek me out. I don't act evangelistic. I don't ever get 'in their face' or seek them out for debunking.

At times like this, I miss Complexity. He didn't tip-toe around the fragile egos of the misinformed.
 
What I also realize is that for us to claim high ground thinking, it seems rather contradictive to then just immediately jump the poor fella and mob him to submission.

I think that you will find a wide variety of responses depending on the sub-forum and if the person is a newbie or not. In SMT most responses will be very neutral and open, there may be some bold and over the top ones as well. In General Scepticism there is about the same, as well as in R&P and SCE, however in Politics and and CT there is a much wider spectrum of responses and flaming.
 
. In General Scepticism there is about the same, as well as in R&P and SCE, however in Politics and and CT there is a much wider spectrum of responses and flaming.

My dad warned me never to discuss politics or religion.
 
I think that you will find a wide variety of responses depending on the sub-forum and if the person is a newbie or not. In SMT most responses will be very neutral and open, there may be some bold and over the top ones as well. In General Scepticism there is about the same, as well as in R&P and SCE, however in Politics and and CT there is a much wider spectrum of responses and flaming.

Agreed response to such with below quote.

My dad warned me never to discuss politics or religion.




JoeBentley, you again also make a very good point.
false assumption that constructive debate is always the point

My only answer is "Walk away". In the obvious light of a genuine troll, or otherwise steadfast woo walking about with no intent other than starting a fight... Walk away!
I do not see what purpose is served by further indulging the conversation at all. Insulting, ridiculing, and openly giving him exactly what he came for.
What is to be won by that?

Why has it become so hard for us, as skeptics, to just walk away when a lost case is obvious?
And even if one holds that no case is ever lost, how do these negative actions result in anything positive? Wouldn't EVERYBODY's interest be best served by walking away from a clearly welded-shut door?
Let those who want to salvage the lost case do so. It is their choice to do want to do so. I applaud them for their patience.
 
If the skeptics are the ones doing the pointing and laughing and insulting, why is it that the paranormal claimants often end up being suspended? A very good summary of the usual woo thread, by the way.


Nominated even.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom