Is Mainstream Skepticism turning into Fanaticism?

Wheunis, I've now read some of your posting history, and I'd answer your question with: No, but skeptics who've been around the merry-go-round tend to get cynical.

Let me explain: It is actually a fairly common tactic for believers to use an argument that goes more or less like this:
"Hahaa! You just admitted that you can't absolutely prove I'm wrong, so I can say [wildly unsupported assertion] and you can't do anything about it."

Seeing how this argument requires a set-up in which a skeptic is led to explain, for the umpteenth time, that (s)he can't be 100% certain about things, you may come to understand that what you were doing in some of your previous posts is suspiciously like this set-up.
 
Last edited:
Which of these are YOU?

I'm the skeptic. You seem to be the whiner, but I'm willing to be open-minded about it.

You're not a skeptic. You're a fanatic.

About what ? Skepticism ? Sure.

Me: Hey, Don't you think there could be REALLY big things in there?
You: Obviously some bigger than others, how big did you have in mind?
Me: Oh, I figure there might be stuff in there as large as Pluto, maybe bigger.
You: Wait, PLANETS inside the belt?!
Me: Yeah. I think it's possible.
You: I don't.
Me: Well, I'm gonna go peek at it some more, see if I can fund some scope for it.
You: Don't waste your time. It's impossible.
Me: What is impossible? Getting funding?
You: No. It is impossible for anything THAT large to be in there.

That's odd. I've been here since 2005 and I never had the impression that this kind of close-mindedness was the norm. Maybe you're cherry-picking.
 
You're not a skeptic. You're a fanatic.
About what ? Skepticism ? Sure.

Bob: Ted are you a mathmatician or a fanatic?
Ted: Errr... a mathmatician I guess.
Bob: I see. Does 2+2=4?
Ted: Well yeah it does.
Bob: Are you sure of that?
Ted: Of course I am.
Bob: FANATIC!

Wheunis, I've now read some of your posting history, and I'd answer your question with: No, but skeptics who've been around the merry-go-round tend to get cynical.

I wouldn't say I'm cynical. I just learned to recognize patterns, woo language, and such and have no desire to keep having the same discussons over and over.

Let me explain: It is actually a fairly common tactic for believers to use an argument that goes more or less like this:
"Hahaa! You just admitted that you can't absolutely prove I'm wrong, so I can say [wildly unsupported assertion] and you can't do anything about it."

H'ethetheth is right. This is just the latest variation on the sad old "You need to be skeptical of skepticism!" special pleading that seems to pop up routinely.

Seeing how this argument requires a set-up in which a skeptic is led to explain, for the umpteenth time, that (s)he can't be 100% certain about things, you may come to understand that what you were doing in some of your previous posts is suspiciously like this set-up.

And let's not dance around the elephant in the room. That's exactly what the OP was, yet another sad, clumsy attempt at trapping people that hold reasonable intellectual standards in some sort of solipsistic "gotcha."

Bob: Do you know everything with 100% absolute certainty?
Ted: Of course not.
Bob: Ah ha! You fell into my clever trap. You can't know everything, therefore woo.

I know this dance, I know the steps, and I know how it ends.

And honestly the "People are mean for expecting me to have evidence for things I say and won't let me make up woo." chestnut got old a long, long, long time ago.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't say I'm cynical. I just learned to recognize patterns, woo language, and such and have no desire to keep having the same discussons over and over.

H'ethetheth is right. This is just the latest variation on the sad old "You need to be skeptical of skepticism!" special pleading that seems to pop up routinely.

And let's not dance around the elephant in the room. That's exactly what the OP was, yet another sad, clumsy attempt at trapping people that hold reasonable intellectual standards in some sort of solipsistic "gotcha."
And this is exactly what I mean by cynical. :)

I say this because I'm fairly confident that this is not what the OP is. I suspect he is one of the rare skeptics who explains skepticism to skeptics, and then gets disappointed by the two possible reactions to this, namely confusion and suspicion of alternate motives or general grumpiness.

ETA: By the way, I'm aware I may have to eat the above words, should the circumstances arise, and then I too shall have to become cynical and disillusioned.
 
Last edited:
I say this because I'm fairly confident that this is not what the OP is. I suspect he is one of the rare skeptics who explains skepticism to skeptics, and then gets disappointed by the two possible reactions to this, namely confusion and suspicion of alternate motives or general grumpiness.

ETA: By the way, I'm aware I may have to eat the above words, should the circumstances arise, and then I too shall have to become cynical and disillusioned.

I'm, of course, open to the possibility that I am wrong as to the OPs motives. I however am not optimistic.

I've never seen the "But you can't be sure!" appeal come anywhere except from woo. If I'm wrong I'm wrong, but this will be the first time.
 
And this is exactly what I mean by cynical. :)

I say this because I'm fairly confident that this is not what the OP is. I suspect he is one of the rare skeptics who explains skepticism to skeptics, and then gets disappointed by the two possible reactions to this, namely confusion and suspicion of alternate motives or general grumpiness.

ETA: By the way, I'm aware I may have to eat the above words, should the circumstances arise, and then I too shall have to become cynical and disillusioned.

The problem with the OP is that he (IMHO) is trying to hold skepticism in these boards to the same high standard as the scientific method. He feels that skepticism needs to be 100% all the time, with no room for emotion, when really this is just a forum full of human beings.

Also, I agree with you about cynicism, the problem is people don't disassociate cynicism of one act with being a cynic.
 
I'm, of course, open to the possibility that I am wrong as to the OPs motives. I however am not optimistic.

I've never seen the "But you can't be sure!" appeal come anywhere except from woo. If I'm wrong I'm wrong, but this will be the first time.
So you're saying you're not cynical, but just pessimistic about him because you've been disillusioned by frequent disappointments?

:D
 
Last edited:
Wheunis, I've now read some of your posting history, and I'd answer your question with: No, but skeptics who've been around the merry-go-round tend to get cynical.

Let me explain: It is actually a fairly common tactic for believers to use an argument that goes more or less like this:
"Hahaa! You just admitted that you can't absolutely prove I'm wrong, so I can say [wildly unsupported assertion] and you can't do anything about it."

Seeing how this argument requires a set-up in which a skeptic is led to explain, for the umpteenth time, that (s)he can't be 100% certain about things, you may come to understand that what you were doing in some of your previous posts is suspiciously like this set-up.
And there's the classic "I don't believe this myself, but it's making the rounds so I thought I'd ask you guys what you thought about it." In some cases it's a genuine position, but it's been abused enough to trigger cynicism in the veteran reader.
 
The problem with the OP is that he (IMHO) is trying to hold skepticism in these boards to the same high standard as the scientific method. He feels that skepticism needs to be 100% all the time, with no room for emotion, when really this is just a forum full of human beings.

Also, I agree with you about cynicism, the problem is people don't disassociate cynicism of one act with being a cynic.
Certainly. But if he's the young whipper snapper I think he is, he'll see soon enough.

Unless, of course, he continues on this confrontational course and follows up his explanations of skepticism by more vehement explanations of skepticism, in which case I foresee a huffy departure.
 
Last edited:
And there's the classic "I don't believe this myself, but it's making the rounds so I thought I'd ask you guys what you thought about it." In some cases it's a genuine position, but it's been abused enough to trigger cynicism in the veteran reader.
Yup, very true, that.
 
Being the devil's advocate, hypotheticals, thought experiments, and just good old fashioned, plain "throwing something out there" are all fine rhetorical devices and ways to start an discussion and keep one going. I have no problem with them in theory and often use them myself.

However certain tones and wording in certain instances of their use do cause my Skep-dar to go from passive to active ping.
 
Last edited:
We could gen up a list of cliched "starter lines", I think.

"Now I don't believe ..... but I know folks who do" and the like. Perhaps a "Before you post, here are some lines to avoid." list?

Add to the list:

"just got send this video, what do you guys think?"

Which is usually replied with "What do YOU think?"

Then there is the casual "I heard about this so and so, anyone know any specifics?" When the links to whatever so and so give ALL of the specifics.
 
But if there's someone out there who's genuinely interested in what we'd think about this or that etc, they're not going to feel very encouraged, are they? I think this is a question of not becoming cynical too quickly, or at least pretending not to be cynical.
In fact, I think if you pretend not to be cynical when you are, it will become apparent sooner if you're dealing with a genuine person or a disingenuous kook.
What's more, if you were right to be cynical, you can feel good about yourself afterward, and if you're wrong, you will have been a friendly person to someone.

That's my take, though I realize your mileage may vary.

ETA: Hehehe. I just noticed this thread by a poster named "skepticalnotcynical" asking pretty much one of these red flag questions.
 
Last edited:
Do you have any real case to illustrate your point with, instead of you imagining what you think is the case?

Yes, I suppose I do.
But as a newly active user, I don't think that calling people out by name would be a necessarily good move towards making friends...

You think calling out the entire forum with a straw man is a better approach?

A rather vast majority of people who call themselves skeptics, would actually not be as skeptic as they claim themselves to be.
Behaviorally, on these forums, I have noticed a rather disturbing trend.

I've noticed a disturbing trend as well. The extremes in any online debate are more vocal and more noticable and they tend to discourage participants who prefer rational debate without what they see as unnecessary and provocative (even when true) replies of the "no, you're wrong"-flavour.

What I haven't done is conclude from this that this vocal group consists of A rather vast majority of the participants. To come to such a conclusion I'd need more than notice a trend. Jumping from "trend" to "everyone's a fanatic" is wholly unskeptical. And even if they were a rather vast majority I wouldn't conclude that their forum behaviour necessarily implies that they are fanatics rather than skeptics.

Even if your example had taken place on this forum there could be other explanations. It could be that the seemingly close minded participant had dozens of discussions and hundreds of contributions under his belt with people proposing planets outside Pluto and jumping on his "well, there's no evidence and our current models make it unlikely, but the models aren't perfect and absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence" with "So you admit there are more planets, and then you have to agree they account for the discrepancies of astrology" or "that's where the greys come from".

It could also be he was just an ornery dick who prefered an unnuanced and formally incorrect mode of communication.

Both can be argued to be detrimental to the environment of the debate (although the latter character won't care, and the first may not always be able to stop himself... or care) but you need a lot more evidence than noticing a trend and jumping to conclusions to present it as an actual trend of fanaticism.

And just to add another fallacy to your burden: Equating this forum with "Mainstream Skepticism"? Really?
 
Last edited:
Science on the other hand starts by not stating, but asking "is it possible?"

No it doesn't. Science asks "What evidence do we have so far, and what conclusions can I come to based on that?". The idea that we should never state any conclusions just because we're not absolutely 100% sure of something is utterly incorrect, and seems to come mostly from people who aren't happy about a pet belief being dismissed due to lack of evidence.

Creating imaginary energies out of nowhere just to fit the model.

Can I take it from this that you dismiss at least some accepted particle physics or cosmology, and that your rant against skeptics is based on being called out as a crackpot?

But as a newly active user, I don't think that calling people out by name would be a necessarily good move towards making friends...

Whereas obviously calling everyone a non-skeptical fanatic is going to make you tons of friends.:boggled:

I tell you right now, THAT exchange was NOT between 2 scientists of skeptic nature. THAT conversation has 1 fanatic in it...

There was exactly one person in that conversation - you. According to your own claim, there was one fanatic in it. Interesting.
 
You can't prove we don't turn into cup cakes when we die.

Yeah but we keep making that point over and over to the Woo Slingers and the Woo Apologists and it never seems to stick.

They continue to use "But you can't know for sure!" as their shield, their trump card, their pancea.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom