Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

The historical record of the Climate Change Chicken Littles:
A picture speaks a thousand words:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=808&pictureid=7092[/qimg]

Here's about a thousand words instead.

http://www.nationalcenter.org/Time-Ice-Age-06-24-1974-Sm.jpg

That article is older than I am!

Indeed this is the first of three things that bothers me about the climate debate...

Great post, all of it.
 
But I've seen many denialists say that AGW is just a front for profiteers, eco-terrorists, tree huggers, etc., so I'm good with it being a conspiracy theory. This is further reinforced when you consider my belief that the target of a conspiracy theory is the real reason for the CTers' actions, not the event or events in question. They use the event as a means of attacking a party or group, and thus the actuality of the theory is irrelevant.

You are "editing" denialism and keeping a collection of attributes that you find nasty of them so, must they be nasty? I'm not so sure of they being that or saying that, but I'm pretty sure of them doing such kind of editing.

This thread is interesting because many denialists that don't participate in global warming threads -or they just hit and run- are trying to sell their product doing that kind of editing by themselves. You can dismiss comfortably Robert Prey's #6 as an example of "I just can't help it and keep it under control no matter it goes against my own interest of seeding our ideology". You can consider StankApe's #17 as much better, but it turns AGW into a sort of grail hidden in a distant region: AGW is not crazy woo but crazy woo-la-boos keep it hostage so nobody knows what real AGW is and whatever is said about AGW is not the grail but the woo. You can take a look to what he or she really thinks abut that, here.

What is very interesting to me is the composing done in JayUtah's #71. It succeeds in creating an image of "we all agree in doing something" while dismissing the whole thing. It contains traps like "if we agree on ..." that looks like openness, but don't waste your time hoping, the agreement is never to come from their part.

As you see, three very different ways to do the same, three very different styles for being the same: behind denialism there is just the stance of mankind maximizing economical outputs and the individuals doing their own convenience with a practical disregard of the consequences. Then, if AGW doesn't exist, it is inevitable, it is not worth fighting against, or it is not solvable just because business interests, zealot environmentalist or any possible group but the denialists themselves obstructs it, that is just a matter of personal style and how each individual imagines how he or she is perceived by others.

And again, I disagree about them being conspiracy theorists in limine. They are just a plain and simple social nuisance, like half of the environmentalists.
 
What is very interesting to me is the composing done in JayUtah's #71. It succeeds in creating an image of "we all agree in doing something" while dismissing the whole thing. It contains traps like "if we agree on ..." that looks like openness, but don't waste your time hoping, the agreement is never to come from their part.

Let me clarify that I'm not a climate-change denialist. The thread asks whether denialism is a form of religion, and I argue that religion can be found on either extreme end of the debate spectrum. One can religiously advocate a certain environment policy, and one can just as religiously deny the need for one. I interpret the science to argue strongly and persuasively for an anthropogenic cause for climate change. However, I am not as easily swayed by proposals for what to do about it, especially if there appears to be an ulterior motive or signs of railroading.

I'm not centrist either. I believe there is a problem and that we should address it. I want to edge away from the religion of extremism keep feet firmly planted in reason. But not so close to the center that nothing gets done.
 
Let me clarify that I'm not a climate-change denialist. The thread asks whether denialism is a form of religion, and I argue that religion can be found on either extreme end of the debate spectrum. One can religiously advocate a certain environment policy, and one can just as religiously deny the need for one. I interpret the science to argue strongly and persuasively for an anthropogenic cause for climate change. However, I am not as easily swayed by proposals for what to do about it, especially if there appears to be an ulterior motive or signs of railroading.

I'm not centrist either. I believe there is a problem and that we should address it. I want to edge away from the religion of extremism keep feet firmly planted in reason. But not so close to the center that nothing gets done.

I find curious that need of defining one's position in comparison with extremists, but if I had to, I would chose a way that clearly stated I wasn't an obstructionist.

Because the old denialism of saying AGW doesn't exist is really dead though some people are like communists that don't accept that the iron curtain felt. The new denialism is just obstructionism. It is "it's happening, but ..." and staying long years in the but(t) part of the debate. And no matter the new denialism says they are not the old one at all because they don't "deny" AGW, they are their legitimate heirs in the struggle to dilute the debate and move societies far from any kind of practical coordinated and fair effort to curb it.

Take this into account when you are stating your position about the whole topic.
 
Here's about a thousand words instead.

http://www.nationalcenter.org/Time-Ice-Age-06-24-1974-Sm.jpg

That article is older than I am!



Great post, all of it.

Chicken Littles never die. They will be with us till the end of time.

picture.php
 
Last edited:
Chicken Littles never die. They will be with us till the end of time.
picture.php


Loons who fear the communist peril never die. They will be with us till the end of time - Robert since you admitted to being a communist yourself could you explain how the Vatican is also marxist and leftie too?
 
Chicken Littles never die. They will be with us till the end of time.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=808&pictureid=7096[/qimg]

Yeah there are even people out there who still get all panicked and paranoid about communists. Can you believe it?
 
Well call me a nut but I don't think man made global warming is as big of crisis as what we are lead to believe. As far as I am aware, the climate has always changed and there are natural forces out there which I believe are far more influential than anything man can put into the atmosphere. Although I do not deny the fact that we contribute, I believe our contribute is so tiny its almost negligible.

It doesn't help that the people pushing these ideas tend to have ulterior motives. Its no secrete neo-maxist hide up the skirt of the environmentalist movement. In my experience, especially here in New Zealand, the global warming/carbon footprint/carbon taxes/'green' policy is all a front to mask a leftist political agenda aimed at transforming our country further away from capitalism. All one has to do is look behind the environmental policies of our 'Green Party' to see its built on socialist ideologies.
 
You are "editing" denialism and keeping a collection of attributes that you find nasty of them so, must they be nasty? I'm not so sure of they being that or saying that, but I'm pretty sure of them doing such kind of editing.

This thread is interesting because many denialists that don't participate in global warming threads -or they just hit and run- are trying to sell their product doing that kind of editing by themselves. You can dismiss comfortably Robert Prey's #6 as an example of "I just can't help it and keep it under control no matter it goes against my own interest of seeding our ideology". You can consider StankApe's #17 as much better, but it turns AGW into a sort of grail hidden in a distant region: AGW is not crazy woo but crazy woo-la-boos keep it hostage so nobody knows what real AGW is and whatever is said about AGW is not the grail but the woo. You can take a look to what he or she really thinks abut that, here.

What is very interesting to me is the composing done in JayUtah's #71. It succeeds in creating an image of "we all agree in doing something" while dismissing the whole thing. It contains traps like "if we agree on ..." that looks like openness, but don't waste your time hoping, the agreement is never to come from their part.

As you see, three very different ways to do the same, three very different styles for being the same: behind denialism there is just the stance of mankind maximizing economical outputs and the individuals doing their own convenience with a practical disregard of the consequences. Then, if AGW doesn't exist, it is inevitable, it is not worth fighting against, or it is not solvable just because business interests, zealot environmentalist or any possible group but the denialists themselves obstructs it, that is just a matter of personal style and how each individual imagines how he or she is perceived by others.

And again, I disagree about them being conspiracy theorists in limine. They are just a plain and simple social nuisance, like half of the environmentalists.

i resent being called a denialist, It appears that anyone who doesn't fall in lockstep behind the greeners is stomped with the jackboots of labeling....

All I ask is that when the world doesn't turn out to be a disaster area in 50 years that I get an apology.

I also have not heard a legit argument for even why global warming is bad for the planet, bad for people? maybe,but good for the planet I think. More temperate areas, more biodiversity. Good things right?

Call me selfish, but I don't really care if the world goes to hell. By then I will probably be dead.
 
I also have not heard a legit argument for even why global warming is bad for the planet, bad for people? maybe,but good for the planet I think. More temperate areas, more biodiversity. Good things right?

Erm, why do you think that the result would be more biodiversity? Or indeed more temperate regions? When you consider the areas that will no longer be viable for growth, raised sea level, altered gulf streams and weather patterns, etc, you are pretty much working on the "Costa Blackpool" fallacy where currently cold and miserable places will be mediterranian, while reasonably hot and vibrant places will be just a little hotter.

It does not take much of a temperature change to turn our current bread baskets into dustbowls. Or to reduce bio diversity to zero. A dead coral reef is no use to anybody.
 
why do you think the result will be this big terrible mass devastation? When the earth was much much warmer, was there not more bio-diversity?

I'm just using the past as a mirror for the future here, if this is in error , an explanation why it would be in error would be appreciated. being called a denier is pissing me off though. When i have repeatedly stated that I have no beef with the science behind AGW promoters, merely in the way I feel the consequences have been sensationalized and used by certain people to promote an agenda. These people are not affiliated with any climate scientists that I know of, so i am not claiming that the data was hoaxed to promote an agenda or any such nonsense like that.

I tend to be skeptical when extremes are thrust upon me by human beings. We tend to exaggerate and make things worse then they are.
 
why do you think the result will be this big terrible mass devastation? When the earth was much much warmer, was there not more bio-diversity?

Sure. The continents were also in different places, there had been no agricultural development and there were no glacial masses that were were going to melt and redistribute the sea.

The clock is not being rolled back on geography a few million years. We can map where the probable effects of increasing climate with a fair amount of accuracy.

It is also worth noting that not everywhere had more biodiversity when the world was on average warmer. It may have had different species but not every where had more.
 
i resent being called a denialist, It appears that anyone who doesn't fall in lockstep behind the greeners is stomped with the jackboots of labeling....

All I ask is that when the world doesn't turn out to be a disaster area in 50 years that I get an apology.

I also have not heard a legit argument for even why global warming is bad for the planet, bad for people? maybe,but good for the planet I think. More temperate areas, more biodiversity. Good things right?

Call me selfish, but I don't really care if the world goes to hell. By then I will probably be dead.

The labels denialist and warmist are well applied to everyone who had a "feeling" first and then cherry-picked what they needed from the wide menu reality offers. The fact that their process has been sort of feeling1>cherry1>feeling2>cherry2>feeling3>cherry3>... (which has the epistemological charm of "which came first? hen or egg?") have convinced them that they arrived to their "certainties" by means of reason and supported by evidence when in fact they only have a conviction and a human yet sick attachment to epistemological hedonism.

If you didn't want that label to be applied to you, you should have avoided first engaging in a "there's much hype around + it's not so bad" line of argumentation to later topping it with an après moi le déluge stance. That was topping epistemological hedonism with simple and pure hedonism (no matter you getting some pleasure from doing that or none).

It's as simple as there's no reason for me to stand you smoking a cigar in the same room I am, or farting there because you felt like it, or having you alone in a SUV driving on paved roads adding your share in changing the climate no matter you may be located in the antipodes. As eventually I may escape from that room but not from the planet you may smoke of fart in private, open air or special places all you want, but you have no such ample liberty about climate changing polluters. And I don't care if you don't smoke, you don't have a SUV or your intestines have an unblemished record.
 
Well call me a nut but I don't think man made global warming is as big of crisis as what we are lead to believe. As far as I am aware, the climate has always changed and there are natural forces out there which I believe are far more influential than anything man can put into the atmosphere. Although I do not deny the fact that we contribute, I believe our contribute is so tiny its almost negligible.
What evidence do you base this belief on?

People have always died of lung cancer, but it's estimated that around 90% of modern cases of lung cancer are caused by smoking. If someone said to you that "there are natural forces out there which I believe are far more influential than anything man can put into his lungs" would you think that was a valid reason to doubt that estimate? Or would you ask him on what evidence he based his belief that the doctors who spend their lives studying this subject had got their estimate of the contribution made by smoking so wrong?
 
Last edited:
Well call me a nut but I don't think man made global warming is as big of crisis as what we are lead to believe. As far as I am aware, the climate has always changed and there are natural forces out there which I believe are far more influential than anything man can put into the atmosphere. Although I do not deny the fact that we contribute, I believe our contribute is so tiny its almost negligible.

It doesn't help that the people pushing these ideas tend to have ulterior motives. Its no secrete neo-maxist hide up the skirt of the environmentalist movement. In my experience, especially here in New Zealand, the global warming/carbon footprint/carbon taxes/'green' policy is all a front to mask a leftist political agenda aimed at transforming our country further away from capitalism. All one has to do is look behind the environmental policies of our 'Green Party' to see its built on socialist ideologies.

Well you asked specifically for it so "you're a nut".:D

two points.
First. Capitalist policy makers will always work against spending on anything that does not reflect in at least a 10 year outlook of increasing the bottom line whereas leftists (which does not require one being Marxist) will consider more prominantly, the outlook for the greater good.

Second. Perhaps you are correct and Global climate change is not as man made as is being deduced by the scientific community. Perhaps there is little we can do to change the course of climate change. However that brings up two other points. First that reducing carbon output in many ways also reduces other pollutants, which is a good thing on other levels. Reducing carbon output also reduces our dependance of fossil fuels which must at some point run out. Even if that point can be shown to be 50-75 years in the future we might as well begin trying to change now rather than wait until gasoline in the USA is $15/litre and then wail and gnash our teeth and cry out 'why me?'.
Second, if climate change is indeed being driven more by natural effects such as solar cycles then our civilisation is still in danger and thus it would behoove us to look to ways to limit adverse affect on our civilisation and to look towards possibly finding ways to actually limit climate change on a global scale.

If the Capitalist way to go about it is to let it all slide I submit that is like saying " yeah my car is sliding on the ice and taking me towards the on coming lanes but since there is nothing I can do about the ice on the street I am going to simply hold the steering wheel tight as I slam into the oncoming semi trailer truck. I and the car are fine right now therefore no sense possibly ruining the steering system by trying to get out of the way" then count me out.
 
Last edited:
i resent being called a denialist, It appears that anyone who doesn't fall in lockstep behind the greeners is stomped with the jackboots of labeling....

Nobody cares if you resent it or not. It's the proper label for the rhetoric you spew.

All I ask is that when the world doesn't turn out to be a disaster area in 50 years that I get an apology.

When it is a disaster area, will you apologize? Well, there wouldn't be any point by then, would it?

I also have not heard a legit argument for even why global warming is bad for the planet, bad for people? maybe,but good for the planet I think. More temperate areas, more biodiversity. Good things right?

Then you haven't looked.

Call me selfish, but I don't really care if the world goes to hell. By then I will probably be dead.

And this is why nobody should ever take you seriously.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom