Is Mainstream Skepticism turning into Fanaticism?

Yeah but we keep making that point over and over to the Woo Slingers and the Woo Apologists and it never seems to stick.

They continue to use "But you can't know for sure!" as their shield, their trump card, their pancea.

Because they think certain claims you "can't prove" just sound more plausible than other things, but they don't understand what that means for the argument that you can't prove a negative therefore you cannot be skeptical of a claim. But they are blind to the fact they are ruling something out based on it's level of probability they perceive, namely that people turning into cup cakes is just too absurd to consider.

It's amazing to see them do anything BUT explain why turning into a cup cake is absurd but turning into a spirit is not. They seem to rely on what is self evident while ignoring their cultural conditioning.
 
It's amazing to see them do anything BUT explain why turning into a cup cake is absurd but turning into a spirit is not. They seem to rely on what is self evident while ignoring their cultural conditioning.

Which now that I think about it, tying this back into the whole "Skeptics are mean" argument, is where some of the perception comes from.

I will admit that on occasion I will draw attention to the logical problems in Woo by pointing out it's absurdities, which to be fair I can understand from the surface might look like I'm "mocking" these beliefs.

Things like the Invisible Pink Unicorn, Russell's Teapot, Rastafarianism, Sagan's Invisible Garage Dragon, etc are mean to point out the absurdities of religious beliefs on an intellectual level, not mock them on an emotional one.

But I do sympathize with how unclear that distinction might be to some people.
 
...



I wouldn't say I'm cynical. I just learned to recognize patterns, woo language, and such and have no desire to keep having the same discussons over and over.


...
.
Yes, there's a lot of people who will donate their forum time to beating the dead horse of woo language.. out of a desire to set the goofball on the straight and narrow.
I bet we've all got stuff in DOC's thread that will never die, none of which has made a iota of difference. :)
 
I'm, of course, open to the possibility that I am wrong as to the OPs motives. I however am not optimistic.

I've never seen the "But you can't be sure!" appeal come anywhere except from woo. If I'm wrong I'm wrong, but this will be the first time.
.
That's my impression too. He's not a skeptic per se, almost a woo proselityzer hoping to score some sorta points somehow.
 
Which now that I think about it, tying this back into the whole "Skeptics are mean" argument, is where some of the perception comes from.

I will admit that on occasion I will draw attention to the logical problems in Woo by pointing out it's absurdities, which to be fair I can understand from the surface might look like I'm "mocking" these beliefs.

Things like the Invisible Pink Unicorn, Russell's Teapot, Rastafarianism, Sagan's Invisible Garage Dragon, etc are mean to point out the absurdities of religious beliefs on an intellectual level, not mock them on an emotional one.

But I do sympathize with how unclear that distinction might be to some people.

Actually, Bentley - apart from your first post in this thread, you conduct yourself rather exemplary. I personally do not feel that use of Russel's pot and the likes are wrong or demeaning.
If anything, they offer the believers something else to look at. Something to consider. Something uncomplicated, but infinite in depth.

The sorts of responses that comes of wholly uncouth, is more frequently of the 1-line nature as example: "Really?! We doing this **** AGAIN now?!"
Variations included, I saw that one response from 3 different people in one thread, with 9 other responses backing it up.

Is that how we operate? We belittle, insult, and gang up on the poor fella? Chase him away for good so he never comes back again?
...
And here I thought most of us have some inner will to help people get rid of these false thoughts, bad conclusions, and superstitious woo.
How exactly then, does alienating the exact people we should be helping, contribute to that cause?


Secondly, I had such a neat multi-quote going on from the previous page's posts, sadly I have lost them in paging over.
So anyway - You need not worry.
I am not in this thread to discuss anything other than just the way people discuss (or for that matter DONT) certain topics with woo's, believers, other skeptics, and devil's advocates.

With that said, a fair warning is probably warranted.
I am not a believer. I do not believe in any particular phenomena. I am willing to consider certain unknowns as unknowns. I am willing to speculate on someone's suggestions, thoughts, or contributions, regardless of how insignificant.
I consider myself truly open-minded. I do not personally believe that UFO's are visiting us en-masse, or abducting people.
The difference is, I am willing to entertain the notion in order to hear somebody else's view.
Difference is, I am willing (from time to time) to play devil's advocate to issues, and play the role I might not necessarily support myself.

But never, not ever, do I BELIEVE in some magical juju monster that flies amazing crafts, plants gorilla robots in the forests, sets up gunmen to kill presidents, then crashes in the desert and brainwashes army officials into covering it up - thus achieving his master plan on blowing up the twin towers decades later, successfully shifting the blame to 16 Saudi innocents.

Lol, that juju monster has been quite busy.

Difference between a skeptic and fanatic is - I would actually take the time of day to engage such a believer at equal level, instead of automatically assuming that he is lower than dirt, with no truth to be found anywhere.
At the very least, he might even accidentally bring something up that makes me think on a completely different matter in a different light...
 
Most of the people I have engaged on this site are not critical thinkers. They are knee jerk cynics with agendas to push which is not at all the same as skepticism. In fact one of my very first threads on this site was about exactly this observation.

There are many very intelligent critical thinkers on here. And the level of this site is light years ahead of most of the people on other sites I've gone to where people are basically lemmings of the media.

But in general many people on here are narrow in their line of study (if they have any real academic background at all) and are biased. They are then blind to their own bias so it is very difficult to have meaningful dialogue. Sardonic comments are often taken at face value. The term "troll" is thrown around quite a bit. Engaging in debate in a sort of "let's look at both sides" comes across to many as trolling. Or pretending to really hold personal views of atheism but secretly being a fundy.

I'll go away for long periods of time when I notice my disgust seeping into my posts because this is probably the most intelligent general discussion board I've ever joined. But it's quite sad to be confronted with lack of logic and reasoning and critical thinking on a regular basis.
 
When I read posts like yours, truethat, I always wonder why that never happens to me. Yes, there are people in any thread who have their opinion ready and stick to it, but I've somehow always been able to have intelligent discussions. Snide, sometimes perhaps, but never mean-spirited. Maybe you take too much personally.
 
When I read posts like yours, truethat, I always wonder why that never happens to me. Yes, there are people in any thread who have their opinion ready and stick to it, but I've somehow always been able to have intelligent discussions. Snide, sometimes perhaps, but never mean-spirited. Maybe you take too much personally.

Mostly because I like to discuss opinions I don't necessarily agree with as a way of trying to understand the other side a bit better. It's easier to just say believers are idiots and dust your hands of the whole thing. When you do that on here you are treated golden. But when you try to really try to understand the views of others, prepare for the backlash.

I don't really remember any of your posts. Could also be the topic of discussion.
 
Even knowing that the Journalist's information is a lie, by proven tests etc - Should we allow ourselves such lowblows and cheapshots just to swing the argument our way?

That is the heart of the issue on these forums. Far too many people are here for the entertainment of being seen as right, well above actually being right. The first part is easy, its the second part that takes all the effort.

An honest intellectual conversation requires a lot of give and take and asking what the other person meant, and going out of your way to not get them in a gotcha moment. What we have here is the opposite with a sprinkling of good will.

I see it as fairly standard on the internet. Many are just here to troll to one degree or another along a troll spectrum.

Even the quick little posts here in this thread are just people wanting to feel good about having some kind of answer, even if its meaningless, trite, and snarky they feel justified in posting.

This is true of all of us from one degree to another, however if your mission statement is to get to the heart of a topic, have only true statements, and put your ego second then you can be a good poster without the standard chip on the shoulder responses we see so often.

You are never going to find a person without bias, however you will find people who place ego, and snark a distance second to attaining true information, and presenting honest opinions devoid of gotcha tactics.
 
Last edited:
Mostly because I like to discuss opinions I don't necessarily agree with as a way of trying to understand the other side a bit better. It's easier to just say believers are idiots and dust your hands of the whole thing. When you do that on here you are treated golden. But when you try to really try to understand the views of others, prepare for the backlash.

I don't really remember any of your posts. Could also be the topic of discussion.
Yeah, I'm not what you call prolific, and I've spent most of my time on science and philiosophy threads. I don't think we've crossed paths much. Oh, and I pretty much steer clear of the politics section. :)

But about playing devils advocate, that is a fine line to tread in discussions with people who don't know you. I can imagine people getting confused, especially because it is popular among woos to start off under ambiguous pretenses, though I admire your reasons for doing so.
 
That is the heart of the issue on these forums. Far too many people are here for the entertainment of being seen as right, well above actually being right. The first part is easy, its the second part that takes all the effort.

An honest intellectual conversation requires a lot of give and take and asking what the other person meant, and going out of your way to not get them in a gotcha moment. What we have here is the opposite with a sprinkling of good will.

I see it as fairly standard on the internet. Many are just here to troll to one degree or another along a troll spectrum.

Even the quick little posts here in this thread are just people wanting to feel good about having some kind of answer, even if its meaningless, trite, and snarky they feel justified in posting.

This is true of all of us from one degree to another, however if your mission statement is to get to the heart of a topic, have only true statements, and put your ego second then you can be a good poster without the standard chip on the shoulder responses we see so often.

You are never going to find a person without bias, however you will find people who place ego, and snark a distance second to attaining true information, and presenting honest opinions devoid of gotcha tactics.
The thing to do, though, is not to complain but to ignore posts without content and focus on the intelligent replies, because they're always there.
 
The thing to do, though, is not to complain but to ignore posts without content and focus on the intelligent replies, because they're always there.

Yeah, probably a skill I am going to have to develop.
Ignore, I mean...

I've never been the sort to ignore the negative, just because it doesn't suit me... I enjoy the negative. I like people not necessarily agreeing with me.

That said, you wont convince me into the Political subforum either.
 
Having been a lurking reader for some relatively medium amount of time, I have seen some quite horrible reponses from so-called skeptics on this Forum.

So I decided against debating this further within those threads, but instead (as appropriate), separate that discussion into it's own thread.

First and foremost, some definitions, as to make my intent and point come across as clear as possible.
I do however encourage any discussion of these definitions as well!

Skeptic:
A person that challenges knowledge, until nothing but truth remains.
Skeptics will normally accept no information as-is, but rather disseminate the given information for fallacies, misinformation, falsehoods, and other inconsistencies - until nothing remains but that which is reliable, provable, and quantifiable as true.
These same values (SHOULD) hold true in challenging the information generally thought to be previously true.

Fanatic:
A person that blindly accepts and/or believes information presented to him.
Fanatics will normally accept any reasonable sounding information, without investigating claims made therein.
Moreover, they will often refuse to see the errors within such information, even when such errors are presented in clear form.
The values of fanatics within previously proven information can vary from situation to situation, as it suits their beliefs.


Which of these are YOU?
If I were a betting man, 90%+ of forum-goers here would loudly proclaim themselves as skeptics. Those same people would take a great offense to what I am about to say.

You're not a skeptic. You're a fanatic.
A rather vast majority of people who call themselves skeptics, would actually not be as skeptic as they claim themselves to be.
Behaviorally, on these forums, I have noticed a rather disturbing trend.

The trend of "No, not now, not ever, impossible".

It's quite easy to spot he divide where skeptics fanatics end, and skeptics start.

A little short story, let's rewind and imagine we are there, at that time.

The Kuiper Belt was "discovered" in the late 1980's. (1987 I think - damn you I'm lazy right now!)
The hypothesis of it's existence has long since been discussed, however.

(The following is an imagine scenario, mixed with factual information)
From that point on, many scientists have been investigating this belt.
At some point, I was one of them.
The following exchange took place between me and you:

Me: Hey, Don't you think there could be REALLY big things in there?
You: Obviously some bigger than others, how big did you have in mind?
Me: Oh, I figure there might be stuff in there as large as Pluto, maybe bigger.
You: Wait, PLANETS inside the belt?!
Me: Yeah. I think it's possible.
You: I don't.
Me: Well, I'm gonna go peek at it some more, see if I can fund some scope for it.
You: Don't waste your time. It's impossible.
Me: What is impossible? Getting funding?
You: No. It is impossible for anything THAT large to be in there.


Turns out, you would have been dead wrong. Even more than just finding what you said was impossible, MULTIPLE such objects were found. One of them even turned out to have become one of Neptune's moons looooooooong ago.

So. The hypothetical You in that conversation...
Do you think he acted skeptically, or fanatically?

I tell you right now, THAT exchange was NOT between 2 scientists of skeptic nature. THAT conversation has 1 fanatic in it...


Is it really ethical for us, here in this forum, to behave that way?
Are we just committing the same crimes as the woo-salesmen by preying on people's weaknesses?
Did you discredit a source of possible information to a fanatic because he was a Journalist; Fully knowing that the fanatic might discard that source because he is distrustful of Journalists?

Even knowing that the Journalist's information is a lie, by proven tests etc - Should we allow ourselves such lowblows and cheapshots just to swing the argument our way?
Shouldn't we, the skeptics, take the high road and maintain to disprove the fallacies by scientific method, instead of just leaning on "because I already know"?

Just because you already know, does not mean that everyone should know.
Dismissing questions about it, theories around it, or discussions into it is NOT how I think we should conduct ourselves.

Anyway, just my take on how we, here in this forum, are fast behaving more and more like the enemies we have sworn to conquer.

No. I am a skeptic. Show me proof that somethings exists and I will believe in the existence of said something. It's as simple as that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom