Is Mainstream Skepticism turning into Fanaticism?

Third skeptic joins the fray, insulting, belittling and degrading the poster...

Third skeptic jumps back in with more insults, veiled thinly in-between vague statements such as ..."you're an idiot" "...
If you see any of that, you should report it. It's the little triangle with the exclamation point at the bottom left of each post.
 
Talking of cows, how are we supposed to respond to Bjarne, in another thread he constantly says that we are as stupid as cows. How can you have a reasoned debate with a woo who believes in his insane contracting space theory?
.
It's obviously insane!
I have proof positive the universe expands daily!
Every spring, after only moderate exercise in the winter, I find when out on my 10-speed the hills have gotten higher, and the miles longer.
As I exercise more, the time to do the standard lap decreases by almost 25% by the end of autumn, but the next spring, because I haven't kept up with the expansion, back to baseline.
Gotta keep up with the universe!
 
So I decided against debating this further within those threads, but instead (as appropriate), separate that discussion into it's own thread.


You're wasting your time. Fanatics can't be reasoned with whether they are non-religious fanatics or religious fanatics.

But you're right.
 
You're wasting your time. Fanatics can't be reasoned with whether they are non-religious fanatics or religious fanatics.

But you're right.

Especially those fanatics who are fanatical about fanaticism.
 
@wheunis: When someone here says "impossible", they usually do so with the backing of a LARGE amount of countermanding evidence. Like when it is said that "perpetual motion machines are impossible" -- that is said with the backing of EVERY experiment that has vetted the laws of thermo AND all the failures throughout history to build a working perpetual motion machine (which are themselves evidence FOR the laws of thermo being right!). ALL of that serves to countermand the claim of perpetual motion machines. There is no need to tear apart the latest claim when we already have a giant crapload of evidence that it's false from previous work! So thus the dismissal "that's impossible".
 
To the OP: in other words, posters here often react to claims the same way you feel about the Discovery Network

In that thread, you didn't provide us with a detailed description of why the UFO and ghost "documentaries" you were complaining about were inaccurate; you just called it all "crap" and expressed your frustration. (A sentiment with which many of us wholly agree.) That doesn't make you a "fanatic," does it?
 
To the OP: in other words, posters here often react to claims the same way you feel about the Discovery Network

In that thread, you didn't provide us with a detailed description of why the UFO and ghost "documentaries" you were complaining about were inaccurate; you just called it all "crap" and expressed your frustration. (A sentiment with which many of us wholly agree.) That doesn't make you a "fanatic," does it?

I was actually very clear about it.
I will even quote it for your convenience.
Heck, why don't I just highlight it for ya, too?


Was watching some Discovery Channel documentaries with my wife yesterday...

What the sweet excrement has happened to those people?!

Documentaries about an imaginary captured UFO?! "In this insightful next hour, we will take apart this mysterious craft and lay to bare, all it's inner workings for you, the viewer."
Documentaries about ghosts being real?!

I could go on, but seriously... WTF has happened to the world of documentaries?

THERE ARE KIDS WATCHING THIS CRAP!!!


Almost forgot - History Channel, TruthTV, all the rest of em too...
 
I did not say that you eluded it. Asking for proof a claim of say, telepathy is not drivel.

He didn't say asking for proof was drivel. Indeed, in the very same post he argued for just the opposite. What I think he was saying was drivel was the accusation that he was claiming that "asking for proof indicates an inability to think logically".
 
You're wasting your time. Fanatics can't be reasoned with whether they are non-religious fanatics or religious fanatics.

But you're right.

Why can't you simply supply a sound argument for others to consider your belief? Anecdotes of your first hand experience are not sound arguments. That's just preaching and forcing people to trust you. These are the tactics of confidence men.

If you have a good reason to consider your claims, make your case. Alluding to esoteric comparisons between mythological archtypes is not an argument in favor of the reality of higher states or the existence of what we would consider the supernatural. It could just as easily apply to cultural psychology. If you think there's a way to make a distinction between the two findings, make your case.

Or sit in the corner and pretend we're all just close minded fanatics who won't let you preach of your superior intellect while pounding your chest about your level of superior spiritual advancement.

You can't seem to present a valid argument for why anyone should consider what you say, as if we're bad for not simply trusting your experiences over those of any other stranger because you feel yours are valid.
 
My only answer is "Walk away".

And I simply disagree with you. As I have said this is not a battle I am in lightly. Woo isn't just some pet peeve I have that annoys me like people that don't use their blinkers. Woo is dangerous nonsense. I can no more walk away from it then I can walk away from someone being mugged on the street. For me to do so would be cowardly.

When someone spews out some nonsense that shows that they are not simply wrong, being wrong is a sin I can easily forgive, but delibertly and intentionally just refusing to deal with reality, I cannot walk away from this. I harbor no illusions about my ability to change this, but that doesn't change the fact that I can not leave it alone.

This isn't about correcting a falsehood, nothing that simple. 99% of the human race is wrong about 99% of everything they think and I have no problem with that. It takes very little effort to make me give you a pass. You can be wrong on a monumental level but as long as you are at least trying I'll let you slide provided your wrongness is causing any direct harm.

But pseudoscience, Woo, religion, conspiracy theories... these people aren't just wrong. They are thinking wrong on a base level.
 
Unholy cow.

Someone is doing wrong-think on the internet.

Send $10 for my pamphlet, "How to overcome gullibility".
 
And I simply disagree with you. As I have said this is not a battle I am in lightly. Woo isn't just some pet peeve I have that annoys me like people that don't use their blinkers. Woo is dangerous nonsense. I can no more walk away from it then I can walk away from someone being mugged on the street. For me to do so would be cowardly.

When someone spews out some nonsense that shows that they are not simply wrong, being wrong is a sin I can easily forgive, but delibertly and intentionally just refusing to deal with reality, I cannot walk away from this. I harbor no illusions about my ability to change this, but that doesn't change the fact that I can not leave it alone.

This isn't about correcting a falsehood, nothing that simple. 99% of the human race is wrong about 99% of everything they think and I have no problem with that. It takes very little effort to make me give you a pass. You can be wrong on a monumental level but as long as you are at least trying I'll let you slide provided your wrongness is causing any direct harm.

But pseudoscience, Woo, religion, conspiracy theories... these people aren't just wrong. They are thinking wrong on a base level.

I accept your passion. It is a valid one.

Where do we draw the line?
At what point in this, do we do more harm than good?

Is it possible that when we approach these situations from the position of ridicule, insults, etc that we actually scare these people away from us, instead of away from danger?
 
I accept your passion. It is a valid one.

Where do we draw the line?
At what point in this, do we do more harm than good?

Is it possible that when we approach these situations from the position of ridicule, insults, etc that we actually scare these people away from us, instead of away from danger?

Scaring them away isn't a bad idea, if they're in your yard.
Ironically, I scare off the Witness's by having lots of witchy art hanging around the entry.
The periodic table of the elements runs off the organitrons.

I want them all off my lawn, like yesterday.
 
Is it possible that when we approach these situations from the position of ridicule, insults, etc that we actually scare these people away from us, instead of away from danger?

Yet again the point is that this people are already well and lost and any attempt to save them is futile.

I've given up on the Woo Slingers as individuals for the most part. I'm no longer trying to save the Woo Slingers from themselves. I spent the better part of a decade doing that and at best accomplished nothing.

What I'm trying to do now is save the rest of us from the Woo Slingers. If the possibility shows itself that I can do that by helping them out of their intellectual death spirals so be it, such occasions are wonderful but so rare as to be statistically meaningless.

What you have to understand is that for all practical purposes I have abandoned the Woo Slingers to their own stupidity and as time passes I feel less and less guilty about doing so. We're talking people that went to school, hold down jobs, interact normally in society, have access to the internet and libraries, and have had the same opportunity presented to them as to the rest of us to not be an clueless window licker. If they choose to wallow in self enforced ignorance so be it. I frankly can no longer spare the effort of banging my head against the latest brick wall in the vein hope that this brick wall will finally be the one I knock down before the lose of blood from the wounds in my head force me into delirium.

It's horrible. It's cruel. A big part of me still feels bad about saying it but I just can't care about them anymore. Believe me I take no pleasure in this. I would give anything to rekindle that hope but I simply cannot. If that makes me cynical, jaded, a bastard whatever. I've been called worse for less valid reasons and I can still sleep at night.

My main concern now is protecting the masses from the idiotic minority that should no better but chooses not to because thinking is just too hard for them.

The more stupid there is out there the harder it is to filter it out. No one is so rational as they can survive intellectually in a world in which stupidity is the norm. No B.S. filter is perfect. If 99% of popular opinions are factually wrong no matter how good you are filtering information a lot is going to leak through that's just reality. Across the board high intellectual standards making coming to the correct conclusion easier on all of us.
 
I feel much the same as JoeBentley, except, for me, the slinging of woo comes in the form of mainstream economics and politics. The idiocy burns, especially when the occasional bright and decent person gets dragged down into the mindless charade.

In my hick zone, the Bible thumpers are the least of the worry.
Fox News, and an utter lack of curiosity is the problem.
I could care less about Jesus coming back, or how pissed he is.

I'm worried about Hitler coming back.
 
I'm worried about Hitler coming back.

Last I heard he is stewing in a cryo-vat next to Walt Disney.
I dunno... If I had to choose the lesser of 2 evils...
:eek:

More seriously, I see where you're coming from JoeB.
Heck I even understand it (Translatable experiences in my line of work etc).
I can sympathize with the situation, you having done this for longer than I have, most likely.

I am just cautious (maybe misguidedly) to making ourselves seem even worse than the believers.
Some certainly act worse on occasion...

Looking crazy, foaming at the mouth, is not exactly the picture you wanna paint to a fencer within a situation. He might just opt to go for the woo side on the basis that the science side folks seem iguana piss crazy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom