Is Mainstream Skepticism turning into Fanaticism?

Most of the people I have engaged on this site are not critical thinkers. They are knee jerk cynics with agendas to push which is not at all the same as skepticism. In fact one of my very first threads on this site was about exactly this observation.

There are many very intelligent critical thinkers on here. And the level of this site is light years ahead of most of the people on other sites I've gone to where people are basically lemmings of the media.

But in general many people on here are narrow in their line of study (if they have any real academic background at all) and are biased. They are then blind to their own bias so it is very difficult to have meaningful dialogue. Sardonic comments are often taken at face value. The term "troll" is thrown around quite a bit. Engaging in debate in a sort of "let's look at both sides" comes across to many as trolling. Or pretending to really hold personal views of atheism but secretly being a fundy.

I'll go away for long periods of time when I notice my disgust seeping into my posts because this is probably the most intelligent general discussion board I've ever joined. But it's quite sad to be confronted with lack of logic and reasoning and critical thinking on a regular basis.

Sorry guv, I never 'ad no heducation.
 
So asking for evidence of a claim is proof of an inability to think logically? I don't think so.
 
No. I am a skeptic. Show me proof that somethings exists and I will believe in the existence of said something. It's as simple as that.

Seems simple. Yet so many have trouble with this.
 
So asking for evidence of a claim is proof of an inability to think logically? I don't think so.

And where did I elude to this drivel?

I have no problem with people responding as such.

What I do have a problem with, is when they don't even bother to do as much. Dismissive from the start, regardless of premise, topic, or any other such.

Apart from that, asking for evidence is by no means a bad response. But at the same time, you're not really contributing much in a DISCUSSION at the same time.
Just something to consider...

Maybe you could actually ADD SOMETHING to the discussion by instead trying a response like:
"Look, Jeff, if you can produce a data-set from tests, that shows at least X% outcome of larger peaches when grown while people are praying for them, then it will go a long way towards your premise."

Don't you agree that it's rather presumptuous, not to mention arrogant, for us to expect new entrants into the forums, discussion, or otherwise to simply just know how it should be done?
If we believe instead, as probably quite a few "intellectuals" do, that Joe Public has no business in these affairs, I invite such people to breeze on by their closest active volcano and take a leap...
 
And where did I elude to this drivel?

I have no problem with people responding as such.

What I do have a problem with, is when they don't even bother to do as much. Dismissive from the start, regardless of premise, topic, or any other such.

Apart from that, asking for evidence is by no means a bad response. But at the same time, you're not really contributing much in a DISCUSSION at the same time.
Just something to consider...

Maybe you could actually ADD SOMETHING to the discussion by instead trying a response like:
"Look, Jeff, if you can produce a data-set from tests, that shows at least X% outcome of larger peaches when grown while people are praying for them, then it will go a long way towards your premise."

Don't you agree that it's rather presumptuous, not to mention arrogant, for us to expect new entrants into the forums, discussion, or otherwise to simply just know how it should be done?
If we believe instead, as probably quite a few "intellectuals" do, that Joe Public has no business in these affairs, I invite such people to breeze on by their closest active volcano and take a leap...

I did not say that you eluded it. Asking for proof a claim of say, telepathy is not drivel. How you you deal with such a claim? I don't see that there is much to discuss. Skeptics are a diverse group of people, some of them may be fanatics. I'm not, I am just very skeptical about paranormal claims. When I was younger I did believe in the paranormal but age and experience has shown me that not a shred of evidence exists for such claims. As for new entrants here, all are welcome but if they claim to be able to perform telekinesis, telepathy, clairvoyance and suchlike surely it is not surprising if they are asked to back up their claim? This is a skeptic's site, what else do they expect?
 
Last edited:
I did not say that you eluded it. Asking for proof a claim of say, telepathy is not drivel. How you you deal with such a claim?

Coincidentally amazing you would ask. Was considering that same question for the last few hours myself.
Mostly to engage it into another conversation here...

Well, as much as I can gather, telepathy by the claims of it's proponents varies greatly. Hard to pull definition out of it that will always be the same.
What I have found, however, in almost EVERY single proponent, is that they elude to some "transfer". Most commonly this transfer is in reference to "thoughts". And in the vast majority of cases, when asked about thoughts, the answer is typically that thoughts are a sort of energy.

So, really, it's quite simple.

"Show me the energy transfer!"
You tell Jeff:
Set up the test. Pick your energy meter. Place between 2 people. Place THOUSANDS of them!
Make sure to document each meter's position
...
<im gonna snip the obvious testing protocols>
...
and then come back to me with your test results, showing the energy meters read and register this energy being transferred.


Problem with the claim in itself is the same problem as us blindly refusing it as possible.
Of course something is possible!
But to be recognized as REAL it needs to be proven.

We refuse to even consider something as possible, long before we even choose anything else.
We all, myself included, much too often just jump the impossible gun. We don't know that it is, in fact, impossible.

It would be wise for us to remember, that a century ago, what we are doing right now was impossible too...

Am I now suddenly saying that I believe in Telepathy?
No. I do not.
I am saying however, that I am willing to engage is constructive discussion with someone on the topic.
I am saying that, given the chance, I would participate and cooperate FULLY in designing, taking part (if required), and investigating the topic - should the discussion lead to a point where investigation becomes warranted.

But, above all, I am not so shut-in that I would stand on the sidelines, as most skeptics do - pointing, laughing, and ridiculing their actions...
At no point in the history of ever did that help anyone achieve anything, other than being a successful dick...
 
Coincidentally amazing you would ask. Was considering that same question for the last few hours myself.
Mostly to engage it into another conversation here...

Well, as much as I can gather, telepathy by the claims of it's proponents varies greatly. Hard to pull definition out of it that will always be the same.
What I have found, however, in almost EVERY single proponent, is that they elude to some "transfer". Most commonly this transfer is in reference to "thoughts". And in the vast majority of cases, when asked about thoughts, the answer is typically that thoughts are a sort of energy.

So, really, it's quite simple.

"Show me the energy transfer!"
You tell Jeff:
Set up the test. Pick your energy meter. Place between 2 people. Place THOUSANDS of them!
Make sure to document each meter's position
...
<im gonna snip the obvious testing protocols>
...
and then come back to me with your test results, showing the energy meters read and register this energy being transferred.


Problem with the claim in itself is the same problem as us blindly refusing it as possible.
Of course something is possible!
But to be recognized as REAL it needs to be proven.

We refuse to even consider something as possible, long before we even choose anything else.
We all, myself included, much too often just jump the impossible gun. We don't know that it is, in fact, impossible.

It would be wise for us to remember, that a century ago, what we are doing right now was impossible too...

Am I now suddenly saying that I believe in Telepathy?
No. I do not.
I am saying however, that I am willing to engage is constructive discussion with someone on the topic.
I am saying that, given the chance, I would participate and cooperate FULLY in designing, taking part (if required), and investigating the topic - should the discussion lead to a point where investigation becomes warranted.

But, above all, I am not so shut-in that I would stand on the sidelines, as most skeptics do - pointing, laughing, and ridiculing their actions...
At no point in the history of ever did that help anyone achieve anything, other than being a successful dick...

In my experience here the pointing and laughing occurs after protracted discussions, and not everyone indulges in it. I would disagree with your statement that most skeptics do this. It is usually the paranormal claimants who start the insults.
 
Last edited:
Am I now suddenly saying that I believe in Telepathy?
No. I do not.
I am saying however, that I am willing to engage is constructive discussion with someone on the topic.
I am saying that, given the chance, I would participate and cooperate FULLY in designing, taking part (if required), and investigating the topic - should the discussion lead to a point where investigation becomes warranted.

But, above all, I am not so shut-in that I would stand on the sidelines, as most skeptics do - pointing, laughing, and ridiculing their actions...
At no point in the history of ever did that help anyone achieve anything, other than being a successful dick...

Typical JREF thread #1

initially anonymous extraordinary claimant: I have telepathic powers, look, here is some weak evidence
skeptics: no sorry that is not enough evidence, we're not convinced
extraordinary claimant: I AM THE GREAT CORNHOLIO!!!! (posts link to personal website)
skeptics: sod off

Typical JREF thread #2

extraordinary claimant: is telepathy possible? Look, here is some weak evidence, I'm not saying I believe it myself, my friends believes it, blah
skeptics: no sorry that is not enough evidence, we're not convinced
extraordinary claimant: meanies
skeptics: please provide evidence for telepathy. Study x, y, z did not find anything
extraordinary claimant: FANATICS!!!!

Typical JREF thread #3

extraordinary claimant: prove to me thermite cannot have brought down WTC7
skeptics: prove to us it does.
extraordinary claimant: you're government truthers, nur nur
skeptics: oh grow up
extraordinary claimant: [trolls until suspended]
 
In my experience here the pointing and laughing occurs after protracted discussions, and not everyone indulges in it. I would disagree with your statement that most skeptics do this. It is usually the paranormal claimants who start the insults.

I do not dispute that, either.
But this discussion is about OUR conduct, not theirs...

Even if they did throw the first stone, does that justify anything we do in retaliation?

Besides, how do you expect a person to react when their beliefs are being torn apart right in front of them?
Heck, even Einstein acted like a child with the whole (starting of) Quantum debate...
 
Typical JREF thread #1

initially anonymous extraordinary claimant: I have telepathic powers, look, here is some weak evidence
skeptics: no sorry that is not enough evidence, we're not convinced
extraordinary claimant: I AM THE GREAT CORNHOLIO!!!! (posts link to personal website)
skeptics: sod off

Typical JREF thread #2

extraordinary claimant: is telepathy possible? Look, here is some weak evidence, I'm not saying I believe it myself, my friends believes it, blah
skeptics: no sorry that is not enough evidence, we're not convinced
extraordinary claimant: meanies
skeptics: please provide evidence for telepathy. Study x, y, z did not find anything
extraordinary claimant: FANATICS!!!!

Typical JREF thread #3

extraordinary claimant: prove to me thermite cannot have brought down WTC7
skeptics: prove to us it does.
extraordinary claimant: you're government truthers, nur nur
skeptics: oh grow up
extraordinary claimant: [trolls until suspended]

If the skeptics are the ones doing the pointing and laughing and insulting, why is it that the paranormal claimants often end up being suspended? A very good summary of the usual woo thread, by the way.
 
I do not dispute that, either.
But this discussion is about OUR conduct, not theirs...

Even if they did throw the first stone, does that justify anything we do in retaliation?

Besides, how do you expect a person to react when their beliefs are being torn apart right in front of them?
Heck, even Einstein acted like a child with the whole (starting of) Quantum debate...

Sometimes you have to be cruel to be kind. If they can't stand the heat then let them depart from the kitchen and head for the David Icke site.
 
Last edited:
If the skeptics are the ones doing the pointing and laughing and insulting, why is it that the paranormal claimants often end up being suspended? .

probably got something to do with the woo only being able to report one poster at a time, if they even know about the report function versus scores of reports against them whenever they retaliate, which tends to be over the top because theyre getting mobbed

Suspension usually follows, its a warning isn't it, change your behaviour or the next one will be permanent. Thats when they usually complain a little too vociferously by mail about how unfair it is and get banned

Sauce for the goose really, I've been banned from pretty much every pseudo history forum on the web for posting the facts
:D
 
probably got something to do with the woo only being able to report one poster at a time, if they even know about the report function versus scores of reports against them whenever they retaliate, which tends to be over the top because theyre getting mobbed

Suspension usually follows, its a warning isn't it, change your behaviour or the next one will be permanent. Thats when they usually complain a little too vociferously by mail about how unfair it is and get banned

Sauce for the goose really, I've been banned from pretty much every pseudo history forum on the web for posting the facts
:D

I am banned for life from the David Icke site. It's an honour.
 
Typical JREF thread #3

extraordinary claimant: prove to me thermite cannot have brought down WTC7
skeptics: prove to us it does.
extraordinary claimant: you're government truthers, nur nur
skeptics: oh grow up
extraordinary claimant: [trolls until suspended]
A decent example. If I may, however, just point out what I mean?
I understand this is just a hypothetical discussion example, but do you agree with the following?

Instead of "prove to us that it does", wouldn't the better response from a true sckeptic better be reflected as:
"I do not need to, because thermite can do that. Just like Explosives can. Just like an Airplane flying into it can. It is not the question whether it CAN or CANNOT, but rather DID IT, or DID IT NOT?
The only way to show this is by showing the presence of thermite.
Upon all testing done, no such presence was found. Neither was the presence of explosives.
The presence we did, however, find in abundance - was airplane parts and exhausted fuel residue.
If there are crumbs in the plate, it is NOT reasonable to think that Jello was eaten..."


I do not doubt that the rest of the conversation example would transpire to the same exact end.
I completely agree with the premise that woos, conspiracy theorists, and their kin are far too often irrational and emotional.
My question, one skeptic to another, is:
"Do you think it's ethical for us to resort to the same tactics (lowblows, outbursts, dismissive, arrogant, etc) just to win the argument?"

If the skeptics are the ones doing the pointing and laughing and insulting, why is it that the paranormal claimants often end up being suspended? A very good summary of the usual woo thread, by the way.
It is not my intent to question the actions of moderators. I would not be opposed to engage any moderators in a discussion of such an example, within this thread's premise, though.
But that not being a prerequisite, as the core of my topic is not about their actions, but instead ours.
As I asked the above quote, and others in this thread:

If we are to present our case as the high ground, shouldn't we conduct ourselves from high ground as well?

Sometimes you have to be cruel to be kind. If they can't stand the heat then let them depart from the kitchen and head for the David Icke site.
Poor Dave lol.
 
Last edited:
My question, one skeptic to another, is:
"Do you think it's ethical for us to resort to the same tactics (lowblows, outbursts, dismissive, arrogant, etc) just to win the argument?"

That behavior is often the result of boredom and irritation while waiting for the claimant to come up with an intelligent argument.


Poor Dave lol.

I don't know, the site is comedy gold and Dave is making money.
 
"Do you think it's ethical for us to resort to the same tactics (lowblows, outbursts, dismissive, arrogant, etc) just to win the argument?"
It's not "just to win the argument", it's usually after the argument has been won and the opponent simply doesn't accept it.

You'll also find as a sceptic, that if your opponent wins an argument, he's not actually your opponent anymore (at least on the subject matter of the argument)... and therefore there will be no pointing and laughing.
 
It's not "just to win the argument", it's usually after the argument has been won and the opponent simply doesn't accept it.

You'll also find as a sceptic, that if your opponent wins an argument, he's not actually your opponent anymore (at least on the subject matter of the argument)... and therefore there will be no pointing and laughing.

I don't even care what you say, your avatar wins!
If you told me you found the Invisible Pink Unicorn, I would believe you just to see that avatar again!

Seriously... it draws me in...

On a more serious note:
So the slamming, punching, kicking, and all that is nothing more than
FINISH HIM!!!
?

That's not very admirable either...
 
I don't even care what you say, your avatar wins!
If you told me you found the Invisible Pink Unicorn, I would believe you just to see that avatar again!

Seriously... it draws me in...
Ironically, the avatar was made to mock and ridicule a UFOlogist. :D

On a more serious note:
So the slamming, punching, kicking, and all that is nothing more than ?

That's not very admirable either...
No, I don't think it's a "finish him" at all.
We can (and regularly do) engage with people for many pages, providing reams of evidence to support our positions, to be faced with someone who doesn't accept any of it and only provides hand waving and anecdote to refute it.
This can only go on for so long before it becomes very repetitive.
So some of us like to break up the monotony with a few gags, cartoons or a copy of Squid Fishing Monthly.
These things don't stop discussion, if the opponent brings fresh new evidence, we look at that seriously before another round of repetition and a bit more mocking.

The way I see it, rightly or wrongly, if people are going to present things which are ridiculous, after they have been reasonably, logically and/or scientifically show to be ridiculous, they will attract ridicule. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom